Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 3633]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
June 23, 2025.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
__________
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
60-752 WASHINGTON : 2025
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
119th Congress } { REPT. 119-168
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
1st Session } { Part 2
======================================================================
DIGITAL ASSET MARKET CLARITY ACT OF 2025
_______
June 23, 2025.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
_______
Mr. Hill of Arkansas, from the Committee on Financial Services,
submitted the following
R E P O R T
together with
Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 3633]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 3633) to provide for a system of regulation of
the offer and sale of digital commodities by the Securities and
Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading
Commission, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that
the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 61
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 62
Committee Consideration.......................................... 73
Related Hearings................................................. 73
Committee Votes.................................................. 74
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 108
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 108
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 108
New Budget Authority and CBO Cost Estimate....................... 108
Unfunded Mandates Statement...................................... 108
Earmark Statement................................................ 108
Federal Advisory Committee Act Statement......................... 108
Applicability to the Legislative Branch.......................... 109
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 109
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 109
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 119
Minority Views................................................... 472
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Digital Asset Market
Clarity Act of 2025'' or the ``CLARITY Act of 2025''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
TITLE I--DEFINITIONS; RULEMAKING; PROVISIONAL REGISTRATION
Sec. 101. Definitions under the Securities Act of 1933.
Sec. 102. Definitions under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Sec. 103. Definitions under the Commodity Exchange Act.
Sec. 104. Definitions under this Act.
Sec. 105. Rulemakings.
Sec. 106. Provisional registration for digital commodity exchanges,
brokers, and dealers.
Sec. 107. Commodity Exchange Act and securities laws savings
provisions.
Sec. 108. Administrative requirements.
Sec. 109. International cooperation.
Sec. 110. Treatment of certain non-controlling blockchain developers.
Sec. 111. Application of the Bank Secrecy Act.
Sec. 112. Implementation.
TITLE II--OFFERS AND SALES OF DIGITAL COMMODITIES
Sec. 201. Treatment of investment contract assets.
Sec. 202. Exempted primary transactions in digital commodities.
Sec. 203. Treatment of secondary transactions in digital commodities
that originally involved investment contracts.
Sec. 204. Requirements for offers and sales of digital commodities by
digital commodity related persons and digital commodity affiliated
persons.
Sec. 205. Mature blockchain system requirements.
Sec. 206. Effective date.
TITLE III--REGISTRATION FOR INTERMEDIARIES AT THE SECURITIES AND
EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Sec. 301. Treatment of digital commodities and permitted payment
stablecoins.
Sec. 302. Anti-fraud authority over permitted payment stablecoins and
certain digital commodity transactions.
Sec. 303. Eligibility of alternative trading systems.
Sec. 304. Operation of alternative trading systems.
Sec. 305. Modernization of recordkeeping requirements.
Sec. 306. Exemptive authority.
Sec. 307. Additional registrations with the Commodity Futures Trading
Commission.
Sec. 308. Exempting digital commodities from State securities laws.
Sec. 309. Exclusion for decentralized finance activities.
Sec. 310. Treatment of custody activities by banking institutions.
Sec. 311. Broker and dealer disclosures regarding the treatment of
assets.
Sec. 312. Digital commodity activities that are financial in nature.
Sec. 313. Effective date; administration.
Sec. 314. Studies on foreign adversary participation.
TITLE IV--REGISTRATION FOR DIGITAL COMMODITY INTERMEDIARIES AT THE
COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION
Sec. 401. Commission jurisdiction over digital commodity transactions.
Sec. 402. Requiring futures commission merchants to use qualified
digital asset custodians.
Sec. 403. Trading certification and approval for digital commodities.
Sec. 404. Registration of digital commodity exchanges.
Sec. 405. Qualified digital asset custodians.
Sec. 406. Registration and regulation of digital commodity brokers and
dealers.
Sec. 407. Registration of associated persons.
Sec. 408. Registration of commodity pool operators and commodity
trading advisors.
Sec. 409. Exclusion for decentralized finance activities.
Sec. 410. Resources for implementation and enforcement.
Sec. 411. Digital commodity activities by SEC-registered entities.
Sec. 412. Requirements related to control persons.
Sec. 413. Effective date.
Sec. 414. Sense of Congress.
TITLE V--INNOVATION AND TECHNOLOGY IMPROVEMENTS
Sec. 501. Findings; sense of Congress.
Sec. 502. Modernization of the Securities and Exchange Commission
mission.
Sec. 503. Strategic Hub for Innovation and Financial Technology.
Sec. 504. Codification of LabCFTC.
Sec. 505. Study on decentralized finance.
Sec. 506. Study on non-fungible tokens.
Sec. 507. Study on expanding financial literacy amongst digital
commodity holders.
Sec. 508. Study on financial market infrastructure improvements.
Sec. 509. Study on blockchain in payments.
TITLE I--DEFINITIONS; RULEMAKING; PROVISIONAL REGISTRATION
SEC. 101. DEFINITIONS UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933.
Section 2(a) of the Securities Act of 1933 (15 U.S.C. 77b(a)) is
amended by adding at the end the following:
``(20) Blockchain.--The term `blockchain' means--
``(A) any technology--
``(i) where data is--
``(I) shared across a network to
create a distributed ledger of
independently verifiable transactions
or information among network
participants;
``(II) linked using cryptography to
maintain the integrity of the
distributed ledger and to execute other
functions; and
``(III) propagated among network
participants to reach consensus on the
state of the distributed ledger and any
other functions; and
``(ii) composed of source code that is
publicly available; and
``(B) any similar technology to the technology
described in subparagraph (A).
``(21) Blockchain application.--The term `blockchain
application' means any executable software that is deployed to
a blockchain and composed of source code that is publicly
available, including a smart contract or any network of smart
contracts, or other similar technology.
``(22) Blockchain protocol.--The term `blockchain protocol'
means publicly available source code of a blockchain that is
executed by the network participants of a blockchain to
facilitate its functioning, or other similar technology.
``(23) Blockchain system.--The term `blockchain system' means
any blockchain, together with its blockchain protocol or any
blockchain application or network of blockchain applications.
``(24) Decentralized governance system.--
``(A) In general.--The term `decentralized governance
system' means, with respect to a blockchain system, any
transparent, rules-based system permitting persons to
form consensus or reach agreement in the development,
provision, publication, maintenance, or administration
of such blockchain system, where participation is not
limited to, or under the effective control of, any
person or group of persons under common control.
``(B) Relationship of persons to decentralized
governance systems.--With respect to a decentralized
governance system, the decentralized governance system
and any persons participating in the decentralized
governance system shall be treated as separate persons
unless such persons are under common control or acting
pursuant to an agreement to act in concert.
``(C) Legal entities for decentralized governance
systems.--The term `decentralized governance system'
shall include a legal entity used to implement the
rules-based system described in subparagraph (A),
provided that the legal entity does not operate
pursuant to centralized management. For the purposes of
this subparagraph, the delegation of ministerial or
administrative authority at the direction of the
participants in a decentralized governance system shall
not be construed to be centralized management.
``(25) Digital asset.--The term `digital asset' means any
digital representation of value which is recorded on a
cryptographically-secured distributed ledger or other similar
technology.
``(26) Digital commodity.--The term `digital commodity' has
the meaning given that term under section 1a of the Commodity
Exchange Act (7 U.S.C. 1a).
