Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On April 19, 2023, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``Examining Biden's War on
Independent Contractors,'' which discussed independent
contractors and worker classification under the FLSA, including
classification of real estate agents and direct sellers. The
witnesses were Ms. Karen Anderson, Founder, Freelancers Against
AB 5, Dana Point, CA; Ms. Tammy McCutchen, Senior Affiliate,
Resolution Economics, New Market, TN; Mr. David Long, Chief
Executive Officer, National Electrical Contractors Association,
Washington, DC; Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow,
Mercatus Center at George Mason University, Arlington, VA; Ms.
Laura Padin, Director of Work Structures, National Employment
Law Project, Washington, DC; and Ms. Kim Kavin, Freelance
Writer and Editor, Morris County, NJ.
Second Session--Hearing
On February 14, 2024, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and
Priorities of the Wage and Hour Division,'' which discussed the
U.S. Department of Labor's (DOL) wage-and-hour priorities,
including the lack of clarity in worker classification for
direct sellers, real estate agents, and other independent
contractors. The sole witness was the Honorable Jessica Looman,
Administrator, Wage and Hour Division, DOL.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On February 26, 2025, the Committee on Education and
Workforce held a hearing titled ``Unleashing America's
Workforce and Strengthening our Economy,'' which addressed,
among other topics, the shortcomings of the Biden
administration's independent contractor rule on worker
classification under the FLSA and on potential regulatory
solutions. Witnesses were Ms. Rosanna Maietta, President and
CEO, American Hotel and Lodging Association, Washington, DC;
Dr. William Beach, Senior Fellow in Economics, Economic Policy
Innovation Center, Arlington, VA; Dr. Heidi Shierholz,
President, Economic Policy Institute, Washington, DC; and Ms.
Elizabeth Milito, Vice President and Executive Director, NFIB
Small Business Legal Center, Washington, DC.
On March 25, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``The Future of Wage Laws:
Assessing the FLSA's Effectiveness, Challenges, and
Opportunities,'' which discussed, among other topics,
independent contractors and worker classification under the
FLSA. Witnesses were Ms. Tammy McCutchen, Senior Affiliate,
Resolution Economics, New Market, TN; Ms. Pagie Boughan, Senior
Vice President and Director of Human Resources, Farmers and
Merchants Bank, Hampstead, MD, on behalf of the Society for
Human Resource Management (SHRM); Mr. Andrew Stettner, Director
of Economy and Jobs, The Century Foundation, New York, NY; and
Mr. Jonathan Wolfson, Chief Legal Officer and Policy Director,
Cicero Institute, Austin, TX.
On May 20, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce Protections
held a hearing titled ``Empowering the Modern Worker,'' which
discussed worker classification under the FLSA and challenges
faced by independent contractors. The National Association of
Realtors submitted a statement for the record making clear that
real estate professional should be treated as independent
contractors under federal labor laws. Witnesses were Mr. Nathan
Mehrens, Vice President of Workforce Policy, American Trucking
Associations, Washington, DC; Ms. Kim Kavin, Freelance Writer
and Editor, Morris County, NJ; Ms. Laura Padin, Director of
Work Structures, National Employment Law Project, New York, NY;
and Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow, Mercatus
Center at George Mason University, Arlington, VA.
On June 5, 2025, the Committee on Education and Workforce
held a hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities
of the Department of Labor,'' which included discussion of
worker classification and independent contractors. The sole
witness at the hearing was the Honorable Lori Chavez-Deremer,
Secretary, DOL.
Legislative Action
On May 19, 2025, Representative Kevin Kiley (R-CA)
introduced H.R. 3495, the Direct Seller and Real Estate Agent
Harmonization Act, with Representative Henry Cuellar (D-TX) as
an original cosponsor. The bill was referred solely to the
Committee on Education and Workforce. On September 17, 2025,
the Committee considered H.R. 3495 in legislative session and
reported it favorably, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 19-16. Chairman Tim
Walberg (R-MI) offered an amendment in the nature of a
substitute making a technical change to the bill. The amendment
was adopted by voice vote.
