Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4054]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 4054) to amend the Higher Education Act
of 1965 to reform accreditation, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that
the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Striking all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Accreditation Choice and Innovation
Act''.
SEC. 2. ACCREDITING AGENCY RECOGNITION.
(a) Criteria Required.--Section 496(a) of the Higher Education Act of
1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(a)) is amended--
(1) in the matter preceding paragraph (1), in the first
sentence, by striking ``or training'' and inserting ``or skills
development'';
(2) by amending paragraph (1) to read as follows:
``(1) the accrediting agency or association (other than an
accrediting agency or association described in paragraph
(2)(D)) shall be a State or national agency or association and
shall demonstrate the ability to operate as an institutional or
programmatic accrediting agency or association within the State
or nationally, as appropriate;'';
(3) in paragraph (2)--
(A) in subparagraph (A)--
(i) in clause (i), by striking ``principal'';
and
(ii) in clause (ii), by striking ``its
principal'' and inserting ``a''; and
(B) in subparagraph (B), by striking ``or'' at the
end;
(C) in subparagraph (C)--
(i) by striking ``its principal'' and
inserting ``a''; and
(ii) by inserting ``or'' at the end; and
(D) by adding at the end the following:
``(D) is an entity (such as an industry-specific
quality assurance entity) that has been--
``(i) determined by a State to be a reliable
authority as to the quality of education or
skills development offered in such State for
the purposes of this Act; and
``(ii) designated (in accordance with
subsection (b)(1)) by such State as an
accrediting agency or association with respect
to such State for such purposes;'';
(4) in paragraph (3)--
(A) by amending subparagraph (A) to read as follows:
``(A) subparagraph (A), (C), or (D) of paragraph (2),
then such agency or association is--
``(i) distinctly incorporated or organized;
and
``(ii) both administratively and financially
separate from, and independent of, any related,
associated, or affiliated trade association or
membership organization, by ensuring that--
``(I) the members of the board or
governing body of the accrediting
agency or association are not elected
or selected by the board or chief
executive officer (or the
representative of such board or
officer) of any related, associated, or
affiliated trade association or
membership organization;
``(II) among the membership of the
board or governing body of the
accrediting agency or association--
``(aa) if such board or body
is comprised of 5 or fewer
members, there is a minimum of
one member who is not also a
member of any related,
associated, or affiliated trade
association or membership
organization (referred to in
this subclause as a `public
member') and who represents
business (such as an owner of a
business (including a small
business), a chief executive or
operating officer of a
business, or another other
business executive or employer
with optimum policymaking or
hiring authority); and
``(bb) if such board or body
is comprised of 6 or more
members, there is a minimum of
2 public members (at least one
of whom represents business (as
described in item (aa))) for
every 6 members;
``(III) guidelines are established
for such members to avoid conflicts of
interest, including specific guidelines
to ensure that no such member is an
employee of any institution accredited
by the agency or association or has a
financial interest in any such
institution;
``(IV) dues to the accrediting agency
or association are paid separately from
any dues paid to any related,
associated, or affiliated trade
association or membership organization;
and
``(V) the budget of the accrediting
agency or association is developed,
determined, and maintained by the
accrediting agency or association
without any review by, consultation
with, or approval by any related,
associated, or affiliated trade
association or membership organization;
or'';
(B) by striking ``or'' at the end of subparagraph
(B); and
(C) by striking subparagraph (C);
(5) in paragraph (4)--
(A) in subparagraph (A)--
(i) by inserting ``(in the manner described
in subparagraph (B))'' after ``religious
missions''; and
(ii) by striking ``and'' at the end; and
(B) by striking subparagraph (B) and inserting the
following:
``(B) such accrediting agency or association consistently
applies and enforces standards that respect the stated
religious mission of an institution of higher education by--
``(i) basing decisions regarding accreditation and
preaccreditation on the standards of accreditation of
such agency or association; and
``(ii) not using as a negative factor the
institution's religious mission based policies,
decisions, and practices in the areas covered by
subparagraphs (B), (C), (D), (E), and (F) of paragraph
(5), except that the agency or association may require
that the institution's or a program of study's
curricula include all core components required by the
agency or association that are not inconsistent with
the institution's religious mission; and
``(C) such agency or association demonstrates the ability to
review, evaluate, and assess the quality of any instruction
delivery model or method such agency or association has or
seeks to include within its scope of recognition, without
giving preference to or differentially treating (such as
through separate standards, procedures, or policies) a
particular instruction delivery model or method offered by an
institution or program, except that in a case in which an
instruction delivery model allows for the separation of the
