Committee Action
112TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearing
On July 25, 2012, the Subcommittee on Health, Employment,
Labor, and Pensions (HELP Subcommittee) held a hearing entitled
``Examining Proposals to Strengthen the National Labor
Relations Act,'' reviewing decisions by the NLRB affecting
tribal sovereignty, among other topics. The hearing also
examined the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act (H.R. 2335, 112th
Congress). The witness testifying on tribal sovereignty stated
that the NLRB finding that Indian tribal governments are not
exempt from NLRA requirements was unfounded and violated treaty
rights.\1\ Witnesses were the Honorable Robert Odawi Porter,
President, Seneca Nation of Indians, Salamanca, New York; Mr.
William L. Messenger, Staff Attorney, National Right to Work
Legal Defense Foundation, Springfield, Virginia; Ms. Devki K.
Virk, Member, Bredhoff and Kaiser, P.L.L.C., Washington, D.C.;
and Dr. Tim Kane, Chief Economist, Hudson Institute,
Washington, D.C.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Examining Proposals to Strengthen the National Labor Relations
Act: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Health, Emp., Lab., & Pensions of
the H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, 112th Cong. 9 (statement of the
Hon. Robert Odawi Porter) [hereinafter Porter statement].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
114TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On June 16, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a legislative
hearing on H.R. 511, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015.
Witnesses were the Honorable Rodney Butler, Chairman,
Mashantucket Pequot Nation, Mashantucket, Connecticut; Mr.
Richard Guest, Senior Staff Attorney, Native American Rights
Fund, Washington, D.C.; the Honorable Jefferson Keel,
Lieutenant Governor, Chickasaw Nation, Ada, Oklahoma; and, Mr.
Gary Navarro, Slot Machine Attendant and Bargaining Committee
Member for UNITE HERE Local 2850, Graton Casino and Resort,
Rohnert Park, California. Witnesses testified H.R. 511 is
necessary to clarify the rights of Indian tribes on Indian
lands and provide parity for tribal governments with federal,
state, and local governments under the NLRA.
Legislative Action
On January 22, 2015, Representative Todd Rokita (R-IN)
introduced H.R. 511, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015,
with 14 original cosponsors. On July 22, 2015, the Committee on
Education and the Workforce considered H.R. 511, the Tribal
Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015, in legislative session.
Representative Todd Rokita (R-IN) offered an amendment in the
nature of a substitute, making a technical change to clarify
that an Indian tribe is not considered an employer covered by
the NLRA, which was adopted by voice vote. The Committee
favorably reported H.R. 511, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by voice vote.
On November 17, 2015, the House of Representatives passed
H.R. 511, as amended, by a vote of 249-177. The bill was
introduced in the Senate as S. 248, introduced by Senator Jerry
Moran (R-KS), and favorably reported by the Committee on Indian
Affairs, but not taken up by the full Senate.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On March 29, 2017, the HELP Subcommittee held a legislative
hearing entitled ``H.R. 986, Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of
2017.'' Witnesses testified to the urgent need to prevent the
NLRB from usurping power from sovereign Indian tribes.
Witnesses were the Honorable Brian Cladoosby, President,
National Congress of American Indians, Washington, D.C.; the
Honorable Nathaniel Brown, Delegate, 23rd Navajo Nation
Council, Navajo Nation, Window Rock, Arizona; Mr. John Gribbon,
California Political Director, UNITE HERE International Union,
AFL-CIO, San Francisco, California; and the Honorable Robert J.
Welch, Jr., Chairman, Viejas Band of Kumeyaay Indians, Alpine,
California.
Legislative Action
On February 9, 2017, Representative Todd Rokita (R-IN)
introduced H.R. 986, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2017,
with nine original cosponsors. On June 29, 2017, the Committee
considered H.R. 986, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2017,
in legislative session. Representative Todd Rokita (R-IN)
offered an amendment in the nature of a substitute, making
technical changes to clarify the definition of ``Indian
lands,'' which was adopted by voice vote. The Committee
favorably reported H.R. 986, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a vote of 22-16.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 26, 2025, the Committee on Education and
Workforce held a hearing entitled ``Unleashing America's
Workforce and Strengthening Our Economy,'' which included a
discussion of the regulatory onslaught of the Biden-era NLRB.
