Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 5242]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, to whom
was referred the bill (H.R. 5242) to repeal the Second Chance
Amendment Act of 2022 and the Incarceration Reduction Amendment
Act of 2016, having considered the same, reports favorably
thereon with an amendment and recommends that the bill as
amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Summary and Purpose of Legislation............................... 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 6
Legislative History.............................................. 7
Committee Consideration.......................................... 7
Roll Call Votes.................................................. 7
Explanation of Amendments........................................ 11
List of Related Committee Hearings............................... 11
Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of the
Committee...................................................... 11
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 11
Application of Law to the Legislative Branch..................... 11
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 12
Federal Advisory Committee Act Statement......................... 12
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement........................... 12
Earmark Identification........................................... 12
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 12
New Budget Authority and Congressional Budget Office Cost
Estimate....................................................... 12
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 16
Minority Views................................................... 37
The amendment is as follows:
Strike out all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. REPEAL OF SECOND CHANCE AMENDMENT ACT OF 2022 AND
INCARCERATION REDUCTION AMENDMENT ACT OF 2016.
(a) Second Chance Amendment Act of 2022.--The Second Chance Amendment
Act of 2022 (D.C. Law 24-284) is hereby repealed, and any provision of
law amended or repealed by such Act is restored or revived as if such
Act had not been enacted into law.
(b) Incarceration Reduction Act of 2016.-- The Incarceration
Reduction Amendment Act of 2016 (title III of the Comprehensive Youth
Justice Amendment Act of 2016; D.C. Law 21-238) is hereby repealed, and
any provision of law amended or repealed by such Act is restored or
revived as if such Act had not been enacted into law.
SEC. 2. TERMINATION OF AUTOMATED TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT SYSTEM.
Title IX of the Fiscal Year 1997 Budget Support Act of 1996 (sec. 50-
2209.01 et seq., D.C. Official Code) is hereby repealed.
SEC. 3. ELIMINATING RESTRICTIONS ON RIGHT TURNS AT RED TRAFFIC SIGNALS.
Section 9e of the District of Columbia Traffic Act, 1925, approved
March 3, 1925 (sec. 50- 2201.04e, D.C. Official Code) is repealed.
SEC. 4. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Act, and the amendments made by this Act, shall apply with
respect to criminal conduct that occurred after the date of the
enactment of this Act.
Summary and Purpose of Legislation
H.R. 5242 repeals the Incarceration Reduction Amendment Act
of 2016 (IRAA; title III of the Comprehensive Youth Justice
Amendment Act of 2016, D.C. Law 21-238), passed by the D.C.
Council in 2016. The Incarceration Reduction Act allows
individuals convicted of certain serious crimes committed
before their 18th birthday to petition the court for a sentence
reduction after serving at least 15 years. In repealing the
IRAA, the D.C. Code will reflect the codified language
predating the passage of the Act and all subsequent amendments.
This bill also repeals the Second Chance Amendment Act (SCAA)
of 2022 (D.C. Law 24-284) which expanded D.C.'s expungement and
sealing process to allow more individuals to petition the
District for expungement or sealing of prior conviction records
as well as the automatic expungement or sealing for certain
other convictions, including marijuana possession. The bill
also repeals provisions of D.C. Code authorizing the District's
use of automated traffic enforcement systems and the
requirement for the District to prohibit right turn on red
signage on D.C. streets.
Background and Need for Legislation
The District of Columbia has seen a staggering juvenile
crime rate since the pandemic. In 2023, over 500 arrests of
minors were made on robbery charges alone, rising to levels not
seen since the 1990s.\1\ In 2023, most carjackers were under
the age of 17.\2\ A poll given by Fox 5 DC asked, ``Should
juveniles who commit violent crimes face tougher
punishments?''\3\ 98% of respondents said yes.\4\ There is an
overwhelming desire from the public to find a solution to this
crime epidemic, yet the D.C. Council continues to push lenient
legislation, and AG Schwalb continues to fail to hold juveniles
accountable. In response to an outbreak of juvenile arrests
over the Fourth of July weekend in 2025,\5\ Mayor Bowser signed
emergency legislation, passed by the D.C. Council, that
implemented and expanded the pre-existing summer curfew across
the District.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Id.
\2\The Top 3, FOX 5 DC, at 0:44 (Apr. 26, 2023) [hereinafter ``The
Top 3''], at 4:20.
\3\Id. at 5:15.
