Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4312]
The Committee on Education and Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 4312) to protect the name, image, and
likeness rights of student athletes and to promote fair
competition with respect to intercollegiate athletics, and for
other purposes, having considered the same, reports favorably
thereon with an amendment and recommends that the bill as
amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Student Compensation and Opportunity
through Rights and Endorsements Act'' or the ``SCORE Act''.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Agent.--The term ``agent'' means an individual who
receives compensation to represent a student athlete with
respect to--
(A) a name, image, and likeness agreement; or
(B) another agreement for compensation related to the
participation of such student athlete on a varsity
sports team.
(2) Antitrust laws.--The term ``antitrust laws'' has the
meaning given such term in the 1st section of the Clayton Act
(15 U.S.C. 12) and includes section 5 of the Federal Trade
Commission Act (15 U.S.C. 45) to the extent that such section 5
applies to unfair methods of competition.
(3) Associated entity or individual.--The term ``associated
entity or individual'' means, with respect to an institution,
each of the following:
(A) An entity that is known or should be known to the
employees of the athletic department of such
institution to exist, in significant part, for the
purpose of--
(i) promoting or supporting the varsity
sports teams or student athletes of such
institution; or
(ii) creating or identifying opportunities
relating to name, image, and likeness
agreements solely for the student athletes of
such institution.
(B) An individual who is or has been a member,
employee, director, officer, owner, or other
representative of an entity described in subparagraph
(A).
(C) An individual who directly or indirectly
(including through contributions by an entity
affiliated with such individual or an immediate family
member of such individual) has contributed more than
$50,000 (as adjusted on July 1 each year by the
percentage increase (if any), during the preceding 12-
month period, in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban
Consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics)
over the lifetime of the individual to the athletic
programs of such institution or to an entity described
in subparagraph (A).
(D) An individual or entity who--
(i) is directed or requested by the employees
of the athletic department of such institution
to assist in the recruitment or retention of
prospective student athletes or student
athletes, respectively; or
(ii) otherwise assists in such recruitment or
retention.
(E) Any entity (other than a publicly traded
corporation) owned, controlled, operated by, or
otherwise affiliated with an individual or entity
described in subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D).
(4) College sports revenue.--The term ``college sports
revenue'' means any revenue (without regard to ownership or
legal title to such revenue) received by an institution with
respect to intercollegiate athletics--
(A) from the sale of admission to intercollegiate
athletic competitions or any other event involving a
varsity sports team, including actual monetary revenue
received by or for the benefit of such institution for
a suite license (unless such suite license is
associated with philanthropy or any purpose not related
to intercollegiate athletic competitions, including a
concert);
(B) from participation by the varsity sports teams of
such institution in intercollegiate athletic
competitions held at other institutions, including
payments received due to cancellations of such
intercollegiate athletic competitions;
(C) for radio, television, internet, digital, and e-
commerce rights, including revenue relating to media
rights distributed by a conference to members of the
conference, if applicable;
(D) from an interstate intercollegiate athletic
association, including any grant, distribution of
revenue, reimbursement relating to travel with respect
to a championship of such interstate intercollegiate
athletic association, and payment for hosting such a
championship;
(E) generated by a post-season football bowl,
including any distribution of revenue by a conference
to members of the conference and any other payment
related to the participation of such institution in
such post-season football bowl, including for ticket
sales and reimbursement of expenses;
(F) from a conference, other than any revenue
otherwise described in this paragraph;
(G) for sponsorships, licensing agreements,
advertisements, royalties, and in-kind products and
services as part of a sponsorship agreement; or
(H) relating to any additional form of revenue,
including fundraising, an interstate intercollegiate
athletic association uses with respect to the pool
limit of such interstate intercollegiate athletic
association.
(5) Compensation.--The term ``compensation''--
(A) means, with respect to a student athlete or a
prospective student athlete, any form of payment or
remuneration, whether provided through cash, benefits,
awards, or any other means, including payments for--
(i) licenses relating to, or the use of,
name, image, and likeness rights; or
(ii) licenses relating to, or the use of, any
other Federal or State intellectual or
intangible property right; and
(B) does not include--
(i) grants-in-aid;
(ii) Federal Pell Grants and other Federal or
State grants unrelated to and not awarded with
regard to participation in intercollegiate
athletics;
(iii) health insurance and payments for the
costs of health care, including health
insurance and payments for the costs of health
care wholly or partly self-funded by an
institution, conference, or interstate
intercollegiate athletic association;
(iv) disability and loss-of-value insurance,
including disability and loss-of-value
insurance that is wholly or partly self-funded
by an institution, conference, or interstate
intercollegiate athletic association;
(v) career counseling, job placement
services, and other guidance available to all
students at an institution;
(vi) payment of hourly wages and benefits for
work actually performed (and not for
participation in intercollegiate athletics) at
a rate commensurate with the going rate in the
locality of an institution for similar work;
(vii) academic awards paid to student
athletes by institutions;
(viii) provision of financial literacy or tax
education resources and guidance; or
(ix) any program to connect student athletes
with employers and facilitate employment
opportunities, if--
(I) the financial terms of such
employment opportunities are consistent
with the terms offered to similarly
situated employees who are not student
athletes; and
(II) such program is not used to
induce a student athlete to attend a
particular institution.
(6) Conference.--The term ``conference'' means an entity
that--
(A) has as members 2 or more institutions;
(B) arranges regular season intercollegiate athletic
competitions and championships for such members; and
(C) sets rules with respect to such intercollegiate
athletic competitions and championships.