Committee Views
Introduction
An independent contractor\1\ is a self-employed individual
contracted to perform work or provide services to a person or
business. In 2024, an estimated 72.7 million Americans worked
as independent contractors, a diverse and rapidly expanding
segment of the labor force.\2\ According to the Internal
Revenue Service and the Department of the Treasury, the share
of workers in independent contracting grew by 22 percent
between 2001 and 2016.\3\ McKinsey's American Opportunity
Survey shows further acceleration, with the independent
workforce jumping from 27 percent of the employed population in
2016 to 36 percent by 2022.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Examples include over 120 professions such as translators, youth
sports coaches, golf caddies, certain health care workers, financial
advisors, cartoonists, musicians, tutors, writers, direct sellers,
delivery drivers, electricians, software developers, fitness
instructors, nannies, graphic designers, photographers, and
nutritionists.
\2\https://www.mbopartners.com/state-of-independence/.
\3\https://www.mercatus.org/research/policy-briefs/unleashing-
portable-benefits-solutions.
\4\https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/sustainable-
inclusive-growth/future-of-america/freelance-side-hustles-and-gigs-
many-more-americans-have-become-independent-workers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Worker Classification
As the number of independent contractors continues to
increase, professions such as direct selling have become more
attractive. The direct selling industry markets or sells
products and services outside of a fixed retail establishment.
Direct selling is a retail channel used by top global brands
and smaller entrepreneurial companies alike to market products
and services to consumers. Through direct selling, companies
market a variety of goods and services, including jewelry,
cookware, energy, insurance, and more.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\https://www.dsa.org/about/direct-selling.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Real estate agents whose pay is tied to output rather than
hours worked are considered independent contractors. Out of 1.5
million real estate agents registered with the National
Association of REALTORS, 87 percent are classified as
independent contractors.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://www.nar.realtor/washington-report/nar-supports-new-
legislation-protecting-
independent-contractor-status.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is clear that direct sellers and real estate agents are
properly understood as independent contractors in part because
there is no salary cap for either profession. If the direct
seller sells more products, he or she earns more. If the real
estate agent sells more properties, he or she earns more. On
the other hand, an employee might be subject to a fixed income
or a fixed bonus. Direct sellers and real estate agents often
decide that independent contracting is best for them because it
gives them the flexibility to work on multiple projects or with
multiple clients at once based on their income needs and
available work hours.
Both direct sellers and qualified real estate agents have
been defined as independent contractors, and distinguished from
employees, by the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) for federal tax
purposes since 1982. However, this distinction is limited to
the tax code: the FLSA only defines ``employee'' and does not
address or extend itself to independent contractors. Because
both direct sellers and most real estate agents are clearly
independent contractors with respect to the way they work, the
FLSA should be clarified to ensure these individuals are
considered independent contractors under the statute,
reflecting the clarity that exists for these workers under the
IRC.
Conclusion
The FLSA is woefully outdated and no longer reflects the
American workforce in 2025. Enacting H.R. 3495 offers a
practical way to modernize this 1938 law and to address gaps
that leave today's workers unserved. Both the National
Association of REALTORS and Direct Selling Association--the
organizations that represent the only two industries which are
affected by the bill--are supportive of the effort. This
bipartisan legislation is a common-sense reform that benefits
workers and businesses.
H.R. 3495 Section-by-Section Summary
Section 1 identifies the bill's short title as the Direct
Seller and Real Estate Agent Harmonization Act.
Section 2 clarifies that the definition of employee in
section 3(e) of the FLSA does not include any direct seller or
qualified real estate agent, to mirror the language in section
3508(b) of the IRC.
Explanation of Amendments
The amendment in the nature of a substitute is explained in
the body of this report.
Application of Law to the Legislative Branch
Section 102(b)(3) of Public Law 104-1 requires a
description of the application of this bill to the legislative
branch because the bill pertains to conditions of employment.
H.R. 3495 amends the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) to
clarify the definition of employee, only as it relates to
direct sellers and qualified real estate agents and not
legislative branch employees, and therefore does not apply to
the legislative branch.
