Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 6498]
The Committee on Education and Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 6498) to amend the Higher Education Act
of 1965 to increase transparency in college tuition for
consumers, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that
the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Student Financial Clarity Act of
2025''.
SEC. 2. TRANSPARENCY IN COLLEGE TUITION FOR CONSUMERS.
(a) Amendment.--Section 132 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20
U.S.C. 1015a) is amended by striking subsections (a) through (j) and
inserting the following:
``(a) Definitions.--In this section:
``(1) College scorecard website.--The term `College Scorecard
website' means the College Scorecard website required under
subsection (b) and includes any successor website.
``(2) Cost of attendance.--The term `cost of attendance' has
the meaning given such term in section 472(a).
``(3) Required costs.--The term `required costs' means the
sum of all the items listed in section 472(a) that are required
by an institution of higher education for a program of study
for the program length of a program of study, for the time to
credential for a student, or for an award year of a program of
study, as applicable, including--
``(A) the tuition and fees normally assessed a
student enrolled in such program of study carrying the
same academic workload, as determined by the
institution; and
``(B) in a case in which the institution requires a
student to reside in institutionally owned or operated
housing or to use institutionally owned or operated
food services, the applicable standard allowance for
such housing or food services determined by the
institution in accordance with section 472(a)(5).
``(4) Amount of grant and scholarship aid.--The term `amount
of grant and scholarship aid' means the sum of all of the grant
and scholarship aid that is available to the student for the
program length of a program of study, for the time to
credential for a student, or for an award year of a program of
study, as applicable, that a student does not have to repay,
including need-based, merit-based, or athletic-based, or
another type of grant and scholarship aid, that is--
``(A) offered under title IV;
``(B) offered through other Federal programs;
``(C) offered by the institution;
``(D) offered by a State; or
``(E) offered by any other source.
``(5) Net price required for completion.--
``(A) Total net price required for completion.--The
term `total net price required for completion' means,
with respect to a student in a program of study--
``(i) the required costs charged to such
student for the program of study for the time
to credential; minus
``(ii) the amount of grant and scholarship
aid that is available to the student for such
program for the time to credential.
``(B) Annual net price required for completion.--The
term `annual net price required for completion' means,
with respect to a student in a program of study--
``(i) the required costs charged to such
student for the program of study for an award
year; minus
``(ii) the amount of grant and scholarship
aid that is available to the student for such
program for such award year.
``(6) Net price of attendance.--
``(A) Total net price of attendance.--The term `total
net price of attendance' means, with respect to a
student in a program of study, the sum of--
``(i) the total net price required for
completion; and
``(ii) the sum, for the time to credential,
of all the costs listed in section 472(a) that
are not required costs.
``(B) Annual net price of attendance.--The term
`annual net price of attendance' means, with respect to
a student in a program of study, the net price of
attendance for a specific year of the program of study,
determined by disaggregating the total net price of
attendance for the student by each year of the
student's time to credential.
``(7) Program length.--The term `program length' means the
minimum amount of time in weeks, months, or years that is
specified in the catalog, marketing materials, or other
official publications of an institution of higher education for
a full-time student to complete the requirements to obtain the
degree or credential awarded for a specific program of study.
``(8) Time to credential.--The term `time to credential'
means, with respect to a student, the actual amount of time in
weeks, months, or years it takes the student to complete the
requirements to obtain the degree or credential awarded for a
specific program of study.
``(b) Consumer Information.--
``(1) Availability of information for title iv institutions
and programs.--Not later than 18 months after the effective
date of this subsection, the Secretary shall make publicly
available on the College Scorecard website the following
information with respect to students of the institution who
have received Federal financial assistance described in
paragraph (2)(I), for the most recent award year for which such
information is available:
``(A) Institutions.--With respect to each institution
of higher education that participates in a program
under title IV, the following:
``(i) A link to the website of the
institution.
``(ii) A link to the Universal Net Price
calculator described in subsection (c) and, if
applicable, a link to any net price calculator
developed by the institution in accordance with
paragraph (7) of such subsection.
``(iii) Information on the type of
institution, including predominant and highest
credential awarded, research intensity, and
programs of study offered.
``(iv) In the case of an institution that
requires scores for a college entrance
examination (such as the SAT or ACT) to be
submitted, data on such submitted scores.
``(v) The acceptance rate, determined by
calculating the percentage of individuals who
submitted a completed application to the
institution who were accepted for enrollment.
``(vi) The institution's cohort default rate,
as defined under section 435(m).
