Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 302]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 302) to prohibit the conditioning of any permit,
lease, or other use agreement on the transfer of any water
right to the United States by the Secretary of the Interior and
the Secretary of Agriculture, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Water Rights Protection Act''.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Secretary.--The term ``Secretary'' means, as applicable--
(A) the Secretary of Agriculture; or
(B) the Secretary of the Interior.
(2) Water right.--The term ``water right'' means any surface
water, groundwater, or water storage use filed, permitted,
certificated, confirmed, decreed, adjudicated, or otherwise
recognized by a judicial proceeding or by the State, in which
the user acquires possession of the water or puts the water to
beneficial use, including water rights of federally recognized
Indian Tribes.
SEC. 3. POLICY DEVELOPMENT.
In developing any rule, policy, directive, management plan, or
similar Federal action relating to the issuance, renewal, amendment, or
extension of any permit, approval, license, lease, allotment, easement,
right-of-way, or other land use or occupancy agreement, the Secretary--
(1) shall--
(A) recognize the longstanding authority of the
States relating to evaluating, protecting, allocating,
regulating, permitting, and adjudicating water use; and
(B) coordinate with the States to ensure that any
rule, policy, directive, management plan, or similar
Federal action is consistent with, and imposes no
greater restriction or regulatory requirement, than
applicable State water law; and
(2) shall not--
(A) assert any connection between surface water and
groundwater that is inconsistent with such a connection
recognized by State water law; or
(B) take any action that adversely affects--
(i) the authority of a State in--
(I) permitting the beneficial use of
water; or
(II) adjudicating water rights;
(ii) any definition established by a State
with respect to the term ``beneficial use'',
``priority of water rights'', or ``terms of
use''; or
(iii) any other right or obligation of a
State established under State law.
SEC. 4. TREATMENT OF WATER RIGHTS.
The Secretary shall not--
(1) condition the issuance, renewal, amendment, or extension
of any permit, approval, license, lease, allotment, easement,
right-of-way, or other land use or occupancy agreement on the
transfer of any water right (including joint and sole
ownership) directly or indirectly to the United States, or on
any impairment of title or interest, in whole or in part,
granted or otherwise recognized under State law, by Federal or
State adjudication, decree, or other judgment, or pursuant to
any interstate water compact;
(2) require any water user (including any federally
recognized Indian Tribe) to apply for or acquire a water right
in the name of the United States under State law as a condition
of the issuance, renewal, amendment, or extension of any
permit, approval, license, lease, allotment, easement, right-
of-way, or other land use or occupancy agreement; or
(3) condition or withhold the issuance, renewal, amendment,
or extension of any permit, approval, license, lease,
allotment, easement, right-of-way, or other land use or
occupancy agreement, in whole or in part, on--
(A) limiting the date, time, quantity, location of
diversion or pumping, or place of use of a State water
right beyond any applicable limitations under State
water law; or
(B) the modification of the terms and conditions of
groundwater withdrawal, guidance and reporting
procedures, or conservation and source protection
measures established by a State.
SEC. 5. EFFECT.
(a) Reclamation Contracts.--Nothing in this Act in any way interferes
with any existing or future Bureau of Reclamation contract entered into
pursuant to Federal reclamation law (the Act of June 17, 1902 (32 Stat.
388, chapter 1093), and Acts supplemental to and amendatory of that
Act).
(b) Endangered Species Act.--Nothing in this Act affects the
implementation of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1531 et
seq.).
(c) Federal Reserved Water Rights.--Nothing in this Act limits or
expands any existing or future reserved water rights of the Federal
Government on land administered by the Secretary.
(d) Federal Power Act.--Nothing in this Act limits or expands
authorities pursuant to sections 4(e), 10(j), or 18 of the Federal
Power Act (16 U.S.C. 797(e), 803(j), 811).
(e) Indian Water Rights.--Nothing in this Act limits or expands any
existing or future reserved water right or treaty right of any
federally recognized Indian Tribe.
(f) Federally Held State Water Rights.--Nothing in this Act limits
the ability of the Secretary, through applicable State procedures, to
acquire, use, enforce, or protect a State water right owned by the
United States.
(g) Interstate Compacts.--Nothing in this Act affects an allocation
contained in, or limitations and requirements of, any interstate water
compact or decree of the Supreme Court of the United States
interpreting or enforcing an interstate water compact.
PURPOSE OF THE LEGISLATION
The purpose of H.R. 302 is to prohibit the conditioning of
any permit, lease, or other use agreement on the transfer of
any water right to the United States by the Secretary of the
Interior and the Secretary of Agriculture, and for other
purposes.