``(27) Digital commodity affiliated person.--The term
`digital commodity affiliated person' means a person (including
a digital commodity related person) that, with respect to any
digital commodity--
``(A) acquires or has any right to acquire 5 percent
or more of the total outstanding units of such digital
commodity from a digital commodity issuer or an agent
or underwriter thereof (other than a decentralized
governance system);
``(B) is a founder of the digital commodity issuer;
or
``(C) is an executive officer, director, trustee,
general partner, or person serving in a similar
capacity of the digital commodity issuer or held such
role at any point in the previous 12-month period.
``(28) Digital commodity issuer.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a digital
commodity, the term `digital commodity issuer' means
any person that--
``(i) issues or causes to be issued, or
proposes to issue or cause to be issued, a unit
of such digital commodity to a person; or
``(ii) offers or sells a right to a future
issuance of a unit of such digital commodity to
a person.
``(B) Prohibition on evasion.--It shall be unlawful
for any person to knowingly evade classification as a
`digital commodity issuer' and facilitate an
arrangement for the primary purpose of effecting an
offer, sale, distribution, or other issuance of a
digital commodity, including via any arrangement
involving the transfer of intellectual property
associated with the blockchain system to which the
digital commodity relates.
``(29) Digital commodity related person.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a digital
commodity issuer, the term `digital commodity related
person' means a person--
``(i) that is or was in the previous 6-month
period a promoter, senior employee, advisory
board member, consultant, advisor, or person
serving in a similar capacity; or
``(ii) that acquires or has any right to
acquire 1 percent or more of the total
outstanding units of such digital commodity
from a digital commodity issuer or an agent or
underwriter thereof (other than a decentralized
governance system).
``(B) Senior employee defined.--In this paragraph and
with respect to a digital commodity issuer, the term
`senior employee' means any employee materially
involved in the management of the digital commodity
issuer, including management of the development of the
blockchain system to which the digital commodity
relates.
``(30) End user distribution.--The term `end user
distribution' means a distribution of a unit of a digital
commodity that--
``(A) does not involve an exchange of more than a
nominal value of cash, property, or other assets; and
``(B) is distributed in a broad and equitable manner
based on conditions capable of being satisfied by any
participant in the blockchain system, including, as
incentive-based rewards--
``(i) to users of the digital commodity or
any blockchain system to which the digital
commodity relates;
``(ii) for activities directly related to the
operation of the blockchain system, such as
mining, validating, staking, or other activity
directly tied to the operation of the
blockchain system; or
``(iii) to the existing holders of another
digital commodity, in proportion to the total
units of such other digital commodity as are
held by each person.
``(31) Mature blockchain system.--The term `mature blockchain
system' means a blockchain system, together with its related
digital commodity, that is not controlled by any person or
group of persons under common control.
``(32) Permitted payment stablecoin.--
``(A) In general.--The term `permitted payment
stablecoin' means a digital asset--
``(i) that is or is designed to be used as a
means of payment or settlement;
``(ii) that is denominated in a national
currency;
``(iii) the issuer of which is subject to the
regulatory and supervisory authority of a State
or Federal agency;
``(iv) the issuer of which--
``(I) is obligated to convert,
redeem, or repurchase for a fixed
amount of monetary value; or
``(II) represents that the digital
asset will maintain or creates the
reasonable expectation that the digital
asset will maintain a stable value
relative to the value of a fixed amount
of monetary value; and
``(v) that is not--
``(I) a national currency;
``(II) a security issued by--
``(aa) an investment company
registered under section 8(a)
of the Investment Company Act
of 1940 (15 U.S.C. 80a-8(a));
or
``(bb) a person that would be
an investment company under the
Investment Company Act of 1940
but for paragraphs (1) and (7)
of section 3(c) of that Act (15
U.S.C. 80a-3(c));
``(III) a deposit (as defined under
section 3 of the Federal Deposit
Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813)),
regardless of the technology used to
record such deposit; or
``(IV) an account (as defined in
section 101 of the Federal Credit Union
Act (12 U.S.C. 1752)), regardless of
the technology used to record such
account.
``(B) Monetary value defined.--The term `monetary
value'--
``(i) means--
``(I) a national currency;
``(II) a deposit (as defined in
section 3 of the Federal Deposit
Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813)) that is
denominated in a national currency; or
``(III) an account (as defined in
section 101 of the Federal Credit Union
Act (12 U.S.C. 1752)); and
``(ii) does not include any agricultural or
other physical commodity (as defined in section
1a of the Commodity Exchange Act (7 U.S.C.
1a)).
``(33) Securities laws.--The term `securities laws' has the
meaning given that term under section 3(a) of the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78c(a)).''.
SEC. 102. DEFINITIONS UNDER THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934.
Section 3(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C.
78c(a)) is amended--
(1) by redesignating the second paragraph (80) (relating to
funding portals) as paragraph (81); and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(82) Bank secrecy act.--The term `Bank Secrecy Act' means--
``(A) section 21 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act
(12 U.S.C. 1829b);
``(B) chapter 2 of title I of Public Law 91-508 (12
U.S.C. 1951 et seq.); and
``(C) s
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on May 29, 2025, by Chairman French Hill (AR-
02), H.R. 3633, the Digital Asset Market Clarity (CLARITY) Act,
provides the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) with
jurisdiction over digital commodities and clarifies the
Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) jurisdiction over
investment contracts involving digital commodities.
Additionally, the bill clarifies the regulatory treatment of
secondary market trading of digital commodities that were
initially offered as part of an investment contract. Finally,
the bill imposes robust customer protections on all entities
required to be registered with the CFTC and the SEC.
Background and Need for Legislation
H.R. 3633, as reported, establishes a digital asset market
structure framework that is consistent with existing regulatory
financial market requirements and recognizes the unique
characteristics of digital assets. This functional framework
provides digital asset firms with regulatory certainty,
establishes clear jurisdictional lines between the SEC and
CFTC, and ensures Americans have comparable protections in
digital asset markets to those in the traditional financial
system. The reported legislation will ensure the United States
sets the global standard for the future of innovation.
INNOVATION
Digital assets and blockchain technology have the potential
to make our financial system more efficient and accessible to
consumers. At a May 6, 2025, Joint Roundtable of the House
Committee on Financial Services (HFSC) Subcommittee on Digital
Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial Intelligence and
the House Committee on Agriculture (HAC) Subcommittee on
Commodity Markets, Digital Assets, and Rural Development (May
2025 Joint Roundtable), James Rathmell, General Counsel of Haun
Ventures, explained, ``With crypto, we believe money, assets,
and markets will become like everything else on the internet:
transferable at the speed of information, accessible,
programmable, transparent, and auditable.''
Because digital assets can be accessed from anywhere, at
any time, by anyone with an internet connection, digital assets
solve some of the accessibility constraints associated with
traditional financial services. At an April 9, 2025, hearing
before the HFSC Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial
Technology, and Artificial Intelligence (April 2025 HFSC
Hearing), Jacob Werrett, Chief Legal Officer of Polygon Labs,
testified, ``Unlike traditional financial services, blockchains
do not typically require users to meet specific eligibility
criteria such as credit checks, geographic restrictions, or
minimum financial thresholds. Whether for saving, investing, or
borrowing, blockchains offer the opportunity for greater
financial freedom and access, particularly in regions where
traditional banking infrastructure is lacking or unavailable.''