Unfunded Mandate Statement
Pursuant to Section 423 of the Congressional Budget and
Impoundment Control Act of 1974, Pub. L. No. 93-344 (as amended
by Section 101(a)(2) of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of
1995, Pub. L. No. 104-4), the Committee traditionally adopts as
its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office (CBO) pursuant to section 402 of
the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974.
Earmark Statement
H.R. 3495 does not contain any congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9 of House rule XXI.
Roll Call Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee Report to include for
each record vote on a motion to report the measure or matter
and on any amendments offered to the measure or matter the
total number of votes for and against and the names of the
Members voting for and against.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
In accordance with clause (3)(c) of House of
Representatives rule XIII, the goal of H.R. 3495, the Direct
Seller and Real Estate Harmonization Act, is to clarify the
worker classification of direct sellers and qualified real
estate agents.
Duplication of Federal Programs
No provision of H.R. 3495 establishes or reauthorizes a
program of the Federal Government known to be duplicative of
another Federal program, a program that was included in any
report from the Government Accountability Office to Congress
pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program
related to a program identified in the most recent Catalog of
Federal Domestic Assistance.
Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of the Committee
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
the Committee's oversight findings and recommendations are
reflected in the body of this report.
Required Committee Hearing
In compliance with clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives the following hearing held
during the 119th Congress was used to develop or consider H.R.
3495: on March 25, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing on ``The Future of Wage Laws:
Assessing the FLSA's Effectiveness, Challenges, and
Opportunities.''
New Budget Authority and CBO Cost Estimate
Clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires an estimate and a comparison of the
costs that would be incurred in carrying out H.R. 3495.
However, clause 3(d)(2)(B) of that rule provides that this
requirement does not apply when, as with the present report,
the Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate for the bill
prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.
H.R. 3495 would amend the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
to exclude any direct sellers and real estate agents from the
definition of ``employee''. That change would align the
definition of employee for those individuals in both the FLSA
and the Internal Revenue Code.
The FLSA authorizes the Department of Labor (DOL) to impose
and collect civil monetary penalties from employers that
repeatedly and willfully violate the law's minimum wage and
overtime provisions. The penalties are recorded in the federal
budget as revenues, and a portion can be spent without further
appropriation. DOL typically collects less than $20 million per
year in such penalties for all FLSA violations, according to
agency enforcement statistics.
Enacting the bill would result in fewer entities being
subject to those penalties. Under H.R. 3495, CBO estimates that
the reduction in amounts collected would be small and that the
decrease in revenues and direct spending, and the resulting net
increase in the deficit would be less than $500,000 over the
2026-2035 period.
Mandates
H.R. 3495 would impose a private-sector mandate, as defined
in the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA), on workers who
would no longer be covered by the FLSA and therefore would not
have legal grounds to seek financial compensation for
violations of that act.
The cost of the mandate on workers would be the value of
financial settlements that they would have received for
violations of the FLSA in the absence of the bill. Using data
from DOL on back wages and financial compensation for FLSA
violations, CBO estimates that the cost of this mandate is
below the threshold for private-sector mandates established in
UMRA ($206 million in 2025, adjusted annually for inflation).
H.R. 3495 contains no intergovernmental mandates.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Susan Beyer (for
federal spending) and Erich Dvorak (for mandates). The estimate
was reviewed by Christina Hawley Anthony, Deputy Director of
Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
Committee Cost Estimate
Clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires an estimate and a comparison of the
costs that would be incurred in carrying out H.R. 3495.
However, clause 3(d)(2)(B) of that rule provides that this
requirement does not apply when, as with the present report,
the Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate for the bill
prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (new matter is
printed in italics and existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
FAIR LABOR STANDARDS ACT OF 1938
* * * * * * *
definitions
Sec. 3. As used in this Act--
(a) ``Person'' means an individual, partnership, association,
corporation, business trust, legal representative, or any
organized group of persons.
(b) ``Commerce'' means trade, commerce, transportation,
transmission, or communication among the several States or
between any State and any place outside thereof.
(c) ``State'' means any State of the United States or the
District of Columbia or any Territory or possession of the
United States.