Witnesses were Ms. Rosanna Maietta, President and CEO, American
Hotel and Lodging Association, Washington, D.C.; Dr. William
Beach, Senior Fellow in Economics, Economy Policy Innovation
Center, Arlington, Virginia; Ms. Elizabeth Milito, Executive
Director, National Federation of Independent Business--Small
Business Legal Center, Wasington, D.C.; and Dr. Heidi
Shierholz, President, Economic Policy Institute, Washington,
D.C.
On April 8, 2025, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Game Changer: The NLRB, Student-Athletes, and the
Future of College Sports,'' which included discussion of the
application and scope of the NLRA and overreach by the NLRB.
Witnesses were Mr. Daniel L. Nash, Shareholder, Littler,
Washington, D.C.; Ms. Morgyn Wynne, former softball student-
athlete, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, Oklahoma; Mr.
Ramogi Huma, Executive Director, National College Players
Association, Norco, California; and Ms. Jacquie McWilliams
Parker, Commissioner, Central Intercollegiate Athletic
Association, Charlotte, North Carolina.
On June 11, 2025, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Restoring Balance: Ensuring Fairness and
Transparency at the NLRB,'' which examined NLRB policies,
including interpretation of the NLRA, the purposes and scope of
the NLRA, and overreach by the NLRB. Witnesses were Mr. Roger
King, Senior Labor and Employment Counsel, HR Policy
Association, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Vincent Vernuccio,
President, Institute for the American Worker, Hamilton,
Virginia; Mr. Aaron Solem, Staff Attorney, National Right to
Work Legal Defense Foundation, Springfield, Virginia.; and Ms.
Jennifer Abruzzo, Senior Advisor to the President,
Communications Workers of America, Washington, D.C.
On September 9, 2025, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Unmasking Union Antisemitism,'' which included a
discussion of the scope of the NLRB's application of the NLRA
to certain employees. Witnesses were Ms. Kyle Koeppel Mann,
Senior Staff Attorney, New York Legal Assistance Group, New
York, New York; Mr. David Rubinstein, Ph.D. Candidate,
Department of History, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York;
Dr. Joseph McCartin, Professor and Executive Director,
Kalmanovitz Initiative for Labor and the Working Poor,
Georgetown University, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Glenn Taubman,
Staff Attorney, National Right to Work Legal Defense
Foundation, Springfield, Virginia.
Legislative Action
On February 27, 2025, Rep. John Moolenaar (R-MI) introduced
H.R. 1723, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2025. The bill
was referred solely to the Committee on Education and
Workforce. On September 17, 2025, the Committee considered H.R.
1723 in legislative session and adopted by voice vote an
amendment in the nature of a substitute offered by Rep. Mark
Messmer (R-IN), which made technical changes to the bill. The
Committee reported the bill, as amended, favorably to the House
of Representatives by a recorded vote of 19-16.
Committee Views
Introduction
For decades, Indian tribes determined the labor laws
governing tribally owned and operated enterprises on tribal
land, just as state governments set the rules for state-owned
enterprises and their employees. However, in 2004, the NLRB
began asserting jurisdiction over labor-management relations at
tribal enterprises on tribal lands, applying a test of its own
design to decide which enterprises would be considered
employers. That test has created uncertainty and undermined
tribal self-determination. H.R. 1723, the Tribal Labor
Sovereignty Act of 2025, codifies in the nation's labor law
respect for tribal sovereignty and restores parity between
states and Indian tribes by amending the NLRA to exclude from
its coverage tribal enterprises located on tribal lands. H.R.
1723 recognizes the inherent sovereignty of tribal governments
and ensures that tribes, like states, have the authority to
establish laws that reflect their unique circumstances,
priorities, and responsibilities to their members.
The NLRA
In 1935, Congress passed the NLRA, guaranteeing the right
of most private sector employees to organize and select their
own representative.\2\ In 1947, Congress amended the NLRA
through the Taft-Hartley Act,\3\ abandoning ``the policy of
affirmatively encouraging the spread of collective bargaining .