At a February 11, 2025, hearing before the Subcommittee on
Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial
Intelligence, (February 2025 HFSC Hearing), Ji Hun Kim,
President and Acting CEO of the Crypto Council for Innovation,
testified, ``We are in the early innings of increased
traditional finance adoption of digital asset and blockchain
technologies to enhance the efficiency, transparency, and
security of market infrastructure.'' At the same hearing,
former CFTC Chairman Timothy Massad, who currently serves as a
Research Fellow and Director of the Digital Assets Policy
Project at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard
University, provided an explanation for traditional firms
staying on the sidelines of the digital asset ecosystem. He
explained, ``the absence of a clear regulatory framework has
caused some institutions to refrain from making investments
that might lead to applications of greater utility.'' Mr. Kim
further emphasized the need for regulatory and legislative
clarity to preserve digital asset innovation in the United
States, emphasizing ``It is important for the U.S. to build
upon the progress made during the 118th Congress and ensure
U.S. leadership in digital assets at the global level . . .
increased clarity regarding regulatory expectations will
unleash further innovation and ensure that American markets
remain the envy of the world.''
Mark Tague, Co-Founder and Chief Revenue Officer of
CattleProof Verified LLC, testified at an April 9 HAC
Subcommittee on Commodity Markets, Digital Assets, and Rural
Development hearing (April 2025 HAC Hearing) stating, ``other
jurisdictions are actively creating regulatory certainty for
digital assets and blockchain technology. The U.S. risks
falling behind if it does not foster an environment that
encourages and supports innovation in this space.'' At the same
hearing, Mike Horton, Project Creator at the GEODNET
Foundation, testified that ``it is imperative that future
innovators have absolute clarity around how digital assets are
to be regulated. A lack of clarity stifles innovation and
discourages investment in the U.S.''
At a June 4, 2025, hearing before the HAC (June 2025 HAC
Hearing), Dr. Avery Ching, the CEO and Co-Founder of blockchain
developer Aptos Labs, also spoke on the importance of
supporting innovation:
``Just as the internet rewired everyday life,
decentralized networks will form the core
infrastructure of the coming digital economy--
delivering systems that are transparent, interoperable,
designed for innovation, and will redefine how we
engage with the world around us.
``Tokens serve a vital role in every application
built on a blockchain. For blockchain innovation to
expand responsibly in the U.S., developers need clear
regulatory guidance around token issuance and
distributions. We're ready to help realize that
mission, and we're grateful for the Committee's
leadership in making it possible.
``Market structure legislation and well-defined,
consistent rules around token issuance and distribution
will ensure that networks like Aptos can function as
designed, U.S. builders can innovate while staying
compliant and competitive, and regulators can enforce
meaningful consumer protections.
``The infrastructure is ready. Regulatory clarity
will ensure U.S. leadership in the next era of the
internet.''
ECONOMIC IMPACT
The lack of a comprehensive federal regulatory framework
for digital assets incentivizes digital asset innovators to
move offshore to pursue development overseas, at the expense of
U.S. economic growth. Other countries have built frameworks and
become developmental hubs for the digital asset ecosystem.
Currently, the largest trading platform and the largest
stablecoin issuer are based outside of the United States.
Many jurisdictions are successfully building digital asset
regulatory frameworks and incorporating distributed ledger
technology into their financial systems. For example, the
European Union approved its Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA)
framework, and the United Kingdom has worked toward its own
digital asset regulatory framework.
At the February 2025 HFSC Hearing, Coy Garrison, Partner at
Steptoe LLP and former counsel to SEC Commissioner Hester
Peirce, testified, ``On the global stage, the U.S. ceded
leadership in this technology to other jurisdictions as
entrepreneurs and capital flew to jurisdictions willing to
provide regulatory certainty for the industry, including the
European Union, United Arab Emirates, and Hong Kong.'' During
the May 2025 Joint Roundtable, Greg Tusar, Vice President of
Institutional Product of Coinbase Global, Inc., further
emphasized the competitive disadvantage the United States faces
in the absence of market structure legislation:
``While Singapore, Switzerland, and the European
Union have adopted unified frameworks that attract
talent and capital, the fragmented U.S. regulatory
landscape coupled by an enforcement-first approach has
pushed innovators overseas. Without a clear, consistent
roadmap for compliance across all states, developers
and businesses find themselves focusing on
jurisdictions where regulations are predictable and
accessible, leaving the United States at a competitive
disadvantage.''
During the April 2025 HAC Hearing, Bill Hughes, Senior
Counsel and Director of Global Regulatory Matters of Consensys
Software Inc., highlighted the potential of blockchain
projects, emphasizing, ``new computer networks like Ethereum
have enticed meaningful computer engineering talent to migrate
to the blockchain space to build the apps that will impact our
future. What we see with Ethereum is the building of a new
world computer.'' He added, ``Blockchain unlocks a software
application frontier that can meaningfully impact the real
world in ways the current internet simply cannot.''
CONSUMER PROTECTION
The current regulatory framework for digital assets fails
to provide adequate consumer protection. At a June 4, 2025,
hearing before the HFSC (June 2025 HFSC Hearing), former CFTC
Chairman Rostin Behnam, who currently serves as a Distinguished
Fellow at the Psaros Center for Financial Markets & Policy at
Georgetown University, explained, ``for far too long, the vast
majority of the digital asset market [has been] unregulated and
American investors vulnerable to fraud and manipulation.''
Digital commodities, as defined in the CLARITY Act, account for
roughly 70 percent of the total market capitalization on
digital assets traded today. Because there is no direct federal
oversight of the digital commodity marketplace, there are no
federally mandated customer protections, including requirements
pertaining to customer disclosures, segregation of customer
funds, and conflicts of interest. Additionally, without
registration and oversight of digital commodity intermediaries
and trading platforms, customers are unable to discern the
reputable firms from the disreputable. Consequently, customers
face significant risks with respect to the digital commodities
they purchase, how they purchase those digital commodities, how
an intermediary or trading platform custodies their cash,
securities, and digital commodities, and their ability to
access those digital commodities, especially if the
intermediary or trading platform holding their digital
commodities dissolves.
At the February 2025 HFSC Hearing, Coy Garrison outlined
how the lack of a comprehensive market structure framework for
digital assets has impacted consumers: ``Americans who hold and
trade digital assets are left unprotected with no regulatory
framework imposing baseline protections.'' During the June 2025
HFSC Hearing, Vivek Raman, Co-Founder and CEO of Etherealize,
testified, ``the lack of clarity harms the very investors we
aim to protect. A prime example is the collapse of offshore
exchanges or issuers that were not subject to robust oversight
and U.S. regulatory standards. Regulatory clarity will raise
the bar for conduct in this industry by bringing serious
players into compliance and weeding out bad actors.''
At the June 2025 HFSC Hearing, Katherine Minarik, Chief
Legal Officer at Uniswap Labs, explained why all Americans--
even those that are crypto skeptics--should want comprehensive
digital asset legislation stating ``If you are deeply skeptical
of crypto, then you should want this legislation even more.
Because without it, we are not protecting the public, we are
abandoning them.''
Daniel J. Davis, former General Counsel at the CFTC,
participating in the May 2025 Joint Roundtable, stated that
``there are significant rules [at the CFTC] regarding the
segregation and protection of customer funds.'' He added that
``[t]he CFTC also has extensive rules to protect retail
customers engaging in certain foreign exchange transactions.''
Chelsea Pizzola, Partner at Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP,
highlighted at the June 2025 HAC Hearing how CFTC oversight
provides necessary consumer protections in her testimony:
``The CFTC's oversight of digital asset markets is
not only long-running but also battle-tested: in the
2022 failure of digital asset exchange operator FTX,
while other FTX trading platforms revealed a total $8.9
billion shortfall in customer funds and went into
bankruptcy, FTX's CFTC-regulated DCM, swap execution
facility (``SEF''), and [derivatives clearing
organization] survived without any loss of customer
assets and remain in operation today under new
ownership.''
