Committee Action
113TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On June 24, 2014, the Subcommittee on Health, Employment,
Labor, and Pensions (HELP) held a hearing titled ``What Should
Workers and Employers Expect Next from the National Labor
Relations Board?'' Witnesses were Mr. Andrew F. Puzder, CEO,
CKE Restaurants Holdings, Inc., Carpinteria, CA; Mr. Seth H.
Borden, Partner, McKenna Long & Aldridge, New York, NY; Mr.
James B. Coppess, Associate General Counsel, AFL-CIO,
Washington, DC; and Mr. G. Roger King, Of Counsel, Jones Day,
Columbus, OH. Witnesses discussed upcoming National Labor
Relations Board (NLRB or Board) cases as well as Board policy
and cited changes to the joint employer standard as one of the
most significant and controversial issues before the Board.
On September 9, 2014, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Expanding Joint Employer Status: What Does It Mean for
Workers and Job Creators?'' Witnesses were Mr. Todd Duffield,
Shareholder, Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak & Stewart, Atlanta,
GA; Mr. Clint Ehlers, President, FASTSIGNS of Lancaster and
Willow Grove, Lancaster and Willow Grove, PA, testifying on
behalf of the International Franchise Association; Mr. Harris
Freeman, Professor, Western New England University School of
Law, Springfield, MA; Ms. Catherine Monson, Chief Executive
Officer, FASTSIGNS International, Inc., Carrollton, TX,
testifying on behalf of the International Franchise
Association; and Mrs. Jagruti Panwala, owner of hotel
franchises, Bensalem, PA. Witnesses spoke about how an expanded
joint employer standard would negatively impact franchises and
other small businesses.
114TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On August 25, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing titled ``Redefining `Employer' and the Impact on
Alabama's Workers and Small Business Owners'' in Mobile,
Alabama. Witnesses were Mr. Marcel Debruge, Burr and Forman
LLP, Birmingham, AL; Mr. Chris Holmes, CEO, CLH Development
Holdings, Tallahassee, FL; and Col. Steve Carey, Owner and
Operator, CertaPro Painters of Mobile and Baldwin Counties,
Daphne, AL, testifying on behalf of the Coalition to Save Local
Businesses and the International Franchise Association.
Witnesses testified that the new joint employer standard would
threaten the independence of small businesses in Alabama and
deter franchisors from licensing new franchisees.
On August 27, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing titled ``Redefining `Employer' and the Impact on
Georgia's Workers and Small Business Owners'' in Savannah,
Georgia. Witnesses were Mr. Jeffrey M. Mintz, Shareholder,
Littler Mendelson, P.C., Atlanta, GA; Mr. Kalpesh ``Kal''
Patel, President and COO, Image Hotels, Inc., Pooler, GA; Mr.
Alex Salguerio, Savannah Restaurants Corp., Savannah, GA; and
Mr. Fred Weir, President, Meadowbrook Restaurant Company Inc.,
Cumming, GA, testifying on behalf of the Coalition to Save
Local Businesses and the International Franchise Association.
Witnesses testified the new joint employer standard would hurt
small business growth in Georgia and create barriers to entry
for potential franchise owners.
On September 29, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a
legislative hearing on H.R. 3459 (114th Congress), the
Protecting Local Business Opportunity Act. Witnesses were Mr.
Ed Braddy, President, Winlee Foods, LLC, Timonium, MD,
testifying on behalf of himself and the National Franchisee
Association; Mr. Kevin Cole, CEO, Enniss Electric Company,
Manassas, VA, testifying on behalf of the Independent
Electrical Contractors; Mr. Charles Cohen, Senior Counsel,
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP, Washington, DC; Ms. Mara Fortin,
President and CEO, Nothing Bundt Cakes, San Diego, CA,
testifying on behalf of herself and the Coalition to Save Local
Businesses; Mr. Michael Harper, Professor, Boston University
School of Law, Boston, MA; and Dr. Anne Lofaso, Professor, West
Virginia University College of Law, Morgantown, WV. Witnesses
testified that H.R. 3459 would restore the joint employer
standard that had worked well for workers and business owners
for decades and would protect opportunities for small business
growth.