. . [and] striking a new balance between protection of the
right to self-organization and various opposing claims.''\4\
The Taft-Hartley Act clarified that employees have the right to
refrain from participating in union activity,\5\ expanded the
definition of unlawful employer or union actions and activities
known as unfair labor practices (ULP),\6\ codified employer
free speech,\7\ and made changes to the determination of
bargaining units.\8\ The NLRA established the NLRB, an
independent federal agency, to fulfill two principal functions:
(1) to prevent and remedy ULPs, and (2) to determine by secret
ballot election whether employees wish to be represented by a
union. In determining whether employees wish to be represented
by a union, the NLRA is wholly neutral.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\The NLRA does not cover all employees and employers in the
United States. For example, public sector employers (state, local, and
federal employees), employers covered by the Railway Labor Act
(airlines and railroads), agricultural laborers, and supervisors are
not covered by the Act. 29 U.S.C. Sec. 152(2)-(3).
\3\29 U.S.C. Sec. 141 et. seq.
\4\Archibald Cox, Some Aspects of the Labor Management Relations
Act of 1974, 61 Harv. L. Rev. 1, 4 (1974).
\5\29 U.S.C. Sec. 157.
\6\Id. Sec. 158.
\7\Id. Sec. 158(c).
\8\Id. Sec. 159(b).
\9\NLRB v. Savair Mfg., 414 U.S. 270, 278 (1973).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Regulation of State Labor Relations
Congress recognized the differences between the private and
public sectors when it excluded states from the NLRA. States
have promulgated various labor laws based on the specific needs
of the states. For example, most states permit collective
bargaining and collective wage negotiations for public-sector
workers, while a minority of states prohibits public-sector
workers from such collective action.\10\ Conversely, most
states do not afford public-sector workers the right to
strike.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Milla Sanes & John Schmitt, Regulation of Public Sector
Collective Bargaining in the States, Ctr. for Econ. & Pol. Research 4-8
(Mar. 2014), http://www.cepr.net/documents/state-public-cb-2014-03.pdf.
\11\Id. at 8-9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tribal Labor and Employment Law
Like the states, tribal nations have worked to protect the
rights of their employees, passing labor and employment laws
modeled after federal laws but tailored to the specific needs
of the tribes. In testimony before the HELP Subcommittee in
2015, the Honorable Rodney Butler, chairman of the Mashantucket
Pequot Nation (the Nation), described a number of provisions of
the Mashantucket Pequot Labor Relations Law (MPLRL). The law
guarantees ``the Nation's employees the right to organize and
bargain collectively with their employers'' and ``allows labor
organizations to be designated as the exclusive collective
bargaining representatives of employees.''\12\ Chairman Butler
stated:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\H.R. 511, Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015: Hearing Before
the Subcomm. on Health, Emp., Lab., & Pensions of the H. Comm. on Educ.
& the Workforce, 114th Cong. 28 (2015) (statement of the Hon. Rodney
Butler, Chairman, Mashantucket Pequot Nation) (internal quotation marks
omitted) [hereinafter H.R. 511 hearing].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In sum, the MPLRL is modeled after other public
sector laws, is similar to the NLRA in many aspects,
and essentially furthers the policies and principles
that are fundamental to federal labor policy as
enforced by the Board. It provides employees of Tribal
Employers with protections that are in many instances
identical to or, in some respects, more effective than
those provided to employees of private employers under
the NLRA. At the same time, the Nation's labor law
protects important tribal and federal objectives in
preserving and enhancing the Nation's self-governance
through the use and recognition of its institutions and
the preservation of its sovereignty.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chairman Butler noted the Mashantucket Employment Rights
Office had conducted at least six elections under the MPLRL,
with four unions certified as the exclusive bargaining
representatives of units of employees. The Mashantucket Pequot
Nation subsequently entered into collective bargaining
agreements with those four unions.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similarly, the Navajo Nation's labor laws protect the right
to collectively bargain while additionally including a right-
to-work provision. Mr. Richard Guest, senior staff attorney of
the Native American Rights Fund, discussed unionization rights
under the Navajo Nation labor code in his testimony to the HELP
Subcommittee. Mr. Guest stated that in 1985 the Navajo Nation
council ``incorporate[d] the most basic privileges of the
[NLRA] to tribal employees, whom the council acknowledged were
otherwise exempt from the NLRA.''\15\ This included the right
to collectively bargain.\16\ In 1990, the council voted for the
Navajo Nation to become a ``right to work'' jurisdiction,
disallowing labor organizations from collecting union dues from
non-members.\17\ Unions are collectively bargaining with the
Navajo Nation and private employers on tribal land. Mr. Guest
stated:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Id. at 15-16 (statement of Richard Guest, Senior Staff Att'y,
Native Am. Rights Fund).
\16\Id. at 16.