(d) ``Employer'' includes any person acting directly or
indirectly in the interest of an employer in relation to an
employee and includes a public agency, but does not include any
labor organization (other than when acting as an employer) or
anyone acting in the capacity of officer or agent of such labor
organization.
(e)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4),
the term ``employee'' means any individual employed by an
employer.
(2) In the case of an individual employed by a public agency,
such term means--
(A) any individual employed by the Government of the
United States--
(i) as a civilian in the military departments
(as defined in section 102 of title 5, United
States Code),
(ii) in any executive agency (as defined in
section 105 of such title),
(iii) in any unit of the judicial branch of
the Government which has positions in the
competitive service,
(iv) in a nonappropriated fund
instrumentality under the jurisdiction of the
Armed Forces,
(v) in the Library of Congress, or
(vi) the Government Printing Office;
(B) any individual employed by the United States
Postal Service or the Postal Rate Commission; and
(C) any individual employed by a State, political
subdivision of a State, or an interstate governmental
agency, other than such an individual--
(i) who is not subject to the civil service
laws of the State, political subdivision, or
agency which employs him; and
(ii) who--
(I) holds a public elective office of
that State, political subdivision, or
agency,
(II) is selected by the holder of
such an office to be a member of his
personal staff,
(III) is appointed by such an
officeholder to serve on a policymaking
level,
(IV) is an immediate adviser to such
an officeholder with respect to the
constitutional or legal powers of his
office, or
(V) is an employee in the legislative
branch or legislative body of that
Minority Views
Introduction
H.R. 3495, the Direct Seller and Real Estate Agent
Harmonization Act, would amend federal wage-and-hour law so
that people who work in commissioned sales (including real
estate agents and salespersons in multi-level marketing
businesses) and newspaper delivery workers are excluded from
the definition of an employee entitled to wage-and-hour
protections. The law that would be changed by this bill--the
Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938\1\ (FLSA)--already
accommodates the industries' customary commission-based pay
practices. By categorically excluding these occupations from
FLSA, this bill would threaten the independence of legitimate
independent contractors and imperil the protections of low-wage
workers in call centers. The Committee has not conducted any
hearings on whether there is a problem to be fixed in these
industries or any potential downstream consequences of the
changes this bill could create.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. L. No. 75-718, 52 Stat. 1060 (1938).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This bill is opposed by the Communication Workers of
America and the National Employment Lawyers Association.
Background on Direct Sellers and Real Estate Agents
The short title of H.R. 3495 draws attention to two
categories of workers: direct sellers and real estate agents.
Direct Sellers
The direct selling business model is predicated on direct
sales of products and services outside of a traditional retail
setting.\2\ Today, a prominent form of direct selling is multi-
level marketing (MLM). In an MLM business model, a company
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Johanna Leggatt, Understanding Multi-Level Marketing, Forbes
(Apr. 11, 2025), https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/multi-level-
marketing-mlm/.
distributes products or services through a network of
participants. Typically, the company does not directly
recruit new participants, but relies on its existing
participants to recruit additional participants, who,
in turn, also recruit new participants. This creates
multiple levels of participants organized in
``downlines.'' A participant's ``downline'' is the
network of their recruits, and recruits of those
recruits, and so on. A participant's ``upline'' is the
person who recruited them, and the person who recruited
their recruiter, and so on.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing, Fed. Trade
Comm., https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/business-
guidance-concerning-multi-level-marketing (last visited Sept. 26,
2025).
Some notable MLM companies include Amway, Herbalife, and
Mary Kay.\4\ Although not necessarily illegal by definition,
``many MLMs have become infamous for their controversial
business practices.''\5\ MLM businesses ``tend to appeal to new
recruits with promises of wealth and independence,''\6\ but
``it's the [MLM] company that hoards most of the advantages of
the arrangement: an individual direct seller receives no
salary, benefits, or paid time off; does not set her own prices
or sales goals; has no say on suppliers or marketing strategy;
and generally does not even choose what products she is
selling.''\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Peter Gratton, What Is MLM? How Multilevel Marketing or Network
Marketing Works, Investopedia (May 14, 2025), https://
www.investopedia.com/terms/m/multi-level-marketing.asp.
