Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4312]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4312) to protect the name, image, and likeness
rights of student athletes and to promote fair competition with
respect to intercollegiate athletics, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 11
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 11
Committee Action................................................. 13
Committee Votes.................................................. 13
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 16
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 16
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 16
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 16
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 16
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 16
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 16
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 17
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 17
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 17
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 17
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 17
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 21
Minority, Additional, or Dissenting Views........................ 68
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Student Compensation and Opportunity
through Rights and Endorsements Act'' or the ``SCORE Act''.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Agent.--The term ``agent'' means an individual who
receives compensation to represent a student athlete with
respect to--
(A) a name, image, and likeness agreement; or
(B) another agreement for compensation related to the
participation of such student athlete on a varsity
sports team.
(2) Antitrust laws.--The term ``antitrust laws'' has the
meaning given such term in the 1st section of the Clayton Act
(15 U.S.C. 12) and includes section 5 of the Federal Trade
Commission Act (15 U.S.C. 45) to the extent that such section 5
applies to unfair methods of competition.
(3) Associated entity or individual.--The term ``associated
entity or individual'' means, with respect to an institution,
each of the following:
(A) An entity that is known or should be known to the
employees of the athletic department of such
institution to exist, in significant part, for the
purpose of--
(i) promoting or supporting the varsity
sports teams or student athletes of such
institution; or
(ii) creating or identifying opportunities
relating to name, image, and likeness
agreements solely for the student athletes of
such institution.
(B) An individual who is or has been a member,
employee, director, officer, owner, or other
representative of an entity described in subparagraph
(A).
(C) An individual who directly or indirectly
(including through contributions by an entity
affiliated with such individual or an immediate family
member of such individual) has contributed more than
$50,000 (as adjusted on July 1 each year by the
percentage increase (if any), during the preceding 12-
month period, in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban
Consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics)
over the lifetime of the individual to the athletic
programs of such institution or to an entity described
in subparagraph (A).
(D) An individual or entity who--
(i) is directed or requested by the employees
of the athletic department of such institution
to assist in the recruitment or retention of
prospective student athletes or student
athletes, respectively; or
(ii) otherwise assists in such recruitment or
retention.
(E) Any entity (other than a publicly traded
corporation) owned, controlled, operated by, or
otherwise affiliated with an individual or entity
described in subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D).
(4) College sports revenue.--The term ``college sports
revenue'' means any revenue (without regard to ownership or
legal title to such revenue) received by an institution with
respect to intercollegiate athletics--
(A) from the sale of admission to intercollegiate
athletic competitions or any other event involving a
varsity sports team, including actual monetary revenue
received by or for the benefit of such institution for
a suite license (unless such suite license is
associated with philanthropy or any purpose not related
to intercollegiate athletic competitions, including a
concert);
(B) from participation by the varsity sports teams of
such institution in intercollegiate athletic
competitions held at other institutions, including
payments received due to cancellations of such
intercollegiate athletic competitions;
(C) for radio, television, internet, digital, and e-
commerce rights, including revenue relating to media
rights distributed by a conference to members of the
conference, if applicable;
(D) from an interstate intercollegiate athletic
association, including any grant, distribution of
revenue, reimbursement relating to travel with respect
to a championship of such interstate intercollegiate
athletic association, and payment for hosting such a
championship;
(E) generated by a post-season football bowl,
including any distribution of revenue by a conference
to members of the conference and any other payment
related to the participation of such institution in
such post-season football bowl, including for ticket
sales and reimbursement of expenses;
(F) from a conference, other than any revenue
otherwise described in this paragraph;
(G) for sponsorships, licensing agreements,
advertisements, royalties, and in-kind products and
services as part of a sponsorship agreement; or
(H) relating to any additional form of revenue,
including fundraising, an interstate intercollegiate
athletic association uses with respect to the pool
limit of such interstate intercollegiate athletic
association.