\17\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Collective bargaining is occurring on the Navajo
Nation, with private enterprise as well as government.
The United Mine Workers of America (``UMWA'')
represents employees at the Navajo Nation Head Start
Program, a tribal government program. The Nal-Nishii
Federation of Labor, AFL-CIO includes 12 labor
organizations that represent miners, power plant
workers, construction workers, school employees and
city employees working on or near the Navajo
Nation.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Id. at 17.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Honorable Nathaniel Brown, Navajo Nation Council
Member, testified before the HELP Subcommittee in a subsequent
hearing and agreed with Mr. Guest that employees of the Navajo
Nation have basic labor rights. He stated that a ``Navajo
worker's right to join a union is protected.'' In addition, Mr.
Brown stated the Navajo Nation's laws protect other employee
rights.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\H.R. 986, Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2017: Hearing Before
the Subcomm. on Health, Emp., Lab., & Pensions of the H. Comm. on Educ.
& the Workforce, 115th Cong. 24 (statement of the Hon. Nathaniel Brown,
Council Member, Navaho Nation) [hereinafter H.R. 986 hearing].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Indian tribes have also addressed labor rights through the
California tribal labor relations ordinances. In his testimony,
Mr. Guest described how in 1999 Indian tribes negotiated
tribal-state gaming compacts in California. A tribe would only
qualify for the compact if it ``adopt[ed] a process for
addressing union organizing and collective bargaining rights of
tribal gaming employees.''\20\ The negotiations resulted in the
drafting of a Model Tribal Labor Relations Ordinance
(Ordinance), which tribes with 250 or more casino-related
employees were required to adopt.\21\ The Ordinance is similar
to the NLRA in many ways, including the right to organize and
bargain collectively. However, Mr. Guest noted the Ordinance
also differs from the NLRA, with some differences favoring
labor unions and some favoring Indian tribes:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\H.R. 511 hearing, supra note 12, at 17 (statement of Richard
Guest).
\21\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Ordinance provides labor unions at tribal gaming
facilities with a number of advantages not provided for
under the NLRA. Most importantly, under the Ordinance
unions at tribal casinos: (1) have the right to enter
onto casino property at any time to talk to employees
and post leaflets and posters there in order to
facilitate the organizing of employees; and (2) may
engage in secondary boycotts after an impasse is
reached in negotiations without suffering any penalty
under the Ordinance. The Ordinance also provides tribes
with certain advantages not enjoyed by employers under
the NLRA. Most importantly, unions representing tribal
casino employees may not strike, picket, or engage in
boycotts before an impasse is reached in
negotiations.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Id. at 18-19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Honorable Robert J. Welch, Jr., chairman of the Viejas
Band of Kumeyaay Indians from San Diego County, California,
discussed in his testimony before the HELP Subcommittee the
tribal labor ordinance that the Viejas Band passed in 1999:
On September 14, 1999, the Viejas Band passed its own
law governing labor relations: a Tribal Labor Relations
Ordinance (the ``TLRO''). The TLRO, like similar
volunta
Committee Action
110th Congress
On August 3, 2007, Rep. John Kline (R-MN) introduced H.R.
3413, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2007, which would
have exempted any enterprise or institution owned and operated
by an Indian tribe and located on its Indian lands from being
considered an employer under the NLRA. The bill was referred to
the Committee on Education and Labor (Committee). It had zero
Democratic cosponsors.
111th Congress
On March 9, 2009, Rep. Kline introduced H.R. 1395, the
Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2009. The bill was referred to
the Committee. It had zero Democratic cosponsors.
112th Congress
On June 23, 2011, Rep. Kristi Noem (R-SD) introduced H.R.
2335, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2011. The bill was
referred to the Committee. It had one Democratic cosponsor.
On July 25, 2012, the Committee's Subcommittee on Health,
Employment, Labor, and Pensions (HELP Subcommittee) held a
hearing on H.R. 2335. The Democratic witness was Ms. Devki K.
Virk, Member, Bredhoff and Kaiser, P.L.L.C., Washington, DC.
113th Congress
On March 15, 2013, Rep. Noem introduced H.R. 2335, the
Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2013. The bill was referred to
the Committee. It had zero Democratic cosponsors.
114th Congress
On January 22, 2015, Rep. Todd Rokita (R-IN) introduced
H.R. 511, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015. The bill
was referred to the Committee. It had two Democratic
cosponsors.