``(vii) A link to the website of the
institution containing the information on
campus safety required to be collected under
section 485(i).
``(B) Institutions and programs of study.--With
respect to each such institution and to each program of
study at each such institution, the following:
``(i) The geographic location.
``(ii) Information on student enrollment,
including the number and percentage of students
enrolled full-time, less than full-time, and
enrolled in distance education.
``(iii) Information on the number of degree-
or certificate-seeking undergraduate students
who have transferred from another institution.
``(iv) Information on student progression and
completion, including time to credential and
rates of withdrawal, retention, transfer, or
completion.
``(v) Information on college costs and
financial aid, including--
``(I) the average, median, minimum,
and maximum values of--
``(aa) the required costs for
such award year (determined for
an institution based on the
required costs for all programs
of study);
``(bb) the cost of attendance
for such award year (determined
for an institution based on the
cost of attendance for all
programs of study);
``(cc) the amount of grant
and scholarship aid received by
students for such award year
(determined for an institution
based on the amount of grant
and scholarship aid received by
students for all programs of
study);
``(dd) the information
described in item (cc) and
subclause (II)(cc),
disaggregated--
``(AA) by the type of
source described in
subparagraphs (A)
through (E) of
subsection (a)(4); and
``(BB) by whether
such aid is need-based,
merit-based, or
athletic-based, or is
another type of aid;
``(II) with respect to students who
completed a credential during the most
recent award year, the average, median,
minimum, and maximum values of--
``(aa) the program length
(determined for an institution
based on the program length for
all programs of study);
``(bb) the time to credential
(determined for an institution
based on the time to credential
for all programs of study);
``(cc) the amount of grant
and scholarship aid received
for the time to credential
(determined for an institution
based on the amount of grant
and scholarship aid received by
students for all programs of
study);
``(dd) the total net price
required for completion
(determined for an institution
based on the total net price
required for completion for all
programs of study); and
``(ee) the total net price
required for attendance
(determined for an institution
based on the total net price
required for attendance for all
programs of study);
``(III) the number and percentage of
students receiving any amount of grant
and scholarship aid for such award
year, and with respect to students who
completed a credential during the most
recent award year, the number and
percentage of such students receiving
any amount of grant and scholarship aid
for the time to credential;
``(IV) the average annual percentage
change and average annual dollar change
in the required costs for each of the
three most recent academic years for
which data are available; and
``(V) the average annual percentage
change and average annual dollar change
in the total and annual net price
required for completion for each of the
three most recent academic years for
which data are available.
``(vi) Information on student debt and
repayment, including--
``(I) the average, median, minimum,
and maximum amounts borrowed by
students under title IV;
``(II) information with respect to
repayment of loans made under title IV,
including borrower-based repayment
rates, dollar-based repayment rates,
and time spent in repayment; and
``(III) the number and percentage of
students who--
``(aa) are borrowers of a
loan made under title IV;
``(bb) are not borrowers of a
loan made under title IV, but
have at least one parent who is
a borrower of a loan made under
title IV on behalf of the
student; and
``(cc) are borrowers of a
loan made under title IV, and
have at least one parent who is
a borrower of a loan made under
title IV on behalf of the
student.
``(vii) Information on the earnings of
students, including the average, median,
minimum, and maximum values of--
``(I) with respect to students who
complete a program of study in the most
recent award year for which data are
available--
``(aa) the annual earnings of
such students; and
``(bb) the value-added
earnings (as defined in section
481(b)(3)(A)(iv)) of such
students; and
``(II) the annual earnings of
students who were enrolled in a program
of study at the institution during the
most recent award year for which data
are available, and who at the time the
information is reported--
``(aa) have not completed
such program of study; and
``(bb) are not enrolled at
the institution in any program
of study.
``(C) Programs of study.--With respect to each
program of study at each such institution, the
credential awarded for completion of the program of
study.
``(2) Disaggregated information.--The Secretary shall ensure
the information described in paragraph (1) is disaggregated, as
applicable, by the following student characteristics:
``(A) Financial circumstances including--
``(i) household income categories, as
determined by students' and families' adjusted
gross income; and
``(ii) student aid index categories, as
determined by the Secretary.
``(B) Sex.
``(C) Race and ethnicity.
``(D) Classification as a student with a disability.
``(E) Enrollment status, including part-time or full-
time enrollment, and status as a distance education
student.