student from the instructor, the agency or association requires
the institution to have processes--
``(i) through which the institution establishes that
the student who registers in a course or program with
such an instruction delivery model is the same student
who participates in the course or program of study
(including, to the extent practicable, the testing or
other assessments required under the course or program
of study), completes the course or program of study,
and receives the academic credit for such course or
program of study; and
``(ii) which are implemented in a manner that is
minimally burdensome to the student;'';
(6) in paragraph (5)--
(A) by amending subparagraph (A) to read as follows:
``(A) success with respect to student achievement
outcomes in relation to the institution's mission and
to the programs the institution offers, or the mission
of a specific degree, certificate, or credential
program, which may include different standards for
different institutions or programs of study, and which
shall include--
``(i) standards for consideration of student
success outcomes measures, including--
``(I) a comparison of the median
total price charged to students in a
program of study student cohort to the
value-added earnings of such cohort;
``(II) completion rates;
``(III) retention rates; and
``(IV) loan repayment rates;
``(ii) standards for consideration of
learning outcomes measures (such as competency
attainment and licensing examination passage
rates); and
``(iii) standards for consideration of labor
market outcomes measures (such as employability
measures, earnings gains, or other similar
approaches);''; and
(B) by amending subparagraph (I) to read as follows:
``(I) record of student complaints received by, or
available to, the agency or association, and the
institution's process for resolving complaints against
the institution; and'';
(C) in the matter following subparagraph (J), by
striking ``subparagraphs (A), (H), and (J)'' and
inserting ``subparagraph (J)''; and
(7) in paragraph (6)(A)(ii), by inserting before the
semicolon at the end the following: ``(including any student
complaints received by, or available to, the agency or
association)''.
(b) Secretarial Requirements and Authority.--Subsection (b) of
section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is
amended to read as follows:
``(b) Secretarial Requirements and Authority.--
``(1) State designated accrediting agency.--
``(A) Approval of state plans.--The Secretary shall--
``(i) if a State's plan with respect to the
State's designation of an entity as an
accrediting agency or association for the
purposes described in subsection (a)(2)(D)
includes each of the elements listed in
subparagraph (B)--
``(I) subject to clause (ii)(I),
approve the State's designation of such
entity as such accrediting agency or
association for the purposes described
in subsection (a)(2)(D) for a 5-year
period, beginning not later than 30
days after receipt of the plan from
such State with respect to such
designation;
``(II) submit to the State and the
authorizing committees, and make
publicly available, the Secretary's
response to the State with respect to
such plan, including whether the plan
includes each of the elements listed in
subparagraph (B); and
``(III) publish in the Federal
Register, with a 30-day public comment
period, the plan submitted by such
State with respect to such designation,
and the Secretary's response to such
plan; and
``(ii) if, not later than 30 days after the
30-day public comment period referred to in
clause (i)(III), a State revises the State's
plan approved under clause (i)(I) to
incorporate one or more of the comments
received during such 30-day comment period, and
such revised plan includes each of the elements
listed in subparagraph (B)--
``(I) revise the 5-year period
described in clause (i)(I) approving
the State's designation of the entity
as an accrediting agency or association
for the purposes described in
subsection (a)(2)(D) to begin not later
than 30 days after receipt of such
revised plan;
``(II) submit to the State and the
authorizing committees, and make
publicly available, the Secretary's
response to the State with respect to
such revised plan, including whether
such revised plan includes each of the
elements listed in subparagraph (B);
and
``(III) publish in the Federal
Register, such revised State plan, and
the Secretary's response to such
revised State plan.
``(B) Required plan elements.--The required elements
of a State plan submitted under subparagraph (A) with
respect to the designation of an entity as an
accrediting agency or association are as follows:
``(i) A description of the process the State
used to select the entity for such designation.
``(ii) A justification of the State's
decision to select the entity for such
designation.
``(iii) A description of any requirements (in
addition to the requirements of this section),
that the State required the entity to comply
with as a condition of receiving and
maintaining such designation, including a
requirement for the entity to use, to the
extent practicable during such designation, the
common terminology developed pursuant to
paragraph (3).
``(iv) A copy of the standards, policies, and
procedures of the entity that the State
considered in selecting the entity for such
designation.
``(v) The State's assessment of how the
standards for accreditation of the entity will
be effective in meeting the requirements of
subsection (a)(5).
``(vi) Evidence that at least one other State
has determined that such entity is a reliable
authority as to the quality of education
offered for the purposes of this Act.
``(vii) An assurance that the State will
comply with the monitoring requirements
described in subparagraph (C).