First Session--Legislative Action
On September 9, 2015, then-Committee on Education and the
Workforce (Committee) Chairman John Kline (R-MN) introduced
H.R. 3459 (114th Congress), the Protecting Local Business
Opportunity Act, with Representatives David P. Roe (R-TN), Tim
Walberg (R-MI), Virginia Foxx (R-VA), Todd Rokita (R-IN), Joe
Wilson (R-SC), Hunter D. Duncan (R-CA), Glenn Thompson (R-PA),
Matt Salmon (R-AZ), Brett Guthrie (R-KY), Lou Barletta (R-PA),
Joseph J. Heck (R-NV), Luke Messer (R-IN), Bradley Byrne (R-
AL), Earl L. ``Buddy'' Carter (R-GA), Mike Bishop (R-MI), Glenn
Grothman (R-WI), Steve Russel (R-OK), Carlos Curbelo (R-FL),
Rick W. Allen (R-GA), Steve Chabot (R-OH), Blaine Luetkemeyer
(R-MO), Vicky Hartzler (R-MO), Jason Smith (R-MO), Cresent
Hardy (R-NV), and Stephen Knight (R-CA) as original cosponsors.
Recognizing the threat to small businesses posed by the NLRB's
August 2015 decision in Browning-Ferris Industries of
California, Inc. (Browning-Ferris), the legislation amended the
NLRA to restore the long-held standard that two or more
employers can only be considered joint employers for purposes
of the NLRA if each shares and exercises control over essential
terms and conditions of employment and such control over these
matters is actual, direct and immediate.
On October 28, 2015, the Committee considered H.R. 3459 in
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 21-15.
Representative Carter offered an amendment in the nature of a
substitute, making a technical change, which was adopted by
voice vote.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 14, 2017, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Restoring Balance and Fairness to the National Labor
Relations Board.'' Witnesses criticized decisions of the NLRB
during the Obama administration, including the expanded joint
employer standard. Witnesses were Ms. Reem Aloul, BrightStar
Care of Arlington, Arlington, VA, testifying on behalf of the
Coalition to Save Local Businesses; Ms. Susan Davis, Partner,
Cohen, Weiss and Simon, LLP, New York, NY; Mr. Raymond J.
LaJeunesse, Jr., Vice President, National Right to Work Legal
Defense and Education Foundation, Springfield, VA; and Mr. Kurt
G. Larkin, Partner, Hunton & Williams LLP, Richmond, VA.
On July 12, 2017, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Redefining Joint Employer Standards: Barriers to Job Creation
and Entrepreneurship.'' Witnesses were Mr. Michael Harper,
Professor, Boston University School of Law, Boston, MA; Mr.
Richard Heiser, Vice President, FedEx Ground Package System,
Inc., Chicago, IL; Mr. G. Roger King, Senior Labor and
Employment Counsel, HR Policy Association, Washington, DC; Mr.
Jerry Reese II, Director of Franchise Development, Dat Dog, New
Orleans, LA, testifying on behalf of the Coalition to Save
Local Businesses; Ms. Catherine K. Ruckelhaus, General Counsel,
National Employment Law Project, New York, NY; and Ms. Mary
Kennedy Thompson, Chief Operating Officer of Franchise Brands,
Dwyer Group, Waco, TX, testifying on behalf of the
International Franchise Association. Witnesses testified about
the importance of reigning in expanded joint employer
standards.
On September 13, 2017, the HELP and Workforce Protections
subcommittees held a joint legislative hearing on H.R. 3441
(115th Congress), the Save Local Business Act. Witnesses were
Mr. Zachary D. Fasman, Partner, Proskauer Rose LLP, New York,
NY; Ms. Tamra Kennedy, President, Twin Cities T.J.'s Inc.,
Roseville, MN, testifying on behalf of the Coalition to Save
Local Businesses; Mr. Granger MacDonald, Chief Executive
Officer, The MacDonald Companies, Kerrville, TX, testifying on
behalf of the National Association of Home Builders; and Mr.