\4\Id.
\5\Press Release, Metro. Pol. Dep't, MPD Provides Update on
Response to Navy Yard Unlawful Activity (July 7, 2025).
\6\Luke Lukert, DC mayor toughens summer curfew after 20 teens
charged with fireworks offenses, WTOP News (Jul. 8, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ``Enclave Clause''--as articulated in Article I,
Section 8, Clause 17 of the United States Constitution--
provides Congressional authority to ``exercise exclusive
Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over such District.'' And
the District of Columbia Home Rule Act (Home Rule Act), which
was signed into law in 1973, provides a charter for the local
government of the District of Columbia granting a degree of
self-governance to D.C. officials, including the authority to
legislate, conduct elections, and otherwise govern local
municipal affairs.\7\ Under the Home Rule Act, Congress has the
right to enact legislation for D.C. on any subject, including
legislation to amend or repeal any law in force in the
District, prior to or after enactment, and any act passed by
the D.C. Council.\8\ Congress also retains control over the
District's budget,\9\ and the President appoints the District's
judges.\10\ Section 740 of the Home Rule Act explicitly grants
the President the authority to assume control of the
Metropolitan Police force as the President deems necessary and
appropriate to respond to ``special conditions of an emergency
nature''.\11\ If the President deems it necessary to extend
this appropriation of control beyond 48 hours, he must notify
the Chairmen and Ranking Members of the House Oversight and
Government Reform and Senate Homeland Security and Governmental
Affairs Committees of his reasoning for exercising this
authority and the period of time which the need for such
services is likely to continue.\12\ The emergency use of the
Metropolitan Police force shall terminate upon the end of such
an emergency, the expiration of thirty days following when the
Metropolitan Police were first made available, or upon the
adoption of a resolution to terminate by either the Senate or
House, whichever comes first.\13\ The Senate and House may
approve of use extending beyond a thirty day period through a
concurrent resolution.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\District of Columbia Home Rule Act, Pub. L. No. 93-198 Sec. 601;
87 Stat. 774 (1973).
\8\Id.
\9\Id. Sec. 603.
\10\Id. Sec. 433.
\11\Id. Sec. 740(a).
\12\Id.
\13\Id. Sec. 740(c).
\14\Id. Sec. 740(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On August 11, 2025, President Trump announced major steps
to address out-of-control crime in the District.\15\ President
Trump declared a public safety emergency over the city (EO
14333--Declaring a Crime Emergency in the District of Columbia)
and, pursuant to authority granted to the President under
Section 740 of the Home Rule Act, took control of the MPD.\16\
This is the first time a President has invoked Section 740.
President Trump subsequently signed a memorandum to permit
Secretary of Defense Hegseth to deploy the National Guard into
D.C. to support the work of local law enforcement and to
enforce law and order.\17\ Additionally, hundreds of federal
agents were deployed into the District by the Department of
Justice (DOJ) from such agencies as the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (FBI), Bureau of Arms, Tobacco, and Firearms
(ATF), and more.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\President Trump Holds a Press Conference, Aug. 11, 2025, The
White House (Aug. 11, 2025). [hereinafter ``White House Press
Conference''].
\16\Exec Order No. 14333, 90 Fed. Reg. 39301 (Aug. 14, 2025).
\17\White House Press Conference, supra note 15.
\18\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
President Trump additionally signed two Executive Orders to
solidify the Administration's work with the District. Building
upon the first EO exercising control over the District's police
force, the President issued EO 14339 (Additional Measures To
Address the Crime Emergency in the District of Columbia) which
addresses restoring safety as well as prioritizing the re-
beautification of the District.\19\ The President also signed
EO 14340 (Measures To End Cashless Bail and Enforce the Law in
the District of Columbia) addressing cashless bail and
unwarranted pretrial release practices in the District.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\Exec. Order No. 14339, 90 Fed. Reg. 42121 (Aug. 28, 2025).
\20\Exec. Order No. 14340, 90 Fed. Reg. 42125 (Aug. 28, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Following the President's orders, the Chairman of the DC
Police Union said the union, ``acknowledges and supports the
President's announcement this morning to assume temporary
control of the MPD in response to the escalating crime crisis
in Washington, D.C.''\21\ Mayor Murial Bowser contends that
D.C. is safer than in the 2023 crime spike but otherwise said
that she would work with President Trump as Home Rule
requires.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Spencer Allen Brooks (@SpencerSays), X, (Aug. 11, 2025, 1:06
PM), available at https://x.com/SpencerSays/status/1954952652887834716.
