Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 6502]
The Committee on Education and Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 6502) to amend the Higher Education Act
of 1965 to require the Secretary of Education to develop
requirements for institutions of higher education on formatting
financial aid offer forms, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``College Financial Aid Clarity Act of
2025''.
SEC. 2. FINANCIAL AID OFFERS.
(a) In General.--Part B of title I of the Higher Education Act of
1965 (20 U.S.C. 1011 et seq.) is amended by adding at the end the
following:
``SEC. 124. FINANCIAL AID OFFERS.
``(a) Institutional Requirements.--
``(1) In general.--Beginning on July 1, 2029, an institution
of higher education that receives Federal financial assistance
under this Act--
``(A) shall--
``(i) for all financial aid offers (including
paper, or mobile-optimized or other electronic
offers), include the information (including
terminology) listed in subsection (c), and meet
the requirements of paragraphs (1) and (2) of
subsection (d), in compliance with the
requirements published pursuant to subsection
(b)(2);
``(ii) provide the supplemental content and
disclosures described in paragraph (2); and
``(iii) for all communications from the
institution related to financial aid offers
(including the supplemental content and
disclosures described in paragraph (2)), use
the terminology referenced in subsection (c) in
a consistent manner; and
``(B) in the case of an electronic financial aid
offer that includes a requirement that a student
confirm receipt of such offer, may not consider such
confirmation an acceptance or rejection of such offer.
``(2) Supplemental content and disclosures.--Each institution
of higher education described in paragraph (1) shall provide,
in supplemental documents or through easily accessible links on
the institution's portal or a website, the following:
``(A) The renewability requirements and conditions
under which the student can expect to receive, for each
award year the student is enrolled at the institution,
similar amounts of financial aid.
``(B) Whether the financial aid offer may change if
aid from outside sources is applied after the student
receives the initial financial aid offer, and, if
applicable, how that financial aid offer will change.
``(C) If loans made under part D of title IV or other
education loans offered through Federal programs are
included--
``(i) a disclosure that the interest rates
and fees on such loans are set annually and
affect total cost over time;
``(ii) a link to any website that includes
current information on interest rates and fees;
and
``(iii) a disclosure that such loans have to
be repaid and the student can borrow an amount
less than the offered loan amount.
``(D) A link to the College Financing Plan website of
the Department (or a successor website).
``(b) Secretarial Requirements.--
``(1) Requirements for institutions of higher education.--
``(A) Consumer testing.--The Secretary shall--
``(i) in consultation with the heads of
relevant Federal agencies, not later than 9
months after the date of enactment of the
College Financial Aid Clarity Act of 2025,
establish a process for consumer testing, with
the representatives described in subparagraph
(B), requirements for institutions of higher
education on formatting financial aid offers to
include the information (including terminology)
listed in subsection (c), and to meet the
requirements of paragraphs (1) and (2) of
subsection (d), in a manner that is simple and
understandable for students and the students'
families; and
``(ii) not later than 8 months after the
process for consumer testing is established
pursuant to clause (i), conduct and conclude
such consumer testing.
``(B) Representatives.--The representatives described
in this subparagraph are representatives of students
(including low-income students, first generation
college students, adult students, veterans,
servicemembers, and prospective students), students'
families (including low-income families, families with
first generation college students, and families with
prospective students), institutions of higher
education, secondary school and postsecondary
counselors, nonprofit organizations (including
scholarship-granting organizations), private lenders,
and States.
``(C) Nonapplication of paperwork reduction act.--
Subchapter I of chapter 35 of title 44, United States
Code, shall not apply to the consumer testing process
under this subsection.
``(2) Publication and notice.--Not later than July 1, 2028,
the Secretary shall--
``(A) publish the requirements developed pursuant to
paragraph (1)(A) on a publicly available website; and
``(B) notify each institution of higher education
that receives Federal financial assistance under this
Act of such requirements and the requirements of
subsection (a).
``(3) Sample of financial aid offers.--Not later than July 1,
2029, and every other year thereafter, the Secretary shall, in
a manner consistent with applicable Federal privacy statutes--
``(A) collect a random representative sample of
financial aid offers made by institutions for the most
recent award year; and
``(B) review such offers for compliance with the
requirements of subsection (a)(1)(A)(i).
``(c) Information Required.--To comply with subsection (a), an
institution of higher education shall include the following information
in any financial aid offer that is made by the institution:
``(1) Information for the award year covered by the offer.--
``(A) Award year information.--The program of study
and the award year of such program of study covered by
the financial aid offer, and an explanation that the
amount of financial aid offered may differ--
``(i) for academic periods not covered by the
financial aid offer, such as a summer term or
future award year; and
``(ii) by program of study.