``(C) State monitoring.--
``(i) In general.--A State that has
designated an entity as an accrediting agency
or association for the purposes described in
subsection (a)(2)(D) shall submit to the
Secretary, and to the State authorizing entity,
as appropriate, a report at the end of the 5-
year period for which the entity has received
such designation, which shall include, with
respect to each program of study or institution
that has been accredited by such entity during
such period, and disaggregated by type of
Committee Action
115TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On April 27, 2017, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Strengthening Accreditation to
Better Protect Students and Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to review the concerns that the current
accreditation system is no longer focused on ensuring a high-
quality education experience and to examine ways to strengthen
its mechanics to provide accountability for both students and
taxpayers. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Mary Ellen
Petrisko, President, WASC Senior College and University
Commission, Alameda, CA; Dr. George A. Pruitt, President,
Thomas Edison State University, Trenton, NJ; Mr. Ben Miller,
Senior Director for Postsecondary Education, Center for
American Progress, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Michale S.
McComis, Executive Director, Accrediting Commission of Career
Schools and Colleges, Arlington, VA.
116TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On April 3, 2019, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Investment Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Strengthening Accountability in Higher Education to Better
Serve Students and Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to review the triad accountability system of higher education,
of which accrediting agencies and associations compromise one-
third of the entities responsible for holding institutions
accountable to students and taxpayers. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Dr. Nicholas Hillman, Associate Professor of
Education Leadership and Policy Analysis, University of
Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI; Ms. Melissa Emrey-Arras,
Director of Education, Workforce, and Income Security, United
States Government Accountability Office, Washington D.C.; Mr.
Noe Ortega, Deputy Secretary of the Office of Postsecondary and
Higher Education, Pennsylvania Department of Education,
Harrisburg, PA; and Dr. Barbara Brittingham, President, New
England Commission of Higher Education, Wakefield, MA.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On July 27, 2023, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on ``Lowering
Costs and Increasing Value for Students, Institutions, and
Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the hearing was to discuss with
policy experts the root causes of student debt and ways to
lower the cost of college through reforms to the postsecondary
education accountability system, including reforms to the
accreditation system that prioritize academics over a social
justice agenda. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Mr.
Michael B. Horn, Author and Co-Founder of the Clayton
Christensen Institute for Disruptive Innovation, Lexington, MA;
Mr. Stig Leschly, President and Founder, Postsecondary
Commission, Boston, MA; Dr. Stephanie Cellini, Professor of
Public Policy and Public Administration, and of Economics,
George Washington University, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Andrew
Gillen, Senior Policy Analyst, Texas Public Policy Foundation,
Austin, TX.
Second Session--Hearings
On March 7, 2024, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Divisive, Excessive, Ineffective: The Real Impact of DEI on
College Campuses.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine
ways in which institutions and accreditors are engaging in
harmful diversity, equity, and inclusion practices (DEI),
including accreditors with DEI-based standards that
institutions are obligated to meet. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Dr. Erec Smith, Associate Professor of
Rhetoric, York College of Pennsylvania, Cato Research Fellow,
York, PA; Dr. James Murphy, Director of Career Pathways and
Post-Secondary Policy, Education Reform Now, Washington, D.C.;
and Dr. Stanley Goldfarb, Chair, Do No Harm, Bryn Mawr, PA; Dr.
Jay Greene, Senior Research Fellow, The Heritage Foundation's
Center for Education Policy, Fayetteville, AK.
Legislative Action
On January 11, 2024, Chairwoman Virginia Foxx introduced
H.R. 6951, the College Cost Reduction Act, with original co-
sponsors Representatives Burgess Owens (R-UT), Glenn Grothman
(R-WI), Rick Allen (R-GA), Lloyd Smucker (R-PA), Lisa McClain
(R-MI), Michelle Steel (R-CA), and Brandon Williams (R-NY). On
January 31, 2024, the Committee considered H.R. 6951 in a
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 22-19. The
Committee considered the following amendments to H.R. 6951:
1. Rep. Owens offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute that makes technical changes to the text.
The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
2. Rep. Hayes (D-CT) offered an amendment that would
increase the total maximum Pell Grant amount awarded
during the 2025-2026 award year from the current amount
of $7,395 to $10,000 and increase it incrementally
thereafter. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
3. Rep. Hayes offered an amendment to strike a
subpart of the bill on the topic of accreditors. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #2, which
failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
4. Rep. Hayes offered an amendment that would provide
federal student loan forgiveness for teachers. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #3, which
failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
5. Rep. Stevens (D-MI) offered an amendment that
would make post baccalaureate students eligible to
receive a Pell Grant. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote
of 17-22.