\22\Meagan Flynn, et al., D.C. Mayor Bowser sticks with cautious
approach amid Trump's takeover, The Wash. Post (Aug. 11, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Following this announcement, U.S. Attorney for the District
of Columbia Jeanine Pirro blamed the D.C. Council and D.C.
Attorney General Schwalb for the crime crisis. Citing lack of
prosecutions of juveniles and rising violent crime in the
District, Pirro called for the Council and AG Schwalb to make
immediate changes to stop the crime crisis in D.C.\23\ Mayor
Bowser agreed with some of U.S. Attorney Pirro's concerns while
committing to examine laws at issue and potentially address
these concerns in an omnibus package.\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Id.
\24\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On August 27, Mayor Bowser held a press conference where
she credited the Trump Administration's deployment of federal
law enforcement personnel with a dramatic decrease in crime
between August 11 and August 25.\25\ Carjackings had decreased
87% during this period.\26\ Nearly 1,200 arrests have been made
since President Trump's actions, including members of
designated foreign terrorist organizations MS-13 and Tren de
Aragua.\27\ During this time, federal law enforcement also
seized nearly 120 illegal firearms\28\ and busted a drug
trafficking ring attempting to smuggle fentanyl, PCP, and
cocaine into D.C.\29\ A joint effort by ICE and MPD resulted in
the arrest of an illegal alien previously charged with sex
crimes against a child.\30\ Most notably, D.C. went a full 12
days without a single homicide.\31\ U.S. Attorney Pirro
reported that 88% of arrests made between the start of the
federal deployment on August 11 and August 25 resulted in
charges being filed\32\ representing a substantially higher
than in 2024 where the Biden-appointed U.S. Attorney charged
suspects only 57% of the time.\33\ Clearly the Executive
actions taken by the Trump Administration are working.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Rebeca Shabad, Bowser says Trump's police takeover has lowered
D.C. crime, NBC News (Aug. 27, 2025).
\26\Rebecca Shabad, Mayor Muriel Bowser says Trump's surge of
federal law enforcement has lowered crime in D.C., Yahoo! News (Aug.
27, 2025).
\27\Cameron Arcand, Trump's DC crime crackdown busts another
alleged Tren de Aragua gang member: `Make DC Safe Again,' Fox News
(Aug. 26, 2025).
\28\Id.
\29\Shabad, supra note 25.
\30\Press Release, U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement, ICE,
Metro PD arrest illegal Mexican alien previously charged with sex
crimes against a Virginia child (Aug. 27, 2025).
\31\Sam Kosmas, Trump's executive orders target DC crime as city
hits 12 days without a homicide, Fox 5 Washington, D.C. (Aug. 25,
2025).
\32\Nick Beake & Lucy Gilder, Has crime in Washington fallen two
weeks on from Trump's crackdown?, BBC (Aug. 27, 2025).
\33\Off. of the U.S. Att'y for D.C., 2024 Violent Crime Outcomes
(Dec. 31, 2024), at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2016, the D.C. Council passed the IRAA, providing
criminals convicted of serious crimes committed before their
18th birthday to petition the court for a sentence reduction
after serving at least 15 years, regardless of mandatory
minimum sentences. Since then, violent crime in Washington,
D.C. has soared, particularly carjacking, among juvenile
offenders. Former D.C. Police Chief Peter Newsham has publicly
stated: ``These young people knew they could get away with it .
. . There was very little consequence, and it spiraled out of
control.''\34\ Metropolitan Police carjacking task force
leader, Lieutenant Scott Dowling has said ``the same people
were committing multiple, multiple, multiple offenses,''
mentioning one 2023 case where just three people were arrested
for suspicion of carrying out roughly 50 carjackings and
thefts.\35\ Furthermore, the SCAA expanded expungement and
records sealing for more individuals, as well as expanded
automatic expungement for certain crimes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\Rich Schapiro, Carjacked in the capital: The `crime of the
pandemic' is still roiling D.C., NBC News (Aug, 24, 2025).