``(B) Annual cost information.--Information on the
student's estimated cost of attendance for the award
year covered by the financial aid offer, including the
following:
``(i) The required costs for such award year,
including the academic workload used to
determined such required costs.
``(ii) The cost of attendance for such award
year.
``(iii) An indication, as applicable, about
whether any of the items used to calculate the
required costs included in clause (i) are--
``(I) estimated based on the previous
year; or
``(II) set for the award year covered
by the financial aid offer.
``(C) Annual grants and scholarships.--The amount of
grant and scholarship aid for the award year covered by
the financial aid offer.
``(D) Annual net price.--
``(i) Annual net price for completion.--The
annual net price for completion for the award
year covered by the financial aid offer, and a
disclosure that such amount is an estimate.
``(ii) Annual net price of attendance.--The
annual net price of attendance for the award
year covered by the financial aid offer, and a
disclosure that such amount--
``(I) includes costs that are not
required costs; and
``(II) is an estimate.
``(E) Loans.--Information on each loan for which the
student is eligible for the award year covered by the
offer (including any institutional, Federal, State, or
private loan), including--
``(i) with respect to each such loan--
``(I) the total amount offered to the
student;
``(II) any applicable interest rate,
including information on circumstances
in which interest may be capitalized on
the loan, and any applicable fees
(including origination fees and
additional costs); and
``(III) information on any applicable
loan repayment assistance offered by
the institution;
``(ii) a disclosure that the interest rates
and fees on such loans can affect total cost
over time;
``(iii) a disclosure that such loans have to
be repaid; and
``(iv) a disclosure that the student can
borrow an amount less than the offered loan
amount.
``(2) Grants and scholarships for the program length.--The
amount of grant and scholarship aid for the program length of
the program of study for which the financial aid offer is
provided.
``(3) Student employment.--Information on work-study
employment opportunities (including work-study programs under
part C of title IV, institutional work-study programs, or State
work-study programs), including--
``(A) the maximum annual amount the student may earn
through such an employment opportunity; and
``(B) a disclosure that any amounts received pursuant
to such an employment opportunity may be--
``(i) subject to the availability of
qualified employment opportunities upon
enrollment; and
``(ii) disbursed over time as earned by the
student.
``(4) Net price calculator.--A link to the universal net
price calculator website described in section 132(c)(4).
``(5) Average costs for the most recent award year.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a program of study
for which the financial aid offer is provided--
``(i) for the most recent award year for
which data is available--
``(I) the average annual net price
required for completion; and
``(II) the average annual price of
attendance; and
``(ii) with respect to students who completed
a credential for the program of study during
the most recent award year--
``(I) the average total net price
required for completion based on the
time to credential for the program of
study; and
``(II) the average total net price of
attendance based on the time to
credential for the program of study.
``(B) Disclosure.--A disclosure that the information
provided in subparagraph (A) is based on the required
costs and amounts of grant and scholarship aid
applicable to other students for the most recent award
year, and such information may not be applicable to the
student receiving the financial aid offer.
``(6) Process for accepting, adjusting, or declining aid and
next steps.--
``(A) Deadlines.--The deadlines and a summary of the
process (including the next steps) for--
``(i) accepting the financial aid offered;
``(ii) adjusting the amount of aid offered;
and
``(iii) declining the aid offered.
``(B) Payment.--Information on when and how costs
described in paragraph (1)(B) must be paid.
``(C) Disclosure.--A disclosure that verification of
information provided on the Free Application for
Federal Student Aid may require the student to submit
further documentation.
``(D) Financial aid information.--Information about
where a student or the student's family can seek
additional information regarding the financial aid
offered, including contact information for the
institution's financial aid office and a link to the
Department of Education's student financial aid
website.
``(E) College costs and student outcome
information.--Information about where a student or a
student's family can seek additional information on
college costs and student outcomes, including a link to
the Department of Education's College Scorecard website
(or a successor website) and how to use such website to
compare information from institutions of higher
education regarding such costs and outcomes.
``(d) Format Requirements.--
``(1) In general.--To comply with subsection (a), any
financial aid offer made by an institution of higher education
shall be titled `Financial Aid Offer', use plain language
wherever possible, and format the information listed in
subsection (c) in accordance with paragraph (2).
``(2) Format of required information.--The information listed
in subsection (c) shall be formatted in a financial aid offer
made by an institution of higher education as follows:
``(A) The information required in subparagraphs (A)
through (E) of subsection (c)(1) is listed in such
order, under separate headings, and in the same font.
``(B) There is a clear distinction between the
required costs and any other costs of attendance
included in such financial aid offer.
``(C) There is a clear distinction between the aid
offered under subparagraphs (C) and (E) of subsection
(c)(1), including--
``(i) by not combining the different types of
aid described in such paragraphs; and
``(ii) in such subparagraph (E)--
``(I) by using the word `loan' to
clearly describe the recommended loan
amounts; and
``(II) by clearly distinguishing
between subsidized and unsubsidized
loans.
