Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 5346, the
Fair and Accountable IRS Act, on September 17, 2025, and
favorably reported the bill, as amended, to the House of
Representatives (with quorum being present).
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearing was used to develop and consider H.R. 5346:
On February 11, 2025, the Committee on Ways and Means
Oversight Subcommittee held a hearing titled, ``IRS Return on
Investment and the Need for Modernization'' to examine the lack
of return on investment from funding provided to the IRS by the
Inflation Reduction Act and the need for information technology
modernization at the agency.
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Reform Penalty Assessment Procedural Requirements
PRESENT LAW
The Code includes multiple provisions governing the proper
application of penalties and additions to tax. Under those
provisions are rules specifying the procedures and limitations
applicable to assertion of such additions to tax and penalties.
The Secretary of Treasury (``Secretary'') and Internal Revenue
Service (``IRS'') publish guidance for the public and IRS
employees on the administration of penalties consistent with
the statute and in support of encouraging voluntary compliance,
and by adherence to long-standing policy that penalties be
administered based on the merits and with fairness to the
taxpayer.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Sec. 6751, generally, and Internal Revenue Manual, 1.2.1.12.1
Policy Statement 20-1, Penalties are used to enhance voluntary
compliance (June 29, 2004), available at https://www.taxnotes.com/
research/federal/internal-revenue-manual/1.2.1, (last visited September
14, 2025), outlining the obligations of managers and employees in
evaluating assertion of penalties, noting, ``This means that penalties
are not a `bargaining point' in resolving the taxpayer's other tax
adjustments. Rather, the imposition of penalties in appropriate cases
serves as an incentive for taxpayers to avoid careless or overly
aggressive tax reporting positions.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These penalties are categorized into two types: additions
to tax and additional amounts (``additions to tax''), and
assessable penalties. The additions to tax penalties are
generally subject to deficiency proceedings and include
delinquency penalties, failure by individuals to pay estimated
income tax, failure by corporations to pay estimated income
tax, failure to make deposit of taxes, accuracy-related
penalties,\2\ and the fraud penalty,\3\ and may be waived under
certain circumstances, including a showing of reasonable cause.
In contrast, assessable penalties can be assessed without
restrictions (and thus without the opportunity for
preassessment judicial review) applicable in deficiency cases,
although they may be eligible for waiver due to reasonable
cause in administrative proceedings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Sec. 6662 (a penalty equal to 20 percent of the underpayment of
tax that is attributable to any of several enumerated types of error or
negligence, in the absence of reasonable cause; the penalty may
increase to 40 percent in certain other specified circumstances).
\3\Sec. 6663 (a penalty of 75 percent of any portion of an
underpayment of tax resulting from fraud).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 6751(b), added by the IRS Restructuring and Reform
Act of 1998 (the ``Act''), states, ``No penalty under this
title shall be assessed unless the initial determination of
such assessment is personally approved (in writing) by the
immediate supervisor of the individual making such
determination or such higher level official as the Secretary
may designate.''\4\ No definition of ``initial determination''
is provided, nor does the Act specify when the requisite
supervisory approval must be signed. The provision provides
that the immediate supervisor of the person initially
determining the penalty as the party whose approval is
required, although it does not define ``immediate supervisor''
and authorizes the Secretary to designate a higher-level
official to provide the requisite approval.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Sec. 6751(b)(1); IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998, Pub.
L. No. 105-206, Title III, sec. 3306(2), July 22, 1998, as amended by
Pub. L. No. 106-554, Title III, sec. 302(b). The provision applies to
notices issued and penalties assessed after June 30, 2001. A special
rule provided a brief transition rule under which the provision was
considered to have been met with respect to penalties that were subject
of notices issued prior to July 1, 2003, if such notices included a
telephone contact and number at which a taxpayer could obtain a record
of the assessment and payment history regarding that penalty.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two groups of penalties are outside the scope of the
requirement for prior written supervisory approval. First,
several delinquency penalties as well as two accuracy related
penalties are specifically identified as exempt from the
requirement.\5\ Second, those penalties ``automatically
calculated through electronic means'' are also exempt from the
requirement of prior supervisory approval. The United States
Tax Court (``Tax Court'') has held that such standard is met if
a penalty or addition is determined by a computer program
without human review, including accuracy-related penalties
under section 6662(a) and (b).\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Sec. 6751(b)(2), specifically excepts sections 6651, 6654 and
6655 (delinquency penalties for failure to pay tax and estimated taxes)
and accuracy related penalties under section 6662(b)(9) (overstatement
of charitable deduction under section 170(p)); and section 6662(b)(10)
(disallowance of charitable deduction under section 170(h)(7)).