(7) Cost of attendance.--The term ``cost of attendance'' has
the meaning given such term in section 472 of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1087ll).
(8) Grant-in-aid.--The term ``grant-in-aid'' means a
scholarship, grant, stipend, or other form of financial
assistance, including the provision of tuition, room, board,
books, or funds for fees or personal expenses, that--
(A) is paid or provided by an institution to a
student for the undergraduate or graduate course of
study of the student; and
(B) is in an amount that does not exceed the cost of
attendance at the institution for such student.
(9) Image.--The term ``image'' means, with respect to a
student athlete, a picture or a video that identifies, is
linked to, or is reasonably linkable to such student athlete.
(10) Institution.--The term ``institution'' has the meaning
given the term ``institution of higher education'' in section
102 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1002).
(11) Intercollegiate athletic competition.--The term
``intercollegiate athletic competition'' means any contest,
game, meet, match, tournament, regatta, or other event in which
varsity sports teams of more than 1 institution compete.
(12) Intercollegiate athletics.--The term ``intercollegiate
athletics''--
(A) means the varsity sports teams for which the
length of time a student athlete is eligible to
participate and the academic standards for
participation are established by a conference or an
interstate intercollegiate athletic association; and
(B) does not include any recreational, intramural, or
club teams.
(13) Interstate intercollegiate athletic association.--The
term ``interstate intercollegiate athletic association''
means--
(A) any entity that--
(i) sets common rules, standards, procedures,
or guidelines for the administration and
regulation of varsity sports teams and
intercollegiate athletic competitions;
(ii) is composed of 2 or more institutions or
conferences located in more than 1 State; and
(iii) has rules or bylaws prohibiting the
provision of prohibited compensation to student
athletes and prospective student athletes; and
(B) does not include any entity affiliated with
professional athletic competitions.
(14) Likeness.--The term ``likeness'' means, with respect to
a student athlete, a physical or digital depiction or
representation that identifies, is linked to, or is reasonably
linkable to such student athlete.
(15) Name.--The term ``name'' means, with respect to a
student athlete, the first, middle, or last name, or the
nickname or former name, of such student athlete if used in a
context that identifies, is linked to, or is reasonably
linkable to such student athlete.
(16) Name, image, and likeness agreement.--The term ``name,
image, and likeness agreement'' means a contract or similar
agreement under which a student athlete licenses or authorizes,
or a contract or similar agreement that otherwise is in
relation to, the commercial use of the name, image, or likeness
of the student athlete.
(17) Name, image, and likeness rights.--The term ``name,
image, and likeness rights'' means rights recognized under
Federal or State law that allow an individual to control and
profit from the commercial use of the name, image, and likeness
of such individual, including all rights commonly referred to
as ``publicity rights''.
(18) Pool limit.--The term ``pool limit'' means a dollar
amount based on college sports revenue that--
(A) is calculated and published by an interstate
intercollegiate athletic association pursuant to the
rules the interstate intercollegiate athletic
association establishes under section 6; and
(B) serves as the annual maximum amount that an
institution that is a member of such interstate
intercollegiate athletic association may provide, in
total, to student athletes of such institution,
including in the form of a name, image, and likeness
agreement or direct payment.
(19) Prohibited compensation.--The term ``prohibited
compensation'' means--
(A) compensation (including an agreement for
compensation) to a student athlete from an associated
entity or individual of the institution at which the
student athlete is enrolled (or to a prospective
student athlete from an associated entity or individual
of an institution for which the prospective student
athlete is being recruited) for any license or use of
the name, image, and likeness rights of such student
athlete or prospective student athlete (or any other
license or use), unless the license or use is for a
valid business purpose related to the promotion or
endorsement of goods or services provided to the
general public for profit, with compensation at rates
and terms commensurate with compensation paid to
individuals with name, image, and likeness rights of
comparable value who are not student athletes or
prospective student athletes with respect to such
institution; and
(B) compensation to a student athlete (or a
prospective student athlete) if such compensation is
paid by or on behalf of the institution at which the
student athlete is enrolled (or for which the
prospective student athlete is being recruited) and
results in the exceeding of the pool limit established
by the interstate intercollegiate athletic association
of which such institution is a member.
(20) Prospective student athlete.--The term ``prospective
student athlete'' means an individual who is solicited to
enroll at an institution by, or at the direction of, an
employee or an associated entity or individual of the
institution in order for such individual to participate in a
varsity sports team of such institution.
(21) State.--The term ``State'' means each State of the
United States, the District of Columbia, and each commonwealth,
territory, or possession of the United States.
(22) Student athlete.--The term ``student athlete'' means an
individual who--
(A) is enrolled or has agreed to enroll at an
institution; and
(B) participates in a varsity sports team of such
institution.
(23) Varsity sports team.--The term ``varsity sports team''
means an entity composed of an individual or group of
individuals enrolled at an institution that is organized by
such institution for the purpose of participation in
intercollegiate athletic competitions.
SEC. 3. PROTECTION OF NAME, IMAGE, AND LIKENESS RIGHTS OF STUDENT
ATHLETES.
(a) Right To Enter Into Name, Image, and Likeness Agreements.--
(1) In general.--No institution, conference, or interstate
intercollegiate athletic association may restrict the ability
of a student athlete to enter into a name, image, and likeness
agreement.