Ryne Miller, Partner at Lowenstein Sandler LLP and Former
General Counsel of FTX US, illustrated the vital nature of a
comprehensive market structure framework to consumer protection
at the June 2025 HAC Hearing:
``Had the regulatory structure provided for in the
bill currently being considered by this Committee and
ultimately Congress applied to FTX, the story I just
told would almost certainly have a much different
ending. Examinations, governance requirements, audits,
reporting, recordkeeping, and customer asset
segregation requirements directly address the
shortfalls that have allowed various digital asset
industry failures and thefts to occur.''
REGULATORY GAP
Currently, there is no comprehensive federal regulatory
regime for the cash or spot digital commodity markets. The
Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and the CFTC regulations
promulgated thereunder provide a comprehensive regulatory
regime for the trading of commodity derivatives, including
digital commodity derivatives (e.g., buying or selling Bitcoin
futures contracts). This includes registration and regulatory
requirements for exchanges and intermediaries. Under the CEA,
the CFTC also has ``after-the- fact'' enforcement jurisdiction
over fraud and manipulation in the cash or spot commodity
markets (e.g., buying or selling a commodity, including digital
commodities, like Bitcoin). However, the CFTC has no power to
impose registration and regulatory requirements for exchanges
or intermediaries, or on market participants in the cash or
spot digital commodity markets. This lack of a comprehensive
federal regulatory framework for digital commodity cash or spot
transactions is referred to as the ``spot market regulatory
gap.''
Daniel J. Davis, former General Counsel at the CFTC,
explained at the May 2025 Joint Roundtable that ``neither the
CFTC nor any other federal regulator has plenary regulatory
authority over the trading of digital assets that qualify as
commodities . . . there appears to be a significant gap at the
federal level in the regulation of spot digital assets.'' At
the June 2025 HAC Hearing, Mrs. Pizzola, Partner at Willkie
Farr & Gallagher LLP, shared this view, testifying ``[t]hough
the CFTC currently does not have plenary regulatory authority
over spot commodity markets, it has anti-fraud and anti-
manipulation authority over such markets.''
During the June 2025 HFSC Hearing, former CFTC Chairman
Behnam testified about the longstanding nature of the spot
market gap and its detrimental impact:
``The principal objective of market structure
legislation . . . should be to provide regulatory
oversight of the spot market for digital asset tokens
that are not securities. That structural gap in our
regulatory framework has led to the high degree of
fraud, manipulation and lack of investor protection, as
well as rampant speculation, that has characterized the
digital asset sector to date. I have spoken about this
gap since shortly after I became chairman of the [CFTC]
in 2014 and we declared bitcoin to be a commodity.''
COMMODITY VS. SECURITY
Under the Biden Administration, former SEC Chairman Gary
Gensler opined on numerous occasions that the ``test to
determine whether a crypto asset is a security is clear.''
However, SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce and former SEC
Commissioner and Acting Chairman Elad Roisman disagreed, citing
requests the SEC received for clarity and the consistent
outreach to the Commission staff for no-action and other
relief. During Chairman Gensler's tenure at the SEC,
Commissioner Peirce repeatedly emphasized her concerns with the
SEC's enforcement-centric approach and highlighted the
importance of regulatory clarity for the digital asset markets.
Under the Securities Act of 1933 (Securities Act) and the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Exchange Act), the SEC has
full regulatory authority over the offer, sale, and the trading
of securities, including investment contracts, and many
security derivatives. Under the federal securities laws, every
offer and sale of securities must be either registered with the
SEC or conducted pursuant to an exemption to registration.
Both the term ``security'' and the term ``commodity'' are
broadly defined in statute. The federal securities laws define
the term ``security'' to include not only specific types of
financial instruments, such as stocks and bonds, but also
several undefined terms, notably ``investment contract.'' The
term ``investment contract'' captures unique or novel
instruments and arrangements, including many utilized by
digital asset projects which raised funds.
The CEA defines ``commodity'' broadly to include all
``goods and articles and all services, rights, and interests .
. . in which contracts for future delivery are presently or in
the future dealt in.'' In 2015, during the Obama
Administration, the CFTC clarified that bitcoin and certain
other virtual currencies are commodities under the CEA.
Because these legal definitions are broad and overlapping,
the boundary between a security and commodity can be unclear,
and it can be difficult to determine whether a digital asset is
offered as part of an investment contract or falls under the
definition of commodity in the CEA. As Tiffany Smith, Partner
at WilmerHale, pointed out during the April 2025 HFSC Hearing,
the SEC's broad interpretation of its authority has made
determining the legal classification of digital asset
difficult:
``The term `digital assets' has broadly been used by
the SEC to refer to `an asset that is issued and
transferred using distributed ledger or blockchain
technology' and includes virtual currency, coins, and
tokens. The SEC also used the term `crypto asset
security' to refer to digital assets that meet the
definition of `security' under the federal securities
laws and that rely on cryptographic protocols.
Importantly, these broad terms combined with the
expansive past views of SEC officials that most digital
assets are offered and sold as securities, failed to
distinguish between different types of digital assets,
including those that are intended to be offered and
sold as securities, like tokenized securities and
security tokens, versus assets that were not intended
to be offered and sold as securities, like many other
types of crypto assets.''
Until there is a consistent, clear framework in place,
market participants, consumers, and investors will continue to
seek regulatory clarity given the requirements that stem from
the classification of a particular digital asset. This is a
reality reiterated by Greg Tusar, Vice President of
Institutional Product of Coinbase Global, Inc., during the May
2025 Joint Roundtable:
``The root of the current regulatory confusion is
token classification . . . current frameworks fail to
offer objective criteria for determinin
Committee Consideration
On May 29, 2025, Chairman Hill introduced H.R. 3633, the
CLARITY Act of 2025, with Representatives Glenn Thompson (R-
PA), Angie Craig (D-MN), Tom Emmer (R-MN), Dusty Johnson (R-
SD), Don Davis (D-NC), Bryan Steil (R-WI), Ritchie Torres (D-
NY), and Warren Davidson (R-OH), as original cosponsors.
Representatives Josh Gottheimer (D-NJ), Bill Huizenga (R-MI),
Zachary Nunn (R-IA), Mike Lawler (R-NY), Daniel Meuser (R-PA),
Buddy Carter (R-GA), Riley Moore (R-WV), Nicholas Begich (R-
AK), Kristen McDonald Rivet (D-MI), Shri Thanedar (D-MI), Mark
Messmer (R-IN), Robert Bresnahan (R-PA), and Haley Stevens (D-
MI) were added subsequently as cosponsors. The bill was
referred to the Committee on Financial Services, and in
addition to the Committee on Agriculture. The bill was attached
to the June 4, 2025, Committee on Financial Services hearing
titled ``American Innovation and the Future of Digital Assets:
From Blueprint to a Functional Framework.''
On June 10, 2025, the Committee on Financial Services met
in open session to consider, among others, H.R. 3633. The
Committee ordered H.R. 3633, as amended, to be favorably
reported to the House of Representatives.
Related Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following hearings were used to
develop H.R. 3633:
119TH CONGRESS
The Full Committee held a hearing on June 4, 2025, entitled
``American Innovation and the Future of Digital Assets: From
Blueprint to a Functional Framework.'' H.R. 3633 was attached
to the hearing. The following witnesses testified: The
Honorable Elad Roisman, Partner, Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP
and Former SEC Commissioner; Mr. Vivek Raman, Founder,
Etherealize; the Honorable Rostin Behnam, Distinguished Fellow,
Psaros Center for Financial Markets & Policy, Georgetown
University and Former CFTC Chairman; Ms. Katherine Minarik,
Chief Legal Officer, Uniswap Labs, and The Honorable Timothy
Massad, Research Fellow and Director of Digital Assets Policy
Project of the Mossavar-Rahmani Center for Business and
Government, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University
and Former CFTC Chairman.