(5) Compensation.--The term ``compensation''--
(A) means, with respect to a student athlete or a
prospective student athlete, any form of payment or
remuneration, whether provided through cash, benefits,
awards, or any other means, including payments for--
(i) licenses relating to, or the use of,
name, image, and likeness rights; or
(ii) licenses relating to, or the use of, any
other Federal or State intellectual or
intangible property right; and
(B) does not include--
(i) grants-in-aid;
(ii) Federal Pell Grants and other Federal or
State grants unrelated to and not awarded with
regard to participation in intercollegiate
athletics;
(iii) health insurance and payments for the
costs of health care, including health
insurance and payments for the costs of health
care wholly or partly self-funded by an
institution, conference, or interstate
intercollegiate athletic association;
(iv) disability and loss-of-value insurance,
including disability and loss-of-value
insurance that is wholly or partly self-funded
by an institution, conference, or interstate
intercollegiate athletic association;
(v) career counseling, job placement
services, and other guidance available to all
students at an institution;
(vi) payment of hourly wages and benefits for
work actually performed (and not for
participation in intercollegiate athletics) at
a rate commensurate with the going rate in the
locality of an institution for similar work;
(vii) academic awards paid to student
athletes by institutions;
(viii) provision of financial literacy or tax
education resources and guidance; or
(ix) any program to connect student athletes
with employers and facilitate employment
opportunities, if--
(I) the financial terms of such
employment opportunities are consistent
with the terms offered to similarly
situated employees who are not student
athletes; and
(II) such program is not used to
induce a student athlete to attend a
particular institution.
(6) Conference.--The term ``conference'' means an entity
that--
(A) has as members 2 or more institutions;
(B) arranges regular season intercollegiate athletic
competitions and championships for such members; and
(C) sets rules with respect to such intercollegiate
athletic competitions and championships.
(7) Cost of attendance.--The term ``cost of attendance'' has
the meaning given such term in section 472 of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1087ll).
(8) Grant-in-aid.--The term ``grant-in-aid'' means a
scholarship, grant, stipend, or other form of financial
assistance, including the provision of tuition, room, board,
books, or funds for fees or personal expenses, that--
(A) is paid or provided by an institution to a
student for the undergraduate or graduate course of
study of the student; and
(B) is in an amount that does not exceed the cost of
attendance at the institution for such student.
(9) Image.--The term ``image'' means, with respect to a
student athlete, a picture or a video that identifies, is
linked to, or is reasonably linkable to such student athlete.
(10) Institution.--The term ``institution'' has the meaning
given the term ``institution of higher education'' in section
102 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1002).
(11) Intercollegiate athletic competition.--The term
``intercollegiate athletic competition'' means any contest,
game, meet, match, tournament, regatta, or other event in which
varsity sports teams of more than 1 institution compete.
(12) Intercollegiate athletics.--The term ``intercollegiate
athletics''--
(A) means the varsity sports teams for which the
length of time a student athlete is eligible to
participate and the academic standards for
participation are established by a conference or an
interstate intercollegiate athletic association; and
(B) does not include any recreational, intramural, or
club teams.
(13) Interstate intercollegiate athletic association.--The
term ``interstate intercollegiate athletic association''
means--
(A) any entity that--
(i) sets common rules, standards, procedures,
or guidelines for the administration and
regulation of varsity sports teams and
intercollegiate athletic competitions;
(ii) is composed of 2 or more institutions or
conferences located in more than 1 State; and
(iii) has rules or bylaws prohibiting the
provision of prohibited compensation to student
athletes and prospective student athletes; and
(B) does not include any entity affiliated with
professional athletic competitions.
(14) Likeness.--The term ``likeness'' means, with respect to
a student athlete, a physical or digital depiction or
representation that identifies, is linked to, or is reasonably
linkable to such student athlete.
(15) Name.--The term ``name'' means, with respect to a
student athlete, the first, middle, or last name, or the
nickname or former name, of such student athlete if used in a
context that identifies, is linked to, or is reasonably
linkable to such student athlete.
(16) Name, image, and likeness agreement.--The term ``name,
image, and likeness agreement'' means a contract or similar
agreement under which a student athlete licenses or authorizes,
or a contract or similar agreement that otherwise is in
relation to, the commercial use of the name, image, or likeness
of the student athlete.
(17) Name, image, and likeness rights.--The term ``name,
image, and likeness rights'' means rights recognized under
Federal or State law that allow an individual to control and
profit from the commercial use of the name, image, and likeness
of such individual, including all rights commonly referred to
as ``publicity rights''.