Michael Rubin, Partner, Altshuler Berzon LLP, San Francisco,
CA. Witnesses testified that H.R. 3441 clarifies the joint
employer standard used under both the NLRA and the FLSA and
benefits workers and business owners.
First Session--Legislative Action
On July 27, 2017, then-Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections Chairman Bradley Byrne (R-AL) introduced H.R. 3441,
the Save Local Business Act, with 29 original cosponsors. The
bill amended the NLRA and the FLSA to provide that two or more
employers can only be considered joint employers if each shares
and exercises control over essential terms and conditions of
employment and if such control over those matters is actual,
direct, and immediate.
On October 4, 2017, the Committee considered H.R. 3441 in
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 23-17.
Representative Byrne offered an amendment in the nature of a
substitute, making technical changes. The amendment was adopted
by voice vote. On November 7, 2017, H.R. 3441 passed the House
of Representatives by a recorded vote of 242-181.
117TH CONGRESS
Legislative Action
On May 13, 2021, Representative James Comer (R-KY)
introduced H.R. 3185 (117th Congress), the Save Local Business
Act, with 54 original cosponsors. The bill set the standard by
which a worker may be considered employed by a joint employer
under the NLRA and the FLSA.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On December 11, 2023, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Protecting Workers and Small Businesses from Biden's
Attack on Worker Free Choice and Economic Growth'' to examine
solutions to protect small businesses, including regarding the
joint-employer standard. Witnesses were Mr. G. Roger King,
Senior Labor and Employment Counsel, HR Policy Association,
Washington, DC; Mr. Matthew Haller, President and CEO,
International Franchise Association, Washington, DC; Mr. F.
Vincent Vernuccio, President, Institute for the American
Worker, Hamilton, VA; and Mr. Richard Griffin, Of Counsel,
Bredhoff and Kaiser, Washington, DC.
First Session--Legislative Action
On April 25, 2023, Representative James Comer (R-KY)
introduced H.R. 2826 (118th Congress), the Save Local Business
Act, with 61 original cosponsors. The bill set the standard by
which a worker may be considered employed by a joint employer
under the NLRA and the FLSA.
On November 9, 2023, Representative John James (R-MI)
introduced H.J. Res. 98 (118th Congress), Providing for
congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United
States Code, of the rule submitted by the National Labor
Relations Board relating to ``Standard for Determining Joint
Employer Status'', with Representatives Virginia Foxx (R-NC),
Mike Johnson (R-LA), Jim Banks (R-IN), Aaron Bean (R-FL), Earl
L. ``Buddy'' Carter (R-GA), Tom Cole (R-OK), James Comer (R-
KY), Eric A. ``Rick'' Crawford (R-AR), Jeff Duncan (R-SC),
Scott Fitzgerald (R-WI), Bob Good (R-VA), Lance Gooden (R-TX),
Diana Harshbarger (R-TN), Clay Higgins (R-LA), Ashley Hinson
(R-IA), Erin Houchin (R-IN), Jake LaTurner (R-KS), Julia Letlow
(R-LA), Lisa C. McClain (R-MI), John R. Moolenaar (R-MI),
Alexander X. Mooney (R-WV), Greg Pence (R-IN), John W. Rose (R-
TN), Adrian Smith (R-NE), Michelle Steel (R-CA), Glenn Thompson
(R-PA), Tim Walberg (R-MI), Elise M. Stefanik (R-NY), and David
G. Valadao (R-CA). H.J. Res. 98 was a Congressional Review Act
resolution of disapproval to overturn the NLRB's 2023 joint
employer rule. On December 12, 2023, the Committee considered
H.J. Res. 98 in legislative session and reported it favorably
to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 25-20.
Second Session--Legislative Action
On January 12, 2024, H.J. Res. 98 passed the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 206-177.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On June 11, 2025, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Restoring Balance: Ensuring Fairness and Transparency
at the NLRB,'' which examined the NLRB's joint-employer
standard, among other topics. Witnesses were Mr. G. Roger King,
Senior Labor and Employment Counsel, HR Policy Association,
Washington, DC; Mr. F. Vincent Vernuccio, President, Institute
for the American Worker, Hamilton, VA; Mr. Aaron Solem, Staff
Attorney, National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation,
Springfield, VA; and Ms. Jennifer Abruzzo, Senior Advisor to
the President, Communication Workers of America, Washington DC.