\35\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Collectively, these D.C. laws have created an environment
where convicted criminals in the District are not held fully
accountable for their crimes. Notably, United States Attorney
for the District of Columbia Jeanine Ferris Pirro has expressed
strong concern about these current laws, calling on the DC
Council ``to immediately reconsider the'' legislation while her
two predecessors have also echoed many of her concerns with the
SCAA, specifically.\36\ Pirro stresses the problems with using
limited criminal justice resources on the process ``sealing
past convictions rather than addressing present threats and
prosecuting crime.''\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Letter from Jeanine Ferris Pirro, United States Attorney,
District of Columbia, to the Council of the District of Columbia (Aug.
6, 2025), https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/media/1410891/dl.
\37\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
By repealing these two laws, H.R. 5242 would help restore
justice and accountability by better ensuring that the
criminals in our nation's capital remain in jail until the
sentence imposed by the criminal justice system is fully
realized. The effects of H.R. 5242 will apply to criminal
conduct occurring after the date of enactment of the act so as
to not impact those who have already utilized the IRAA and the
SCAA.
In addition to addressing juvenile crime in the District of
Columbia by repealing these two existing laws, the bill, as
reported by the Committee, also repeals two other provisions in
local D.C. law dealing with local traffic management.
Specifically, the bill repeals Title IX of the Fiscal Year 1997
Budget Support Act of 1996 (sec. 50-2209.01 et seq., D.C.
Official Code), which relates to automated traffic enforcement
by striking both the mayor's authorization to use automated
traffic enforcement systems and the liability for an owner of a
vehicle to pay fines associated with a traffic infraction from
an automated traffic enforcement system. Furthermore, the bill
repeals section 9e of the District of Columbia Traffic Act of
1925, approved March 3, 1925 (sec. 50-2201.04e, D.C. Official
Code) which provides for the District's ability to erect
signage prohibiting right turns on red, prohibits right turns
on red, and requires an education campaign on the law. It is
the Committee's view that--rather than relying on traffic
enforcement systems that do less to advance traffic safety than
harass unsuspecting citizens and visitors to bridge budget
gaps--the Washington, D.C. municipal government should
implement sound budget policies that match modest spending
levels with proper revenue sources.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Repeal of Second Chance Amendment Act of 2022 and
Incarceration Reduction Amendment Act of 2016
Subsection (a) repeals the Second Chance Amendment Act of
2022 (D.C. Law 24-284) to restore the D.C. Code to reflect the
codified language predating the passage of the Act.
Subsection (b) repeals the Incarceration Reduction
Amendment Act of 2016 (title III of the Comprehensive Youth
Justice Amendment Act of 2016; D.C. Law 21-238) to restore the
D.C. Code to reflect the codified language predating the
passage of the Act.
Section 2. Termination of automated traffic enforcement system
Repeals Title IX of the FY 1997 Budget Support Act of 1996
(sec. 50-2209.01 et seq., D.C. Official Code), which relates to
automated traffic enforcement. The amendment strikes the
mayor's authorization to use automated traffic enforcement
systems and strikes the requirement for an owner of a vehicle
to pay fines associated with a traffic infraction from an
automated traffic enforcement system.
Section 3. Eliminating restrictions on right turns at red traffic
signals.
Repeals section 9e of the District of Columbia Traffic Act,
1925 (sec. 50-2201.04e, D.C. Official Code) which directs the
District government to erect signage prohibiting right turns on
red and requires an education campaign on the law.
Section 4. Effective date
Clarifies that the bill applies to criminal conduct
occurring after the date of enactment.
Legislative History
H.R. 5242, to repeal the Second Chance Amendment Act of
2022 and the Incarceration Reduction Amendment Act of 2016, was
introduced on September 10, 2025, by Representative David
Kustoff (R-TN). The following Representative is a cosponsor of
the bill: Joe Wilson (R-SC). The bill was referred to the
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. The Committee
considered H.R. 5242 at a business meeting on September 10,
2025, and ordered the bill, as amended, favorably reported by a
recorded vote.
Committee Consideration
On September 10, 2025, the Committee met in open session
and ordered the bill, H.R. 5242, favorably reported, by a roll
call vote of 24-20, a quorum being present.
Roll Call Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the following roll call votes
occurred during the Committee's consideration of H.R. 5242:
The first roll call vote was on Amendment #1 offered by Mr.
Comer to H.R. 5242. The amendment was agreed to by voice vote.
The second roll call vote was on Amendment #1 offered by
Mr. Perry to H.R. 5242. The amendment was agreed to in a
recorded vote of 25-20.
The third roll call vote was on Amendment #2 offered by Mr.