(2) Exceptions.--
(A) Prohibited compensation.--Paragraph (1) does not
apply with respect to a name, image, and likeness
agreement to the extent such agreement provides
prohibited compensation.
(B) Codes of conduct and conflicting agreements.--
Notwithstanding paragraph (1), an institution may
restrict the ability of a student athlete of such
institution (including a prospective student athlete
who has agreed to attend such institution) to enter
into a name, image, and likeness agreement that--
(i) violates the code of conduct of such
institution; or
(ii) conflicts with the terms of a contract
or similar agreement to which such institution
is a party.
(b) Right to Representation.--Except as provided by this Act,
Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On March 6, 2024, the Committee's Subcommittees on Health,
Employment, Labor, and Pensions and Higher Education and
Workforce Development held a hearing on ``Safeguarding Student-
Athletes from NLRB Misclassification.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to examine the National Labor Relations Board's
(NLRB or Board) efforts to classify student-athletes as
employees, including the NLRB Region 1's decision finding that
Dartmouth College's men's basketball players are employees
under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). Testifying
before the Subcommittees were Ms. Jill Bodensteiner, Vice
President and Director of Athletics, Saint Joseph's University,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Mr. Tyler Sims, Shareholder,
Littler Mendelson, Tampa, Florida; Mr. Matthew Mitten,
Professor of Law and Executive Director, National Sports Law
Institute, Marquette University Law School, Milwaukee,
Wisconsin; and Mr. Mark Gaston Pearce, Executive Director,
Workers' Rights Institute at Georgetown Law, Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On May 23, 2024, Representative Bob Good (R-VA) introduced
H.R. 8534, the Protecting Student Athletes' Economic Freedom
Act, with then-Committee Chairwoman Virginia Foxx (R-NC) and
Representatives Burgess Owens (R-UT), Eric Burlison (R-MO),
Andrew Ogles (R-TN), Tim Walberg (R-MI), Rick Allen (R-GA),
Mike Kelly (R-PA), Doug LaMalfa (R-CA), Mary E. Miller (R-IL),
and Robert B. Aderholdt (R-AL) as original cosponsors. The bill
was referred solely to the Committee on Education and the
Workforce.
On June 13, 2024, the Committee considered H.R. 8534 in
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 23-16.
Representative Good offered an amendment in the nature of a
substitute making a technical change. The amendment was adopted
by voice vote.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On April 8, 2025, the Committee on Education and Workforce
Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions held a
hearing on ``Game Changer: the NLRB, Student-Athletes, and the
Future of College Sports.'' The purpose of the hearing was to
examine the changing intercollegiate athletics landscape and
the NLRB's efforts during the Biden administration to classify
student-athletes as employees. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Mr. Daniel L. Nash, Shareholder, Littler,
Washington, D.C.; Ms. Morgyn Wynne, Former Softball Student-
Athlete, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, Oklahoma; Ms.
Jacqie McWilliams Parker, Commissioner, Central Intercollegiate
Athletic Association, Charlotte, North Carolina; and Mr. Ramogi
Huma, Executive Director, National College Players Association,
Norco, California.
Legislative Action
On July 9, 2025, Representative Gus Bilirakis (R-FL)
introduced H.R. 4312, the Student Compensation and Opportunity
through Rights and Endorsements (SCORE) Act, with Chairmen
Walberg, Brett Guthrie (R-KY), and Jim Jordan (R-OH), House
Republican Conference Chairwoman Lisa McClain (R-MI), and
Representatives Russell Fry (R-SC), Janelle Bynum (D-OR), and
Shomari Figures (D-AL) as original cosponsors. The bill was
referred to the Committee on Education and Workforce and the
Committee on Energy and Commerce.
On July 23, 2025, the Committee considered H.R. 4312 in
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 18-17. The
Committee considered the following amendments to H.R. 4312:
1. Representative McClain offered an amendment in the
nature of a substitute that strengthens enforcement of the bill
and ensures the representation of smaller institutions in
college sports decision making, among other changes. The
amendment passed by voice vote.
2. Representative Joe Courtney (D-CT) offered an amendment
that extends medical coverage for athletic related injuries
from 3 to 10 years. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of
16-20.
3. Representative Michael Baumgartner (R-WA) offered an
amendment that builds on college sports governance provisions
in the bill and requires the council established in section 6
to develop polices on revenue sharing between institutions and
compensation limits. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of
16-19.
4. Representative Summer Lee (D-PA) offered an amendment
that strikes the prohibition on student-athletes being
classified as employees. The amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 15-20.
5. Representative Baumgartner offered an amendment that
requires any institution that provides compensation to student-
athletes to distribute compensation in equal amounts to all
student-athletes. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of
14-21.
6. Representative Alma Adams (D-NC) offered an amendment
that inserts broad language regarding discrimination on the
basis of sex into the bill. The amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 16-19.
7. Representative Kevin Kiley (R-CA) offered an amendment
that removes authorization for an interstate intercollegiate
athletic association to set membership rules, remove members,
or control participation, ensuring these actions remain subject
to fair competition laws by excluding them from the antitrust
exemption in section 7. The amendment was withdrawn.
8. Representative Adams offered an amendment that inserts a
new Section 13 to amend the Higher Education Act of 1965 to
include data reporting on gender equity in athletic programs.
The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 16-19.