\6\Walquist v. Commissioner, 152 T.C. No. 3 (February 25, 2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Assessment of tax generally refers to the formal recording
of a tax liability for a specific taxable period of a specific
taxpayer, and time and manner of assessment is generally
prescribed by regulations to the extent not specified in
statute.\7\ In proceedings to determine deficiencies, further
restrictions on assessment apply.\8\ A separate provision
contemporaneously enacted with the supervisory approval
requirement imposes a burden of production on the Secretary
with respect to his compliance with assertion of penalties
against individuals.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Secs. 6201-6207.
\8\See secs. 6211-6216.
\9\Sec. 7491(c), added by Pub. L. 105-206, title III, Sec. 3001(a),
July 22, 1998, 112 Stat. 726.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In resulting litigation over the restrictions of section
6751(b), the Tax Court established varying benchmarks as the
point at which an ``initial determination'' occurs that could
require the Secretary to produce evidence of compliance with
the supervisory approval requirement, even if the Secretary
does not bear the burden of proof as to the merits of the
penalty.\10\ These rules have been applied by the Tax Court
without regard to efforts made to comply with standards as they
existed at the time of the examination of years before the
Court.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Chai v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2015-42, rev'd 851 F.3d 190
(2d Cir. 2017); Graev v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. 485, 492-93 (2017),
supplementing and overruling in part 147 T.C. 460 (2016) (supervisory
approval could occur at any point before the assessment was made); Clay
v. Commissioner, 152 T.C. 223, 249-50 (2019) (section 6751(b)
requirement was not satisfied because approval was not obtained before
a communication that advised the taxpayer that penalties would be
proposed and gave the taxpayer the right to appeal them with Appeals),
appeal on other issues aff'd, 990 F.3d 1296 (11th Cir. 2021); and
Belair Woods, LLC v. Commissioner, 154 T.C. 1, 15 (2020) (IRS letter
and summary report, setting forth the tentative proposed adjustments
and inviting taxpayer to a conference to discuss them, was not the
initial determination of a penalty that required prior supervisory
approval; instead the 60-day letter was the initial determination of
the penalties and the IRS satisfied sec. 6751(b)(1) for three of the
penalties asserted by obtaining written supervisory approval for the
penalties before the 60-day letter was issued).
\11\See Chief Counsel Notice 2018-006 (June 6, 2018), discussing
various scenarios in which the provisions of section 6751(b) could be
at issue. See Beland v. Commissioner, 156 T.C. 80 (2021) (granting
taxpayer's motion for partial summary judgment that a fraud penalty was
not timely where the supervisory approval was signed August 21, 2015,
after a revenue agent report was provided to the taxpayer during a
summons administration conference convened on August 19, 2015, citing
the standards first articulated in Chai and Graev, supra, in 2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the Tax Court is a court of national jurisdiction,
Tax Court decisions have been appealed to multiple circuit
courts of appeals based on residence of the taxpayer in the
case, with the result that there is a split of authority among
the Circuits.\12\ In regulations finalized in December 2024,
the Secretary distinguishes between penalties subject to
deficiency procedures and assessable penalties. According to
the regulations, for those subject to deficiency procedures,
the IRS employee who makes an initial determination to assess a
penalty is required to obtain written approval prior to
issuance of the notice from which a petition may be filed. For
assessable penalties, supervisory approval is timely if
obtained prior to assessment.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Contrast the Second Circuit opinion in Chai v. Commissioner,
851 F.3d at 220-21 (referring to the task of determining whether a
specific scenario is a ``consequential moment'' in forming IRS position
on asserting a penalty) with Kroner v. Commissioner, 48 F.4th 1272
(11th Cir. 2022) (holding that approval is timely if provided before
the penalty is assessed, interpreting ``initial determination'' to
describe what is subject to approval, not a timing requirement) and
with Laidlaw's Harley Davidson Sales, Inc. v. Commissioner, 29 F.4th
1066 (9th Cir. 2022) (holding that the statute requires approval before
the assessment of a penalty or, if earlier, before the relevant
supervisor loses discretion whether to approve the penalty assessment).