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology,
and Artificial Intelligence held a hearing on April 9, 2025,
entitled ``American Innovation and the Future of Digital
Assets: Aligning the U.S. Securities Laws for the Digital
Age.'' The following witnesses testified: Mr. Rodrigo Seira,
Special Counsel, Cooley LLP, Ms. Tiffany J. Smith, Partner and
Co-Chair of the Blockchain & Cryptocurrency Working Group,
WilmerHale, Mr. Jake Werrett, Chief Legal Officer, Polygon, and
Ms. Alexandra Thornton, Senior Director, Financial Regulation,
Center for American Progress.
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology,
and Artificial Intelligence held a hearing on February 11,
2025, entitled ``A Golden Age of Digital Assets: Charting a
Path Forward.'' The following witnesses testified: Mr. Jonathan
Jachym, Deputy General Counsel and Global Head of Policy &
Government Relations, Kraken Digital Asset Exchange, Mr. Ji Hun
Kim, President and Acting CEO, Crypto Council for Innovation,
Mr. Coy Garrison, Partner, Steptoe LLP, Mr. Jose Fernandez da
Ponte, Senior Vice President and General Manager of Blockchain,
Crypto and Digital Currencies, PayPal, and the Honorable
Timothy Massad, Research Fellow and Director of Digital Assets
Policy Project, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard
University and Former CFTC Chairman.
118TH CONGRESS
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on June
13, 2023, titled ``The Future of Digital Assets: Providing
Clarity for the Digital Asset Ecosystem.''
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion of the Committee on Financial Services and the
Subcommittee on Commodity Markets, Digital Assets, and Rural
Development of the Committee on Agriculture held a joint
hearing on May 10, 2023, titled ``The Future of Digital Assets:
Measuring the Regulatory Gaps in the Digital Asset Markets.''
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion of the Committee on Financial Services held a
hearing on April 27, 2023, titled ``The Future of Digital
Assets: Identifying the Regulatory Gaps in Digital Asset Market
Structure.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on April
18, 2023, titled ``Oversight of the Securities and Exchange
Commission.''
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion of the Committee on Financial Services held a
hearing on March 9, 2023, titled ``Coincidence or Coordinated?
The Administration's Attack on the Digital Asset Ecosystem.''
117TH CONGRESS
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
December 13, 2022, titled ``Investigating the Collapse of
FTX.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
December 8, 2021, titled ``Digital Assets and the Feature of
Finance: Understanding the Challenges and Benefits of Financial
Innovation in the United States.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
October 5, 2021, titled ``Oversight of the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission: Wall Street's Cop Is Finally Back on the
Beat.''
The Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations held a
hearing on June 30, 2021, titled ``Will the Crypto Frenzy Lead
to Financial Independence and Early Retirement or Financial
Ruin?''
115TH CONGRESS
The Subcommittee on Capital Markets held a hearing on March
14, 2018, titled ``Examining the Cryptocurrencies and ICO
Markets.''
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee Report to include for
each record vote on a motion to report the measure or matter
and on any amendments offered to the measure or matter the
total number of votes for and against and the names of the
Members voting for and against.
On June 10, 2025, the Committee ordered H.R. 3633, as
amended, to be reported favorably to the House by a recorded
vote of 32 yeas and 19 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-169).
The Committee considered the following amendments to H.R.
3633:
Representative French Hill (R-AR) offered an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, which requires
the prudential regulators to develop capital
requirements for financial institutions that address
netting agreements, clarifies that certain blockchain
developers and service providers that do not custody or
control consumer funds are not classified as money
transmitters, requires rulemaking regarding disclosures
related to the treatment of certain assets held by SEC
registrants in the event of their insolvency and the
use of certain exemptions under securities laws, and
makes minor edits and technical changes. This amendment
was adopted by a voice vote.
Representative Maxine Waters (D-CA) offered
an amendment (No. 6), designated HR3633_T01. This
amendment would prohibit the President, Vice President,
Members of Congress, and certain members of their
families from participating or trading--directly or
indirectly--in digital asset projects. This amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a
quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-142).
Representative Brad Sherman (D-CA) offered
an amendment (No. 7), designated SHERMA_047. This
amendment would prevent federal agencies from providing
financial assistance to digital asset issuers and
exchanges in the event of failure or bankruptcy through
any emergency liquidity facility or the Exchange
Stabilization Fund. This amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present.
(Record Vote No. FC-143).
Representative Sherman offered an amendment
(No. 8), designated SHERMA_050. This amendment would
prohibit the Federal Government and Federal Reserve
banks from purchasing digital assets. This amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a
quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-144).
Representative Waters offered an amendment
(No. 9), designated HR3633_T27. This amendment would
require a person acting as a broker, dealer, or
Alternative Trading System for blockchain-based
securities to register with the SEC and all the states
in which they seek to operate. This amendment failed by
a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being
present. (Record Vote No. FC-145).
Representative Waters offered an amendment
(No. 10), designated HR3633_T25. This amendment would
establish a bill of rights for crypto investors that
requires digital asset trading platforms to develop
policies and procedures to uphold. This amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a
quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-146).
Representative Vicente Gonzalez (D-TX)
offered an amendment (No. 11), designated GONZTX_005.
This amendment would require the Treasury Secretary to
conduct a review of transnational criminal
organizations financing and submit a report to
Congress, issue guidance, and support the CFTC and SEC
with AML enforcement. This amendment is duplicative of
an amendment adopted by the House Agriculture
Committee. This amendment was withdrawn.
Representative Sean Casten (D-IL) offered an
amendment (No. 12), designated CASTEN_050. This
amendment would prevent the SEC and CFTC from jointly
issuing or finalizing rulemakings required by the
CLARITY Act unless both Commissions have three
Commissioners and one of them is affiliated with the
opposite political party of the President. This
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30
nays, a quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-147).
Representative Casten offered an amendment
(No. 13), designated CASTEN_056. This amendment would
require the Secretary of the Treasury in consultation
with FinCEN, OFAC, FBI, USS, NIST, and CISA to develop
a public-private partnership program with DeFi services
and relevant risk management experts. This amendment
also requires FinCEN to do an advisory related to the
responsible development of DeFi to strengthen
compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA). This
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30
nays, a quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-148).
Representative Sherman offered an amendment
(No. 14), designated SHERMA_051. This amendment would
prohibit political campaigns from owning or making use
of a digital asset wallet or making use of a digital
asset in connection with a political campaign
contribution. This amendment failed by a recorded vote
of 20 yeas and 31 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-149).
Representative Sherman offered an amendment
(No. 15), designated SHERMA_052. This amendment would
require hosted wallet providers to comply with Know-
Your-Customer and anti-money laundering requirements
under the BSA. This amendment failed by a recorded vote
of 20 yeas and 31 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-150).
Representative Sherman offered an amendment
(No. 16), designated SHERMA_054. This amendment would
require the Secretary of the Treasury to certify to
Congress that digital assets cannot be used to avoid
the excise tax on remittance transfers, as outlined in
H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. This amendment
was defeated by a voice vote.
Representative Sherman offered an amendment
(No. 17), designated SHERMA_055. This amendment would
reaffirm that the SEC can still regulate stocks and
bonds as securities, even if they are distributed on a
blockchain. This amendment was withdrawn.