6. Rep. DeSaulnier (D-CA) offered an amendment that
would increase the total number of semesters a student
can be eligible for Pell Grants from 12 to 18. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1, which
failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
7. Rep. Courtney (D-CT) offered an amendment that
would expand the Public Service Loan Forgiveness
program. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
8. Rep. Wilson (D-FL) offered an amendment that would
allow graduate or professional students to be eligible
to receive a federal Direct Stafford Loan, excluding
graduate medical school, nursing school, veterinary
school or a school located outside the U.S. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1, which
failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
9. Rep. Stevens offered an amendment that would
stipulate that nothing under the bill can be construed
to prevent graduate students from exercising collective
bargaining rights under the National Labor Relations
Act. The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc
#2, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
10. Rep. Wilson offered an amendment that would
strike a provision to repeal regulations related to
financial value transparency and gainful employment,
and stipulate that the Department of Education would
not be permitted to promulgate or enforce any
regulation or rules related to the application of the
term ``gainful employment.'' The amendment was included
in amendment En Bloc #4, which failed by a roll call
vote of 19-22.
11. Ranking Member Scott (D-VA) offered an amendment
that would establish an interest rate equal to the high
yield of the 10-year Treasury note auctioned at the
final auction prior to June 1, 2025, or 5 percent for
new federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford loans, federal
Direct Stafford loans, and federal Direct PLUS loans
issued on or after July 1, 2025. It also would
establish a new rate for any federal Direct
Consolidation Loan. The amendment would also authorize
the Department of Education to establish a program to
refinance federal Direct Loans. It also would authorize
the Department to establish a program to refinance
eligible private education loans. It would establish
guidelines for determining the interest rate for
refinanced loans through both programs, which would be
fixed. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of 19-
22.
12. Rep. Leger Fernandez (D-NM) offered an amendment
that would direct the Department of Education, in
consultation with the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau, Financial Literacy and Education Commission,
and IRS, to establish a personal finance education
portal on a centralized and publicly available
Department website for federal financial aid. Rep.
Leger Fernandez subsequently withdrew the amendment.
13. Rep. Leger Fernandez offered an amendment that
would authorize the Department of Education to award
grants for tuition-free community college to eligible
states and tribal colleges and universities. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #5, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
14. Rep. Takano (D-CA) offered an amendment that
would strike a provision to repeal the current 90/10
regulation that caps the percentage of revenue that a
for-profit school can receive from federal financial
aid sources at 90 percent and stipulate that the other
10 percent of revenue must come from alternative
sources. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of
19-22.
15. Rep. Takano offered an amendment that would add
language to stipulate that the bill's provisions would
not take effect until the inspectors general of the
departments of Education and Veterans Affairs submit a
report to Congress certifying that the bill will not
result in fraud or abuse of veteran students. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
16. Rep. Adams (D-NC) offered an amendment that would
stipulate that no claim from a federal student loan can
be collected by administrative offset for any payments
related to Social Security. It would apply to any
payments made after the bill's enactment. The amendment
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
17. Rep. Adams offered an amendment that would
require the Department of Education, a guaranty agency,
or an eligible loan holder to remove any adverse item
of information related to a loan from a borrower's
credit history upon the sale or assignment of a loan
after the loan is reported as being in default. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #3, which
failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
18. Rep. Gregorio Sablan (D-MP) offered an amendment
that would establish a program to enable college-bound
residents of the Northern Mariana Islands and American
Samoa to have additional choices to attend higher
education institutions. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a roll call vote
of 19-22.
19. Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA) offered an amendment that
would strike a provision to repeal current regulations
related to closed school loan discharges. The amendment
was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
20. Rep. Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR) offered an amendment
that would add language to require colleges and
universities to accept individualized education
programs or plans describing services or accommodations
provided to an individual with a disability, pursuant
to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as
proper documentation for disability accommodations. The
amendment failed by a roll call vote of 19-21.
21. Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) offered an amendment
that would strike a provision that would repeal current
regulations related to borrower repayment defense. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
22. Rep. Jayapal offered an amendment that would
require the postsecondary student data system to
include data on applications received, students
accepted, and students placed on the wait list
disaggregated by race and ethnic subgroup at each IHE.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #5,
which failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
23. Rep. Jayapal offered an amendment that would
require the Department of Education to adjust the
median cost of college for a program of study for
institutions located in a metropolitan area to account
for the higher cost of living. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a
roll call vote of 18-22.
24. Rep. Omar offered an amendment that would strike
a provision that would stipulate that the Department of
Education would not issue a proposed rule, final
regulation, or exhaustive action to carry out the
bill's provisions if it is determined that it would be
economically significant or result in a subsidy cost
increase. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
25. Rep. Omar offered an amendment that would
authorize a program for the Department of Education to
provide grants for a period of five years to eligible
IHEs to provide childcare services for student parents.