On June 16, 2015, the Committee's Subcommittee on Health,
Employment, Labor, and Pensions (HELP Subcommittee) held a
hearing on H.R. 511. The Democratic witness was Mr. Gary
Navarro, Slot Machine Attendant and Bargaining Committee Member
for UNITE HERE Local 2850, Graton Casino and Resort, Rohnert
Park, California.
The Committee held a markup of H.R. 511 on July 22, 2015.
The Committee voted to favorably report H.R. 511 to the House
of Representatives by voice vote, however numerous Committee
Democrats opposed the bill as explained in their Minority Views
to the Committee Report.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\See H.R. Rep. No. 114-260, at 27 (2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On November 17, 2015, the House passed the bill by a vote
of 249 to 177. Prior to the vote, the Obama Administration
issued a Statement of Administration Policy opposing the bill
but stated that the Administration could support a compromise
that would ``exempt[] tribes from the jurisdiction of the
[NLRB] only if the tribes adopt labor standards and procedures
. . . reasonably equivalent to those in the National Labor
Relations Act.''\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Barack Obama, Statement of Administration Policy: H.R. 511--
Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015 (Nov. 17, 2015) https://
www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/files/uploads/hr_511.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
115th Congress
On February 9, 2017, Rep. Rokita introduced H.R. 986, the
Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2017. The bill was referred to
the Committee. It had four Democratic cosponsors.
On March 29, 2017, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing on
H.R. 986. The Democratic witness was Mr. John Gribbon,
California Political Director, UNITE HERE International Union,
AFL-CIO, San Francisco, California.
On June 29, 2017, the Committee held a markup of H.R. 986.
The Committee voted to favorably reported H.R. 986 to the House
of Representatives by a vote of 22-16 along party lines.
116th Congress
On January 24, 2019, Rep. John Moolenaar (R-MI) introduced
H.R. 779, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2019. The bill
was referred to the Committee. It had one Democratic cosponsor.
117th Congress
On July 29, 2021, Rep. Moolenaar introduced H.R. 4839, the
Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2021. The bill was referred to
the Committee. It had zero Democratic cosponsors.
118th Congress
On February 9, 2023, Rep. Moolenaar introduced H.R. 937,
the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2023. The bill was referred
to the Committee. It had zero Democratic cosponsors.
Background
Enacted in 1935, the NLRA provides private sector workers
with the right to join or form a union, engage in concerted
activity, and collectively bargain over pay, benefits, and
working conditions with their employer.\4\ The NLRA is enforced
by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 27, 2025, Rep. John Moolenaar (R-MI) introduced
H.R. 1723, the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act.\5\ H.R. 1723 would
exempt all American Indian-owned and -operated businesses
located on Tribal lands--including casinos, mines, ski resorts,
sawmills, restaurants, construction companies, and retail
stores--from coverage under the NLRA. This would result in
every employee of these businesses, whether or not they are a
member of the American Indian Tribe, being stripped of their
rights under the NLRA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2025, H.R. 1723, 119th Cong.
(2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prior to marking up the bill on September 17, 2025, the
Majority provided no opportunity for discussion or debate on
Tribal labor relations and did not hold a hearing to consider
H.R. 1723 or the issues implicated by the legislation.
The bill is designed to overturn the NLRB's San Manuel
Indian Bingo and Casino (San Manuel) decision, a case in which
the NLRB, under President George W. Bush, asserted jurisdiction
over a Tribal-owned enterprise on Tribal land.\6\ In that 2004
case, the NLRB applied a widely used framework for determining
if, and when, a federal law of general applicability would
apply to an Indian Tribe. Under that test, which was
articulated in Donovan v. Coeur d'Alene Tribal Farm (Couer
d'Alene),\7\ a federal law of general applicability will not
apply to a Tribe if (1) it touched upon a Tribe's intramural
governance; (2) it abrogated the federal government's treaty
obligations; or (3) Congress indicated that a law should not
apply to Indian Tribes. The NLRB went a step further and
adopted a fourth exception when there are policy reasons not to
assert jurisdiction in order ``to balance the Board's interest
in effectuating the policies of the Act with its desire to
accommodate the unique status of Indians in our society and
legal culture.''\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\341 NLRB 1055.
\7\751 F.2d 1113 (9th Cir. 1985).