``(D) The terminology referenced in subsection (c) is
used in a consistent manner.
``(E) Such information is listed--
``(i) in a manner that ensures none of the
information is inappropriately omitted or
deemphasized; and
``(ii) in a consistent format for all
financial aid offers made by such institution.
``(e) Definitions.--In this section:
``(1) Required costs.--The term `required costs' means the
sum of all the items listed in section 472(a) that are required
by an institution of higher education for a program of study
for the program length of a program of study, for the time to
credential for a student, or for an award year of a program of
study, as applicable, including--
``(A) the tuition and fees normally assessed a
student enrolled in such program of study carrying the
same academic workload, as determined by the
institution; and
``(B) in a case in which the institution requires a
student to reside in institutionally owned or operated
housing or to use institutionally owned or operated
food services, the applicable standard allowance for
such housing or food services determined by the
institution in accordance with section 472(a)(5).
``(2) Amount of grant and scholarship aid.--The term `amount
of grant and scholarship aid' means the sum of all of the grant
and scholarship aid that is available to the student for the
program length of a program of study, for the time to
credential for a student, or for an award year of
Committee Action
113TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On April 24, 2013, the Subcommittee on Higher Education and
Workforce Training held a hearing on ``Keeping College Within
Reach: Enhancing Transparency for Students, Families, and
Taxpayers.'' The hearing examined efforts to improve higher
education transparency, including tools like the College
Navigator and College Scorecard, and challenges students face
in navigating postsecondary options. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Dr. Donald Heller, Dean, College of
Education, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI; Mr.
Alex Garrido, Student, Keiser University, Miami, FL; Dr. Nicole
Farmer Hurd, Founder and Executive Director, National College
Advising Corps, Carrboro, NC; and Mr. Travis Reindl, Program
Director, Postsecondary Education, National Governors
Association Center for Best Practices, Washington, D.C.
On November 13, 2013, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Keeping College Within Reach:
Simplifying Federal Student Aid.'' The purpose of the hearing
was to examine the need to streamline, consolidate, and
simplify federal student aid programs. Testifying before the
Committee were Ms. Kristin D. Conklin, Founding Partner, HCM
Strategies, LLC, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Sandy Baum, Research
Professor of Education Policy, George Washington University
Graduate School of Education and Human Development, and Senior
Fellow, Urban Institute, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Jennifer
Mishory, J.D., Deputy Director, Young Invincibles, Washington,
D.C.; and Mr. Jason Delisle, Director, Federal Education Budget
Project, New America Foundation, Washington, D.C.
118TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On April 10, 2024, the Subcommittee on Higher Education
and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``FAFSA Fail:
Examining the Impact on Students, Families, and Schools.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to assess the causes and impacts of
the failed FAFSA rollout, including the effects of delays and
data inaccuracies on students and postsecondary institutions.
Testifying before the Subcommittee were Mr. Mark Kantrowitz,
President, Cerebly, Inc, York, Skokie, IL; Dr. Justin Draeger,
President & CEO, National Association of Student Financial Aid
Administrators, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Kim Cook, CEO, National
College Attainment Network, Washington, D.C.; and Ms. Rachelle
Feldman, Vice Provost, Enrollment, University of North Carolina
Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC.
On September 24, 2024, the Subcommittee on Higher Education
and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``GAO Uncovers
Biden-Harris FAFSA Failures.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to review data and findings from the Government Accountability
Office (GAO) on the Department of Education's implementation of
the new FAFSA, with a focus on timelines, technical challenges,
and transparency and communication with students, institutions,
and taxpayers. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Ms.
Melissa Emrey-Arras, Director, Education, Workforce, and Income
Security Issues, GAO, Washington, D.C.; and Mrs. Marisol Cruz
Cain, Director, Information Technology and Cybersecurity Team,
GAO, Washington D.C.
Legislative Action
On January 11, 2024, then-Chairwoman Virginia Foxx
introduced H.R. 6951, the College Cost Reduction Act, with
original co-sponsors Representatives Burgess Owens (R-UT),
Glenn Grothman (R-WI), Rick W. Allen (R-GA), Lloyd Smucker (R-
PA), Lisa McClain (R-MI), Michelle Steel (R-CA), and Brandon
Williams (R-NY). On January 31, 2024, the Committee considered
H.R. 6951 in a legislative session and reported it favorably,
as amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote
of 22-19. The Committee considered the following amendments to
H.R. 6951:
1. Representative Owens offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute that made technical changes to
the text. The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
2. Representative Jahana Hayes (D-CT) offered an
amendment to increase the total maximum Pell Grant
amount awarded during the 2025-2026 award year from
$7,395 to $10,000 and increase it incrementally
thereafter. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
3. Representative Hayes offered an amendment to
strike the bill's accreditation provisions. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #2, which
failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
4. Representative Hayes offered an amendment to
provide federal student loan forgiveness for teachers.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #3,
which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
5. Representative Haley Stevens (D-MI) offered an
amendment to make post baccalaureate students eligible
to receive a Pell Grant. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote
of 17-22.