(18) Pool limit.--The term ``pool limit'' means a dollar
amount based on college sports revenue that--
(A) is calculated and published by an interstate
intercollegiate athletic association pursuant to the
rules the interstate intercollegiate athletic
association establishes under section 6; and
(B) serves as the annual maximum amount that an
institution that is a member of such interstate
intercollegiate athletic association may provide, in
total, to student athletes of such institution,
including in the form of a name, image, and likeness
agreement or direct payment.
(19) Prohibited compensation.--The term ``prohibited
compensation'' means--
(A) compensation (including an agreement for
compensation) to a student athlete from an associated
entity or individual of the institution at which the
student athlete is enrolled (or to a prospective
student athlete from an associated entity or individual
of an institution for which the prospective student
athlete is being recruited) for any license or use of
the name, image, and likeness rights of such student
athlete or prospective student athlete (or any other
license or use), unless the license or use is for a
valid business purpose related to the promotion or
endorsement of goods or services provided to the
general public for profit, with compensation at rates
and terms commensurate with compensation paid to
individuals with name, image, and likeness rights of
comparable value who are not student athletes or
prospective student athletes with respect to such
institution; and
(B) compensation to a student athlete (or a
prospective student athlete) if such compensation is
paid by or on behalf of the institution at which the
student athlete is enrolled (or for which the
prospective student athlete is being recruited) and
results in the exceeding of the pool limit established
by the interstate intercollegiate athletic association
of which such institution is a member.
(20) Prospective student athlete.--The term ``prospective
student athlete'' means an individual who is solicited to
enroll at an institution by, or at the direction of, an
employee or an associated entity or individual of the
institution in order for such individual to participate in a
varsity sports team of such institution.
(21) State.--The term ``State'' means each State of the
United States, the District of Columbia, and each commonwealth,
territory, or possession of the United States.
(22) Student athlete.--The term ``student athlete'' means an
individual who--
(A) is enrolled or has agreed to enroll at an
institution; and
(B) participates in a varsity sports team of such
institution.
(23) Varsity sports team.--The term ``varsity sports team''
means an entity composed of an individual or group of
individuals enrolled at an institution that is organized by
such institution for the purpose of partic
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 4312 establishes a federal framework governing Name,
Image, and Likeness (NIL) rights for college student-athletes.
It defines key terms used throughout the legislation, including
associated entity or individual, college sports revenue,
Interstate Intercollegiate Athletic Associations (IIAA), pool
limit, and prohibited compensation. It affirms the rights of
student-athletes to enter into NIL agreements, including the
right to representation, privacy, and transparent agreements.
The bill prohibits colleges, conferences, and IIAAs from
restricting those rights or penalizing athletes for engaging in
NIL deals which are to be enforced by State Attorney's General.
H.R. 4312 modifies the Sports Agent Responsibility and
Trust Act (SPARTA) to reflect the new NIL environment. It
requires agents involved in NIL deals to disclose if they are
registered with an IIAA and caps agent fees at five percent.
The bill also removes outdated provisions in SPARTA related to
eligibility risk when hiring agents.
The legislation codifies benefits such as continued access
to medical coverage, academic support services, and scholarship
protections. It authorizes IIAAs to establish and enforce rules
related to collecting and sharing NIL data, prohibited
compensation, recruitment of student athletes, the revenue
sharing pool limit, transferring between schools, student-
athlete eligibility, and competition and championship
management.
Further, the legislation includes limits on liability
conditioned on compliance with Section 6 of the Act. The bill
requires IIAAs to have a governance structure to include
student athletes. H.R. 4312 affirms student-athletes are
student-athletes, and the bill clarifies employment-related
obligations for academic institutions under state and federal
labor laws. The legislation requires public reporting of the
use of student fees to fund athletic programs and prohibits
top-revenue programs from using student fees to cover
intercollegiate athletics costs. Additionally, it preempts any
state or local laws that conflict with the Act. Finally, the
H.R. 4312 requires studies and reports, including a Federal
Trade Commission study on a potential independent agent
certification program, regular compliance reports from IIAAs
and the Comptroller General, and a separate Comptroller General
study on the bill's impact on Olympic sports.