``(F) Status as a first year, second year, third
year, or subsequent year student, based on the number
of years a student has been enrolled at the institution
Committee Action
113TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On April 24, 2013, the Subcommittee on Higher Education and
Workforce Training held a hearing on ``Keeping College Within
Reach: Enhancing Transparency for Students, Families, and
Taxpayers.'' The hearing examined efforts to improve higher
education transparency, including tools like the College
Navigator and College Scorecard, and challenges students face
in navigating postsecondary options. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Dr. Donald Heller, Dean, College of
Education, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI; Mr.
Alex Garrido, Student, Keiser University, Miami, FL; Dr. Nicole
Farmer Hurd, Founder and Executive Director, National College
Advising Corps, Carrboro, NC; and Mr. Travis Reindl, Program
Director, Postsecondary Education, National Governors
Association Center for Best Practices, Washington, D.C.
On November 13, 2013, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Keeping College Within Reach:
Simplifying Federal Student Aid.'' The purpose of the hearing
was to examine the need to streamline, consolidate, and
simplify federal student aid programs. Testifying before the
Committee were Ms. Kristin D. Conklin, Founding Partner, HCM
Strategies, LLC, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Sandy Baum, Research
Professor of Education Policy, George Washington University
Graduate School of Education and Human Development, and Senior
Fellow, Urban Institute, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Jennifer
Mishory, J.D., Deputy Director, Young Invincibles, Washington,
D.C.; and Mr. Jason Delisle, Director, Federal Education Budget
Project, New America Foundation, Washington, D.C.
118TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On April 10, 2024, the Subcommittee on Higher Education and
Workforce Development held a hearing on ``FAFSA Fail: Examining
the Impact on Students, Families, and Schools.'' The purpose of
the hearing was to assess the causes and impacts of the failed
FAFSA rollout, including the effects of delays and data
inaccuracies on students and postsecondary institutions.
Testifying before the Subcommittee were Mr. Mark Kantrowitz,
President, Cerebly, Inc, York, Skokie, IL; Dr. Justin Draeger,
President & CEO, National Association of Student Financial Aid
Administrators, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Kim Cook, CEO, National
College Attainment Network, Washington, D.C.; and Ms. Rachelle
Feldman, Vice Provost, Enrollment, University of North Carolina
Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC.
On September 24, 2024, the Subcommittee on Higher Education
and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``GAO Uncovers
Biden-Harris FAFSA Failures.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to review data and findings from the Government Accountability
Office (GAO) on the Department of Education's implementation of
the new FAFSA, with a focus on timelines, technical challenges,
and transparency and communication with students, institutions,
and taxpayers. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Ms.
Melissa Emrey-Arras, Director, Education, Workforce, and Income
Security Issues, GAO, Washington, D.C.; and Mrs. Marisol Cruz
Cain, Director, Information Technology and Cybersecurity Team,
GAO, Washington D.C.
Legislative Action
On January 11, 2024, then-Chairwoman Virginia Foxx
introduced H.R. 6951, the College Cost Reduction Act, with
original co-sponsors Representatives Burgess Owens (R-UT),
Glenn Grothman (R-WI), Rick W. Allen (R-GA), Lloyd Smucker (R-
PA), Lisa McClain (R-MI), Michelle Steel (R-CA), and Brandon
Williams (R-NY). On January 31, 2024, the Committee considered
H.R. 6951 in a legislative session and reported it favorably,
as amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote
of 22-19. The Committee considered the following amendments to
H.R. 6951:
1. Representative Owens offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute that made technical changes to
the text. The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
2. Representative Jahana Hayes (D-CT) offered an
amendment to increase the total maximum Pell Grant
amount awarded during the 2025-2026 award year from
$7,395 to $10,000 and increase it incrementally
thereafter. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
3. Representative Hayes offered an amendment to
strike the bill's accreditation provisions. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #2, which
failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
4. Representative Hayes offered an amendment to
provide federal student loan forgiveness for teachers.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #3,
which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
5. Representative Haley Stevens (D-MI) offered an
amendment to make post baccalaureate students eligible
to receive a Pell Grant. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote
of 17-22.