First Session--Legislative Action
On July 14, 2025, Representative James Comer (R-KY)
introduced H.R. 4366, the Save Local Business Act, which sets
the standard by which a worker may be considered employed by a
joint employer under the NLRA and the FLSA. On July 23, 2025,
the Committee considered H.R. 4366 in legislative session and
reported it favorably, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a vote of 20-16. The Committee considered
the following amendments to H.R. 4366:
1. Representative Robert F. Onder (R-MO) offered an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, making technical
changes to the bill. The Committee adopted the amendment by
voice vote.
2. Representative Alma S. Adams (D-NC) offered an amendment
to prevent the provision in the bill amending the definition of
employer under the FLSA from coming into effect in cases of
unlawful child labor under the FLSA. The amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 16-20.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
The joint-employer standard can impact any business that
contracts with another business, such as franchisors and
franchisees, contractors and subcontractors, suppliers, and
other corners of the economy. The test for determining when two
or more entities are to be considered joint employers has
fluctuated with presidential administrations for the last
decade, sowing chaos for job creators. During the first Trump
administration, the NLRB and the Department of Labor (DOL)
reversed disastrous Obama-era policies and promulgated
commonsense rules that limited liability for job creators.\1\
However, the Biden NLRB replaced the first Trump administration
NLRB's joint-employer final rule, destabilizing this area of
the law again. Because the NLRA currently only defines
``employer'' and does not include a definition for ``joint
employer,'' each iteration of the Board can adopt its own
standard, subjecting America's workforce to the political winds
of the moment. H.R. 4366, the Save Local Business Act, would
calm this area of the law and allow small business owners to
start and grow their businesses in peace.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Joint Employer Status Under the National Labor Relations Act, 85
Fed. Reg. 11,184 (Feb. 26, 2020); Joint Employer Status under the Fair
Labor Standards Act, 86 Fed. Reg. 40,939 (Jan. 16, 2020).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE NLRB JOINT EMPLOYER STANDARD
The NLRA's purpose is to protect the rights of most
private-sector employees to organize and collectively bargain
with their employers, or to refrain from those activities; to
minimize industrial strife; and to curtail certain behaviors of
labor and management deemed harmful to the general welfare of
workers, businesses, and the economy overall.\2\ The NLRB is an
independent federal agency established by the NLRA to fulfill
two principal functions: (1) to determine whether employees
wish to be represented by a union and (2) to prevent and remedy
employer and union unlawful acts, called unfair labor practices
(ULPs).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\See 29 U.S.C. Sec. 151.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
From 1984 to 2015, the NLRB determined whether two separate
entities should be considered joint employers by analyzing
whether the entities shared control over or co-determined the
essential terms and conditions of employment.\3\ Essential
terms and conditions of employment could include hiring,
firing, discipline, supervision, and direction of employees.
Prior to 2015, each entity's control over these employment
matters needed to be ``actual, direct, and immediate'' for the
Board to find two or more entities to be joint employers.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\TLI, Inc., 271 NLRB 798, 798-99 (1984), overruled by Browning-
Ferris Indus. (BFI), 362 NLRB No. 186 (2015).
\4\See Airborne Express, 338 NLRB 597, 597 n.1 (2002) (``[The]
essential element in [joint employer] analysis is whether a putative
joint employer's control over employment matters is direct and
immediate.''); AM Prop. Holding Corp., 350 NLRB 998, 1000 (2007) (``In
assessing whether a joint employer relationship exists, the Board . . .
looks to the actual practice of the parties.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2015, the NLRB issued its decision in Browning-Ferris
Industries, radically revising the joint employer standard.\5\
Under this standard, companies sharing indirect or potential
control over another entity's workforce may be considered joint
employers.\6\ Practically, an entity could be held liable for
the decisions of another entity--whether or not the first
entity was even aware of the second entity's decisions and
activities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\BFI, 362 NLRB No. 186 (2015).