Background and Need for Legislation
The adoption of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) rights for
collegiate athletes has fundamentally altered the landscape of
college sports by enabling student-athletes to profit from
their personal brands. While there is widespread support for
this long overdue change, the current system--characterized by
rapid implementation, lack of transparency, and inconsistent
regulation--lacks long-term viability.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Sportse Media, NIL Is a Bad: How the Current System Is Failing
College Sports, SportsEpreneur (May 18, 2025), https://
sportsepreneur.com/nil-is-bad-system-failing-college-sports/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For years, the National Collegiate Athletic Association
(NCAA) had strict amateurism rules prohibiting student-athletes
from profiting off of the commercialization of their NIL.\2\
Beginning on July 1, 2021, the NCAA allowed student-athletes to
profit from commercial use of their NIL, and permitted schools
and conferences to establish their own NIL policies, provided
they adhere to state laws.\3\ This shift followed several court
decisions related to NCAA antitrust violations.\4\ Since the
rule change, over 30 different state NIL laws have gone into
effect.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\See NCAA, Nat'l Collegiate Athletic Ass'n Const., Art. 1.3.1, in
2002-03 NCAA Division I Manual (2002).
\3\NCAA Media Center, NCAA adopts interim name, image and likeness
policy, NCAA, (June 30, 2021, at 16:20 ET), https://www.ncaa.org/news/
2021/6/30/ncaa-adopts-interim-name-image-and-likeness-policy.aspx.
\4\Claire Haws, The Death of Amateurism in the NCAA: How the NCAA
Can Survive the New Economic Reality of College Sports, Michigan
Business & Entrepreneurial L. Rev., Vol. 11, Iss. 2, (2022), https://
repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/
viewcontent.cgi?article=1132&context=mbelr.
\5\Troutman Pepper Locke, State and Federal Legislation Tracker
(last updated May 5, 2025), https://www.troutman.com/state-and-federal-
nil-legislation-tracker.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After years of legal battles on antitrust grounds, a
historic settlement was reached between the NCAA, the power
conferences, and former college athletes on June 6, 2025.\6\
The $2.8 billion agreement in House v. NCAA allows Division I
schools to directly compensate athletes starting July 1, 2025,
effectively ending the NCAA's amateurism model.\7\ While the
settlement provides retroactive payments and a new compensation
structure, it also introduces legal and operational
uncertainties that have intensified calls for federal
regulation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Ross Dellenger, NCAA's House Settlement Approved, Ushering in
New Era Where Schools Can Directly Pay Athletes, Yahoo! Sports, (June
6, 2025), https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/ncaas-
house-settlement-approved-ushering-in-new-era-where-schools-can-
directly-pay-athletes-011814078.html.
\7\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The rapidly evolving NIL landscape, combined with the
absence of consistent and enforceable rules around athlete
eligibility and the transfer portal, has intensified recruiting
battles and led to a surge in student-athlete transfers.
Meanwhile, the rise of donor-funded collectives and increased
booster involvement has normalized pay-for-play arrangements,
raising serious concerns about academic integrity and the
erosion of amateurism in college sports. With the 2025
settlement allowing institutions to directly compensate student
athletes, whether student-athletes should be classified as
employees is a pivotal question. Classifying student-athletes
as employees, however, would likely place enormous financial
burdens on college athletic departments and create additional
legal uncertainty, possibly forcing schools to cut programs and
reduce opportunities for student-athletes nationwide.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Nick Tremps, The Memorandum heard Around the College Athletics
World: Why Student-Athletes in Non-Revenue-Generating Sports Should not
Enjoy the Status of ``Employee'' Under the NLRA, 14 Wake Forest L. Rev.
Online 47, 47-68 (Apr. 1, 2025), https://www.wakeforestlawreview.com/
2024/04/the-memorandum-heard-around-the-college-athletics-world-why-
student-athletes-in-non-revenue-generating-sports-should-not-enjoy-the-
status-of-employee-under-the-nlra/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Action
On March 4, 2025, the Subcommittee on Commerce,
Manufacturing, and Trade held a hearing on name, image and
likeness issues in college sports. The title of the hearing
was, ``Moving the Goalposts: How NIL is Reshaping College
Athletics.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Shane Beamer, Head Football Coach,
University of South Carolina;
Josh Whitman, Director of Athletics,
University of Illinois;
Emily Cole, All-American Track Athlete, Duke
University '24;
Anthony Egbo Jr., Football Athlete, Abilene
Christian University '24;
Justin Falcinelli, Former College Athlete,
Clemson Football, and Vice President, College Football
Players Association.