Background and Need for Legislation
H.R. 302 requires that any federal action taken by the
Departments of the Interior and Agriculture (Departments) that
impact water rights impose no greater restriction on those
rights than applicable state law and does not adversely affect
state authority over water rights. In addition, the bill
prohibits agencies within the Departments from acquiring state
recognized water rights as a condition of federal permits,
leases, allotments or other land use agreements.
Western states have historically held the right to their
own water rights, however in the 1920s the federal government
began to pursue the establishment of water rights with
increased frequency. During this period, the federal government
could not be bound by a water rights determination in state
court because the federal government was immune from state
court decisions.\1\ This changed in 1952 when Congress passed
the so called ``McCarran Amendment'' (43 U.S.C. 666), which
waived the federal government's immunity from State court
decisions and laws to such proceedings. This landmark law
continued a tradition of federal deference to state water laws
but put in place a framework under which the federal government
was treated like a private entity for the purposes of seeking
water rights within western states.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Bill Report, Water Rights Protection Act of 2017. July 25, 2017.
\2\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The issue of the relationship between federal agencies and
state water rights resurfaced in 2014 when the United States
Forest Service (USFS) published a press release stating that
USFS needed to ``improve the Forest Service's ability to manage
and analyze the potential uses of National Forest Service (NFS)
land that could affect groundwater resources.''\3\ The USFS
indicated that this proposal would not impact a state's ability
to manage their own water rights despite the proposal including
that the USFS would ``evaluate all applications to States for
water rights on NFS lands and applications for water rights on
adjacent lands that could adversely affect NFS groundwater
resources.''\4\ For example, in 2011 USFS issued a national
interim directive for all 122 public land ski areas in the
United States. The directive included a clause requiring
applicant ski areas to relinquish privately held water rights
to the United States as a permit condition.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\United States Department of Agriculture: U.S. Forest Service
Proposes New Management Practices for Stewardship of Water Resources,
May 5, 2014 (press release).
\4\Forest Service Groundwater Resource Management Chapter
2560.03.03: p. 9-10.
\5\Bill Report, Water Rights Protection Act of 2017. July 25, 2017.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This bill would ensure the long-standing precedent giving
states primacy over water rights determinations. Similar
versions of this bill have been introduced each Congress since
the 113th Congress. A similar version of this bill passed the
House by a bipartisan vote of 238-174 during the 113th
Congress\6\ and another was reported favorably by the Committee
on Natural Resources in the 115th Congress.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Text-H.R. 3189-113th Congress (2013-2014): Water Rights
Protection Act | Congress.gov | Library of Congress.
\7\Actions-H.R. 2939-115th Congress (2017-2018): Water Rights
Protection Act of 2017 | Congress.gov | Library of Congress.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Action
H.R. 302 was introduced on January 9, 2025, by
Representative Celeste Maloy (R-UT). The bill was referred to
the Committee on Natural Resources. The bill was also referred
to the Committee on Agriculture. On February 12, 2025, the
Committee on Natural Resources met to consider the bill.
Representative Celeste Maloy (R-UT) offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute designated Maloy_011 ANS. The Amendment
in the Nature of a Substitute was agreed to by voice vote. The
bill, as amended, was ordered favorably reported to the House
of Representatives by a roll call vote of 22 yeas to 16 nays,
as follows:
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing in the 118th Congress by the Subcommittee on Water,
Wildlife and Fisheries held on July 9, 2024.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
Section 2. Definitions
Section 3. Policy development
When developing any Federal action related to a
land use or occupancy agreement, the Secretary shall recognize
State authority over adjudicating water use.
The Secretary shall not take any action that
adversely affects State authority over adjudicating water
rights.
Section 4. Treatment of water rights
The Secretary shall not condition the issuance of
any land use or occupancy agreement on the transfer of water
rights directly or indirectly to the United States.
The Secretary shall not require any water user to
apply for or acquire a water right in the name of the United
States under state law as a condition of receiving land use or
occupancy agreement.
The Secretary shall not condition a land use or
occupancy agreement on limitation State water right beyond any
applicable limitations under State water law, this includes
managing groundwater based on measures established by a State.
Section 5. Effect
Clarifies that this bill does not affect the
implementation of Bureau of Reclamation contracts, the
Endangered Species Act, federal reserved water rights the
Federal Power Act, Indian water rights, federal held State
water rights or interstate compacts.
COMMITTEE OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
COMPLIANCE WITH HOUSE RULE XIII AND CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET ACT
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
sections 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for the
bill from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
H.R. 302 would prohibit the Departments of Agriculture and
the Interior from requiring certain entities to transfer their
water rights to the United States as a condition for using
public lands. The bill also would require the departments to
consult with states when developing policies related to land
use agreements.