Representative Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) offered
an amendment (No. 18), designated TLAIB_053. This
amendment would prohibit digital assets from being
traded on any platform or exchange that controls, is
controlled by, or is under common control with a
private fund. This amendment was defeated by a voice
vote.
Representative Tlaib offered an amendment
(No. 19), designated HR3633_T09. This amendment would
prohibit the government from requiring the use of a
digital asset to enter into any transaction with the
Government if it is owned, affiliated, or controlled by
the President, Vice President, or certain members of
their family. This amendment failed by a recorded vote
of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-151).
Representative Stephen Lynch (D-MA) offered
an amendment (No. 20), designated LYNCH_036. This
amendment would require the Inspectors General of the
Treasury Department and the SEC to jointly conduct an
investigation of any digital asset holdings of the
President. This amendment failed by a recorded vote of
21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-152).
Representative Lynch offered an amendment
(No. 21), designated HR3633_T07. This amendment would
require the SEC, the CFTC, and the Secretary of the
Treasury, in consultation with the Attorney General, to
re-establish the National Cryptocurrency Enforcement
Team. This amendment failed by a recorded vote of 21
yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record Vote
No. FC-153).
Representative Lynch offered an amendment
(No. 22), designated LYNCH_035. This amendment would
amend Section 314(a) of the USA PATRIOT Act to include
cyber-enabled financial crime activities, would require
FinCEN to develop a standardized form for financial
institutions to use when sharing information, and would
require FinCEN to submit a report to Congress that
evaluates whether Section 314 of the PATRIOT Act should
apply to non-financial institutions. This amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a
quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-154).
Representative Lynch offered an amendment
(No. 23), designated HR3633_T08. This amendment would
remove Section 502 from the CLARITY Act, which adds
innovation to the SEC's mission. This amendment failed
by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum
being present. (Record Vote No. FC-155).
Representative Jim Himes (D-CT) offered an
amendment (No. 24), designated HIMES_015. This
amendment would prohibit Senior Federal elected
officials from issuing a digital asset or holding a
financial interest in an issuer of a digital asset and
give these Senior officials 60 days to divest from any
such involvement. This amendment would authorize the
Attorney General to enforce this provision. This
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30
nays, a quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-156).
Representative Himes offered an amendment
(No. 25), designated HIMES_017. This amendment would
strike Section 202, which is the new exemption for
digital commodity issuers. This amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being
present. (Record Vote No. FC-157).
Representative Himes offered an amendment
(No. 26), designated HR3633_T20. This amendment would
give the SEC the ability to require additional
information to verify certifications of a blockchain's
maturity and the sole authority to determine if a
blockchain is mature. This amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being
present. (Record Vote No. FC-158).
Representative Bill Foster (D-IL) offered an
amendment (No. 27), designated FOSTER_038. This
amendment would require the Secretary of the Treasury
in consultation with the CFTC, the SEC, and FinCEN to
submit a report to Congress on the utility and
implementation of a Digital Identity Passport. This
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30
nays, a quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-159).
Representative Foster offered an amendment
(No. 28), designated HR3633_T10. This amendment would
direct the CFTC and SEC to establish a senior scam
hotline and require Bitcoin ATM operators to display
this hotline on their machines. This amendment failed
by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum
being present. (Record Vote No. FC-160).
Representative Foster offered an amendment
(No. 29), designated FOSTER_036. This amendment would
require the SEC and CFTC to jointly establish a
Financial Influencer Task Force to help investors
identify social media influencers and platforms that
have violated the law. This amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being
present. (Record Vote No. FC-161).
Representative Ayanna Pressley (D-MA)
offered an amendment (No. 30), designated PRESMA_030.
This amendment would require the GAO to conduct a study
on the financial abuse and exploitation of vulnerable
populations. This amendment failed by a recorded vote
of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-162).
Representative Sylvia Garcia (D-TX) offered
an amendment (No. 31), designated GARCTX_028. This
amendment would require individuals to submit
Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) for cross-border
digital commodity and payment stablecoin transactions
and Treasury, in consultation with the CFTC, to propose
rules establishing minimum thresholds for these SARs.
This amendment failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and
30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-
163).
Representative Garcia offered an amendment
(No. 32), designated GARCTX_029. This amendment would
establish requirements for SEC registrants to use
blockchain technology for their books and records under
Section 305 of the CLARITY Act. This amendment failed
by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum
being present. (Record Vote No. FC-164).
Representative Cleo Fields (D-LA) offered an
amendment (No. 33), designated FIELDS_006. This
amendment would require digital commodity trading
platforms to provide educational materials to their
customers that are approved by the SEC. This amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a
quorum being present. (Record Vote No. FC-165).
Representative Sam Liccardo (D-CA) offered
an amendment (No. 34), designated LICCAR_026. This
amendment would prohibit digital commodity exchanges,
brokers, dealers, and Alternative Trading Systems from
listing or trading a digital asset issued by the
President, Vice President, and certain members of their
families. This amendment failed by a recorded vote of
21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-166).
Representative Liccardo offered an amendment
(No. 35), designated LICCAR_027. This amendment would
expand the CLARITY Act's DeFi study to assess the
feasibility of implementing a regulatory sandbox where
the true identity of all users of a DeFi system can be
ascertained. This amendment failed by a recorded vote
of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being present. (Record
Vote No. FC-167).
Representative Gonzalez offered an amendment
(No. 36), designated GONZTX_005. This amendment would
require the Treasury Secretary to conduct a review of
transnational criminal organizations financing and
submit a report to Congress, issue guidance, and
support the CFTC and SEC with AML enforcement. This
amendment is duplicative of an amendment adopted by the
House Agriculture Committee. This amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 21 yeas and 30 nays, a quorum being
present. (Record Vote No. FC-168).
Committee Oversight Findings
Pursuant to clause 3(c) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 3633 is to provide
for a system of regulation of the offer and sale of digital
commodities by the SEC and the CFTC.
Committee Cost Estimate
Clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires an estimate and a comparison of the
costs that would be incurred in carrying out H.R. 3633. The
Committee has requested but not received a cost estimate from
the Director of the Congressional Budget Office. However,
pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee will
adopt as its own the cost estimate by the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office once it has been prepared.
New Budget Authority And CBO Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect
to requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII and section 402
of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, a cost estimate was
not made available to the Committee in time for the filing of
this report. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such
estimate to be printed in the Congressional Record upon its
receipt by the Committee.
Unfunded Mandates Statement
The Committee has requested but not received from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office an estimate of the
Federal mandates pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act. The Committee will adopt the estimate once
it has been prepared by the Director.
Earmark Statement
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the resolution and states that the provisions
of the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of
the rule.
Federal Advisory Committee Act Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to the Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
TITLE I--DEFINITIONS; RULEMAKING; PROVISIONAL REGISTRATION
Sec. 101. Definitions under the Securities Act of 1933
Section 101 provides for definitions under the Securities
Act of 1933.
Sec. 102. Definitions under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Section 102 provides for definitions under the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934.
Sec. 103. Definitions under the Commodity Exchange Act
Section 103 provides for definitions under the Commodity
Exchange Act.
Sec. 104. Definitions under the Act
Section 104 provides for definitions under the Act.
Sec. 105. R
Minority Views
H.R. 3633, the crypto market structure bill Democrats call
the ``CALAMITY Act,'' would legitimize the numerous crypto
scams of President Trump and his family. The bill also creates
new loopholes of other crypto companies not owned by the
President to avoid investor protections and national security
guardrails. Notably, this legislation impedes, blocks or
restricts oversight, funding, and resources to enforce
provisions related to national security, conflict of interests,
and fraud. The CALAMITY Act would also threaten overall
financial stability, as exemptions in the bill are broad enough
to create loopholes for participants to migrate from our
securities markets to this new crypto one.