Perry to H.R. 5242. The amendment was not agreed to in a
recorded vote of 25-20.
The fourth roll call vote was on favorably reporting H.R.
5242. The bill was agreed to in a recorded vote of 24-20.
Explanation of Amendments
During Committee consideration of the bill, Representative
James Comer (R-KY), Chairman of the Committee, offered an
amendment to H.R. 5242 that would make a technical change and
add an effective date. The amendment passed by voice vote.
Representative Scott Perry (R-PA) offered an amendment to
H.R. 5242 that would terminate the automated traffic
enforcement system. The amendment passed by recorded vote.
Representative Scott Perry (R-PA) offered an amendment to
H.R. 5242 that would eliminate restrictions on right turns at
red traffic signals. The amendment passed by recorded vote.
List of Related Committee Hearings
In accordance with House rule XIII, clause 3(c)(6), (1) the
following hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 5242:
On March 11, 2025, the Committee on Oversight and
Government Reform subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement held
a legislative hearing titled ``Enhancing Federal, State, and
Local Coordination in the Fight Against Criminal Illegal
Aliens'' with Joseph Humire, Executive Director, The Center for
a Secure Free Society; the Honorable Bob Gaultieri, Sheriff,
Pinellas County, Florida; and Kerry E. Doyle, Former Principal
Legal Advisor, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
(2) The following related hearing was held:
On March 11, 2025, the Committee on Oversight and
Government Reform subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement held
a legislative hearing titled ``Enhancing Federal, State, and
Local Coordination in the Fight Against Criminal Illegal
Aliens'' with Joseph Humire, Executive Director, The Center for
a Secure Free Society; the Honorable Bob Gaultieri, Sheriff,
Pinellas County, Florida; and Kerry E. Doyle, Former Principal
Legal Advisor, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of the Committee
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
(2)(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the Committee's oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the Background and Need for
Legislation section above.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
In accordance with clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee's performance
goals or objectives of this bill are to repeal the Second
Chance Amendment Act of 2022 and the Incarceration Reduction
Amendment Act of 2016.
Application of Law to the Legislative Branch
Section 102(b)(3) of Public Law 104-1 requires a
description of the application of this bill to the legislative
branch where the bill relates to the terms and conditions of
employment or access to public services and accommodations.
This bill does not relate to employment or access to public
services and accommodations in the legislative branch.
Duplication of Federal Programs
In accordance with clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII no provision
of this bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
Federal Government known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, a program that was included in any report from the
Government Accountability Office to Congress pursuant to
section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program related to a
program identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal
Domestic Assistance.
Federal Advisory Committee Act Statement
Pursuant to section 5(b) of Public Law 92-463 (5 U.S.C.
1004(b)), the Federal Advisory Committee Act, the Committee
finds that this Committee Print does not direct the
establishment of an advisory committee.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement
Pursuant to section 423 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974 the Committee has included a letter received from the
Congressional Budget Office below.
Earmark Identification
This bill does not include any congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9 of rule XXI of the House of Representatives.
Committee Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee includes below a cost
estimate of the bill prepared by the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office under section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
New Budget Authority and Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the cost
estimate prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act
of 1974 is as follows:
Summary of legislation: On September 10, 2025, the House
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform ordered 14 bills
to be reported. This document provides estimates for nine of
those bills.
Estimated Federal cost: The costs of the legislation fall
within budget function 800 (general government) and 300
(natural resources and environment).
Basis of estimate: For this estimate, CBO assumes that each
bill will be enacted by the end of calendar year 2025 and that
the estimated amounts will be appropriated each year. This cost
estimate does not include any effects of interactions among the
pieces of legislation. If all nine bills were combined and
enacted as a single piece of legislation, the effects could be
different from the sum of the separate estimates, although CBO
expects that any differences would be small.
Spending subject to appropriation: CBO estimates that
implementing three of the bills, H.R. 5103, H.R. 5179, and H.R.
5183, would increase spending subject to appropriation by
insignificant amounts. Any related spending for those bills
would be subject to the availability of appropriated funds. We
further estimate that implementing the other six bills, H.R.
2693, H.R. 5107, H.R. 5163, H.R. 5172, H.R. 5214, and H.R.
5242, would have no effect on spending subject to
appropriation.