On June 12, 2025, the Subcommittee on Commerce,
Manufacturing, and Trade held a legislative hearing on a
discussion draft of H.R. 4312. The title of the hearing was,
``Winning Off the Field: Legislative Proposal to Stabilize NIL
and College Athletics.'' The Subcommittee received testimony
from:
William King, Associate Commissioner/Legal
Affairs Compliance, Southeastern Conference;
Sherika Montgomery, Commissioner, Big South
Conference;
Ashley Cozad, Swimming Student Athlete and
Division I SAAC Chair, University of North Florida '24;
Ramogi Huma, Executive Director, National
College Players Association.
On July 15, 2025, the Subcommittee on Commerce,
Manufacturing, and Trade met in open markup session and
forwarded H.R. 4312, without amendment, to the full Committee
by a record vote of 12 yeas and 11 nays.
On July 23, 2025, the full Committee on Energy and Commerce
met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 4312, as amended,
favorably reported to the House by a record vote of 30 yeas and
23 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held hearings and made findings that
are reflected in this report.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 4312 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to protect
the name, image, and likeness rights of student athletes and to
promote fair competition with respect to intercollegiate
athletics.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 4312 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
related hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 4312:
On March 4, 2025, the Subcommittee on
Commerce, Manufacturing, and Trade held a hearing on
name, image and likeness issues in college sports. The
title of the hearing was, ``Moving the Goalposts: How
NIL is Reshaping College Athletics.'' The Subcommittee
received testimony from:
Shane Beamer, Head Football
Coach, University of South Carolina;
Josh Whitman, Director of
Athletics, University of Illinois;
Emily Cole, All-American Track
Athlete, Duke University '24;
Anthony Egbo Jr., Football
Athlete, Abilene Christian University '24; and
Justin Falcinelli, Former
College Athlete, Clemson Football, and Vice
President, College Football Players
Association.
On June 12, 2025, the Subcommittee on
Commerce, Manufacturing, and Trade held a legislative
hearing on a discussion draft of H.R. 4312. The title
of the hearing was ``Winning Off the Field: Legislative
Proposal to Stabilize NIL and College Athletics.'' The
Subcommittee received testimony from:
William King, Associate
Commissioner/Legal Affairs Compliance,
Southeastern Conference;
Sherika Montgomery,
Commissioner, Big South Conference;
Ashley Cozad, Swimming Student
Athlete and Division I SAAC Chair, University
of North Florida '24; and
Ramogi Huma, Executive Director,
National College Players Association.
Committee Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 4312 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short title
This Section provides the short title of the bill: the
``Student Compensation and Opportunity through Rights and
Endorsements Act.''
Section 2. Definitions
This Section defines key terms used throughout the bill,
including:
Associated Entity or Individual: An entity
or individual tied to a specific school's athletic
program--such as boosters, NIL collectives, or large
donors--who promotes or supports student-athletes or
helps arrange name, image, and likeness (NIL)
opportunities.
College sports revenue: revenue generated by
college athletic programs from sources including:
Ticket sales;
Media rights (TV, internet,
radio);
Sponsorships and licensing;
Conference and association
distributions;
Postseason games (e.g., bowl
games); or
Advertising, royalties, and in-
kind sponsorships.
Interstate Intercollegiate Athletic
Association (IIAA): An entity made up of schools from
different states that:
Sets rules for college sports;
Has rules or bylaws prohibiting
the provision of prohibited compensation to
student-athletes and prospective student-
athletes; and
Pool limit: An IIAA-set cap limiting the
amount a school can pay student-athletes out of college
sports revenue in a given year.
Prohibited Compensation: Payments or
agreements that are not considered ``valid business
purposes''' or exceed the pool limit as determined by
an IIAA.
Section 3. Protection of name, image, and likeness rights of student-
athletes
Section 3 affirms the right of student-athletes to enter
into NIL agreements in most circumstances by barring
institutions, conferences, and IIAAs from restricting such
agreements with two exceptions including, NIL agreements that
violate an institution's student code of conduct or interfere
with the terms of an institution's existing contracts or
similar agreements; or NIL agreements that provide prohibited
compensation, as defined in Section 2.