\6\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the first Trump administration, the NLRB promulgated
a rule restoring the historic, direct-control, joint-employer
standard and effectively overruled Browning-Ferris.\7\ In 2023,
however, the Biden NLRB issued a final rule of its own,
establishing its standard for determining joint-employer status
under the NLRA,\8\ largely reviving the Obama-era Browning-
Ferris standard.\9\ The 2023 Biden rule rescinded and replaced
the Trump NLRB's joint-employer rule which had refocused the
Board's analysis on the company's ``direct and immediate
control'' of employees.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Joint Employer Status Under the National Labor Relations Act, 85
Fed. Reg. 11,184 (Feb. 26, 2020).
\8\Standard for Determining Joint-Employer Status, 88 Fed. Reg.
53,946 (Oct. 27, 2023).
\9\BFI, 362 NLRB No. 186 (2015).
\10\Joint Employer Status Under the National Labor Relations Act,
85 Fed. Reg. 11,184 (Feb. 26, 2020).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under the 2023 Biden NLRB rule, a joint-employer
relationship is established when employers codetermine, whether
directly or indirectly, employees' essential terms and
conditions of employment.\11\ In other words, under the Biden
NLRB rule, an entity can be considered a joint employer even if
it does not actually control the employees involved. Any entity
that exercises or even reserves the right to exercise control,
even indirect control, over at least one essential term of
employment is a joint employer under this rule. As a pract
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 4366, the Save Local Business Act, would limit the
cases in which more than one person or business can be held
jointly accountable for violations of bedrock policies such as
the minimum wage, child labor rules, and labor law. The bill
would empower companies that effectively hire workers through
subcontractors or temporary employment agencies to escape
accountability for child labor and wage theft and would
restrict unionized workers' ability to collectively bargain
over the full range of the terms and conditions of employment
in their workplaces.
This bill is opposed by the AFL-CIO, National Employment
Law Project, National Partnership for Women and Families,
National Women's Law Center Action Fund, and Signatory Wall and
Ceiling Contractors Alliance.
UNDERLYING LAW
This bill would amend two core workplace laws: the Fair
Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA)\1\ and the National Labor
Relations Act (NLRA).\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. L. No. 75-718, 52 Stat. 1060 (1938).
\2\Pub. L. No. 74-198, 49 Stat. 449 (1935).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair Labor Standards Act
FLSA is the federal workplace standards law governing the
minimum wage,\3\ overtime,\4\ oppressive child labor,\5\
discrimination in pay on the basis of sex,\6\ and the right of
nursing mothers to take paid breaks at work for the purpose of
expressing breast milk.\7\ It is enforced by the Wage and Hour
Division (WHD) of the Department of Labor (DOL), as well as by
workers themselves who bring cases in court.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Id. Sec. 6.
\4\Id. Sec. 7.
\5\Id. Sec. 12.
\6\Id. Sec. 6(d).
\7\Id. Sec. 18D.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In FLSA, the term ``employ'' includes ``to suffer or permit
to work.''\8\ When establishing this broad definition of
employment, Congress consciously sought to expand the
employment relationship to hold accountable employers who would
not otherwise be liable for violations under a common-law
control test.\9\ Courts test the applicability of the FLSA
definition using the ``economic realities'' test, which looks
underneath whatever terms the parties to a relationship use to
describe it and focuses instead on the reality of the
relationship, based on the totality of the circumstances, to
determine whether the putative employee is economically
dependent on the potential employer.\10\ Ultimately, the
application of the economic realities factors is guided by the
overarching principle that the FLSA should be ``construed
liberally to apply to the furthest reaches consistent with
congressional direction.''\11\ The FLSA definition of
employment is the ``broadest definition that has ever been
included in any one act.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id. Sec. 3(g).
\9\Bruce Goldstein et al., Enforcing Fair Labor Standards in the
Modern American Sweatshop: Rediscovering the Statutory Definition of
Employment, 46 UCLA L. Rev. 983, 991 (1999).