CBO expects that implementing H.R. 302 would not affect the
use of public land or any associated federal receipts, which
are recorded in the budget as changes to direct spending. Thus,
CBO estimates that enacting the bill would have no effect on
direct spending. CBO estimates that the administrative costs to
implement the bill would be insignificant over the 2025-2030
period. Any spending would be subject to the availability of
appropriated funds.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Alaina Rhee. The
estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy Director
of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this bill is to prohibit the conditioning of any
permit, lease, or other use agreement on the transfer of any
water right to the United States by the Secretary of the
Interior and the Secretary of Agriculture, and for other
purposes.
EARMARK STATEMENT
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
UNFUNDED MANDATES REFORM ACT STATEMENT
According to the Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 302
contains no unfunded mandates as defined by the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act.
EXISTING PROGRAMS
Directed Rule Making. This bill does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Publc Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
PREEMPTION OF STATE, LOCAL OR TRIBAL LAW
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW
As ordered reported by the Committee on Natural Resources,
H.R. 302 would make no changes in existing law.
Dissenting Views
H.R. 302, the Water Rights Protection Act, would prohibit
the Secretaries of the Interior and Agriculture from
conditioning future permits on federal land on the transfer of
water rights to the federal government or on, in some
instances, a requirement that the permit holder apply for water
rights in the U.S. government's name. The bill would, contrary
to established law, also prohibit the federal government from
requiring the federal permit holder to meet federal resource
protection standards if those conditions supersede the baseline
requirements from the state. These provisions would undermine
long-standing authorities of the Departments of the Interior
and Agriculture to establish conditions to protect the lands
and resources Congress has entrusted both agencies to manage.
The Water Rights Protection Act was initially introduced in
2013, in the 113th Congress, to resolve a dispute between the
U.S. Forest Service and the National Ski Areas Associations
over water rights on federal lands. In 2011, the Forest Service
had issued an Interim Directive for ski area operators on
federal lands, seeking to require ski areas to transfer their
water rights to the federal government. The Forest Service was
concerned that the value of these water rights could
incentivize ski resort owners to sell them, leaving the Forest
Service to manage the land with no access to water for future
resort operations or other uses. The ski areas contended that
the 2011 directive violated Colorado water law and the Colorado
Constitution. In 2012, a federal court ruled that the Forest
Service must withdraw the directive on procedural grounds. The
Forest Service revised its position in 2013, stating the agency
could achieve its land management goals without requiring the
transfer of privately held water rights to the government, and
accordingly the agency issued a final directive, in 2015, that
allows ski areas to maintain ownership of their water rights,
as long as assurances are made that sufficient water will
remain for the ski area's operations, even if the ski resort is
later sold. Importantly, the new directive was supported by the
ski industry, rendering the Water Rights Protection Act
unnecessary.
While the federal government often defers to state law in
the allocation of water, the Supreme Court has established that
the federal government has federal reserved water rights that
allow the federal government to remove water available for
state law appropriation and to establish and exercise federal
water rights that don't necessarily accord with state law.
These federal rights coexist with water rights administered
under state law. Federal reserved water rights were recognized
by the U.S. Supreme Court in Winters v. United States\1\ in
1908. Under the Winters doctrine, when the federal government
reserves land from the public domain for the federal purpose of
creating a tribal reservation, it also reserves water resources
sufficient to fulfill the purpose of the reservation. Although
the Winters Doctrine was recognized in the context of Indian
reservations, courts have clarified that the reasoning applies
to other federal land reservations, including water uses in
national forests, national parks, national monuments, and other
areas. As a result, federal agencies have sometimes asserted or
negotiated reserved water rights under federally authorized
purposes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\207 U.S. 564.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite the resolution of the brief dispute that initially
prompted this legislation, Republicans continue pushing this
flawed bill, which would undermine these long-standing federal
authorities. In previous Congresses, the Department of the
Interior testified that H.R. 302 would severely limit federal
agencies' ability to manage public lands and resources for the
benefit of all Americans. If enacted, the bill would strip
federal land managers of their ability to regulate water use,
leaving public lands vulnerable to increased degradation. It
would also interfere with the protection of national parks,
wildlife refuges, and other public lands that rely on secure
water supplies, while harming recreational areas, wild and
scenic rivers, and cultural sites. Furthermore, even with its
savings clause on the matter, H.R. 302 would jeopardize the
United States' trust and treaty responsibilities toward tribes
by weakening federal reserved water rights.
H.R. 302 would restrict federal agencies in their ability
to protect federal reserved water rights and create
considerable uncertainty and undermine the existing water
rights framework by imposing sweeping, contradictory
prohibitions, which will inevitably trigger significant legal
disputes. Ultimately, this legislation is a poorly drafted bill
that, under the guise of protecting ``states' rights,'' would
disrupt long-standing federal water rights and introduce
significant legal uncertainty, harming both the environment and
the people who rely on these vital resources.
Jared Huffman,
Ranking Member.
[all]