9. Representative Baumgartner offered an amendment that
prohibits a conference from scheduling a regular season
intercollegiate athletics competition in a location that is
more than two time zones away from the primary campus of the
school. The amendment was withdrawn.
10. Representative Greg Casar (D-TX) offered an amendment
that strikes preemption language as it relates to compensation,
payment, benefits, and employment status of student-athletes.
The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 15-20.
11. Representative Baumgartner offered an amendment that
requires institutions generating at least $20 million in
athletic revenue to establish a student-athlete advisory
committee to provide guidance on institutional policies
affecting the well-being of student-athletes and requires these
schools to also provide certain benefits to student-athletes
that are required to travel across more than two time zones.
The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 16-19.
12. Representative Yassamin Ansari (D-AZ) offered an
amendment that requires colleges to provide to any employee
associated with athletics an annual training on Title IX, what
conduct constitutes sex discrimination, and the procedures for
submitting Title IX complaints. The amendment also requires
that these employees notify the Title IX coordinator when the
employee has received information about sex discrimination. The
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 16-19.
13. Ranking Member Robert C. ``Bobby'' Scott (D-VA) offered
an amendment that inserts a private right of action for both
current or previous student-athletes to bring an action in
federal or state court against the interstate intercollegiate
athletic association or institution alleging a violation of the
Act. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 16-20.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
College athletics are in a transformational period, driven
by the introduction of NIL rights and the finalized House v.
NCAA settlement that allows schools to share up to $20.5
million of revenue directly with student-athletes. Student-
athletes deserve to be compensated for their contributions to
college athletics, but the current environment is unsustainable
and risks exploitation of student-athletes. The absence of
uniform NIL regulations across states, coupled with ongoing
antitrust litigation and attempts to classify student-athletes
as employees, has created chaos. Ongoing lawsuits have the
potential to fundamentally alter the financial structure,
operational framework, and governance of college athletics,
creating substantial implications for the NCAA, its member
institutions, and the availability of academic and athletic
opportunities for thousands of student-athletes.
BACKGROUND ON COLLEGE SPORTS LANDSCAPE
In recent years, antitrust laws have been used to challenge
the long-standing policies of the National Collegiate Athletic
Association (NCAA), a nonprofit organization that serves as the
primary governing body for college athletics in the United
States.\1\ For decades, the NCAA enforced strict rules of
amateurism, which barred student-athletes from receiving
compensation for their NIL, a legal concept referring to an
individual's ability to profit from the use of his or her own
name, image, or likeness through activities such as
endorsements, appearances, autographs, or digital content
creation. Courts scrutinized whether these restrictions
unlawfully suppressed competition and violated antitrust
principles. In 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled
in NCAA v. Alston that the NCAA is not exempt from antitrust
law.\2\ Following the ruling, the NCAA quickly adopted an
interim NIL policy that for the first time allowed student-
athletes to benefit financially from their NIL without fear of
NCAA penalty.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/20-512_gfbh.pdf.
\2\Ibid.
\3\https://www.ncaa.org/news/2021/6/30/ncaa-adopts-interim-name-
image-and-likeness-
policy.aspx.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The NCAA v. Alston ruling, combined with the expansion of
NIL rights for student-athletes, has transformed the landscape
of college sports. After the NCAA's interim policy went into
effect in July 2021, so-called ``NIL Collectives'' quickly
emerged at many institutions. NIL Collectives are organizations
that fundraise from boosters with the intent to direct that
money to a school's athletes through NIL deals. Collectives are
not formally associated with schools or athletic departments,
but they exist to benefit those entities. Collectives can pay
student-athletes, but for the student-athletes to remain NCAA-
eligible, the student-athletes must prove they completed a
deliverable service in return for the payment, including:
signing autographs, appearing at commercials or events, or
marketing a product.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\https://www.on3.com/nil/news/what-are-nil-collectives-and-how-
do-they-operate/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In an effort to preserve the principles of amateurism and
support fair competition across college sports, NCAA rules
maintain that NIL opportunities cannot be used as recruiting
inducements or as direct compensation for athletic
performance.\5\ However, in February 2024, a federal judge in
Tennessee issued a preliminary injunction preventing the NCAA
from enforcing rules related to NIL Collectives offering deals
to recruits.\6\ This ruling, stemming from an antitrust lawsuit
filed by the attorneys general of Tennessee and Virginia
against the NCAA, allows recruits to discuss and negotiate NIL
deals with schools and collectives before they commit to a
school.\7\ This shift has fundamentally altered the recruiting
process, with student-athletes now factoring NIL opportunities
and revenue sharing payments into their decisions about where
to enroll or transfer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\https://www.ncaa.org/news/2021/6/30/ncaa-adopts-interim-name-
image-and-likeness-
policy.aspx.
\6\https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/39585390/ncaa-
enforce-nil-rules-judge-grants-injunction.
\7\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Transfer Portal
Alongside the expansion of NIL, the transfer portal has
been a key driver of change in college sports. The transfer
portal is a platform administered by the NCAA to regulate the
process by which student-athletes transfer between NCAA member
schools. The transfer portal allows student-athletes to signal
their intention to transfer by having their name added to an
online database. Once listed, the athlete becomes eligible to
be contacted by coaches and staff from other institutions who
can discuss potential opportunities such as campus visits and
athletic scholarships. It applies across all three NCAA
divisions, though most public attention centers on its use
within Division I.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\https://www.ncaa.org/news/2023/2/8/media-center-what-the-ncaa-
transfer-portal-is-and-what-it-isn-t.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Before the launch of the transfer portal in 2018, student-
athletes transferring between Division I schools had to request
permission to contact other programs, and without it, those
schools were barred from engaging with them. Denials were
common, appeals were slow, and approved transfers often
required athletes to sit out one year. Schools also had the
power to limit or block transfers to specific schools, such as
conference rivals or future opponents.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/23782893/ncaa-passes-
reform-allows-athletes-
transfer-permission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the beginning, the transfer portal complemented the
existing transfer rules. To initiate a transfer, a student-
athlete would notify their current school, which was then
required to enter the athlete's name into the transfer portal.