This Section prohibits institutions, conferences, or IIAAs
from releasing information about an NIL agreement without a
student-athletes express written consent; or restricting a
student-athlete's ability to obtain an agent.
This Section affirms the right of student-athletes to
transparent agreements, requiring a written agreement for
student-agent contracts, among other transparency requirements.
Lastly, this section enables State Attorney's General to bring
a civil action on behalf of their residents whenever it
believes a violation of this section has threatened or
adversely affected an interest of a resident.
Section 4. Modifications to Sports Agent Responsibility and Trust Act
Section 4 updates the Sports Agent Responsibility and Trust
Act (SPARTA) (15 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 7801) to reflect the role of
agents supporting NIL agreements and require agents to disclose
if they are registered with an IIAA. This Section prohibits an
agent from charging fees over 5 percent, requires an agent
agreement with a student athlete to include a provision
allowing the student athlete to terminate the agreement should
they no longer be enrolled at an institution, and strikes
current `warning to student-athlete' language in SPARTA and
replaces it with a required disclosure of if the agent is not
registered with an IIAA.
Section 5. Requirements applicable to certain institutions
Section 5 establishes requirements that institutions must
meet, including providing comprehensive academic support and
career counseling services to student-athletes, providing
medical and health benefits to student-athletes, protection of
grant-in-aid provided to a student-athlete related to their
involvement in intercollegiate athletics regardless of their
athletic performance, contribution to team success, injury,
illness, physical or mental condition, or receipt of
compensation pursuant to an NIL agreement, providing a degree
completion program; and maintaining at least 16 varsity sports
teams after the date July 1, 2027.
The Section establishes that an institution may carry out
these requirements in conjunction with a conference or IIAA.
The section also establishes that an institution is covered by
this section if any member of the coaching staff of a varsity
sports team earns more than $250,000 in base annual salary (as
adjusted annually on July 1 based on the Consumer Price Index
for All Urban Consumers published by the Bureau of Labor
Statistics.
Section 6. Roles of interstate intercollegiate athletic associations
This section authorizes IIAA's to establish and enforce
rules with respect to:
Requiring student-athletes or prospective
student-athletes to disclose the terms of NIL
agreements they enter into;
Establishing a database for collecting and
publicly sharing anonymized data related to NIL
agreements of student-athletes;
Compensation, including processes for
dispute resolution and penalties;
Setting parameters for the manner in which
and the time period during which student athletes and
prospective student athletes may be recruited for
intercollegiate athletics;
Calculating a pool limit, if such rules
provide that such pool limit is at least 22 percent of
the average annual college sports revenue of the 70
highest earning (with respect to such revenue) member
institutions of such interstate intercollegiate
athletic association;
Setting parameters for the manner in which a
student athlete may transfer between institutions;
The length of time a student athlete is
eligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics
and the academic standards to be eligible to
participate in intercollegiate athletics;
Establishing qualifications for and a
process for registration of NIL agents;
Management of membership and participation
in IIAA, including championship events; and
Intercollegiate athletic competitions and
playing seasons, including rules with respect to season
length, maximum number of contests, and student-athlete
time demands (both during and outside of a playing
season).
This Section conditions authority on compliance with
section 3 and the requirements in Section 6. This Section
describes IIAA governance structures, requiring any board,
committee, or other body to consist of at least 20 percent
student-athletes, with men and women being equally represented,
and each student-athlete representing a different sport, and at
least 30 percent of institutions that are not among the 70
highest-earning member institutions. This Section establishes a
council to serve as the primary deliberative body of the IIAA.
Section 7. Liability limitation
Section 7 establishes the adoption of, agreement to,
compliance with, or enforcement of any rule, regulation,
requirement, standard, or other provision established pursuant
to, or in compliance with, section 6 of this Act shall be
treated as lawful under the antitrust laws and any similar
State Section 7 also establishes a rule of construction that
clarifies that the bill does not exempt college sports from any
laws other than antitrust laws and that this exemption is
limited to the narrowly tailored rules listed in section 6.
Section 8. Employment standing
Section 9 establishes that no individual may be considered
an employee of an institution, conference, or IIAA based on the
participation of such individual with a varsity sports team or
in an intercollegiate athletic competition as a student-
athlete.