6. Representative Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) offered an
amendment to increase the total number of semesters a
student can be eligible for Pell Grants from 12 to 18.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1,
which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
7. Representative Joe Courtney (D-CT) offered an
amendment to expand the Public Service Loan Forgiveness
program. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
8. Representative Frederica Wilson (D-FL) offered an
amendment to allow graduate or professional students to
be eligible to receive a federal Direct Stafford Loan,
excluding graduate medical school, nursing school,
veterinary school, or a school located outside the U.S.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1,
which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
8. Representative Stevens offered an amendment to
stipulate that nothing under the bill can be construed
to prevent graduate students from exercising collective
bargaining rights under the National Labor Relations
Act. The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc
#2, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
9. Representative Wilson offered an amendment to
strike a provision to repeal regulations related to
financial value transparency and gainful employment and
stipulate that the Department of Education (Department)
would not be permitted to promulgate or enforce any
regulation or rules related to the application of the
term ``gainful employment.'' The amendment was included
in amendment En Bloc #4, which failed by a roll call
vote of 19-22.
10. Ranking Member Bobby Scott (D-VA) offered an
amendment to establish an interest rate equal to the
high yield of the 10-year Treasury note auctioned at
the final auction prior to June 1, 2025, or 5 percent
for new federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford loans,
federal Direct Stafford loans, and federal Direct PLUS
loans issued on or after July 1, 2025. The amendment
also established a new rate for any federal Direct
Consolidation Loan. The amendment also authorized the
Department to establish programs to refinance federal
Direct Loans and eligible private education loans. The
amendment also established guidelines for determining
the interest rate for refinanced loans through both
programs, which would have been fixed. The amendment
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
11. Representative Teresa Leger Fernandez (D-NM)
offered an amendment to direct the Department, in
consultation with the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau, Financial Literacy and Education Commission,
and Internal Revenue Service (IRS), to establish a
personal finance education portal on a centralized and
publicly available Department website for federal
financial aid. Representative Leger Fernandez
subsequently withdrew the amendment.
12. Representative Leger Fernandez offered an
amendment to authorize the Department to award grants
for tuition-free community college to eligible states
and tribal colleges and universities. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
13. Representative Mark Takano (D-CA) offered an
amendment to strike a provision to repeal the 90/10
regulation that caps the percentage of revenue that a
for-profit school can receive from federal financial
aid sources at 90 percent and stipulate that the other
10 percent of revenue must come from alternative
sources. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of
19-22.
14. Representative Takano offered an amendment to add
language to stipulate that the bill's provisions would
not take effect until the inspectors general of the
Departments of Education and Veterans Affairs submit a
report to Congress certifying that the bill would not
result in fraud or abuse of veteran students. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
15. Representative Alma Adams (D-NC) offered an
amendment to stipulate that no claim from a federal
student loan could be collected by administrative
offset for any payments related to Social Security. It
applied to any payments made after the bill's
enactment. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of
19-22.
16. Representative Adams offered an amendment to
require the Department, a guaranty agency, or an
eligible loan holder to remove any adverse item of
information related to a loan from a borrower's credit
history upon the sale or assignment of a loan after the
loan is reported as being in default. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a
roll call vote of 18-22.
17. Delegate Gregorio Sablan (D-MP) offered an
amendment to establish a program to enable college-
bound residents of the Northern Mariana Islands and
American Samoa to have additional choices to attend
higher education institutions. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
18. Representative Lucy McBath (D-GA) offered an
amendment to strike a provision to repeal current
regulations related to closed school loan discharges.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4,
which failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
19. Representative Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR) offered an
amendment to add language to require colleges and
universities to accept Individualized Education
Programs under the Individuals with Disabilities
Education Act, or plans describing services or
accommodations provided to an individual with a
disability pursuant to Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as proper documentation for
disability accommodations. The amendment failed by a
roll call vote of 19-21.
20. Representative Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) offered an
amendment to strike a provision that would repeal
regulations related to borrower repayment defense. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
21. Representative Jayapal offered an amendment to
require the postsecondary student data system to
include data on applications received, students
accepted, and students placed on the wait list
disaggregated by race and ethnic subgroup at each
institution of higher education (IHE). The amendment
was included in amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
22. Representative Jayapal offered an amendment to
require the Department to adjust the median cost of
college for a program of study for institutions located
in a metropolitan area to account for the higher cost
of living. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
23. Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) offered an
amendment to strike a provision that stipulated that
the Department could not issue a proposed rule, final
regulation, or exhaustive action to carry out the
bill's provisions if it is determined that it would be
economically significant or result in a subsidy cost
increase. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
24. Representative Omar offered an amendment to
authorize a program for the Department to provide
grants for a period of 5 years to eligible IHEs to
provide childcare services for student parents. The
amendment failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
25. Representative Omar offered an amendment to
strike a provision that established annual limits on
federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford Loans, for any
period of instruction beginning on or after July 1,
2025, which would not exceed the cost of attendance for
an academic year. The amendment also struck the
establishment of maximum aggregate student loan amounts
professional, graduate, and undergraduate students
could receive through such loans. The amendment was
included in amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a
roll call vote of 18-22.