\13\Treas. Reg. sec. 301.6751(b)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Reasons for Change
The Committee is aware of continuing controversies
regarding the requirement of supervisory approval before the
IRS can assert certain penalties. The need for clarity as to
the timing for such approvals and who among IRS personnel may
provide the approval has created disparate treatment of cases
involving penalties that neither encourages compliance by
taxpayers nor enables the IRS to meet its obligations. To the
extent that Treasury purported to resolve the disparate
treatment by regulations, it did so in a manner inconsistent
with the statute. Accordingly, the proposed legislation is
intended to provide that clarity and to ensure fairer treatment
for taxpayers.
C. Explanation of Provision
Under the provision, the supervisory approval of a penalty
required under section 6751(b)(1) is timely only if the IRS
employee proposing such penalty obtains such approval in
writing prior to any written communication to the taxpayer with
respect to such penalty. The written approval must be provided
by the immediate supervisor of the person proposing the penalty
or such other higher supervisory person as the Secretary may
identify.
The provision defines the term ``immediate supervisor'' for
purposes of section 6751(b) to be the person to whom the IRS
employee making the determination reports.
D. Effective Date
The provision applies to notices issued, and penalties
assessed, after December 31, 2025.
III. VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE
Pursuant to clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following statement is made
concerning the vote of the Committee on Ways and Means in its
consideration of H.R. 5346, the ``Fair and Accountable IRS
Reviews Act,'' as amended on September 17, 2025.
H.R. 5346 was ordered favorably reported to the House of
Representatives as amended by a roll call vote of 44 yeas to 0
nays (with a quorum being present). The vote was as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)................ X ......... ......... Mr. Neal........ X ......... .........
Mr. Buchanan.................. X ......... ......... Mr. Doggett..... X ......... .........
Mr. Smith (NE)................ X ......... ......... Mr. Thompson.... X ......... .........
Mr. Kelly..................... X ......... ......... Mr. Larson...... X ......... .........
Mr. Schweikert................ X ......... ......... Mr. Davis....... X ......... .........
Mr. LaHood.................... X ......... ......... Ms. Sanchez..... ........ ......... .........
Mr. Arrington................ X ......... ......... Ms. Sewell...... X ......... .........
Mr. Estes..................... X ......... ......... Ms. DelBene..... X ......... .........
Mr. Smucker................... X ......... ......... Ms. Chu......... X ......... .........
Mr. Hern...................... X ......... ......... Ms. Moore....... X ......... .........
Mrs. Miller................... X ......... ......... Mr. Boyle....... X ......... .........
Dr. Murphy.................... X ......... ......... Mr. Beyer....... X ......... .........
Mr. Kustoff................... X ......... ......... Mr. Evans....... X ......... .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick............... X ......... ......... Mr. Schneider... X ......... .........
Mr. Steube.................... X ......... ......... Mr. Panetta..... X ......... .........
Ms. Tenney.................... X ......... ......... Mr. Gomez....... X ......... .........
Mrs. Fischbach................ X ......... ......... Mr. Horsford.... X ......... .........
Mr. Moore..................... X ......... ......... Ms. Plaskett.... X ......... .........
Ms. Van Duyne................. X ......... ......... Mr. Suozzi...... X ......... .........
Mr. Feenstra.................. X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
Ms. Malliotakis............... X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
Mr. Carey..................... X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
Mr. Yakym..................... X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
Mr. Miller.................... X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
Mr. Bean...................... X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
Mr. Moran..................... X ......... ......... ................ ........ ......... .........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
In compliance with clause 3(d) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the following statement is made
concerning the effects on the budget of the bill, H.R. 5346 as
reported. The estimate prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office (CBO) is included below.
The staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation estimates the
bill to have the following effect on Federal fiscal year budget
receipts for the period 2026 through 2035:
FISCAL YEARS
[Millions of dollars]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2026-35
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 7 10 12 13 14 14 14 15 15 117
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NOTE: Details do not add to totals due to rounding. The date of enactment is assumed to be October 1, 2025.
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures Budget
Authority
In compliance with clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee states that the
bill involves no new or increased budget authority.
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget Office
The Congressional Budget Act of 1974, as amended stipulates
that revenue estimates provided by the staff of the Joint
Committee on Taxation (``JCT'') will be the official estimates
for all tax legislation considered by Congress. As such CBO
incorporates these estimates into its cost estimates of the
effects of the legislation. The estimates for the revenue
provisions of H.R. 5346 were provided by JCT (see Part IV, A).
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
With respect to clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the Committee made findings and
recommendations that are reflected in this report.
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
Wit