Section 9. Student athletic fees
Section 9 makes multiple amendments to the Higher Education
Act of 1965. Subsection (a) creates transparency and
publication requirements for fees charged to students to
support intercollegiate athletic programs. Subsection (b) makes
changes regarding media rights revenues and establishes that
institutions which had annual media rights revenues of
$50,000,000 or more in the most recent completed fiscal year
may not use student fees to support intercollegiate athletic
programs in the immediately following fiscal year. The
amendments made to the Higher Education Act of 1965 under this
section come into effect on July 1, 2026.
Section 10. Preemption
Section 10 provides that no state or political subdivision
of a State may maintain, enforce, prescribe, or continue any
law, rule, regulation, requirement, standard, or other
provision having the force and effect of law that conflict with
this Act; that governs or regulates the compensation, payment,
benefits, or employment status of a student-athlete, including
anything that relates to the right of a student athlete to
receive compensation directly or indirectly from an
institution, associated entity or individual, conference, or
IIAA or anything related to the length of time a student
athlete is eligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics
or the academic standards to be eligible to participate in
intercollegiate athletics; limits or restricts a right provided
to an institution, conference, or IIAA under this Act; or
requires a release of license to use the NIL of any
participant(s) in an intercollegiate athletic competition for
purposes of audio-visual, audio, or visual broadcasts or other
distributions of such intercollegiate athletic competition.
Section 10 also provides a rule of construction clarifying
that the preemption in this Act does not preempt state common
law and State laws of generally applicability.
Section 11. Reports
Section 11 requires the Federal Trade Commission to study
and report the impacts of establishing a program administered
by an entity independent of any institution, conference, or
IIAA to develop standards, certification, and other regulations
for agents who enter into agreements with student athletes. It
also requires the Comptroller General of the U.S., not 5 years
after enactment, to conduct an investigation with respect to
compliance with the Act and submit a report to congress that
includes a summary of findings and recommendation to improve
the health, safety, and educational opportunities of student
athletes and conduct a study to assess the impact of this Act
on Olympic Sports and report it Congress not 2 years after the
date of enactment.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
SPORTS AGENT RESPONSIBILITY AND TRUST ACT
* * * * * * *
SEC. 3. REGULATION OF UNFAIR AND DECEPTIVE ACTS AND PRACTICES IN
CONNECTION WITH THE CONTACT BETWEEN AN ATHLETE
AGENT AND A STUDENT ATHLETE.
(a) Conduct Prohibited.--It is unlawful for an athlete agent
to--
(1) directly or indirectly recruit or solicit a
student athlete to enter into an agency contract, by--
(A) giving any false or misleading
information or making a false promise or
representation; or
(B) providing anything of value to a student
athlete or anyone associated with the student
athlete before the student athlete enters into
an agency contract, including any consideration
in the form of a loan, or acting in the
capacity of a guarantor or co-guarantor for any
debt;
(2) charge a student athlete a fee with respect to an
endorsement contract that is in an amount that is
greater than 5 percent of the amount of the
compensation provided to such student athlete under
such contract;
(3) enter into an agency contract with a student
athlete that does not include a provision specifying
that the student athlete may terminate the agency
contract, notwithstanding any other term described in
the agency contract, beginning on the date that is 6
months after the date on which the student athlete is
no longer enrolled at any institution (as defined in
section 2 of the SCORE Act);
[(2)] (4) enter into an agency contract with a
student athlete without providing the student athlete
with the disclosure document described in subsection
(b); or
[(3)] (5) predate or postdate an agency contract.
(b) Required Disclosure by Athlete Agents to Student
Athletes.--
(1) In general.--In conjunction with the entering
into of an agency contract, an athlete agent shall
provide to the student athlete, or, if the student
athlete is under the age of 18, to such student
athlete's parent or legal guardian, a disclosure
document that meets the requirements of this
subsection. Such disclosure document is separate from
and in addition to any disclosure which may be required
under State law.
(2) Signature of student athlete.--The disclosure
document must be signed by the student athlete, or, if
the student athlete is under the age of 18, by such
student athlete's parent or legal guardian, prior to
entering into the agency contract.