\10\Tony & Susan Alamo Found. v. Sec'y of Labor, 471 U.S. 290, 301
(1985) (reiterating that the test of employment under the FLSA is
economic reality); Goldberg v. Whitaker House Co-op, Inc., 366 U.S. 28,
33 (1961).
\11\Mitchell v. Lublin, McGaughy & Assocs., 358 U.S. 207 (1959).
\12\United States v. Rosenwasser, 323 U.S. 360, 363 (1945) (quoting
81 Cong. Rec. 7,657 (1938) (remarks of Sen. Hugo Black)). The FLSA's
definition of ``employ'' is a standard of ``striking breadth'' that
``stretches the meaning of `employee' to cover some parties who might
not qualify as such under a strict application of traditional agency
law principles.'' Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Darden, 503 U.S. 318, 323
(1992).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
National Labor Relations Act
The NLRA is the foundational federal law governing labor
relations. Administered by the National Labor Relations Board
(NLRB), the NLRA protects the rights of employees to organize
and collectively bargain with their employers for improved
working conditions and benefits, among other things.
Under the NLRA, the question of whether a worker is an
employee or an independent contractor is governed by a common
law test of control.\13\ Among the factors courts and the NLRB
apply when examining whether workers are employees within the
meaning of the NLRA are ``the extent of control the employer
has over the work; . . . whether the worker is engaged in a
distinct occupation or business . . . ; whether the kind of
occupation is usually done under the direction of the employer
or by a specialist without supervision; [and] whether the
employer is or is not in business.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See FedEx Home Delivery v. NLRB, 849 F.3d 1123, 1125 (D.C. Cir.
2017).
\14\Id. (internal citations omitted).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOINT EMPLOYMENT
Labor and employment laws have long held that when the
company that signs a worker's paycheck shares authority over
terms and conditions of employment with other companies,
multiple businesses may as a result be accountable as employers
for complying with the law. This is referred to as ``joint
employment.''
FLSA and Joint Employment
Joint employment in FLSA arises not only out of the
definition of employer, which ``includes any person acting
directly or indirectly in the interest of an employer in
relation to an employee,''\15\ but also out of the broad
``suffer or permit'' definition of ``employ,'' which Congress
borrowed from the early state child labor laws of the late 19th
and early 20th centuries.\16\ State authorities used this broad
language to hold businesses accountable for child labor
violations despite arrangements such as the ``inside shop,''
where a manufacturer might subdivide the departments of the
business into shops contracted out to other business operators,
who all nevertheless contributed to the manufacturer's
enterprise.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\See 29 U.S.C. Sec. 203(d) (emphasis added).
\16\See generally Goldstein et al., supra note 9.
\17\Id. at 1057-58.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Supreme Court first examined FLSA joint employment in
the 1947 case Rutherford Food.\18\ In that case, a
slaughterhouse operator retained an independent contractor to
provide labor for a deboning process, and the deboning
contractor directly hired workers to perform that work.\19\ The
employees worked on the meatpacking company's premises,
received cattle carcasses from the meatpacking company's
employees, deboned the cattle using the meatpacking company's
tools and equipment, and then conveyed the deboned cattle along
an overhead rail to another room where the meatpacking
company's employees continued processing the carcasses into
food products.\20\ During this work, the deboning contractor's
employees were supervised by one of the meatpacking company's
``managing official[s].''\21\ Taking account of ``the
circumstances of the whole activity,'' the Court agreed with
WHD that the deboning employees constituted ``a part of the
integrated unit of production under such circumstances that the
workers performing the task were employees of the
establishment.''\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Rutherford Food Corp. v. McComb, 331 U.S. 722 (1947).
\19\Id. at 724-25.
\20\Id. at 726, 730.
\21\Id. at 730.