Once listed, the athlete was free to communicate with coaches
at other NCAA institutions. Initially, the transfer portal did
not change eligibility requirements, and athletes in high-
profile sports were still required to sit out one year of
competition unless they were granted a waiver.
This changed in April 2021 when the NCAA introduced a one-
time transfer rule, allowing student-athletes in all sports to
transfer once without sitting out a year.\10\ In 2024, under
threat of litigation challenging its authority to limit athlete
transfers, the NCAA eliminated the limit on immediate
eligibility, allowing college athletes to transfer multiple
times without sitting out a season.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\NCAA Board of Directors ratifies one-time transfer legislation
allowing athletes immediate eligibility--CBSSports.com.
\11\Division I Council approves changes to transfer rules--
NCAA.org.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These shifts, paired with the expansion of NIL deals, have
fueled a free-agency-like environment that undermines the
educational foundation of college athletics by encouraging
frequent transfers over degree completion. The transfer portal
has disrupted college sports, creating roster instability,
intensifying pay-for-play recruiting, and shifting focus from
academic development to athletic and financial gain.
House v. NCAA Settlement
These shifts also triggered a wave of legal action seeking
retroactive remedies for athletes who had previously been
barred from profiting under the NCAA's former compensation
rules. Chief among these lawsuits was House v. NCAA, a class-
action lawsuit that challenged the NCAA's historical
restrictions on athlete earnings and sought restitution for the
economic harm caused to past and current student-athletes.
That legal effort reached a major milestone on June 6,
2025, when Judge Claudia Wilken of the U.S. District Court for
the Northern District of California granted final approval of
the settlement agreement. The resolution encompassed three
major cases--House v. NCAA, Hubbard v. NCAA, and Carter v.
NCAA--and addressed both back-wage damages and the
establishment of future benefits for Division I student-
athletes.\12\ The settlement was reached after extensive
negotiations between the NCAA, the Power Five conferences (ACC,
Big Ten, Big 12, SEC, and Pac-12), and attorneys representing
the athlete plaintiffs, marking a historic shift in the
collegiate model. This landmark settlement, made effective July
1, 2025, establishes a 10-year injunction with potential
extension and drives a transformative shift in college
athletics. It creates the College Sports Commission (CSC), an
independent body charged with enforcing the settlement terms,
while the NCAA retains its role focused on managing
championships, eligibility standards, and certain regulatory
functions.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/45467505/judge-
grants-final-approval-house-v-ncaa-settlement.
\13\https://www.collegesportscommission.org/faq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The settlement includes four primary changes:
Distributing approximately $2.78 billion in back
damages to Division I athletes who competed between 2016 and
2024, paid over 10 years at roughly $280 million annually.
About 95 percent of these funds will go
to football and men's and women's basketball players
from the Defendant Conferences (ACC, Big Ten, Big 12,
SEC, Pac-12, and Notre Dame).\14\ More than 100,000
former student-athletes will receive back damages.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\https://www.courthousenews.com/ncaa-athletes-score-big-with-
final-approval-2-8-billion-
antitrust-settlement/.
\15\https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/2-8-billion-
house-v-ncaa-settlement-hangs-in-balance-as-federal-judge-extends-
response-deadline/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Permitting schools to share up to 22 percent of
the average athletic revenue generated by schools in the ACC,
Big Ten, Big 12, SEC, and Pac-12 from media rights, ticket
sales, and sponsorships, often referred to as ``revenue
sharing.'' For the 2025-2026 academic year, each institution
that opts-in can share up to $20.5 million, increasing by 4
percent annually for the next two years and subject to re-
evaluation every three years. Under the settlement terms,
institutions are permitted to determine how they will
distribute the money to the institution's individual student-
athletes.
For example, Texas Tech, a Big 12
school, plans to allocate $15.1 million (74 percent) to
football, $3.6 million (17.5 percent) to men's
basketball, $410,000 (2 percent) to women's basketball,
$390,000 (1.9 percent) to baseball, and $920,000 (4.6
percent) to other sports.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\https://www.lubbockonline.com/story/sports/college/red-raiders/
2024/12/16/texas-tech-football-kirby-hocutt-details-plan-for-revenue-
sharing-era/76962416007/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Schools may also facilitate NIL
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 4312, the Student Compensation and Opportunity through
Rights and Endorsements Act, or SCORE Act, seeks to regulate
college athletics and the ``Name, Image, and Likeness''
marketplace. While the SCORE Act is being promoted as a measure
to empower college athletes,\1\ in reality it is a series of
blank checks and bailouts for the revenue-rich National
Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and its most prominent
athletic conferences to the detriment of the athletes the
legislation purports to support. The SCORE Act falls short of
meaningfully addressing the educational, health, and financial
needs of college athletes and instead imposes a radical and
permanent ban on college athletes from ever receiving labor and
employment rights and protections under any federal or state
law as well as eliminates any current or future college athlete
protections at the state level. This legislation puts the NCAA
before the needs and interests of college athletes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\This report uses the phrase ``college athletes'' or ``athletes''
to refer to the population impacted by the legislation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 4312 is opposed by the AFL-CIO, American Association
for Justice, American Economic Liberties Project, Center for
Law and Social Policy, Women's Sports Foundation, National
College Players Association, and Service Employees
International Union.