The amendment failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
26. Rep. Omar offered an amendment that would strike
a provision that would establish annual limits on
federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford Loans, for any
period of instruction beginning on or after July 1,
2025, which would not exceed the cost of attendance for
an academic year. It also would strike the
establishment of maximum aggregate student loan amounts
professional, graduate, and undergraduate students can
receive through such loans. The amendment was included
in amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call
vote of 18-22
27. Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) offered an amendment that
would strike a provision that would establish two
repayment plans for federal loans made on or after July
1, 2024, including a standard repayment plan with a
fixed monthly repayment amount paid over a fixed period
that does not exceed 10 years and a standard repayment
assistance plan under the income-driven repayment
program. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
28. Rep. Jamaal Bowman (D-NY) offered an amendment
that would stipulate that nothing in the bill can be
construed to require any accreditation agency or
association to promulgate a standard that would
prohibit IHEs from offering programs of study in any
academic subject. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #2, which failed by a roll call vote
of 18-22.
29. Rep. Bowman offered an amendment that would
prohibit institutions of higher education from
providing preferential treatment in the admissions
process for donors and alumni, effective on the first
day of the second award year after the bill's
enactment. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #2, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
30. Rep. Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an amendment
that would strike the amended definition of ``third-
party server,'' which would refer to any individual,
state, or private for-profit or nonprofit organization
that enters into a contract with an institution of
higher education to administer any student assistance
programs under the bill. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #4, which failed by a roll call vote
of 19-22.
31. Rep. Manning offered an amendment that would
stipulate that nothing in the bill could be construed
to prevent an institution of higher education from
providing medically accurate and comprehensive
information about sexual and reproductive health
services, including contraception. The amendment failed
by a roll call vote of 20-21.
32. Ranking Member Scott offered an amendment that
would strike a provision to prohibit the Department of
Education from implementing any substantially similar
rule, regulation, policy or executive action related to
regulations repealed under the bill, including closed
school loan discharges, borrower repayment defense,
pre-dispute arbitration, false certification,
administrative capability, certification procedures,
ability to benefit, and personal liability. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On May 21, 2025, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Restoring Excellence: The Case Against DEI.'' The purpose of
the hearing was to examine the ways in which postsecondary
institutions were engaging in harmful diversity, equity, and
inclusion practices, including accreditation reforms that
improve student outcomes. Testifying before the Subcommittee
were Mr. Dan Morenhoff, Executive Director, American Civil
Rights Project, Dallas, TX; Dr. Shaun Harper, Provost Professor
of Education, Public Policy, and Business, University of
Southern California, Los Angeles, CA; Ms. Renu Mukherjee,
Fellow, Manhattan Institute, New York, NY; and Dr. Kurt Miceli,
Medical Director, Do No Harm, Glen Allen, VA.
Legislative Action
On June 20, 2025, Representative Randy Fine (R-FL)
introduced the Accreditation Choice and Innovation Act (H.R.
4054). The bill was referred solely to the Committee on
Education and Workforce. On June 25, 2025, the Committee
considered H.R. 4054 in legislative session and reported it
favorably, as amended, to the House of Representatives by a
recorded vote of 21-15. The Committee considered the following
amendment to H.R. 4054:
1. Representative Fine offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute (ANS) that clarified timelines
and definitions. Among other changes it also made
accreditors pass along student complaints to
institutions and gave states the option to include
public input in their accreditation plans. The
amendment was adopted by voice vote.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
While the Higher Education Act (HEA) requires accrediting
agencies, common
Minority Views
Introduction
H.R. 4054, the Accreditation Choice and Innovation Act,
makes sweeping reforms to the higher education accreditation
process. In general, these ill-informed reforms will create
loopholes in the oversight of both institutions and accreditors
which will in turn establish untested pathways to federal
funding, insert politics and culture wars into the
accreditation process, and erode the quality of higher
education. H.R. 4054 builds on the harmful policies proposed by
both the first and current Trump Administration to further this
Administration's attack on American higher education.
H.R. 4054 IS PART OF THE REPUBLICAN PATTERN OF WEAPONIZING HIGHER
EDUCATION ACCREDITATION
During the first Trump Administration, Department of
Education (Department) Secretary Betsy DeVos drastically shook
up the college accreditation process by dismantling the
regional accreditation framework and allowing colleges to
``accreditor-hop'' to new agencies.\1\ The current Trump
Administration has continued efforts to weaken higher education
accreditation. On April 28, President Trump issued Executive
Order (EO) 14279, Reforming Accreditation to Strengthen Higher
Education, which directs the Secretary of Education (Secretary)
to hold accreditors accountable for what he deemed as
``unlawful'' Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) actions and
litmus tests to ``realign'' accreditation with other standards
seemingly tailored towards student achievement.\2\ This EO
unfairly targets accreditors for the actions of their
accredited colleges that the President deems incongruous with
his vision for higher education. While accreditors do examine
college DEI policies as part of their assessment, that
examination is largely focused on determining whether colleges
are living up to what they themselves are claiming they are
doing. The EO also establishes a process to make it easier for
colleges to change accreditors to evade sufficient oversight,
which will undermine the primary purpose of accreditation: to
ensure students attend high-quality, well-governed
institutions. The Council of Regional Accrediting Commissions,
which represents all institutional accrediting agencies,
``firmly reject[s] President Trump's mischaracterization of
accreditor's role'' in the EO and other remarks.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Paul Fain, New Rules on Accreditation and State Authorization,
Inside Higher Ed (Octo. 31, 2019), https://www.insidehighered.com/news/
2019/11/01/education-department-issues-new-
regulations-accreditation-and-state-authorization.