\22\Id. at 729-30.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
More recently, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth
Circuit advised that scrutiny of potential joint employer
liability should focus less on the relationship between
business and worker and more on the interrelationships of the
businesses themselves.\23\ In Salinas, the Fourth Circuit
considered wage theft allegations brought by workers employed
by a drywall and framing subcontractor, which almost
exclusively worked on jobs for a construction contractor that
specialized in finishing interiors.\24\ Among other things, the
contractor assessed the final work product of the
subcontractor's employees and required the subcontractor to
order re-execution of work the contractor deemed insufficient;
mandated that the subcontractor's employees wear the
contractor's logo and hold themselves out as employees of the
contractor; and periodically instructed the subcontractor to
dispatch workers to meet the contractor's needs.\25\ Finding
that the contractor was indeed jointly liable with the
subcontractor for FLSA violations, the Salinas court clarified
that joint employment inquiry ``requires courts to determine
whether the putative joint employers are not wholly
disassociated or, put differently, share or codetermine the
essential terms and conditions of a worker's employment.''\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Salinas v. Commercial Interiors, Inc., 848 F.3d 125 (4th Cir.
2017).
\24\Id.
\25\Id. at 145-46.
\26\Id. at 139.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Joint employment is not a major factor in FLSA cases. The
National Employment Law Project (NELP) reviewed FLSA
enforcement and litigation in 2019 and found:
there are not very many joint employer cases overall,
as compared to other FLSA cases, despite the [business
community's] pronouncements that the joint employer
question is harming business . . . NELP's research and
case compendium of joint employer cases shows that the
majority arise in FLSA cases brought by agricultural
workers, and over half of all cases do not result in a
finding of joint and several liability.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Christine Owens et al., Nat'l Emp. L. Proj., Comments on RIN
1235-AA26: Joint Employer Status Under the Fair Labor Standards Act 3
n.1 (June 25, 2019), https://s27147.pcdn.co/app/uploads/2019/06/
Comments-USDOL-Joint-Employer-Status-FLSA.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
NLRA and Joint Employment
The NLRA's definition of ``employer'' contemplates that
there can be joint employers in an employment relationship.
Under Section 2(2) of the Act, the term ``employer'' includes
``any person acting as an agent of an employer, directly or
indirectly.''\28\ Likewise, the term ``employee'' is not
limited to the employees of a particular employer. Section 2(3)
of the Act states: ``The term `employee' shall include any
employee, and shall not be limited to the employees of a
particular employer, unless [the Act] explicitly states
otherwise.''\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\See 29 U.S.C. Sec. 152(2) (emphasis added).
\29\See id. Sec. 152(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For most of the time since the 1935 enactment of the NLRA,
the NLRB has held that an entity may be liable to bargain with
the employees of a subcontractor as a joint employer even if
its control over terms and conditions of employment was
indirect, such as exercised through an intermediary, or
reserved but not yet exercised.\30\ This traditional standard
is consistent with the Supreme Court's requirement that the
NLRB interpret the NLRA's definition of employer as consistent
with the common law,\31\ as well as with the legislative
history of the NLRA's 1947 amendments.\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\See, e.g., Floyd Epperson, 202 NLRB 23, 23 (1973) (finding
proof of joint employment where client employer had ``some indirect
control over [employees''] wages'' and ``some control, albeit indirect,
over [employee] discipline''), enforced 491 F.2d 1390 (6th Cir. 1974);
Franklin Stores Corp., 199 NLRB 52, 53 (1972) (upholding ALJ finding of
joint employment where one employer, ``by virtue of the lease
arrangement with'' the other employer, ``has the right to veto the
employment of employees by'' the other ``and to insist on the discharge
of employees by'' the other).
\31\See NLRB v. United Ins. Co. of America, 390 U.S. 254, 256
(1968) (requiring the Board to ``apply general agency principles in
distinguishing between employees and independent contractors under the
Act'').