(3) Required language.--The disclosure document must
contain, in close proximity to the signature of the
student athlete, or, if the student athlete is under
the age of 18, the signature of such student athlete's
parent or legal guardian, a conspicuous notice in
boldface type stating: ``[Warning to Student Athlete:
If you agree orally or in writing to be represented by
an agent now or in the future you may lose your
eligibility to compete as a student athlete in your
sport.] Notice to Student Athlete: Within 72 hours
after entering into this contract or before the next
athletic event in which you are eligible to
participate, whichever occurs first, both you and the
agent by whom you are agreeing to be represented must
notify the athletic director of the educational
institution at which you are enrolled, or other
individual responsible for athletic programs at such
educational institution, that you have entered into an
agency contract.''.
* * * * * * *
SEC. 9. DISCLOSURE AND CONSENT RELATING TO NAME, IMAGE, AND LIKENESS
AGREEMENTS.
(a) In General.--An athlete agent who assists a student
athlete with an endorsement contract shall disclose
Minority Views
College athletics is a multi-billion dollar a year
business. Historically the National Collegiate Athletic
Association (NCAA) and the college athletic conferences (the
Conferences) (both defined in H.R. 4312 as Intercollegiate
Athletic Associations or IIAAs) imposed stringent limitations
on financial opportunities for the college athletes that drive
that revenue. Over the last few years, by bringing antitrust
lawsuits and championing new state laws, college athletes have
won the right to profit from their own name, image, and
likeness (NIL), share in some of the revenue received by their
colleges from their sports, and transfer schools without losing
athletic eligibility.\1\ Instead of celebrating and building
upon these hard fought successes won by athletes, H.R. 4312
returns power to the NCAA and the Conferences, providing them
with unchecked authority to regulate every aspect of the
college athletic experience, exempting them from the antitrust
laws, and preempting state laws that protect athletes'
interests.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Opinion Regarding Order Granting Motion for Final Approval of
Settlement Agreement (June 6, 2025), House v. NCAA, N. D. Cal (No. 717
CV 03919).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 4312 also imposes restrictions on college athletes
that are not imposed on other college students. For example, it
prohibits college athletes from being considered employees of
their institution, regardless of the commitments or other
conditions imposed on them by their colleges. The simplest and
most straightforward way for colleges to avoid an employer-
employee relationship is to make sure they are not treating
college athletes like employees. Employment liability cannot be
triggered if the facts do not support it. On the other hand, if
particular colleges do treat their college athletes like
employees, H.R. 4312 will deny college athletes the benefits
provided by federal and state law to employees, including the
right to engage in collective bargaining and qualify for
disability benefits.
Also, contrary to the Majority's claims in this report,
H.R. 4312 does not protect college athletes' privacy nor does
it ``affirm[] the right of student-athletes to enter into NIL
agreements.''\2\ Instead it allows the NCAA and the Conferences
to require college athletes to disclose their NIL deals to a
designated entity, and to accept that entity's determinations
on the validity of those deals. No other college student is
required to share their confidential business agreements with a
designated entity or to receive approval of those deals. The
Act also institutes arbitrary transfer limits on college
athletes, restricting their ability to transfer more than once
regardless of circumstances which could include a college
athlete's need to escape abuse or mistreatment, find a new team
after being cut from their team, or to deal with personal or
family situations, or financial considerations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, H.R. 4312, Student
Compensation and Opportunity Through Rights and Endorsements (SCORE)
Act, 119th Cong., at 1 (2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, H.R. 4312 does not greatly strengthen existing
health and safety protections and benefits for college athletes
or provide meaningful pathways to protect athletes who have
been harmed. Instead, most of the health and safety benefits
the Act requires colleges to provide to their athletes are
already required by the NCAA. Moreover, the Majority fails to
acknowledge in this report that H.R. 4312 only requires
colleges with highly paid coaches to provide the required
benefits, leaving the vast majority of college athletes,
including a substantial percentage of Division I athletes,
without any mandated health and safety protections. And the
bill provides no federal enforcement to ensure compliance for
those with mandated protections.
H.R. 4312 would strip college athletes of hard-fought
protections and benefits they have won in recent years and
existing pathways they can use to advocate for additional
benefits in the future. H.R. 4312 would give institutions that
have historically put profits over the safety and wellbeing of
athletes virtually unchecked authority to dictate the state of
college sports and athlete prosperity. Therefore, we oppose
this legislation in its current form.
Frank Pallone, Jr.,
Ranking Member.
[all]