\5\See Leggatt, supra note 2.
\6\Id.
\7\Jessica Winter, The Unkillable Appeal of Multilevel Marketing,
The New Yorker (Mar.
20, 2024), https://www.newyorker.com/books/under-review/the-unkillable-
appeal-of-multilevel-
marketing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Real Estate Agents
Real estate agents are licensed professionals who help
clients buy, sell, and manage real estate.\8\ They are
overwhelmingly--87% nationwide, according to the National
Association of Realtors (NAR)\9\--set up as independent
contractors and are customarily paid on a commission basis
rather than a regular wage.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales
Agents, Bureau of Lab. Stats. (Aug. 28, 2025), https://www.bls.gov/ooh/
sales/real-estate-brokers-and-sales-agents.htm.
\9\NAR Issue Brief: Real Estate Professionals Classification as
Independent Contractors, Nat'l Ass'n of Realtors (Jan. 10, 2024),
https://www.nar.realtor/advocacy/nar-issue-brief-real-estate-
professionals-classification-as-independent-contractors [hereinafter
NAR Brief].
\10\Victoria Araj, Real Estate Broker vs. Agent: Differences
Explained, Rocket Mortgage (Jan. 13, 2025), https://
www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/real-estate-broker-vs-agent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Real estate agents are required under state laws to
affiliate with a licensed real estate broker, who is also a
licensed professional able to do the same work as an agent as
well as move money to and from escrow accounts, mediate
conflicts over transactions, and ensure legal compliance for
real estate transactions that they and their affiliated agents
close.\11\ Real estate brokers typically earn commissions for
transactions they close themselves and receive a portion of the
commission earned by real estate agents affiliated with
them.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Lauren Bowling, What Is a Real Estate Broker and What Do They
Do?, Rocket Mortgage (Feb. 2, 2024), https://www.rocketmortgage.com/
learn/real-estate-broker.
\12\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Real estate agents are generally limited to affiliating
with only one broker in a state, although they may be able to
affiliate with brokers in other states for purposes of
arranging real estate transactions across state lines.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Carlton, FAQ: Can a Real Estate Agent Work for Multiple
Brokers?, Realty Hub (June 26, 2025), https://joinrealtyhub.com/can-a-
real-estate-agent-work-for-multiple-brokers/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Upstream Power Players
Whether or not a direct seller or real estate agent works
as an employee or an independent contractor, each is subject to
some sort of supervision or set of rules determined by a
powerful actor. That actor can be a branded MLM firm, the
``upline'' lineage of sellers who collect a percentage of a
seller's commissions,\14\ or a real estate broker, as the case
may be. For convenience, we will refer to these entities
collectively as upstream power players.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\See supra text accompanying note 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Employment Law This Bill Would Amend
H.R. 3495 would change the definition of employee in the
Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA). FLSA is the federal
employment law governing the minimum wage,\15\ overtime,\16\
oppressive child labor,\17\ discrimination in pay on the basis
of sex,\18\ and the right of nursing mothers to take paid
breaks at work for the purpose of expressing breast milk.\19\
It is enforced by the Wage and Hour Division (WHD) of the U.S.
Department of Labor (DOL), as well as by workers themselves who
bring cases in court.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\FLSA Sec. 6.
\16\Id. Sec. 7.
\17\Id. Sec. 12.
\18\Id. Sec. 6(d).
\19\Id. Sec. 18D.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Economic Realities Test
In FLSA, the term ``employ'' includes ``to suffer or permit
to work.''\20\ Courts test the applicability of the FLSA
definition using the ``economic realities'' test, which looks
underneath whatever terms the parties to a relationship use to
describe it and focuses instead on the reality of the
relationship. The economic realities test examines the facts of
the working relationship in light of the totality of the
circumstances to determine whether the putative employee is
economically dependent on the potential employer.\21\
Ultimately, the application of the economic realities factors
is guided by the overarching principle that the FLSA should be
``construed liberally to apply to the furthest reaches
consistent with congressional direction.''\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Id. Sec. 3(g).