\2\Exec. Order No. 14279, 90 Fed. Reg. 17529 (Apr. 23, 2025).
\3\Press Release, Council of Reg. Accred. Commissions, Accreditors
React to President Trump's Latest Executive Order Targeting College
Oversight (Apr. 23, 2025), https://www.c-rac.org/post/accreditors-
react-to-president-trump-s-latest-executive-order-targeting-college-
oversight.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Congressional Republicans have a very similar vision for
accreditation to the President's, pushing to open the doors to
new, untested accreditors, politicize accreditation, and make
it easier for both colleges and accreditors to evade
accountability. In the 118th Congress, the Committee and House
considered several bills that would further weaponize the
accreditation system to weed out practices that Republicans
dislike.\4\ Committee Democrats know the accreditation process
can and should be reformed. However, it is essential that such
reforms protect the role and independence of accrediting
agencies and not attack them for doing what the federal
government has designated them to do: oversee institutional
quality.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Press Release, Cmte. on Educ. & Workforce Democrats, While You
Were Sleeping, Extreme Republicans Voted to Raise College Costs, Return
to DeVos Era Deregulation and Chaos (Jan. 31, 2024), https://democrats-
edworkforce.house.gov/media/press-releases/while-you-were-sleeping-
extreme-republicans-voted-to-raise-college-costs-return-to-devos-era-
deregulation-and-chaos; Press Release, Cmte. on Educ. & Workforce
Democrats, Committee Republicans Vote to Weaken Worker Protections,
Fuel Culture Wars, and Undermine Public Education (Mar. 21, 2024),
https://democrats-edworkforce.house.gov/media/press-releases/committee-
republicans-vote-to-weaken-worker-protections-fuel-culture-wars-and-
undermine-public-education.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 4054 CREATES UNTESTED PATHWAYS TO FEDERAL RECOGNITION AND ERODES
OVERSIGHT OF COLLEGES AND ACCREDITORS
H.R. 4054 establishes several alarming untested pathways to
recognition for prospective accreditors and new paths for low-
quality education providers to receive Title IV aid by
circumventing accreditor oversight. The legislation also erodes
the federal government's ability to provide oversight of the
accreditation process. H.R. 4054 represents an alarming shift
away from the traditional higher education ``triad'' framework
ensuring program integrity (with separate roles for the federal
government, states, and accrediting agencies) to a framework
that fundamentally threatens oversight of program quality and
consumer protection.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Wesley Whistle, Outsourcing Accreditor Oversight to States: A
bad Idea in the Making: Why Letting States Approve Accreditors Puts
Students and Taxpayers at Risk, New America (Jun. 25, 2025), https://
www.newamerica.org/education-policy/edcentral/outsourcing-accreditor-
oversight-to-states-a-bad-idea-in-the-making/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Accelerated Path to Recognition for Accreditors
Section 2(b) establishes an accelerated path to federal
recognition for untested accreditors at both the program-level
and institution-level of accreditation. Under current laws and
regulations, in order to receive federal recognition, the
credential that empowers an accreditor to determine whether a
program or institution can receive federal student aid, an
accreditor must typically provide the Department with proof of
two years of experience it has in accrediting institutions.\6\
H.R. 4054 would circumvent this requirement, allowing untested
prospective accreditors to gain federal recognition without
adequately proving their ability to oversee colleges, which
prevents the Department from ensuring quality institutional
accreditation. Recognizing untested accreditors will likely
result in lower quality oversight of accreditation at the
institutional level. By providing underperforming institutions
with a loophole to accreditation and federal student aid
eligibility while evading accountability, H.R. 4050 will
weaking the current higher ed oversight triad.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\34 C.F.R. Sec. 602.12(a)(2) (2025)(An agency seeking initial
recognition must demonstrate that it has . . . [c]onducted accrediting
activities, including deciding whether to grant or deny accreditation
or preaccreditation, for at least two years prior to seeking
recognition . . .).