H.R. 2693, the District of Columbia Electronic Transmittal
of Legislation Act of 2025, would amend the District of
Columbia Home Rule Act to explicitly allow the chair of the
Council of the District of Columbia to electronically transmit
to the Congress any act passed by the council; under current
law physical copies must be delivered. CBO estimates enacting
H.R. 2693 would have no cost to the federal government.
H.R. 5103, the Make the District of Columbia Safe and
Beautiful Act of 2025, would expand Executive Order 14252 to
require the Department of the Interior to implement a
beautification program in the district. The bill also would
establish within the executive branch the District of Columbia
Safe and Beautiful Commission to develop and coordinate
priorities for the full enforcement of federal and local laws
within the District of Columbia. The bill also would require
the commission to report its findings to the Congress. The
authority for the program and the commission would end on
January 2, 2029. Based on the cost of similar activities, CBO
estimates that the cost of implementing H.R. 5103 would be
insignificant over the 2026-2030 period.
H.R. 5107, the CLEAN DC Act of 2025, would repeal sections
of the Comprehensive Policing and Justice Reform Amendment Act
of 2022 (D.C. Law 24-345), which established certain
restrictions and requirements for the Metropolitan Police
Department. Because the bill would affect only the District of
Columbia, CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 5107 would have no
cost to the federal government.
H.R. 5163, the Clean and Managed Public Spaces Act, would
impose civil and criminal penalties for camping on public
property within the District of Columbia. Because the bill
would affect only the District of Columbia, CBO estimates that
enacting H.R. 5163 would have no cost to the federal
government.
H.R. 5172, the Strong Sentences for Safer D.C. Streets Act
of 2025, would make changes to the District of Columbia Code
regarding mandatory minimum sentencing guidelines for various
violent offenses. Because the bill would affect only the
District of Columbia, CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 5172
would have no cost to the federal government.
H.R. 5179, the District of Columbia Attorney General
Appointment Reform Act of 2025, would amend the District of
Columbia Home Rule Act by overturning the election of the
current attorney general for the District of Columbia and
authorizing the President to appoint a new attorney general.
The current attorney general's appointment would terminate on
the date of enactment. Based on the cost of similar activities,
CBO estimates that the cost of implementing H.R. 5179 would be
insignificant over the 2026-2030 period.
H.R. 5183, the District of Columbia Home Rule Improvement
Act of 2025, would amend the District of Columbia Home Rule Act
to establish a uniform 60-day Congressional review period for
all legislation, regulations, and executive actions of the
District of Columbia; create a line-item veto during
Congressional review; eliminate the ability of the Council of
the District of Columbia to extend emergency laws; prohibit the
council from withdrawing legislation from the Congressional
review process; and prohibit the council from passing laws that
are substantially similar to legislation disapproved by the
Congress. The bill also would provide for expedited
consideration of resolutions of disapproval within the House
and the Senate. Based on the cost of similar activities, CBO
estimates that the cost of implementing H.R. 5183 would be
insignificant over the 2026-2030 period.
H.R. 5214, the District of Columbia Cash Bail Reform Act of
2025, would amend the Code of the District of Columbia to
require mandatory pretrial detention for defendants charged
with certain violent crimes and require mandatory cash bail or
bail bonds for all defendants charged with other specified
crimes. Because the bill would affect only the District of
Columbia, CBO estimates that enacting the bill would have no
cost to the federal government.
H.R. 5242, a bill to repeal the Second Chance Amendment Act
of 2022 and the Incarceration Reduction Amendment of 2016,
would repeal two laws that reduced criminal penalties for youth
offenders in the District of Columbia. Because the bill would
affect only the District of Columbia, CBO estimates that
enacting the bill would have no cost to the federal government.
Pay-as-you-go considerations: The Statutory Pay-As-You-Go
Act of 2010 establishes budget-reporting and enforcement
procedures for legislation affecting direct spending or
revenues. None of the bills would affect direct spending or
revenues; thus, pay-as-you-go procedures do not apply.
Increase in long-term net direct spending and deficits. CBO
estimates that none of the bills would increase net direct
spending or deficits in any of the four consecutive 10-year
periods beginning in 2036.
Mandates: CBO has determined that six of the nine bills
would impose intergovernmental mandates as defined in the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA). Only one, H.R. 5242, would
impose mandates that exceed the annual intergovernmental
threshold established in UMRA ($103 million in 2025, adjusted
annually for inflation).