6. Representative Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) offered an
amendment to increase the total number of semesters a
student can be eligible for Pell Grants from 12 to 18.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1,
which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
7. Representative Joe Courtney (D-CT) offered an
amendment to expand the Public Service Loan Forgiveness
program. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
8. Representative Frederica Wilson (D-FL) offered an
amendment to allow graduate or professional students to
be eligible to receive a federal Direct Stafford Loan,
excluding graduate medical school, nursing school,
veterinary school, or a school located outside the U.S.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1,
which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
9. Representative Stevens offered an amendment to
stipulate that nothing under the bill can be construed
to prevent graduate students from exercising collective
bargaining rights under the National Labor Relations
Act. The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc
#2, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
9. Representative Wilson offered an amendment to
strike a provision to repeal regulations related to
financial value transparency and gainful employment and
stipulate that the Department of Education (Department)
would not be permitted to promulgate or enforce any
regulation or rules related to the application of the
term ``gainful employment.'' The amendment was included
in amendment En Bloc #4, which failed by a roll call
vote of 19-22.
10. Ranking Member Bobby Scott (D-VA) offered an
amendment to establish an interest rate equal to the
high yield of the 10-year Treasury note auctioned at
the final auction prior to June 1, 2025, or 5 percent
for new federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford loans,
federal Direct Stafford loans, and federal Direct PLUS
loans issued on or after July 1, 2025. The amendment
also established a new rate for any federal Direct
Consolidation Loan. The amendment also authorized the
Department to establish programs to refinance federal
Direct Loans and eligible private education loans. The
amendment also established guidelines for determining
the interest rate for refinanced loans through both
programs, which would have been fixed. The amendment
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
11. Representative Teresa Leger Fernandez (D-NM)
offered an amendment to direct the Department, in
consultation with the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau, Financial Literacy and Education Commission,
and Internal Revenue Service (IRS), to establish a
personal finance education portal on a centralized and
publicly available Department website for federal
financial aid. Representative Leger Fernandez
subsequently withdrew the amendment.
12. Representative Leger Fernandez offered an
amendment to authorize the Department to award grants
for tuition-free community college to eligible states
and tribal colleges and universities. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
13. Representative Mark Takano (D-CA) offered an
amendment to strike a provision to repeal the 90/10
regulation that caps the percentage of revenue that a
for-profit school can receive from federal financial
aid sources at 90 percent and stipulate that the other
10 percent of revenue must come from alternative
sources. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of
19-22.
14. Representative Takano offered an amendment to add
language to stipulate that the bill's provisions would
not take effect until the inspectors general of the
Departments of Education and Veterans Affairs submit a
report to Congress certifying that the bill would not
result in fraud or abuse of veteran students. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
15. Representative Alma Adams (D-NC) offered an
amendment to stipulate that no claim from a federal
student loan could be collected by administrative
offset for any payments related to Social Security. It
applied to any payments made after the bill's
enactment. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of
19-22.
16. Representative Adams offered an amendment to
require the Department, a guaranty agency, or an
eligible loan holder to remove any adverse item of
information related to a loan from a borrower's credit
history upon the sale or assignment of a loan after the
loan is reported as being in default. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a
roll call vote of 18-22.
17. Delegate Gregorio Sablan (D-MP) offered an
amendment to establish a program to enable college-
bound residents of the Northern Mariana Islands and
American Samoa to have additional choices to attend
higher education institutions. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
18. Representative Lucy McBath (D-GA) offered an
amendment to strike a provision to repeal current
regulations related to closed school loan discharges.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4,
which failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
19. Representative Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR) offered an
amendment to add language to require colleges and
universities to accept Individualized Education
Programs under the Individuals with Disabilities
Education Act, or plans describing services or
accommodations provided to an individual with a
disability pursuant to section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as proper documentation for
disability accommodations. The amendment failed by a
roll call vote of 19-21.