Throughout the 2024 campaign trail, President Trump
promised to make America the ``crypto capital of the planet and
the Bitcoin superpower of the world.''\1\ What he didn't
mention was that he and his family were also planning to create
several new crypto companies and offer crypto products directly
to the public, including foreign governments. For example, in
the days before his inauguration and during his Presidency, the
President and his family launched a decentralized finance
(defi) platform,\2\ memecoins,\3\ a stablecoin,\4\ a Bitcoin
mining company,\5\ a Bitcoin treasury,\6\ Bitcoin ETF,\7\ and
more.\8\ Purchases of Trump's crypto products have also enabled
access to the President, and have been used by foreign
governments to facilitate commercial deals, all generating
Trump and his family more than a billion dollars. Separately,
Trump has asserted unprecedented control over what were
formerly understood to be independent financial regulators, by
firing Commissioners and Directors, and asserting approval over
the rulewriting process. And notably, President Trump has
directed Republicans in Congress\9\ to pass stablecoin and
crypto market structure legislation before August recess, even
as he and his family roll out new crypto products.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Trump pledges national Bitcoin stockpile, to make US `crypto
capital of the planet', USA Today (July 28, 2024); Trump calls for US
to be `crypto capital of the planet' in appeal to Nashville bitcoin
conference, AP News (July 27, 2024).
\2\Trump Made $57.4 Million From World Liberty Financial, New
Filing Discloses, Forbes (June 14, 2025); Trump Rolls Out His New
Cryptocurrency Business, New York Times (Sept. 16, 2024).
\3\Donald and Melania Trump launch a pair of meme coins ahead of
inauguration, raising serious ethics concerns, CNN (Jan. 20, 2025);
Trump faces crypto world backlash after launch of meme coin, The Hill
(Jan. 20, 2025).
\4\Trump's Crypto Venture Introduces New Digital Currency, New York
Times (Mar. 25, 2025).
\5\Trump family's bitcoin mining venture to go public--as Trump
crypto interests grow, CBS News (May 12, 2025).
\6\Trump Media's Bitcoin treasury registration `declared effective'
by SEC, CoinTelegraph (June 14, 2025).
\7\Trump Media seeks to launch `Truth Social bitcoin ETF',
Financial Times (June 5, 2025).
\8\Trump reports more than $600 million in income from crypto,
golf, licensing fees, Reuters (June 14, 2025).
\9\President Trump's AI and Crypto Czar, David Sacks, as well
House-Senate Bicameral Working Group on Digital Assets announced the
target goal of having stablecoin and market structure legislation
through the Senate within the first 100 days of the new Administration.
See President Trump's Crypto Czar Outlines Federal Government's New
Approach to Digital Assets, wiley (Feb. 5, 2025); Senate Committee on
Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, Scott: Congress, Trump
Administration Committed to Securing U.S. Leadership in Digital Assets
(Feb. 4, 2025).
\10\Trump holds long-awaited crypto summit, calls for bill `on his
desk' before August, Fortune (Mar. 7, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is in this context that on May 5, 2025, Chair Hill
released a revised version of crypto market structure
legislation, H.R. 3633. In his testimony before the House
Financial Services Committee, Timothy Massad, a former
Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chairman and
current Research Fellow and Director of the Digital Assets
Policy Project at Harvard University, summarized major
challenges facing the bill:
With over 200 pages of detailed, complicated
provisions, the implications of which are difficult to
assess, I fear the Clarity Act is likely to have two
principal effects: first, it will guarantee its own
obsolescence, because the technology will evolve and
the particulars of provisions will become outdated or
not relevant. Second, and of far greater danger . . .
it will generate massive exploitation of its provisions
and regulatory arbitrage.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\House Committee on Financial Services, Testimony of Timothy G.
Massad, Democratic Minority Day: Continuation of American Innovation
and the Future of Digital Assets: From Blueprint to a Functional
Framework, 119th Cong. (June 6, 2025).
The loopholes in this bill coupled with a self-profiteering
President, captured agencies, and non-existent enforcement of
current law under the Trump Administration, would allow fraud
to proliferate and result in devastating losses for not just
crypto consumers, but also for non-crypto investors who are
trying to save for college, home ownership, retirement, or
other milestones. Passing this bill into law would make
Congress complicit in Trump's numerous crypto scams and cause
lasting harm to the American economy and public.
PRESIDENT TRUMP'S CRYPTO CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
The CALAMITY Act would not just enable large-scale
conflicts of interest from Trump and his family, it would send
a message that Congress approves and validates the way he is
selling access to the White House, both domestically and
abroad. Existing executive branch ethics requirements contain
loopholes and gaps that can be easily exploited, and certain
conflicts of interest laws exempt the President and Vice
President. This has paved the way for unprecedented corruption
and unchecked self-profiteering. For example, according to
ethics and anti-corruption experts, Democracy Defenders Action:
If President Trump were subject to the same criminal
conflict of interest statute, 18 U.S.C. 208, that
applies to other executive branch employees, he would
have been prohibited from signing the March 23
Executive Order . . . [And] if he were subject to
section 208 like other executive branch employee who
may have interests in stablecoins, he would be barred
from working on legislation that would be viewed as a
particular matter . . .\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Democracy Defenders Fund, Trump's Crypto Conflicts of Interest:
A Growing Concern (Apr. 23, 2025).
The Trump family's high-profile conflicts of interest were
elevated a few days before the presidential inauguration.
President Trump and First Lady Melania Trump launched their own
memecoins ($TRUMP and $MELANIA), with $TRUMP earning a
staggering $350 million in the three weeks after it was
launched, from sales and fees alone.\13\ While early, likely
inside investors profited off of the memecoins, most investors
lost a staggering $2 billion as the coins value plummeted.\14\
Later on, Trump announced that the 220 largest holders would be
invited to an exclusive memecoin dinner at his luxury golf
resort on May 22nd, for which attendees, including foreign
investors, spent millions of dollars to secure a seat.\15\ The
CALAMITY Act exempts memecoins from regulation, leaving them,
including Trump's memecoin, to operate with no oversight at
all. One Committee hearing witness, Professor Timothy Massad,
raised a critical point during his testimony:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Helen Partz, Donald Trump's memecoin generated $350M for
creators: Report, CoinTelegraph (Mar. 07, 2025).
\14\Early Crypto Traders Had Speedy Profit on Trump Coin as Others
Suffered Losses, New York Times (Feb. 9, 2025).
\15\Democracy Defenders Fund, Trump's Crypto Conflicts of Interest:
A Growing Concern (Apr. 23, 2025).
In the words of Vitalik Buterin, [memecoins] are
vehicles for `unlimited political bribery,' because
those seeking to curry favor with the Administration--
whether they be individuals, companies or countries--
may purchase the coins, knowing the President will
profit from their actions, while they can still deny
that seeking government favoritism was their purpose.
Instead, they can claim they were merely speculating on
a digital asset.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\House Committee on Financial Services, Testimony of Timothy G.
Massad, Democratic Minority Day: Continuation of American Innovation
and the Future of Digital Assets: From Blueprint to a Functional
Framework, 119th Cong. (June 6, 2025).