26. Representative Omar offered an amendment to
strike a provision that established two
repayment plans for federal loans made on or after
July 1, 2024, including a standard repayment plan with
a fixed monthly repayment amount paid over a fixed
period that does not exceed 10 years and a standard
repayment assistance plan under the income-driven
repayment program. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #3, which failed by a roll call vote
of 18-22.
27. Representative Jamaal Bowman (D-NY) offered an
amendment to stipulate that nothing in the bill could
be construed to require any accreditation agency or
association to promulgate a standard that would
prohibit IHEs from offering programs of study in any
academic subject. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #2, which failed by a roll call vote
of 18-22.
28. Representative Bowman offered an amendment to
prohibit IHEs from providing preferential treatment in
the admissions process for donors and alumni, effective
on the first day of the second award year after the
bill's enactment. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #2, which failed by a roll call vote
of 18-22.
29. Representative Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an
amendment to strike the amended definition of ``third-
party server,'' which referred to any individual,
state, or private for-profit or nonprofit organization
that enters into a contract with an IHE to administer
any student assistance programs under the bill. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
30. Representative Manning offered an amendment to
stipulate that nothing in the bill could be construed
to prevent an IHE from providing medically accurate and
comprehensive information about sexual and reproductive
health services, including contraception. The amendment
failed by a roll call vote of 20-21.
31. Ranking Member Scott offered an amendment to
strike a provision to prohibit the Department from
implementing any substantially similar rule,
regulation, policy or executive action related to
regulations repealed under the bill, including closed
school loan discharges, borrower repayment defense,
pre-dispute arbitration, false certification,
administrative capability, certification procedures,
ability to benefit, and personal liability. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On September 16, 2025, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on ``No More
Surprises: Reforming College Pricing for Students and
Families.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine ways to
make college costs more transparent. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Mr. Justin Draeger, Senior Vice President,
Affordability, Strada Education Foundation, Washington, D.C.;
Mr. Lee Wishing III, Vice President for Student Recruitment and
Chief Marketing Officer, Grove City College, Grove City, PA;
Ms. Amy Laitinen, Senior Director of Higher Education, New
America, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Andrew Gillen, Research
Fellow, Cato Institute, Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On December 9, 2025, Representative Brett Guthrie (R-KY)
introduced the Student Financial Aid Clarity Act of 2025 (H.R.
6498). The bill was referred solely to the Committee on
Education and Workforce. On December 11, 2025, the Committee
considered H.R. 6498 in legislative session and reported it
favorably, as amended, to the House of Representatives by a
recorded vote of 27-6.\1\ The Committee considered the
following amendments to H.R. 6498:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/6498/
all-actions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Representative Bob Onder (R-MO) offered an
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute that clarified
privacy protections for student data, including clearer
language around data collected through college entrance
exams. It also standardized how institutions calculate
and present costs, program length, time to credential,
and grant and scholarship aid across an award year,
while making technical updates for clarity and
consistency. The amendment passed by voice vote.
2. Representative Takano offered an amendment to
codify the Biden administration's Gainful Employment
regulation and financial value transparency regulations
for for-profit colleges. The amendment failed by a roll
call vote of 14-19.
3. Representative Bonamici offered an amendment to
prohibit the Secretary of Education from entering into
additional Interagency Agreements. The amendment failed
by a roll call vote of 14-19.
4. Representative Adams offered an amendment that
clarified that an individual'
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
As the cost of college continues to rise, increased
transparency of college costs is critical. Students and
families should have accurate, useful information to help them
navigate the college search process and ensure they are making
informed decisions. H.R. 6498, the Student Financial Clarity
Act amends the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) to codify the
College Scorecard and require the Secretary of Education to
develop a Universal Net Price Calculator to help students
compare estimated college costs. The Student Financial Clarity
Act has the potential to increase many students' ability to
make informed decisions for their postsecondary education.
However, Committee Democrats strongly urge Republicans to make
significant changes to this bill prior to its consideration in
the House to ensure it substantially improves transparency for
students, instead of making them more confused.