H.R. 5242 would impose intergovernmental mandates as
defined in UMRA by preempting some laws of the District of
Columbia. CBO considers such preemptions to be
intergovernmental mandates under UMRA. The bill would repeal
two laws that reduced criminal penalties for youth offenders.
H.R. 5242 also would prohibit the city from operating an
automated traffic enforcement system and from restricting right
turns on red traffic lights. Using budget documents from the
District of Columbia, CBO estimates that automatic traffic
enforcement generates about $300 million annually and that the
city would lose that amount of revenue under the bill.
CBO has determined that the following bills also would
impose intergovernmental mandates but estimates that the cost
of the mandates in each bill would not exceed the annual
threshold established in UMRA:
H.R. 5107 would repeal most of the
Comprehensive Policing and Justice Reform Amendment Act
of 2022 (D.C. Law 24-345).
H.R. 5172 would increase mandatory minimum
sentences for certain crimes in the District of
Columbia.
H.R. 5179 would preempt D.C. law by
repealing the local election of the current attorney
general for the District of Columbia and giving
authority to the President to appoint someone to that
position.
H.R. 5183 would expand Congressional review
over the District of Columbia's laws and regulations,
limit the city's emergency authority, and create a
line-item veto during Congressional review.
H.R. 5214 would require mandatory pretrial
detention for defendants charged with violent crimes
and require cash bail or bail bonds for defendants
charged with other crimes as designated by the bill.
CBO has determined that none of the nine bills would impose
a private-sector mandate as defined in UMRA.
Estimate prepared by: Federal costs: Matthew Pickford,
Alaina Rhee; Mandates: Andrew Laughlin.
Estimate reviewed by: Ann Futrell, Chief, Natural and
Physical Resources Cost Estimates Unit; Kathleen FitzGerald,
Chief, Public and Private Mandates Unit; H. Samuel Papenfuss,
Deputy Director of Budget Analysis.
Estimate approved by: Phillip L. Swagel, Director,
Congressional Budget Office.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets and
existing law in which no change is proposed is shown in roman):
SECOND CHANCE AMENDMENT ACT OF 2022
Be It Enacted By The Council of the District of Columbia, [That
this Act may be cited as the ``Second Chance Amendment Act of
2022''].
[TITLE I--CRIMINAL RECORD SEALING AND EXPUNGEMENT
[Sec. 101. Title 16 of the District of Columbia Official
Code is amended as follows:
[(a) The table of contents is amended by striking the phrase
``8. Criminal Record Sealing'' and inserting the phrase ``8.
Criminal Record Sealing and Expungement'' in its place.
[(b) Chapter 8 is amended to read as follows:
[``CHAPTER 8--CRIMINAL RECORD SEALING AND EXPUNGEMENT
[Sec. 16-801. Definitions
[`` For the purposes of this chapter, the term:
[``(1) `Clerk' means the Clerk of the Superior Court
of the District of Columbia.
[``(2) `Completion of the sentence' means the person
has been unconditionally discharged from incarceration,
commitment, probation, parole, or supervised release,
whichever is latest; provided, that nonpayment of
fines, restitution, or any other monetary assessments
imposed by the Court shall not prevent completion of a
sentence.
[``(3) `Conviction' means the entry of judgment on a
verdict or a finding of guilty, a plea of guilty or a
plea of nolo contendere, or a plea or verdict of not
guilty by reason of insanity.
[``(4) `Court' means the Superior Court of the
District of Columbia.
[``(5) `Public' means any person, agency,
organization, or entity other than any:
[``(A) Court;
[``(B) Federal, state, or local prosecutor;
[``(C) Law enforcement agency;
[``(D) Licensing agency, with respect to a
criminal offense that may disqualify a person
from obtaining that license;
[``(E) Licensed school, day care center,
before or after school facility or other
educational or child protection agency or
facility; and
[``(F) Government employer or nominating or
tenure commission with respect to:
[``(i) Employment of a judicial or
quasi-judicial officer; or
[``(ii) Employment at a senior-level,
executive-grade government position.