20. Representative Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) offered an
amendment to strike a provision that would repeal
regulations related to borrower repayment defense. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
21. Representative Jayapal offered an amendment to
require the postsecondary student data system to
include data on applications received, students
accepted, and students placed on the wait list
disaggregated by race and ethnic subgroup at each
institution of higher education (IHE). The amendment
was included in amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
22. Representative Jayapal offered an amendment to
require the Department to adjust the median cost of
college for a program of study for institutions located
in a metropolitan area to account for the higher cost
of living. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
23. Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) offered an
amendment to strike a provision that stipulated that
the Department could not issue a proposed rule, final
regulation, or exhaustive action to carry out the
bill's provisions if it is determined that it would be
economically significant or result in a subsidy cost
increase. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
24. Representative Omar offered an amendment to
authorize a program for the Department to provide
grants for a period of 5 years to eligible IHEs to
provide childcare services for student parents. The
amendment failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
25. Representative Omar offered an amendment to
strike a provision that established annual limits on
federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford Loans, for any
period of instruction beginning on or after July 1,
2025, which would not exceed the cost of attendance for
an academic year. The amendment also struck the
establishment of maximum aggregate student loan amounts
professional, graduate, and undergraduate students
could receive through such loans. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a
roll call vote of 18-22.
26. Representative Omar offered an amendment to
strike a provision that established two repayment plans
for federal loans made on or after July 1, 2024,
including a standard repayment plan with a fixed
monthly repayment amount paid over a fixed period that
does not exceed 10 years and a standard repayment
assistance plan under the income-driven repayment
program. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
27. Representative Jamaal Bowman (D-NY) offered an
amendment to stipulate that nothing in the bill could
be construed to require any accreditation agency or
association to promulgate a standard that would
prohibit IHEs from offering programs of study in any
academic subject. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #2, which failed by a roll call vote
of 18-22.
28. Representative Bowman offered an amendment to
prohibit IHEs from providing preferential treatment in
the admissions process for donors and alumni, effective
on the first day of the second award year after the
bill's enactment. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #2, which failed by a roll call vote
of 18-22.
29. Representative Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an
amendment to strike the amended definition of ``third-
party server,'' which referred to any individual,
state, or private for-profit or nonprofit organization
that enters into a contract with an IHE to administer
any student assistance programs under the bill. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
30. Representative Manning offered an amendment to
stipulate that nothing in the bill could be construed
to prevent an IHE from providing medically accurate and
comprehensive information about sexual and reproductive
health services, including contraception. The amendment
failed by a roll call vote of 20-21.
31. Ranking Member Scott offered an amendment to
strike a provision to prohibit the Department from
implementing any substantially similar rule,
regulation, policy or executive action related to
regulations repealed under the bill, including closed
school loan discharges, borrower repayment defense,
pre-dispute arbitration, false certification,
administrative capability, certification procedures,
ability to benefit, and personal liability. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On September 16, 2025, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on ``No More
Surprises: Reforming College Pricing for Students and
Families.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine ways to
make college costs more transparent. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Mr. Justin Draeger, Senior Vice President,
Affordability, Strada Education Foundation, Washington, D.C.;
Mr. Lee Wishing III, Vice President for Student Recruitment and
Chief Marketing Officer, Grove City College, Grove City, PA;
Ms. Amy Laitinen, Senior Director of Higher Education, New
America, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Andrew Gillen, Research
Fellow, Cato Institute, Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On December 9, 2025, Representative Lisa McClain (R-MI)
introduced the College Financial Aid Clarity Act of 2025 (H.R.
6502). The bill was referred solely to the Committee on
Education and Workforce. On December 11, 2025, the Committee
considered H.R. 6502 in legislative session and reported it
favorably, as amended, to the House of Representatives by a
recorded vote of 23-10.\1\ The Committee considered the
following amendments to H.R. 6502:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/6502/
all-actions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Representative Bob Onder (R-MO) offered an
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute that removed
duplicative or inapplicable language, improved
disclosures and formatting, refined net price
definitions, and established review of aid offers for
compliance. The amendment passed by voice vote.
2. Representative Adams offered an amendment to
strike the bill and insert the Understanding the True
Cost of College Act. The amendment failed by a roll
call vote of 14-19.
3. Representative Bonamici offered an amendment to
prohibit the Secretary of Education from entering into
additional Interagency Agreements. The amendment failed
by a roll call vote of 14-19.
4. Representative Wilson offered an amendment to
prohibit the Secretary of Education from enacting
additional Interagency Agreements. The amendment failed
by a roll call vote of 14-19.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 6502, the College Financial Aid Clarity Act, requires
institutions t
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 6502, the College Financial Aid Clarity Act of 2025,
would require the Secretary of Education to establish
requirements for presenting and formatting financial aid offer
letters for institutions of higher education that receive
federal financial assistance under the Higher Education Act of
1965 (HEA). As students decide which institution of higher
education is right for them, it is imperative that they have
information about the financial aid packages that they are
eligible for at each institution. Ideally these financial aid
packages would be presented in a format that is standardized,
allowing students to easily compare aid packages between
institutions. While this bill does add requirements towards the
goal of a standardized offer letter, H.R. 6502 falls short of
true standardization and overcomplicates the elements necessary
to present cost information on financial aid offer letters in a
clear and transparent manner. Committee Democrats strongly urge
Republicans to make significant changes to this bill prior to
its consideration in the House to ensure it substantially
improves transparency for students, instead of making them more
confused.