Background
National Collegiate Athletic Association
The NCAA is an administrative body that is responsible for
regulating college athletics among nearly 1,100 member colleges
and universities\2\ across 102 athletic conferences in North
America.\3\ NCAA member institutions are divided into three
divisions: Division I (DI), Division II (DII), and Division III
(DIII).\4\ DI is the most competitive level of college
athletics and is primarily populated by sizeable institutions
with large athletic budgets.\5\ Each division is governed by
the member schools in the division through committees.\6\ In
the 2023-2024 season, approximately 197,000 athletes
participated in DI, 137,000 in DII, and over 205,000 in DIII,
totaling 539,000 college athletes in the NCAA.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\The use of ``colleges'' and ``universities'' independently in
this report includes reference to the other.
\3\Overview, NCAA, https://www.ncaa.org/sports/2021/2/16/
overview.aspx (last visited Apr. 2, 2025); What is the NCAA?, NCAA,
https://www.ncaa.org/sports/2021/2/10/about-resources-media-center-
ncaa-101-what-ncaa.aspx (last visited Apr. 2, 2025).
\4\What is the NCAA?, NCAA, https://www.ncaa.org/sports/2021/2/10/
about-resources-media-
center-ncaa-101-what-ncaa.aspx (last visited Apr. 2, 2025). (Of the
1,098 members schools in the NCAA, 350 are in DI, 310 in DII, and 438
in DIII.).
\5\The Differences Between NCAA Divisions, NCSA College Recruiting,
https://www.ncsasports.org/recruiting/how-to-get-recruited/college-
divisions (last visited Apr. 2, 2025).
\6\Our Three Divisions, NCAA, https://www.ncaa.org/sports/2016/1/7/
about-resources-media-
center-ncaa-101-our-three-divisions.aspx (last visited Apr. 2, 2025).
\7\NCAA, NCAA Sports Sponsorship and Participation Rates Report 94-
97 (Oct. 19, 2024), https://ncaaorg.s3.amazonaws.com/research/
sportpart/2024RES_SportsSponsorshipParticipationRatesReport.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In recent years, college athletes across the country have
organized for a meaningful voice and better conditions due to
the failure to address longstanding issues they experience in
many athletic programs. Below are some of the core problems
college athletes face.
Compensation
The NCAA has long asserted that the draw of collegiate
sports is amateurism.\8\ These ``amateur'' sports, however, are
a multi-billion-dollar industry.\9\ In Fiscal Year (FY) 2024,
the NCAA brought in almost $1.4 billion in revenue, a $91
million increase from the prior fiscal year.\10\ The NCAA's
most prominent athletic conferences collectively ``generated
over $3.55 billion in revenue during the 2023 fiscal
year.''\11\ In FY 2023, DI schools ``reported total revenue of
almost $19 billion on athletics,'' nearly a 10 percent increase
over the prior fiscal year.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Safeguarding Student-Athletes from NLRB Misclassification:
Hearing Before the Subcomm. on H, Employ., Lab., & Pensions of the H.
Comm. on Educ. & the Wrkf., 118th Cong. (2024) (statement of Mark
Gaston Pearce, Exec. Dir., Workers' Rights Inst. at Geo. L. Ctr.)
(accessible at https://democrats-edworkforce.house.gov/imo/media/doc/
31424pearcetestimony.pdf) [hereinafter Pearce Testimony].
\9\Andrew Zimbalist, Analysis: Who is winning in the high-revenue
world of college sports?, PBS (Mar. 18, 2023), https://www.pbs.org/
newshour/economy/analysis-who-is-winning-in-the-high-
revenue-world-of-college-sports.
\10\Steve Berkowitz, NCAA shows revenue increase to $1.4 billion
and $166 million surplus in 2024 fiscal year, USA Today (Feb. 27,
2025), https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/college/2025/02/27/ncaa-
financial-report-revenue-surplus/80733616007/.
\11\Will Backus, Big Ten Remains Power Five Revenue Leader with
$880 Million Haul for 2023 Fiscal Year, per Report, CBS Sports (May 23,
2024), https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/big-ten-remains-
power-five-revenue-leader-with-880-million-haul-for-2023-fiscal-year-
per-report/.
\12\NCAA, Division I Athletics Finances: 10-Year Trends from 2014
to 2023 12 (Dec. 2024), https://ncaaorg.s3.amazonaws.com/research/
Finances/2024D1RES_DI-RevExpReport.pdf [hereinafter DI Athletics
Finances].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite the flow of billions of dollars to the NCAA,
athletic conferences, and member schools resulting from
athletics, college athletes do not share in the prosperity
their effort and performance creates. In 2023, DI schools doled
out over $3.1 billion in financial aid for college athletes,
accounting for just 16 percent of total expenses.\13\ However,
not every athlete is able to secure a robust scholarship. In a
2019 survey, almost 25 percent of DI college athletes reported
experiencing food insecurity in the last month and nearly 14
percent were homeless over the last year.\14\ A 2011 study by
the National College Players Association and Drexel University
Department of Sport Management found ``86 percent of players
[receiving full athletic scholarships] living off campus living
below the federal poverty level.''\15\ In an opinion piece
written by two members of Dartmouth's men's basketball team,
they describe a driving factor for their decision to unionize:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Id. at 20.