\21\Tony & Susan Alamo Found. v. Sec'y of Labor, 471 U.S. 290, 301
(1985) (reiterating that the test of employment under the FLSA is
economic reality); Goldberg v. Whitaker House Co-op, Inc., 366 U.S. 28,
33 (1961).
\22\Mitchell v. Lublin, McGaughy & Assocs., 358 U.S. 207 (1959).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FLSA definitions of ``employ'' and ``employee'' also
apply to family and medical leave rights under the Family and
Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA).\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Pub. L. No. 103-3, Sec. 101(2)(C) (1993).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Relevant Exemptions
Even with its broad reach, FLSA still accommodates the
particular needs and longstanding practices of specific
industries and occupations, including a special rule for
outside salespersons and another for news delivery persons.
The FLSA outside sales exemption excludes ``any employee
employed . . . in the capacity of outside salesman'' from the
minimum wage and overtime provisions of the law.\24\ WHD
defines this exemption as applying to an employee (1) whose
primary duty is making sales or obtaining orders or contracts
for services or the use of facilities for which a client or
customer will pay some consideration, and (2) who conducts this
work customarily and regularly outside of a fixed place of
business (including the employee's own home).\25\ This
exemption covers a wide range of sales activity, including real
estate, radio and TV time, print ads, and intellectual
property.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\FLSA Sec. 13(a)(1).
\25\29 C.F.R. Sec. Sec. 541.500-504.
\26\Wage & Hr. Div., U.S. Dep't of Lab., Fact Sheet #17: Exemption
for Outside Sales Employees Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
(Aug. 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FLSA news delivery exemption excludes ``any employee
engaged in the delivery of newspapers to the consumer'' from
minimum wage, overtime, equal pay, and child labor
provisions.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\FLSA Sec. 13(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
How FLSA Would Be Amended
H.R. 3495 would amend the definition of employee in FLSA by
excluding any worker treated for purposes of federal tax law as
a statutory non-employee in section 3508 of the Internal
Revenue Code.
Section 3508 allows, for purposes of tax treatment, that
workers will be deemed independent contractors if they satisfy
the following:
(1) They are either licensed real estate agents or
engaged in multi-level marketing/direct sales (e.g.,
Amway, Avon, Tupperware), trade or sales of consumer
products in the home or anywhere other than a retail
establishment, or engaged in newspaper or shopping news
delivery or distribution;
(2) Substantially all remuneration is directly
related to sales or other output rather than the number
of hours worked; and
(3) Services are performed pursuant to a contract
establishing the non-employee nature of the
relationship.
There is substantial overlap with the FLSA outside sales
and news delivery exemptions, except that the tax code
definition does not include FLSA's specification of sales work
conducted primarily outside of fixed workplaces.
Weaknesses of H.R. 3495
No Established Problem
If there is a problem to be addressed by this bill, it has
never been established in this Committee. No Committee hearing
has been scheduled this Congress, or in any Congress in recent
memory, to identify any cases at all in which the real estate,
direct sales, or news delivery industries have been disrupted,
upset, or even slightly bothered by application of FLSA
employment rules.
In fact, even if a real estate agent or direct seller could
make a case that an employment relationship had been
established in a given set of circumstances, the outside sales
and news delivery exemptions already bar the application of
minimum wage and overtime rules, allowing for the longstanding
commission-oriented pay practices of those industries to
prevail (even where, as is often the case in MLM businesses,
sellers wind up earning less than the minimum wage or just
drown in red ink).\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\Michelle, Singletary, Why Multilevel Marketing Won't Make You
Rich, Wash. Post (Sept. 26, 2018), https://www.washingtonpost.com/
business/2018/09/27/why-that-multilevel-marketing-business-is-probably-
not-going-pay-off/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Same Wrong Song and Dance
In the absence of committee hearings on the matter, the
only resource for the case in favor of this legislation comes
from the groups lobbying for it. They appear, however, to
fundamentally misunderstand the relevant law and recent
rulemakings implementing it.