CONGRESS NEEDS TO IMPROVE FINANCIAL AID OFFERS
Financial aid offers are provided by institutions of higher
education to give admitted students information about the types
of aid the school is offering them to defray the cost of their
higher education.\1\ Institutions that participate in the
student financial assistance programs authorized by the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (HEA) are required to disclose
information on the cost of attending to students.\2\ However
there is no federal law requiring institutions to provide a
financial aid offer to accepted students, let alone one in a
standardized format with consistent terminology and clarity of
information in their financial aid offers.\3\ The lack of
standardization and inconsistent presentation of financial aid
offers across institutions makes it difficult for students and
families to understand and compare cost and aid information. A
groundbreaking 2018 report by New America analyzed award
letters from over 500 institutions of higher education and
found little to no consistency in terms used or how information
was presented.\4\ In one of the reports most egregious
findings, 455 schools offered unsubsidized student loans, but
136 different terms were used to describe that loan, including
24 who did not even use the word ``loan'' in their term.\5\ It
is unsurprising then that students and families face challenges
navigating college financial aid offers between institutions
because these offers often vary widely.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\U.S. Dep't of Educ., Off. of Fed. Stud. Aid, How to Evaluate
Your Aid Offers, https://studentaid.gov/articles/evaluating-financial-
aid-offers/.
\2\20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092 (``the cost of attending the institution,
including (i) tuition and fees, (ii) books and supplies, (iii)
estimates of typical student room and board costs or typical commuting
costs, and (iv) any additional cost of the program in which the student
is enrolled or expresses a specific interest;''). This is not to be
confused with the actual term ``cost of attendance'' defined in HEA
Sec. 472, a definition also modified in H.R. 6502, 20 U.S.C.
Sec. 1087ll.
\3\Stephen Burd et al., Decoding the Cost of College: The Case for
Transparent Financial Aid Award Letters, New America, June 2018
(``There is currently no requirement for institutions to provide
financial aid offers via paper or digital letter to students.'').
\4\Id.
\5\Id. at 12.
\6\Joana Nesbit, 3 Ways College Financial Aid Letters Can Confuse
Families--and What to Do About It, UAspire, Mar. 21, 2022, https://
www.uaspire.org/news-events/3-ways-college-financial-aid-letters-can-
confuse.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to using non-standard terminology, award
letters vary greatly in the data they provide students to make
their decision. In a 2022 report, the U.S. Government
Accountability Office (GAO) found that most colleges and
universities do not provide students with all the information
necessary to help them clearly understand their financial aid
offers.\7\ GAO reported that approximately 55% of institutions
do not provide a total cost of attendance data point, one that
reflects both direct and indirect costs for students.\8\ GAO
also found that an estimated 91% of institutions either do not
include or understate the net price\9\ in their financial aid
offers.\10\ As a result of these findings, GAO recommended
federal lawmakers to take up legislation to mandate
institutions of higher education to follow best practices for
providing students with clear and standard financial aid
offers.\11\ GAO is not alone in this recommendation.
Stakeholders have also urged standardization of financial aid
offers to help students and families make better informed
decisions about college.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\U.S. Gov't Accountability Off., GAO-23-104708, FINANCIAL AID
OFFERS Action Needed to Improve Information on College Costs and
Student Aid 26, (2022) https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-104708.pdf.
\8\Id. at 9. GAO defined direct costs as ``Costs that are typically
billed directly by the college. Examples include tuition, fees, and on-
campus housing and meals.'' Id. at 6. It defined indirect costs as
``Costs that students pay to other parties throughout the academic
term. Examples include books, academic supplies, off-campus housing and
meals, and other miscellaneous expenses, such as transportation.'' Id.
The sum of these direct and indirect costs as defined by GAO greatly
mirrors HEA's cost of attendance.
\9\Id. at 9. GAO defined net price as ``The actual amount a student
will need to pay to attend a particular college. This should be
estimated by subtracting gift aid (and not loans or work-study) from
the full cost of attendance (key direct and indirect costs)''. Id. at
6.
\10\Id. at 9.
\11\Id. at 36.
\12\E.g., The Leadership Conference, We Shall Not Be Moved A Policy
Agenda to Achieve the National Imperative of Racial Equity and
Diversity in Higher Education 52, Sept. 2024, https://civilrights.org/
wp-content/uploads/2024/09/WeShallNotBeMoved.pdf; Rachel Fishman, End
Surprise Bills in Higher Education, New America, Oct. 9, 2025, https://
www.newamerica.org/education-policy/edcentral/ending-surprise-bills-in-
higher-education/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6502 ATTEMPTS TO IMPROVE FINANCIAL AID OFFERS
H.R. 6502 partially addresses the need for standardization
and clarity in the financial aid offer letter process.