CONGRESS NEEDS TO IMPROVE THE COLLEGE SCORECARD AND NET
PRICE CALCULATORS
College Scorecard
The College Scorecard was established in 2015 under the
Obama Administration to serve as a tool to provide consumer
information on specific institutions of higher education.\1\
This new application of public data was the first attempt at
providing the general public a comprehensive review of student
outcomes and federal student aid trends across colleges. The
College Scorecard utilizes data reported to the Department of
Education (Department) through the Integrated Postsecondary
Data System (IPEDS), a data system run by the National Center
for Education Statistics (NCES) within the Department's
Institute of Education Sciences (IES). Although the Department
has continued to operate and update the College Scorecard since
its inception, the tool is not currently codified in the HEA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\College Scorecard, U.S. Dep't of Educ., https://
collegescorecard.ed.gov/; The New College Scorecard, Inside Higher Ed
(Sep. 13, 2015), https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2015/09/14/obama-
administration-publishes-new-college-earnings-loan-repayment-data.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After the launch of the College Scorecard, the Department
has continued to improve the quality and expand the types of
data on college costs and outcomes collected from colleges. As
more robust and disaggregated data was reported through the
College Scorecard, students gained a better sense of which
colleges were best suited to help them achieve their
postsecondary goals.
In 2022 and 2023, the Biden Administration made several
improvements to the College Scorecard aimed at increasing
outcomes and cost transparency. In February 2022, the College
Scorecard was updated to include:\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\IHEP Celebrates Updates to the College Scorecard to Better Equip
Students to Make Higher Ed Choices and Policymakers to Promote Equity-
Driven Policies, Inst. for Higher Educ. Pol. (Feb. 7, 2022), https://
www.ihep.org/press/ihep-celebrates-updates-to-the-college-scorecard-to-
better-equip-students-to-make-higher-education-choices-and-
policymakers-to-promote-equity-driven-policies/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Median earnings data at the institutional
level;
Median earnings data disaggregated by
income, gender and dependency status;
Share of former students earning more than a
typical high school graduate; and
Refreshed cumulative student loan debt data
by field of study.
In April 2023, additional College Scorecard changes were
made, including:\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Letter from the Postsecondary Data Collaborative to Former U.S.
Dep't of Educ. Sec'y Dr. Miguel Cardona (Feb. 23 2022), https://live-
ihep-wp.pantheonsite.io/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/2022_College-
Scorecard-updates.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Median earnings data at the institutional
and program level;
Median earnings data at the institutional
level;
Updated loan repayment rates at the
institutional and program level;
Race/ethnicity and gender data for college
staff and faculty;
Notice if a program of study is provided
entirely through distance education.
Higher education data experts applauded these additions as
big strides in transparency. These experts also emphasized that
additional improvements to the College Scorecard are still
needed ``to increase transparency and fill gaps in our
postsecondary data system so students can more easily find
high-value postsecondary programs that align with their goals,
and steer clear of programs that do not.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Updated College Scorecard Data Shed New Light on Student
Earnings, Borrower Repayment Outcomes, Campus Diversity, and More,
Inst. for Higher Edu. Pol. (May 15, 2023), https://www.ihep.org/
updated-college-scorecard-data-earnings-repayment-campus-diversity/;
Chazz Robinson, New Wins for the College Scorecard, Third Way (Jun. 14,
2023), https://www.thirdway.org/blog/new-wins-for-the-college-
scorecard.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net Price Calculators
Since 2011, the HEA has required colleges to provide
students with a net price calculator on the their websites as a
condition of receiving federal student aid.\5\ Net price
calculators estimate students' net price by sharing the net
prices of students with similar financial and academic
circumstances.\6\ Net price calculators take into account
grants and scholarships to provide a preliminary estimate of
out-of-pocket net price for one year of college.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\20 U.S.C. 1015a; Lucie Lapovsky, Designing a Net Price
Calculator (opinion), Inside Higher Ed (Mar. 3, 2011), https://
www.insidehighered.com/views/2011/03/04/designing-net-price-
calculator.
\6\For a database of all net price calculators, see https://
collegecost.ed.gov/net-price.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Currently, net price calculators require the student to
input the following student information to estimate their
Student Aid Index (SAI):\7\ student and family income;
dependency status; and estimated cost of attendance. Net price
calculators then provide the following estimates back to a
student for one year of college:\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\See IES Net Price Calculator Info Center at https://nces.ed.gov/
ipeds/report-your-data/
resource-center-net-price.
\8\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total cost of attendance;
Tuition and fees; room and board;
Books and supplies; other expenses (personal
expenses, transportation, etc.);
Total grant aid;
Net price;
Percent of the cohort (full-time, first-time
students) that received grant aid; and
Various disclaimers and caveats required by
the HEA.