\14\Mark Gaston Pearce & Daphne Assimakopoulos, Organizing and the
College Athlete, Wrkrs' Rgts Inst (2022), https://
www.law.georgetown.edu/workers-rights-institute/publications/
organizing-and-the-college-athlete/.
\15\Press Release, Drexel University, Study College Athletes Worth
Six Figures Live Below Federal Poverty Line (Sept. 13, 2011), https://
drexel.edu/news/archive/2011/september/study-
college-athletes-worth-six-figures-live-below-federal-poverty-line.
First, many of our players currently juggle part-time
jobs alongside their academic and athletic commitments
to help pay for their tuition and living expenses.
While we currently receive many forms of non-
traditional compensation, these don't pay our bills,
and so we are unionizing to be compensated like other
student employees, with hourly wages similar to other
student wages on campus or scholarships. This would
alleviate the need for second jobs and enhance our
experience as part of the Dartmouth community.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Romeo Myrthil & Cade Haskins, Haskins and Myrthil: Why We Are
Unionizing, The Dartmouth (Sept. 18, 2023), https://
www.thedartmouth.com/article/2023/09/haskins-and-myrthil-why-we-are-
unionizing.
Conversely, DI schools spent more than $3.6 billion
compensating coaches in 2023, making up the largest category
(19%) of expenditures for the schools.\17\ Compensation is only
one part of college athletes' experience, and limiting the
conversation to this ignores the various other issues they face
at academic institutions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\See DI Athletics Finances, supra note 12, at 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Excessive Hours
The NCAA caps the number of hours college athletes may
engage in ``countable athletically related activities'' at four
hours each day and 20 hours each week when in-season, and eight
hours each week during the offseason.\18\ Athletes are also
provided one day off each week during the season and two days
off in the offseason.\19\ NCAA regulations may appear
reasonable, however, the reality is different. NCAA athletes
report significantly exceeding the limit on maximum hours
during the season across all sports.\20\ ``On average,
football, men's basketball, women's basketball, and baseball
players in [DI] spend about 40 hours a week on athletic
activities.''\21\ The issue persists in the offseason, with a
majority of DI and DII college athletes engaging in athletic
related activities for the same or greater number of hours as
their regular season.\22\ A 2015 survey of athletes in the Pac-
12 Conference\23\ found that 73 percent of college athletes
believed an athletic activity labeled as voluntary was
mandatory, leading them to put more time into the sport or face
retaliation.\24\ In addition to a full course load, college
athletes are managing the equivalent of a full-time job that
takes away from rest, sleep, extracurricular activities, social
activities, and academics.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\This Study Proves Just How Much Time College Athletes Spend on
Their Sport, NCSA College Recruiting, https://www.ncsasports.org/blog/
study-time-demands-d1-studentathletes-
excessive (last visited Apr. 2, 2025).
\19\Id.
\20\Jake New, What Off-Season?, INSD. Higher Ed (May 7, 2015),
https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2015/05/08/college-athletes-say-
they-devote-too-much-time-sports-year-round.
\21\Id.
\22\Id.
\23\The Pac-12 Conference was made up of 12 schools on the west
coast and in the southwest region of the U.S. In 2024, 10 of the 12
schools left the conference.
\24\Student-Athlete Time Demands, Penn Schoen Berland (Apr. 2015),
https://sports.cbsimg.net/images/Pac-12-Student-Athlete-Time-Demands-
Obtained-by-CBS-Sports.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Harassment, Discrimination, and Abuse
While many college athletes have a special bond with their
coaches that is built on mutual respect and trust, others have
dealt with coaches that abuse, harass, and discriminate--
harming athletes' health and wellbeing. For example:\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Michael H. LeRoy, Harassment, Abuse, and Mistreatment in
College Sports: Protecting Players through Employment Laws, 42:1 Brkely
Journ. Of Emplymt & Lab. Law 101 (2020), https://law.illinois.edu/wp-
content/uploads/2021/03/LeRoy-42.1-Formatted-w-Edits_12.2.20.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In January 2023, five players on Concordia
University Chicago's men's basketball team were
hospitalized after a practice believed to be in
retaliation for curfew violations.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\Jake Sheridan, Concordia University Chicago basketball players
hospitalized after intense practice, Chic. Tribune (Jan. 6, 2023),
https://www.chicagotribune.com/2023/01/06/concordia-
university-chicago-basketball-players-hospitalized-after-intense-
practice/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2021, Syracuse University women's
basketball coach resigned after allegations of
inappropriate and abusive behavior, including verbal
threats, denial of requests for water, and unwanted
physical contact.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Matt Bonesteel, Syracuse women's basketball coach resigns after
players accuse him of improper behavior, Wash Post (Aug. 2, 2021),
https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2021/08/02/syracuse-coach-
quentin-hillsman-resigns/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2009, a basketball player at Grambling
State University died and another became physically and
psychologically disabled after a punitive practice.\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\Michael H. LeRoy, Considering College Athletes as Employees
Could Curb Coaching Abuse, Sportico (Mar. 1, 2023), https://
www.sportico.com/leagues/college-sports/2023/college-athletes-as-
employees-could-curb-coaching-abuse-1234708592/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Players for the University of Nebraska's
softball team stated their coach engaged in
``systematic emotional abuse'' and created a toxic
culture. Players reported experiencing harassment to
the point that over half of the players in 2018