[Sec. 16-802. Automatic expungement of criminal records
[``(a) The Court shall order automatic expungement of all
criminal records and court proceedings related only to
citations, arrests, charges, or convictions for the commission
of a criminal offense that has subsequently been
decriminalized, legalized, or held to be unconstitutional by
the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia or the
Supreme Court of the United States, or records related only to
simple possession for any quantity of marijuana in violation of
Sec. 48-904.01(d)(1) before February 15, 2015, if:
[``(1) The case was terminated by the prosecutor or
otherwise reached a final disposition; and
[``(2) The prosecutor has not:
[``(A) Filed a written motion, which may be
made ex parte, to:
[``(i) Retain and sequester the
record for a limited period of time; or
[``(ii) Contest that a particular
person qualifies for expungement under
this section; and
[``(B) Demonstrated by clear and convincing
evidence that:
[``(i) Retention is necessary for a
lawful purpose, such as:
[``(I) Investigating,
prosecuting, or defending
another criminal case;
[``(II) Complying with
disclosure obligations in
another criminal case; or
[``(III) Determining the
person's suitability for
Minority Views
Committee Democrats strongly oppose H.R. 5242, which would
repeal two laws enacted by the District of Columbia (D.C.): the
Second Chance Amendment Act of 2022 and the Incarceration
Reduction Amendment Act of 2016. The bill is opposed by D.C.
Mayor Muriel Bowser, the entire D.C. Council, and D.C. Attorney
General Brian Schwalb.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Letter from District of Columbia Mayor Muriel Bowser to Chairman
James Comer and Ranking Member Robert Garcia, House Committee on
Oversight and Government Reform (Sept. 10, 2025); Letter from Council
of the District of Columbia to Chairman James Comer and Ranking Member
Robert Garcia, House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform
(Sept. 8, 2025); Letter from District of Columbia Attorney General
Brian Schwalb to Chairman James Comer and Ranking Member Robert Garcia,
House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform (Sept. 9, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The purpose of the D.C. Home Rule Act (HRA) is to ``grant
to the inhabitants of the District of Columbia powers of local
self-government'' and ``relieve Congress of the burden of
legislating upon essentially local District matters.''\2\ The
bill would undermine the purpose of the HRA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Pub. L. No. 93-198 (1973).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Second Chance Amendment Act is a criminal record
sealing law. All 50 states and the federal government have
criminal record sealing laws, though the specifics vary.\3\
Twelve states have criminal record sealing laws that meet the
bipartisan Clean Slate Initiative's minimum criteria.\4\ Four
Republicans on the Committee are from states whose laws meet
that criteria.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Collateral Consequences Resource Center, 50-State Comparison:
Expungement, Sealing & Other Record Relief (online at
www.ccresourcecenter.org/state-restoration-profiles/50-state-
comparisonjudicial-expungement-sealing-and-set-aside/) (accessed Sept.
20, 2025).
\4\The Clean Slate Initiative, Clean Slate in States (online at
www.cleanslateinitiative.org/states) (accessed Sept. 20, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A criminal record, including for a mere arrest, has
collateral consequences, such as making it more difficult to
get a job or housing. The Second Chance Amendment Act seals
certain criminal records from public view, but not from law
enforcement, the courts, or other eligible entities. Under the
Second Chance Amendment Act, the availability of criminal
record sealing depends on the type of crime, the type of
record, and, in the case of a conviction, the length of time
since the completion of a sentence.
For example, a conviction for certain felonies, such as 1st
degree murder, is not eligible for sealing. In the case of an
eligible felony, the court cannot order sealing earlier than
eight years after the completion of the sentence. In making
such determinations, the court is required to weigh the
interests of the individual in sealing the records, the
community's interest in furthering the individual's
rehabilitation and reintegration into society, and the
community's interest in retaining access to the records. The
court may also consider seven factors, ranging from the nature
of the crime to the individual's history and characteristics.
The Incarceration Reduction Amendment Act is a sentence
review law. Twenty-five states and the federal government have
such policies, though the specifics vary. Sentence review laws
are premised on, among other things, the evidence on brain
development by age, the deterrence effect of lengthy sentences,
and the age-crime curve.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Sara Cohbra and Becky Feldman, The Second Look Movement: An
Assessment of the Nation's Sentence Review Laws (Aug. 27, 2025) (online
at www.sentencingproject.org/reports/the-second-look-movement-a-review-
of-the-nations-sentence-review-laws/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Incarceration Reduction Amendment Act permits an
individual who is convicted of a crime committed before age 25
and has served at least 15 years in prison to petition the
court to reduce the term of imprisonment. To reduce the term,
the court, after considering enumerated factors, must find that
the individual is not a danger and that the interests of
justice warrant a reduction.
Instead of meddling in local D.C. matters, Congress should
pass the D.C. statehood bill.
Robert Garcia,
Ranking Member.