Students typically use these calculators early in their
college search process and prior to completing the Free
Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) form to start
comparing potential costs. However, a student's cost of
attendance is not finalized until they submit a FAFSA and a
college provides a formal financial aid award letter. While net
price calculators are helpful as currently devised, there have
been calls for the calculators to better estimate the full cost
of attendance, account for indirect costs, and differentiate
between merit grants, need-based grants, and the various loan
types.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Monica Maldonado, How Net Price Calculators Can Better Serve
Students, Inst. for Higher Educ. Pol. (Oct. 23, 2019), https://
www.ihep.org/how-net-price-calculators-can-better-serve-
students/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the 116th Congress, the bipartisan Net Price Calculator
Improvement Act was incorporated into the College Affordability
Act, comprehensive legislation to reauthorize the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (HEA) which was reported out of Committee
along party lines.\10\ The Net Price Calculator Improvement Act
would have made changes to the required estimates produced by
colleges' net price calculators and would have allowed the
Department to establish a Universal Net Price Calculator. In
the 118th Congress, Republicans passed out of Committee the
College Cost Reduction Act (CCRA), which incorporated an
updated version of the Net Price Calculator Improvement Act.
This updated version would actually require--not simply allow--
the Department to develop a Universal Net Price Calculator
within the College Scorecard, in addition to making several
changes to the College Scorecard's required data.\11\ Committee
Democrats did not support the passage of CCRA, but did express
support for this provision and suggested it ``could form the
basis of legislation with a viable chance of passage into
law.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Net Price Calculator Improvement Act, H.R. 1915, 116th Cong.
(2019); College Affordability Act, H.R. 4674, 116th Cong. Sec. 1021
(2019).
\11\Net Price Calculator Improvement Act, H.R. 1214, 118th Cong.
(2023); College Cost Reduction Act, H.R. 6951, 118th Cong. Sec. 112
(2024).
\12\H.R. Rep. No. 118-739 at 383 (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6498 ATTEMPTS TO IMPROVE BROKEN COLLEGE SCORECARD
H.R. 6498 partially addresses the need to improve the
College Scorecard and enhance net price calculators. The bill
codifies the College Scorecard and adds required consumer
information on both the College Scorecard and a newly
established Universal Net Price Calculator. Specifically, it
requires the Secretary to display and annually update on the
College Scorecard institutional information and data on
programs of study, disaggregated to the extent privacy laws
allow. This would include information on student enrollment,
progression and completion, college costs and financial aid,
student debt and repayment, and post-program earnings, among
other things. The bill also requires that the College Scorecard
provide users with the ability to compare such information
between institutions. H.R. 6498 also requires the Secretary to
establish a Universal Net Price Calculator that allows
individuals to compare the costs of both institutions and
programs of study along with allowing providing individuals
with various estimated net prices for completion based on self-
identified similarly situated students. Like the College
Scorecard, the bill mandates the Universal Net Price Calculator
be updated annually. Unlike the current system which allows
individual institutions to decide what information goes into
their unique net price calculators, this bill's framework
seemingly aims to set up a one-stop-shop for students to
compare institutions with standardized and streamlined metrics.
H.R. 6498 requires the Secretary to conduct regular consumer
testing to help improve the usefulness and relevance of both
products.
While Committee Democrats have typically been supportive of
codifying and making improvements to the College Scorecard and
creating the Universal Net Price Calculator, there are several
concerns, outlined in these views, which make it difficult to
believe this legislation could be successfully implemented if
enacted as drafted. Several--but not all--of these concerns
could be addressed by reverting to a framework for the College
Scorecard and Net Price Calculator changes contain within the
Republican-led CCRA that the Committee considered last
Congress.
H.R. 6498 DOES NOT INCLUDE ADEQUATE INFORMATION ON INDIRECT
COSTS
H.R. 6498 creates several defined metrics related to a
student's estimated net price, aimed at helping students
understand how much they may pay for college after accounting
for grants and scholarships. However, the bill's multiple net
price definitions will make it very confusing for prospective
students to actually estimate their cost of attendance.
Specifically, the bill defines the following new terms: total
net price required for completion; annual net price required
for completion; total net price of attendance; and annual net
price of attendance. None of these net price estimates paint a
full picture of cost of attendance beyond tuition and fees.
The bill defines total net price required for completion as
the difference between required costs charged a student and the
amount of grant aid available to the student. By using this
definition, students are only able to estimate how much they
will pay for tuition and fees, and, if mandated by their
institution, on-campus housing and dining services fees. This
means that students who plan on living on campus will be unable
to fully evaluate an adequate net price for institutions that
offer, but do not require, on-campus housing or meal plans.