Specifically, the bill would require the Secretary of Education
to develop best practices and standards that institutions must
adopt in formatting their financial aid offer letters. As part
of their financial aid offer, institutions would be required to
include two standardized measures of estimated costs to the
student for the award year the offer covers. The first,
required costs, include tuition, fees, and room and board when
the institution requires these services be purchased through
the institution. The second cost metric institutions would be
required to provide students is the total cost of attendance,
the sum of the required costs and other costs such as
transportation, books, and supplies not typically billed
directly by the institution.
H.R. 6502 would also require offer letters to list any
grants and scholarships awarded to the student both for the
award year the offer covers, and total length of the student's
program of study. The bill mandates inclusion of loan
information for each loan that a student is eligible for, and
student employment options (e.g., federal work-study or state
work-study programs). As most students now view their offer
letters online, the bill requires the letters to include a link
to the universal net price calculator to help students and
families compare college costs across institutions. Finally,
the bill requires financial aid offer letters to also include
four program-level cost metrics based on information from the
most recent award year: (1) average annual net price required
for completion, (2) total average net price required for
completion, (3) average annual price of attendance, and (4)
total average annual net price of attendance.
The requirements in H.R. 6502 represent an effort to bring
some transparency into college costs and financial aid. By
requiring institutions to present information on the cost of
attendance, net price, itemized information on grants and
scholarships, loans, and work-study using consistent formatting
requirements, this bill would mandate some clarity and
standardization where none currently exists. However, the bill
does not go far enough in terms of standardization to be the
true tool students and their families could rely on to make
their college decisions. Conversely, the bill arguably adds too
many data points of dubious value to the letter. The result is
a bill that sews as much confusion in the offer letter process
as it attempts to remove with standardization.
H.R. 6502 CREATES MORE CONFUSION IN EXAMINING AND COMPARING FINANCIAL
AID OFFERS
H.R. 6502 falls short of providing uniform financial aid
offers across institutions. While the bill requires specific
formatting requirements, it simultaneously allows for
variations in how institutions lay out and design their
financial aid offers, variation we know already creates
confusion when students compare aid offers.\13\ Unfortunately,
despite the bill's standardization requirements, H.R. 6502 does
not solve the problem that colleges and universities display
financial aid offers in different ways, which will impede
students' ability to compare college costs and aid
information.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See Burd et al., supra note 3 at 7 (``Without guidelines, like
federally-required nutrition labels or the window sticker for car
sales, the consumer is left without an apples-to-apples comparison for
a major financial decision.''). See Nesbit, supra note 6 (decrying how
even with standardized terms non-standardized layout can make comparing
offers confusing) (``Create a spreadsheet to compare the net cost of
different colleges side by side. Some financial aid letters will make
this information easier to find than others. You may have to dig around
on the college website.'') (emphasis added).
\14\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In that sense, H.R. 5602 is a revision from the
standardization mandate the Majority championed just last year.
Since the 116th Congress, there has been bipartisan Committee
support for the Understanding the True Cost of College Act, a
bill that takes a more proscriptive approach in both the design
and requirements of financial aid award letters.\15\ In the
118th Congress, Republicans passed out of Committee the College
Cost Reduction Act (CCRA), which incorporated an updated
version of the Understanding the True Cost of College Act. This
updated version would actually require the Secretary to develop
the form schools would use as the basis of their offer
letters.\16\ Committee Democrats did not support the passage of
CCRA, but in Minority Views accompanying the bill's Committee
report expressed support for ``creating a standardized
financial aid form to provide students and families with more
clarity on college costs.''\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\H.R. 3153, 119th Cong. (2025) (``The Secretary of Education, in
consultation with the heads of relevant Federal agencies, shall develop
standard terminology and a standard form for financial aid offers. . .
.). Language mandating Secretarially developed ``similar formatting''
can be found in H.R. 1198, 118th Cong. (2023), H.R. 6002, 117th Cong.
(2021), & H.R. 2321, 116th Cong. (2019).
\16\Understanding the True Cost of College Act, H.R. 1198, 118th
Cong. (2023); College Cost Reduction Act, H.R. 6951, 118th Cong.
Sec. 111 (2024).
\17\ H.R. Rep. No. 118-739 at 383 (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6502 DOES NOT INCLUDE ADEQUATE INFORMATION ON
INDIRECT COSTS
H.R. 6502 creates several defined metrics related to a
student's estimated net price, aimed at helping students
understand how much they may pay for college after accounting
for grants and scholarships. However, the bill's multiple net
price definitions will make it very confusing for prospective
students to actually estimate their cost of attendance.