\32\See H.R. Rep. No. 80-510, at 32-33 (1947) (Conf. Rep.),
reprinted in 1 Legislative History of the Labor Management Relations
Act, 1947, at 536-37 (1948) (explaining the exclusion of independent
contractors from the definition of employee in order to overturn a
Supreme Court decision that ``held that ordinary tests of the law of
agency could be ignored by the Board'' in determining the existence of
employment relationships).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SHORTCOMINGS OF THE LEGISLATION
H.R. 4366 proposes to limit workers' protections under
labor and employment laws when there are multiple entities with
the power to determine employment conditions by adopting a
single joint employer test for both NLRA and FLSA, limited to
whether each putative joint employer ``directly, actually, and
immediately exercises significant control over the essential
terms and conditions of employment[,] such as hiring such
employees, discharging such employees, determining the rate of
pay and benefits of such employees, supervising such employees
on a day-to-day basis, assigning such employees a work
schedule, position, or task, or disciplining such
employees.''\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\H.R. 4366, 119th Cong. Sec. 2 (2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many Bosses, No Employers
The bill injects uncertainty into the very heart of the
employment relationship--an uncertainty that businesses would
be able to exploit at the expense of workers. Under current
law, the joint employer doctrine essentially means that
multiple persons share the obligations of the employer under a
relevant labor or employment law. The bill, however, refers to
a ``joint employer of the employees of another employer,''
which could be construed as conceiving of a true employer and a
subsidiary ``joint'' employer. With workplaces increasingly led
by multiple businesses with complex layers of contracting and
subcontracting,\34\ creating new tiered definitions of employer
and joint employer that deviate so significantly from the long-
established uses of the terms would invite endless litigation
by businesses eager to escape accountability under the nation's
labor and employment laws.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\See generally David Weil, The Fissured Workplace: Why Work
Became So Bad for So Many and What Can Be Done to Improve It (2014).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When this bill was discussed in the Committee in a previous
Congress, one confusion that emerged is whether some workers
may find that they have no employer at all. In a 2017
legislative hearing, Ranking Member Scott raised this concern
with legal expert Michael Rubin:
Mr. Scott: [I]f you have a Fair Labor Standards Acts
violation and somebody comes in and says, ``I'm not an
employer under this definition,'' and then the other
guy comes in and says, ``I'm not an employer under this
definition either,'' is it possible that nobody is
responsible?
Mr. Rubin: Wow. In fact, as I look at the language of
the Act, that is possible. Imagine this circumstance:
Company A is in charge of hiring. Company A and B share
responsibility for firing. And company B also sets
wages. The worker says, who is my employer under this
definition? Well, does either company, A or B, control
the essential terms, which are then listed? There are 9
of them in the conjunctive? No. So in that case there
may be no employer.
Mr. Scott: So if there's a finding that I wasn't paid
overtime, nobody owes it?
Mr. Rubin: Neither company is a joint employer and
arguably neither is an employer at all . . . [T]his
language explodes uncertainty to the point where every
single case, where any element, any term or condition
of employment is shared, there's going to be litigation
over whether either company would be [liable].\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\H.R. 3441, Save Local Business Act: Joint Hearing Before the
Subcomm. on Wrkf. Prots. & the Subcomm. on Health, Emp., Lab. &
Pensions of the H. Comm. on Educ. & the Wrkf., 115th Cong. 72 (2017)
(testimony of Michael Rubin) [hereinafter Rubin Testimony].
Even though Committee Democrats have raised this concern
multiple times since, the Majority has not fixed the problem in
the bill.
Hampering Effective Labor Organizing and Negotiation
The bill would narrow the current joint employer test for
the NLRA by eliminating the consideration of indirect or
reserved control. Under the common law, the employer does not
need to exercise direct and immediate control in order to
determine the essential terms and conditions of employment,
because a presumed joint employer can limit the wages and
benefits paid by the employees' direct employers through
contractual arrangements, such as salary caps.
As a result, workers would be hampered from effectively
organizing and negotiating with all of their employers.
According to the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), this form of
a stringent NLRA joint-employer standard ``would result in an
annual transfer of $1.3 billion from workers to
employers.''\36\ Such a standard would have consequences not
only for employees of smaller firms in a set of related firms,
who would be unable to bargain with the lead firm in the chain
with the power to determine wages and other conditions, but
also for employees of the lead firm, whose bargaining power
would be diluted by working with employees of less powerful
firms but with whom they are not able to join in any bargaining
scenario.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Celine McNicholas & Heidi Shierholz, EPI Comments Regarding the
Standard for Determining Joint-Employer Status, Econ. Pol. Inst. (Dec.
9, 2018), https://www.epi.org/publication/epi-comments-regarding-the-
standard-for-determining-joint-employer-status/