\7\Letter from Third Way to the U.S. Dep't. of Educ. Sec'y Miguel
Cardona (Jan. 9, 2024), available at https://www.thirdway.org/letter/
letter-to-the-department-of-education-on-accreditation-rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
State Accreditors
Section 2(a)(3)(D) allows states to serve as an accreditor
or to designate their own accrediting bodies to focus on
specific workforce needs. The legislation provides a minimal
process for secretarial approval (based entirely on state
determinations) of these state-designated accrediting agencies.
While this sounds viable in theory, we know many states do not
have the capacity to serve as accreditors, given the meager
resources they commit to their already-legislated role in the
accountability triad as state authorizing agencies.\8\ This new
provision could also create significant differences in how
colleges are accredited in states that take their consumer
protection role seriously, and those who take a more laissez-
faire approach,\9\ especially should H.R. 4054 be enacted in
conjunction with H.R. 2516, the Accreditation for College
Excellence Act.\10\ H.R. 4054 would empower a state with a lax
state authorization history to designate a similarly lax state
accrediting entity, in effect collapsing two legs of the
accountability triad in an effort to attract schools that could
neither be authorized nor accredited elsewhere. Allowing states
to serve as accrediting bodies also severely limits the
Secretary's accreditation oversight responsibilities, which is
concerning particularly because states have a well-documented
history of avoiding federal oversight in student aid
programs.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Whistle, supra note 5; David Tandberg et al., Improving State
Authorization: The State Role in Ensuring Quality and Consumer
Protection in Higher Education, State Higher Educ. Exec 18-19 (Jul.
2019), https://sheeo.org/improving-state-authorization-the-state-role-
in-ensuring-quality-and-consumer-protection-in-higher-education/.
\9\Whistle, supra note 5.
\10\Accreditation for College Excellence Act, H.R. 2516, 119th
Cong. (2024), https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/
2516/text.
\11\Whistle, supra note 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Accreditor Shopping
Section 2(e) of H.R. 4054 allows any college or program to
change its accrediting body without the approval of the
Secretary. This builds off of EO14279 which directs the
Department to ``streamline the process . . . to change
accreditors.''\12\ Making a college's ability to change
accreditors frictionless will undoubtedly harm students; by
removing the requirement of the Secretary's approval, many
colleges looking to evade oversight could do so simply by
finding an accreditor with less rigorous standards. There is
already a test case for what happens when colleges can easily
switch accreditors: Florida. In 2022, Florida passed a law
requiring all colleges to change their accreditor after every
accreditation cycle.\13\ This has already resulted in chaos and
backlogs at the Department as staff work to review these
accreditor changes in a timely manner.\14\ In a world where
predatory institutions are already testing the fence of
effective oversight for weakness when it comes to accreditor
shopping, H.R. 4054 cuts down the fence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Executive Order 14279 supra note 2.
\13\Gray Rohrer, Gov. DeSantis signs higher education bill with
post-tenure review, accreditation changes, Florida Politics (Apr. 19,
2022), https://floridapolitics.com/archives/517541-gov-desantis-signs-
higher-education-bill-with-post-tenure-review-accreditation-changes/.
\14\Josh Moody, Florida Officials Fume Over Sluggish Accreditation
Changes, Inside Higher Educ. (Nov. 11, 2024), https://
www.insidehighered.com/news/governance/accreditation/2024/11/11/
florida-officials-fume-over-sluggish-accreditation-changes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Substantive Changes Review
Under current law, when colleges want to make substantive
changes--such as adding a new program offering, degree level,
learning modality, or campus location--they are required to
inform their accreditor.\15\ The accreditor is responsible for
confirming that the college has the resources and ability to
implement said substantive change. Section 2(c)(3) of H.R. 4054
drastically loosens the requirements for when an accreditor
must review substantive changes. It requires accreditors to
review colleges' substantive changes only if they significantly
impact the college's mission, legal status, or ownership,
create new programs at a higher credential level, or merge with
another college. This was designed to reduce the review burden
on accreditors; however, alleviating the burden creates a large
loophole for colleges to evade oversight during key substantive
changes, such as moving programs to online platforms. This
change will allow poor-quality programs to not only thrive but
expand.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Developing Substantive Change Proposals, WASC Senior College
and University Commission, https://www.wscuc.org/resources/subchange-
proposals (last accessed Sept. 13, 2025).