The leading voice in support of this legislation appears to
be the NAR and its state affiliates. NAR's materials describe
its efforts as ``protect[ing] independent contractors'' from
federal employment and labor laws adopting a streamlined
employment test (the ``ABC test'') in place of the FLSA
economic realities test and the common law control test used in
the National Labor Relations Act.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\NAR Brief, supra note 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To the extent that the NAR has a rationale at all for this
bill, it appears to be a rehash of an argument that the
Majority has brought to this Committee in other contexts
multiple times since the 118th Congress about supposedly
radical changes to the FLSA employment test:
Before the Trump Rule: The economic
realities test, discussed above, was the test for FLSA
going back to the 1940s.
The Trump Rule: A Trump Administration rule,
published in January 2021 (Trump Rule), completely
rewrote this test.\30\ It emphasized two factors above
all--a worker's opportunity to make a profit under the
arrangement, and the worker's control over schedule or
other aspects of the job.\31\ If a worker could
arguably make a profit and had control over something
basic such as his or her own schedule, those facts
could alone be enough to overwhelm other factors of the
Trump Rule's new test. According to the Economic Policy
Institute (EPI), the Trump Rule would have cost workers
more than $3 billion yearly in lost wages.\32\ Courts
either questioned the validity of the Trump Rule\33\ or
waved it away as an interpretation of law that does not
trump authoritative court precedent.\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\Independent Contractor Status Under the Fair Labor Standards
Act, 86 Fed. Reg. 1168 (Jan. 7, 2021).
\31\Id.
\32\Heidi Shierholz, EPI Comments on Independent Contractor Status
Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, Econ. Pol'y Inst. (Oct. 26, 2020),
https://www.epi.org/publication/epi-comments-on-independent-contractor-
status-under-the-fair-labor-standards-act/.
\33\Wallen v. TendoNova Corp., No. 20-cv-790-SE, 2022 U.S. Dist.
LEXIS 21126, *9, 2022 WL 17128983 (D.N.H. Nov. 22, 2022).
\34\Harris v. Diamond Dolls of Nev., No. 3:19-cv-00598-RCJ CBC,
2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 166300, *4-*5, 2022 WL 4125474 (D. Nev. July 26,
2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Biden Rule: The Biden Administration
attempted to simply withdraw the Trump Rule but, after
that move was rejected by a federal district court in
Texas, opted to replace it in with a January 2024 rule
that restores the decades-old economic realities test
(Biden Rule).\35\ The Biden Rule clarifies that the
ultimate question of the economic realities test is
whether workers are running their own businesses
(making them truly independent contractors) or are
dependent on finding work in the business of
another.\36\ It also adds helpful explanations for how
and why each non-exhaustive factor in the economic
realities test helps answer this ultimate question.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\Employee or Independent Contractor Classification Under the
Fair Labor Standards Act, 89 Fed. Reg. 1638 (Jan. 10, 2024)
[hereinafter Biden Rule].
\36\Id. at 1742 (revising 29 C.F.R. Sec. 795.105(a)).
\37\Id. at 1742-1743.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Attacks on the Biden Rule: The Republicans
have repeatedly criticized the Biden Rule as though it
radically rewrites the law.\38\ Instead, it merely
restores the law as it was applied from 1938 to 2021.
The Republicans have also argued that the purpose of
the Biden Rule is not to fix the damage of the Trump
Rule but, instead, to attack independent contracting in
its entirety by adopting the AB 5 version of the ABC
Test. DOL reiterated more than once in the Biden Rule
that it lacks the power to adopt the ABC test and
merely restored the longstanding economic realities
test laid out by the courts decades ago.\39\ (On-demand
gig companies such as Uber and Instacart, which mounted
a $224 million campaign in California for a ballot
initiative carving themselves out of AB 5,\40\ agreed
with the Biden Administration on this point.\41\) Five
court challenges against the Biden Rule are still
pending. Three were dismissed on standing grounds; of
those, two are being appealed, and the third is likely
to be appealed soon. Two others are on appeal for other
reasons, with each delayed at the request of the Trump
Administration.\42\
---------------