\8\San Manuel, 341 NLRB at 1062.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Using the four-part test described above, the NLRB has
decided to assert jurisdiction on a case-by-case basis. For
example, it has asserted jurisdiction at Tribal casinos in
California, Connecticut, Michigan, and elsewhere, while
declining to assert jurisdiction in several other cases,
including at an Oklahoma Tribal casino due to restrictions in
an 1830 treaty.\9\ Regardless, the NLRB's balancing test has
been repeatedly sustained: every court that has considered the
San Manuel framework--the D.C. Circuit, the Sixth Circuit, the
Ninth Circuit, and a federal district court in the Eighth
Circuit--has upheld it, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined
writ of certiorari in two challenges involving Tribal casinos
in Michigan.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\In another example, the NLRB declined to exercise jurisdiction
over tribal enterprises including a health clinic that served primarily
tribal members in Alaska based on the fourth exception. Yukon Kuskokwim
Health Corp., 341 NLRB 1075 (2004) (on remand from the D.C. Circuit,
234 F.3d 714 (2000)).
\10\Little River Band of Ottawa Indians v. NLRB, 136 S. Ct. 2508
(2016); NLRB v. Little River Band of Ottawa Indians Tribal Gov't., No.
14-2239 2015 WL 3556005 (6th Cir. June 9, 2015); San Manuel Indian
Bingo & Casino v. NLRB, 475 F.3d 1306 (D.C. Cir. 2007); NLRB v. Fortune
Bay Resort Casino, 688 F.Supp.2d 858 (D.Minn. 2010); Casino Pauma v.
NLRB, No. 16-70397 (9th Cir. Apr. 26, 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To be clear, the NLRA's jurisdiction typically covers most
private sector, rather than public sector, employees. Its
relevance here is that some Tribally owned enterprises
operating on Tribal lands, such as casinos, are typically part
of the private sector despite sitting on Tribal lands.
Enterprises on Tribal lands often employ hundreds of thousands
of workers--many of whom are not members of the Tribe that owns
the land on which the employer operates--and generate billions
of dollars in revenue every year. Some of these are
particularly lucrative, such as casinos and other gambling
establishments. For example, in Fiscal Year 2024, 532
independently audited gaming operations owned by 243 federally
recognized Tribes across 29 states generated nearly $44 billion
in revenue.\11\ Also, as of 2021, the Tribal casino industry
employed upwards of 400,000 workers.\12\ Notably, of those
400,000 workers, approximately 75 percent were not members of
the Tribe operating the casino.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Press Release, Nat'l Indian Gaming Commission, NIGC Announces
Record $43.9 Billion in FY 2024 Gross Gaming Revenues (July 31, 2025),
https://www.nigc.gov/nigc-announces-record-43-9-billion-in-fy-2024-
gross-gaming-revenues/.
\12\James Ike Schaap & Angel F. Gonzalez, The Growth of the Native
American Gaming Industry: An Update, Vol. XV, Issue 1 Journal of
Business & Economic Issues (2021), https://www.subr.edu/assets/subr/
COBJournal/Native-American-Study110820Final1896.pdf.
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the Tribal casino industry is one example of the many
industries that operate on Tribal lands, it is illustrative of
the problem of stripping all workers in Tribal lands of their
right to organize and collectively bargain under federal law. A
majority of workers, who are not members of the employing
Tribes, in some of these industries would be left without the
ability to petition a Tribal government for labor standards as
they would a state or local government. Furthermore, Tribal
governments may enact labor protections of their own, but they
are under no requirement to enact labor standards that mirror
or exceed the protections of the NLRA.
DISCUSSION
Labor and Tribal interests are already being balanced under
the NLRB's San Manuel framework. It does this by applying a
case-by-case, nuanced, and fact-specific approach that balances
protecting workers' rights while limiting NLRA jurisdiction
where it would interfere in core Tribal functions or implicate
treaty rights. Further, the NLRA has adopted a policy framework
to address the unique status of American Indians in our
government framework. H.R. 1723 undermines this carefully
balanced framework. The all-or-nothing approach in H.R. 1723 is
too sweeping, and there is no principled basis for excluding
hundreds of thousands of workers from coverage under labor laws
just because they happen to work in enterprises on Tribal
lands.