attended counseling sessions with psychologists and
eventually transferred out of the program. One player
even said she had suicidal thoughts because of the
toxic environment.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\Ben Strauss, Complaints against Nebraska softball coach show
college athletes' limited option, Wash Post (Aug. 30, 2019), https://
www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/08/30/complaints-against-nebraska-
softball-coach-show-college-athletes-limited-options/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2013, a University of Utah swimming coach
was accused of showing up to practices inebriated,
assaulting an assistant coach, using racial slurs, and
coercing an athlete to ``swim underwater with his hands
tied to a PVC pipe that was strapped to his back until
he blacked out.''\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\Utah hires out for new investigation, ESPN (Mar. 11, 2013),
https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/9040762/utah-utes-open-
new-investigation-greg-winslow.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The University of Illinois at Urbana-
Champaign's head football coach was fired for routinely
pressuring players to play through their injuries,
ignoring medical staff, and threatening to revoke
scholarships, among other abusive conduct.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Vinnie Duber, Report contains ugly details of Tim Beckman's
behavior as Illini coach, NBC Sports Chic. (Nov. 9, 2015), https://
www.nbcsportschicago.com/news/report-contains-ugly-
details-of-tim-beckmans-behavior-as-illini-coach/271326/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Rutgers University men's basketball coach
was recorded over two years ``hurling basketballs from
close range at his players' heads, legs and feet;
shoving and grabbing his players; feigning punching
them; kicking them; and screaming obscenities and
homophobic slurs.''\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\Don Van Natta, Video shows Mike Rice's ire, ESPN (Apr. 2,
2013), https://www.espn.com/espn/otl/story/_/id/9125796/practice-video-
shows-rutgers-basketball-coach-mike-rice-berated-
pushed-used-slurs-players.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These examples are just a snapshot of unscrupulous coaches
engaging in inappropriate and abusive behavior that ranges from
vulgar or discriminatory language to punishing commands that
result in injuries.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\See LeRoy, supra note 25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sports-Related Injuries
Unsurprisingly, college athletes are inherently at risk of
injury through their participation in sports. An analysis of
NCAA injury data by the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) estimated that over 210,000 injuries occurred
each year.\34\ Among men's sports, football had the highest
annual average of injuries, and wrestling accounted for the
highest overall injury rate.\35\ Among women's sports,
gymnastics had the top overall injury and practice injury rate,
and soccer yielded the largest competition injury rate.\36\
Importantly, injured college athletes are not eligible for
workers' compensation, which provides cash benefits and medical
care for workers who become injured or ill through their
occupation.\37\ College athletes are mandated by the NCAA to
have their own medical insurance to participate, even if it is
through their parents or guardians, or the school, and many
schools provide some form of coverage. However, there are
college athletes without adequate coverage.\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\Zachary Y. Kerr et al., College Sports-Related Injuries--United
States, 2009-10 Through 2013-14 Academic Years, CDC (Dec. 11, 2015),
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6448a2.htm.
\35\Id.
\36\Id.
\37\Tom Dart, College Athletes Are Unpaid. What If Injury Ruins
Their Chance of Turning Pro?, The Guardian (Sept. 6, 2021), https://
www.theguardian.com/sport/2021/sep/06/college-athletes-are-unpaid-what-
if-injury-ruins-their-chance-of-turning-pro.
\38\Cory McCune, NCAA Policies for Student-Athlete Medical
Insurance Breakdown, Bleacher Report (Apr. 8, 2013), https://
bleacherreport.com/articles/1595326-ncaa-policies-for-student-
athlete-medical-insurance-breakdown.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DISCUSSION
While some college athletes have been engaged in active
organizing and advocacy efforts, there is and has been no
effort to broadly classify college athletes as employees. In
fact, the legal tests used to determine whether there exists an
employee-employer relationship is predicated on a case-by-case
basis using a fact-intensive review of the circumstances under
the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA)\39\ and the
National Labor Relations Act of 1935 (NLRA).\40\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\29 U.S.C. Sec. 201 et seq.
\40\29 U.S.C. Sec. 151 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Given the situation-specific analysis required under both
the FLSA and the NLRA (as described below), it is likely that
only college athletes in the most demanding and controlling
athletic programs would potentially be classified as employees.
The Fair Labor Standards Act
The FLSA is the core federal workplace standards law
governing the minimum wage,\41\ overtime,\42\ oppressive child
labor,\43\ and discrimination in pay on the basis of sex,\44\
among other rights and protections. The FLSA is enforced by
both the U.S. Department of Labor and private litigants.\45\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\41\Id. Sec. 6.
\42\Id. Sec. 7.
\43\Id. Sec. 12.
\44\Id. Sec. 6(d).
\45\Id. Sec. 16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the FLSA, the term ``employ'' includes ``to suffer or
permit to work.''\46\ When establishing this broad definition
of employment, Congress rejected the narrower common law
standard of employment, which turns on the degree to which the
employer has control over an employee. Congress instead sought
to expand the employment relationship to hold accountable
employers who would not be liable for violations under a
control test.\47\ Courts test the applicability of the FLSA
definition using the ``economic realities'' test, whic