\16\Clare McCann, Everything You Never Wanted to Know About the
Education Department's 2019 Higher Education Rulemaking, New America
(May 16, 2019), https://www.newamerica.org/education-policy/edcentral/
everything-you-never-wanted-to-know-about-the-2019-rulemaking/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Risk-Based Reviews
Section 2(f) establishes a new risk-based review process
for both accreditors and colleges. It would allow so-called
``high performing'' accreditors to have federal recognition for
an additional three years without any Secretarial review. It
would also allow accreditors to reduce compliance requirements
for ``high performing'' colleges and programs. Together, these
policies will lead to a serious lapse in oversight for the set
of accreditors, colleges, and programs the Trump Administration
deems as high-quality that may have concerning incidents arise
while not under review. It does not make sense to loosen
compliance requirements simply because an entity is able to
meet said compliance requirements. A stronger approach to risk-
based reviews could be to require the Department to conduct
additional reviews of low-quality programs, colleges, and
accreditors, which would ensure an increase in oversight for
the most problematic actors.
Public Member Requirements
Section 2(a)(4)(A) requires accrediting agency boards and
governing bodies to have at least one public member
representing the business industry for every six members. It
also prohibits any member of trade associations or member
organizations from serving as a public member. This would
prohibit, for example, union trade association members from
being involved in accreditation. This prohibition will
needlessly restrict accreditors from having knowledgeable
experts serve on accrediting agency boards, and has the extra
bonus of applying to group the Majority has spent decades
deriding.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\E.g., John Knefel, Project 2025's extreme anti-labor agenda is
an attack on unions and the entire working class, Media Matters for
America, July 18, 2024, https://www.mediamatters.org/project-2025/
project-2025s-extreme-anti-labor-agenda-attack-unions-and-entire-
working-class.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prohibition on Additional Secretarial Oversight
H.R. 4054 takes away important oversight capabilities of
the Department by limiting the Secretary's ability to intervene
in various places within the accreditation process. Section
2(d) prohibits the Secretary from establishing any criteria for
accreditors that Congress did not expressly authorize. Section
3(4) prohibits the Secretary from giving the National Advisory
Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) any
additional functions established through regulations. Together,
these policies will severely limit the Department's ability to
make improvements to the accrediting agency approval and
oversight process and safeguard federal student aid. The
loopholes created by H.R. 4054's accreditation framework will
take longer to mend as a result of this provision limiting the
Secretary's authority.
H.R. 4054 UNDERMINES ACCREDITATION FOR RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER
EDUCATION
H.R. 4054 allows religious institutions of higher education
to evade accreditation standards for their programs of study
and expands upon the complaint procedure in current law, while
also tilting the process in favor of religious institutions in
a way that makes it difficult for accreditors to provide
meaningful oversight of academic programs at these
institutions. In the end, H.R. 4054 will undermine
accreditation of religious institutions of higher education and
could leave students in the dark about whether their academic
programs at these institutions meet standards for
accreditation.
Religious institutions of higher education have long been
part of our nation's higher education system.\18\ Data from the
Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) show
that during the 2022-2023 Academic Year, 14.5% of U.S.
institutions of higher education were religiously
affiliated.\19\ Current law and regulations already require
accreditors to give religious institutions deference with
respect to their religious mission, but they still maintain the
ability to ensure that religious institutions' programs of
study meet core standards required for accreditation.\20\ For
instance, the Higher Education Act (HEA) requires an accreditor
to be consistent in applying and enforcing its standards for
accreditation in a manner that respects the stated missions,
including religious missions, of institutions of higher
education.\21\ Further, current law also provides that, in the
rare event that a religious affiliated institution loses its
accreditation, the Secretary must allow a religious institution
to maintain their eligibility for Title IV funding for a period
of time sufficient for them to seek alternative accreditation
should the Secretary determine that the reason for the loss of
accreditation was either related to the religious mission of
the institution or not related to accreditation standards.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Christian Colleges: A Journey Through History, Faith on View,
https://www.faithonview.com/historical-context-of-christian-colleges/
#::text=Christian%20higher
%20education%20began%20at,a%20key%20part%20of%20schooling (last visited
Sept. 12, 2025).
\19\U.S. Dep't of Educ., Integrated Postsecondary Education Data
System (IPEDS), Data Collection 2022 for Title IV-participating IHEs
with a Religious affiliation.
\20\20 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 1099b(a)(4), 1099b(k); 34 C.F.R.
Sec. Sec. 600.2, 600.11(d), 602.18(a).
\21\20 U.S.C. Sec. 1099b(a)(4)(A). Regulations also require
accreditors to base any decisions on the standards of accreditation,
without prejudice towards the institution's religious mission, but
allows the accreditor to ``require that the institution's or program's
curricula include all core components required by the [accrediting]
agency.'' See 34 C.F.R. Sec. 602.18(b)(3).
\22\20 USC Sec. 1099b(k); It should be noted that religiously
affiliated institutions also have the option to seek accreditation from
a religious accrediting body if that more appropriately meets their
needs. See Do Christian Colleges Have the Same Process as Public
Colleges, Online Christian Colleges, https://
www.onlinechristiancolleges.co