In addition to dropping or pausing ongoing enforcement
cases against Trump's donors and crypto investors,\17\ the SEC
has also issued statements declaring that certain digital
assets, which include crypto products issued or backed by the
Trump family, are not subject to SEC oversight.\18\ More
recently, on June 13, the SEC approved the Trump Media and
Technology Group's (Trump Media) $2.3 billion Bitcoin treasury
deal, one of the largest Bitcoin treasury deals for a public
company.\19\ On Monday, June 16, President Trump's social media
company, Truth Social, also filed a registration form with the
SEC to launch a dual exchange-traded fund (ETF) for Bitcoin and
Ether.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Matthew Goldstein, S.E.C. Drops Lawsuit Against Binance, a
Crypto Exchange, New York Times (May 29, 2025); Rebecca Balhaus, et.
al., Trump Family Has Held Deal Talks With Binance Following Crypto
Exchange's Guilty Plea, Wall Street Journal (Mar. 13, 2025).
\18\Crypto group Tron to go public after US pauses probe into
billionaire founder, Financial Times (June 16, 2025); Securities and
Exchange Commission, Statement on Stablecoins (Apr. 4, 2025);
Securities and Exchange Commission, Statement on certain proof-of-work
mining activities (Mar. 20, 2025); Securities and Exchange Commission,
Staff Statement on Meme Coins (Feb. 27, 2025).
\19\Trump Media's Bitcoin treasury registration `declared
effective' by SEC, CoinTelegraph (June 14, 2025).
\20\Trump's Truth Social files S-1 for dual Bitcoin and Ether ETF,
CoinTelegraph (June 16, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Not only is Trump and his family, personally and
financially involved in the crypto space through their numerous
crypto businesses, the President also stands to be the largest
direct competitor in the ecosystem. In addition to flouting
ethics standards, Trump has continued to undermine the
independence of the historically bipartisan independent federal
financial agencies. Trump has targeted Democratic appointees
who are protected from removal by the president and can only be
terminated for cause and fired the Democratic Directors of the
National Credit Union Administration, and Commissioners of the
Federal Trade Commission. In her testimony before the House
Financial Services Committee, Amanda Fischer, Policy Director
and COO at Better Markets, discussed this issue:
Federal financial regulatory agencies are under siege
in the current Administration. Democratic
commissioners, dually nominated by the President and
confirmed by the Senate, have been fired without cause,
with the Supreme Court in a two-page decision declining
to place an injunction on the firings. [Soon], the CFTC
will only have one Commissioner, with no further
Commissioner nominations on the horizon. Absent a
nomination by the President, the SEC is separately set
to have a three-member Republican-only commission by
the end of 2025, despite the statutory requirement and
long history of being bipartisan.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\House Committee on Financial Services, Testimony of Amanda
Fischer, Democratic Minority Day: Continuation of American Innovation
and the Future of Digital Assets: From Blueprint to a Functional
Framework, 119th Cong. (June 6, 2025).
This represents an attack on critical democratic safeguards and
sends a message to both Democratic and Republican leaders at
two regulators overseeing this market, the SEC and CFTC.
President Trump also released an executive order stating
that rules drafted by Federal financial regulators must be
reviewed and approved by the Office of Information and
Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) within the White House's Office of
Management and Budget (OMB).\22\ Financial agencies like the
Federal Reserve (Fed), Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
(FDIC), Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), the
National Credit Union Association (NCUA), the SEC, and the CFTC
have traditionally issued regulations independent of the
political influence of the White House. However, when
conducting these reviews, OIRA must now run an interagency
review process to allow other agencies to provide feedback as
well.\23\ As a result, Trump and others in his Administration
would also have a direct hand in reviewing and modifying the
rules implementing the CALAMITY Act to maximize profits for the
crypto companies they own. The CALAMITY Act does nothing to
address these massive conflicts of interest, allowing the
President and his family, along with others in his
Administration, to gain from their government positions,
ensuring the new regulatory framework works best for their
digital assets, if not outright undermining competing digital
asset products. Testifying before the Committee, one panelist,
Bartlett Naylor, a Financial Policy Advocate at Public Citizen,
urged Congress to ``not abdicate any powers to hold Trump
accountable. Without conflict-of-interest guardrails, approving
these bills effectively endorses Trump's conflicts. The bills
will integrate crypto into mainstream banking, serving to
fatten his grift.''\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Federal Register, Executive Order 14215--Ensuring
Accountability for All Agencies (Feb. 18, 2025).
\23\See Obama White House Archives, About OIRA (accessed Apr. 10,
2025).
\24\House Committee on Financial Services, Testimony of Bartlett
Collins Naylor, Democratic Minority Day: Continuation of American
Innovation and the Future of Digital Assets: From Blueprint to a
Functional Framework, 119th Cong. (June 6, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
INCREASED INVESTOR HARM
The CALAMITY Act includes several sections that will
increase and create new harm to investors. A few of these
provisions include:
1. Section 106 creates a provisional registration
process that would allow entities to escape regulation
and oversight while the rules of the bill are written.
To make matters worse, the provisional registration
process is silent on whether the SEC or state
regulators may bring enforcement actions against an
entity that has filed a statement of provisional
registration, so harmed investors would have little
recourse from these entities.
2. Section 202 would bring unprecedented risk to
investors through a new exemption at the SEC, labeled
the 4(a)(8) exemption. It would allow crypto firms to
raise $75 million per year for four years, if they
intend to become a ``mature blockchain system'' (which
is explained below). This exemption allows firms to
engage in general solicitation of retail investors,
which means that everyday investors could be peddled
securities, which would not include audited financials
or issuer obligations to continually disclose material
facts about the project. Non-accredited investors
(i.e., retail investors) would be able to purchase
crypto assets up to all of their net worth or annual
income, which is a stark contrast to the Regulation A
(``Reg A'') exemption, which limits non-accredited
investors to investing up to 10% of their income or net
worth.\25\ Firms taking advantage of Reg A must provide
audited financials,\26\ a business description,
material risk factors, use of proceeds, and other
disclosures.\27\ They also are subject to ongoing
reporting requirements\28\ and SEC approval\29\ for the
offering.\30\ Most worryingly, state securities
regulators are explicitly barred from regulating this
new exempt offering even though the SEC rarely brings
enforcement actions when harms are small. And
inexplicably, there are no requirements that the funds
raised by a crypto company must go towards developing
the crypto business or its blockchain, as is required
of other securities offerings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\17 CFR Sec. 230.251(d)(2)(C).
\26\17 CFR Sec. 230.252(d) (``An offering statement must contain
audited financial statements for Tier 2 offerings.'').
\27\17 CFR Sec. 239.90--Form 1-A content requirements.
\28\17 CFR Sec. 230.257--Ongoing reporting obligations for Tier 2
issuers.
\29\SEC approval is also referred to as the term,
``qualification.''
\30\17 CFR Sec. 230.251(d)(2)(i) (``No sale of securities may be
made until the offering statement has been qualified by order of the
Commission.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Section 205 creates a mechanism for ``digital
commodity issuer, digital commodity related person,
digital commodity affiliated person, or decentralized
governance system of the blockchain system'' to escape
SEC oversight by self-certifying that their blockchain
is a ``mature blockchain.'' Section 205 defines a
``mature blockchain system'' as--among other criteria
related to its functions--a blockchain that ``is not
controlled by any person or group of persons under
common control.''\31\ However, this threshold raises
various issues. According to testimony from Lee
Reiners, a Lecturing Fellow at Duke University, ``There
have been several examples of venture capital firms
controlling less than 20% of governance tokens and
still exerting considerable influence over a digital
asset.''\32\ This section also allows a loophole for
unilateral control to carry out ``regular maintenance''