Most federal employment laws apply to Tribal enterprises;
this bill explicitly singles out and undermines the right to
join a union. Under the Coeur d'Alene framework, many other
federal laws apply to Tribal enterprises, including the
following labor, employment and consumer statutes:
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA);\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\29 U.S.C. Sec. 201 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSH
Act);\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\29 U.S.C. Sec. 651 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Employee Retirement Income Security Act
(ERISA);\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\29 U.S.C. Sec. 1001 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
(ACA)--(the employer mandate);\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\26 U.S.C. Sec. 4980H.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title III (public accommodations) of
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), but are exempt
from Title I (employment discrimination related to a
disability);\18\ and
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Federal Trade Commission Act (protections
related to pay day lenders).\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\15 U.S.C. Sec. 45 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While most federal labor and employment laws do apply to
Tribal enterprises, two notable exceptions are the Age
Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) and Title VII of the
Civil Rights Act.\20\ Thus, employees of a Tribal enterprise
who are subjected to sexual harassment, for example, cannot
bring a claim to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
(EEOC) or in federal court--even where the alleged perpetrator
and victim are both non-Tribal members employed at the Tribal
enterprise. Thus, for employees of Tribal enterprises, the NLRA
provides the only federal protection against discrimination and
harassment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\29 U.S.C. Sec. 621 et seq.; 29 U.S.C. Sec. 2000e et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending NLRA coverage could jeopardize enforcement of
existing union contracts and would undermine established
bargaining relationships. Thousands of employees at Tribal
enterprises--such as casinos--are currently covered by
collective bargaining agreements in units certified by the
NLRB. It is unclear whether these labor contracts would remain
enforceable if H.R. 1723 were enacted and the NLRA no longer
applied. If H.R. 1723 were enacted, a Tribe could unilaterally
terminate the established bargaining relationship with the
union without legal consequence when a contract expires, and
the employer's obligation to bargain in good faith would be
eliminated.
Tribal Labor Relations Ordinances (TLROs), which are labor
relations laws passed by Tribal governments that apply to
workers under the Tribal government's jurisdiction, are not
sufficient alternatives to NLRA coverage. Proponents of this
bill contend that Tribal governments can adopt TLROs that would
protect worker rights while also maintaining Tribal
sovereignty. While these could provide protections, they are
not an adequate substitute for the NLRA by themselves because
there is no minimum labor standard these TRLOs must meet, and
the workers who are not members of the Tribe have no
opportunity for democratic representation to petition or vote
for stronger labor standards, unlike in states or localities.
In addition, as of 2024, there were 574 federally-
recognized Tribes, meaning there can be as many as 574
different TLROs that vary wildly in the degree they protect
workers' right to organize and collectively bargain.\21\
Navigating 574 different TLROs with their own protections,
standards, and enforcement regimes would create an incredibly
complex and varied legal landscape for workers, labor unions,
and worker advocates to navigate. Further, without any minimum
standards, Tribes can enact ordinances that outlaw unions and
collective bargaining outright. For example, the Blackfeet
Nation in Montana has a TLRO that explicitly states, ``[u]nions
are prohibited on the Blackfeet Indian Reservation.''\22\ Under
H.R. 1723, a prohibition on workers' freedom of association to
form or join a union would have the force of law.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Congressional Research Service, CRS Report No. R47414, The 574
Federally Recognized Indian Tribes in the United States (2024).
\22\Blackfeet Tribal Employment Rights Ordinance & Safety
Enforcement Act, Section 3-107.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In a few cases, unions have agreed to be subject to a TLRO,
but only under the condition that the union reserves the right
to seek the protections of the NLRA should the Tribe weaken the
TLRO or fail to enforce it.\23\ This backstop would be
eliminated under H.R. 1723, leaving workers completely
vulnerable to a loss of protections that workers at comparable
enterprises outside of nontribal lands enjoy.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\See, e.g., Gale Courey Toensing, Mashantucket-UAW in
Groundbreaking Agreement to Negotiate Under Tribal Law, ICT (Nov. 8,
2008), https://ictnews.org/archive/mashantucket-uaw-in-groundbreaking-
agreement-to-negotiate-under-tribal-law/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, Committee Democrats
unanimously opposed H.R. 1723 when the Committee on Education
and Workforce considered it on September 17, 2025. We urge the
House of Representatives to do the same.
Robert C. ``Bobby'' Scott,
Ranking Member.
Suzanne Bonamici,
Alma S. Adams,
Mark DeSaulnier,
Jahana Hayes,
Summer Lee,
Members of Congress.
[all]