But, the bill also defines total net price of attendance,
calculated as the sum of the total net price required for
completion and indirect costs. As defined in H.R. 6498, the net
price of completion metric does not adequately take into
consideration ``indirect costs'' that arise for college
students, which calls into question its value for students.
Indirect costs include necessities such as transportation,
housing, technology, and other costs, all of which students
must bear to fully access and complete their coursework.\13\
For example, without having funds to access stable housing as
they matriculate, a student cannot be expected to adequately
tend to their studies. Therefore, the total net price required
for completion metric does not paint the full picture of cost
of attendance and its inclusion makes it harder for students to
make ``apples-to-apples'' comparisons between various colleges.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Planning for Indirect Costs, uAspire (last visited Jan. 5,
2026), https://www.uaspire.org/getattachment/57ed37ef-7ea9-4521-8c41-
39f4494e169c/FY25-Planning-for-Indirect-Expenses.pdf?lang=en-US.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A stronger metric to incorporate in the bill for purposes
of the calculations of net price for completion would be the
cost of attendance. The cost of attendance is typically known
as the full price to attend an institution that more seamlessly
incorporates both direct costs and indirect costs. In a 2022
report, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) found
that most colleges and universities do not provide students
with all the information necessary to help students clearly
understand their financial aid offers.\14\ GAO reported that
approximately 55 percent of institutions do not provide a total
cost of attendance that include key direct and indirect costs
for students.\15\ GAO also found that an estimated 91 percent
of institutions do not include or understate the net price,
including both direct and indirect costs,\16\ in their
financial aid offers.\17\ As a result of these findings, GAO
recommended federal lawmakers to take up legislation to mandate
institutions of higher education to follow best practices for
providing students with clear and standard financial aid
offers. Thus, to improve the College Scorecard and the proposed
Universal Net Price Calculator, Congress must include better
information on indirect costs and incorporate these costs into
the estimates published by the Universal Net Price Calculator.
Specifically, Committee Democrats strongly suggest defining any
definition of ``net price'' as one that shows the difference
between the cost of attendance and grant aid and requiring the
consumer testing of all definitions that will be presented to
students on a net price calculator to determine if they provide
clarity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\U.S. Gov't Accountability Off., GAO-23-104708, Financial Aid
Offers: Action Needed to Improve Information on College Costs and
Student Aid (Nov. 2022), https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-104708.pdf.
\15\Id. GAO defined direct costs as ``Costs that are typically
billed directly by the college. Examples include tuition, fees, and on-
campus housing and meals.'' It defined indirect costs as ``Costs that
students pay to other parties throughout the academic term. Examples
include books, academic supplies, off-campus housing and meals, and
other miscellaneous expenses, such as transportation.''
\16\GAO defined net price as ``The actual amount a student will
need to pay to attend a particular college. This should be estimated by
subtracting gift aid (and not loans or work-study) from the full cost
of attendance (key direct and indirect costs).''
\17\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6498 DATA DOES NOT INCLUDE ALL STUDENTS
H.R. 6498 requires the College Scorecard to include various
data aggregated at the institutional and program levels,
including but not limited to information on college entrance
exams, acceptance rates, retention and completion rates,
college costs, student debt, and post-graduate earnings.
Regrettably, the bill only requires institutions to report this
information for students who have received Federal financial
assistance, specifically tuition assistance from programs
administered by the Departments of Education, Labor, Defense,
or Veterans Affairs. The data of students who do not receive
such funds is not included in these statistical samples.
Committee Democrats are disappointed this legislation does
not include data for all students who are enrolled in
postsecondary education. Currently, roughly one third of
undergraduate students are not represented in College Scorecard
data because they do not receive federal student aid.\18\
Further, when the Committee considered a similar policy in the
118th Congress, the American Association of Community Colleges
estimated that more than half of all community college students
enrolled in credit-bearing coursework would not be included in
the aggregate data.\19\ This makes this data much less reliable
for students interested in community college, and policymakers
trying to analyze how this population is performing. If
Congress is going to reform higher education data, this
information gap is unacceptable. All students, not just those
receiving federal assistance, deserve reliable and accurate
cost estimates and representative information. Incomplete,
nonrepresentative data is not sufficient for students to make
informed choices, and it is harder for policymakers to address
any equity gaps that data could show.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\The analysis found that 72 pe