Specifically, the bill defines the following new terms: total
net price required for completion; annual net price required
for completion; total net price of attendance; and annual net
price of attendance. None of these net price estimates paint a
full picture of cost of attendance beyond tuition and fees.
The bill defines total net price required for completion as
the difference between required costs charged a student and the
amount of grant aid available to the student. By using this
definition, students are only able to estimate how much they
will pay for tuition and fees, and, if mandated by their
institution, on-campus housing and dining services fees. This
means that students who plan on living on campus will be unable
to fully evaluate an adequate net price for institutions that
offer, but do not require, on-campus housing or meal plans. But
the bill also defines total net price of attendance, calculated
as the sum of the total net price required for completion and
indirect costs. As defined in H.R. 6502, the net price of
completion metric does not adequately take into consideration
``indirect costs'' that arise for college students, which calls
into question its value for students. Indirect costs include
necessities such as transportation, housing, technology, and
other costs, all of which students must bear to fully access
and complete their coursework.\18\ For example, without having
funds to access stable housing as they matriculate, a student
cannot be expected to adequately tend to their studies.
Therefore, the total net price required for completion metric
does not paint the full picture of cost of attendance and its
inclusion makes it harder for students to make ``apples-to-
apples'' comparisons between various colleges.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Planning for Indirect Costs, uAspire (last visited Jan. 5,
2026), https://www.uaspire.org/getattachment/57ed37ef-7ea9-4521-8c41-
39f4494e169c/FY25-Planning-for-Indirect-
Expenses.pdf?lang=en-US.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A stronger metric to incorporate in the bill for purposes
of the calculations of net price for completion would be the
cost of attendance. The cost of attendance is typically known
as the full price to attend an institution that more seamlessly
incorporates both direct costs and indirect costs. In a 2022
report, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) found
that most colleges and universities do not provide students
with all the information necessary to help students clearly
understand their financial aid offers.\19\ GAO reported that
approximately 55 percent of institutions do not provide a total
cost of attendance that include key direct and indirect costs
for students.\20\ GAO also found that an estimated 91 percent
of institutions do not include or understate the net price,
including both direct and indirect costs,\21\ in their
financial aid offers.\22\ As a result of these findings, GAO
recommended federal lawmakers to take up legislation to mandate
institutions of higher education to follow best practices for
providing students with clear and standard financial aid
offers. Thus, to improve the financial aid offer letters,
Congress must include better information on indirect costs and
incorporate these costs into the standardized components of aid
offer letters. Specifically, Committee Democrats strongly
suggest defining any definition of ``net price'' as one that
shows the difference between the cost of attendance and grant
aid and requiring the consumer testing of all definitions that
will be presented to students on an aid offer letter to
determine if they provide clarity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\U.S. Gov't Accountability Off., GAO-23-104708, Financial Aid
Offers: Action Needed to Improve Information on College Costs and
Student Aid (Nov. 2022), https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-104708.pdf.
\20\Id. GAO defined direct costs as ``Costs that are typically
billed directly by the college. Examples include tuition, fees, and on-
campus housing and meals.'' It defined indirect costs as ``Costs that
students pay to other parties throughout the academic term. Examples
include books, academic supplies, off-campus housing and meals, and
other miscellaneous expenses, such as transportation.''.
\21\GAO defined net price as ``The actual amount a student will
need to pay to attend a particular college. This should be estimated by
subtracting gift aid (and not loans or work-study) from the full cost
of attendance (key direct and indirect costs)''.
\22\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on the limited standardization between offers
mandated in this bill, and the proliferation of metrics that
could inhibit students and families from making informed
decisions, Committee Democrats recommend that H.R. 6502
integrate language from the Understanding the True Cost of
College Act\23\, as it was incorporated into the College Cost
Reduction Act\24\ last Congress. This would improve
transparency and comparability by requiring a uniform format
for financial aid offers with consistent terminology and a
clear presentation of key cost components. Replacing the
formatting requirements under H.R. 6502 and integrating the
standards found in Understanding the True Cost of College Act
and the College Cost Reduction Act that would fully standardize
aid offers, helping students and families effectively compare
aid offers and make better informed decisions about college
costs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\H.R. 3153, 119th Cong., (2025) https://www.congress.gov/bill/
119th-congress/house-bill/3153.
\24\H.R. 6951, Sec. 111, 118th Cong., (2024) https://
www.congress.gov/118/bills/hr6951/BILLS-118hr6951rh.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM-LEVEL METRICS ARE BEYOND THE SCOPE OF
FINANCIAL AID OFFERS
The program-level metrics required in financial aid offers
by H.R. 6502, such as the average net price of attendance and
the average net price of completion, go beyond what is
necessary for helping students and families understand
financial aid offers. Though Committee Democrats recognize that
program-level metrics are imp