Committee Action
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On February 16, 2017, the Committee on Education and
Labor's Subcommittee on Workforce Protections, held a hearing
titled ``Federal Wage and Hour Policies in the Twenty-First
Century Economy.'' The hearing explored how outdated Fair Labor
Standards Act (FLSA) rules and restrictions affecting
independent-contractor status hinder flexibility, innovation,
and job growth in the modern economy. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Ms. Christine Walters, Sole Proprietor, FiveL
Company, Westminster, MD; Mr. Andy Brantley, President and
Chief Executive Officer, College and University Professional
Association for Human Resources, Knoxville, TN; Ms. Rhea Lana
Riner, President, Rhea Lana's Franchise Systems Inc., Conway,
AR, on behalf of the International Franchise Association; and
Mr. Andrew Stettner, Senior Fellow, The Century Foundation,
Washington, DC.
116TH CONGRESS
First Session--Legislative Action
On July 25, 2019, Representative Elise Stefanik (R-NY)
introduced the Modern Worker Empowerment Act (H.R. 4069) with
Representatives Bradley Byrne (R-AL) and David P. Roe (R-TN) as
original cosponsors.
117TH CONGRESS
First Session--Legislative Action
On March 2, 2021, Representative Stefanik introduced the
Modern Worker Empowerment Act (H.R. 1523) with Representatives
Michelle Steel (R-CA), Ralph Norman (R-SC), Matt Gaetz (R-FL),
Tom Cole (R OK), Carol D. Miller (R-WV), Cathy McMorris Rodgers
(R-WA), and Kevin Hern (R-OK) as original cosponsors.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On April 19, 2023, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``Examining Biden's War on
Independent Contractors.'' The hearing evaluated the advantages
of independent contracting, the economic risks of California's
AB5 and similar reclassification proposals, and legislative
options to safeguard flexible work opportunities for workers
and businesses. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Ms.
Tammy McCutchen, Senior Affiliate, Resolution Economics, New
Market, TN; Ms. Kim Kavin, Freelance Writer and Editor, Morris
County, NJ; Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow,
Mercatus Center at George Mason University, Fairfax, VA; Ms.
Karen Anderson, Founder, Freelancers Against AB5, Dana Point,
CA; Ms. Laura Padin, Director of Work Structures, National
Employment Law Project, Washington, DC; and Mr. David Long,
Chief Executive Officer, National Electrical Contractors
Association, Washington, DC.
First Session--Legislative Action
On September 14, 2023, Representative Stefanik introduced
the Modern Worker Empowerment Act (H.R. 5513) with
Representatives Kevin Kiley (R-CA) and Michelle Steel (R-CA) as
original co-sponsors.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On March 25, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``The Future of Wage Laws:
Assessing the FLSA's Effectiveness, Challenges, and
Opportunities.'' The hearing examined whether the FLSA remains
effective in today's economy and explored reforms to modernize
outdated regulations. Testifying before the Subcommittee were
Ms. Tammy McCutchen, Senior Affiliate, Resolution Economics,
New Market, TN; Ms. Paige Boughan, Senior Vice President and
Director of Human Resources, Farmers and Merchants Bank,
Hampstead, MD, on behalf of the Society for Human Resource
Management; Mr. Jonathan Wolfson, Chief Legal Officer and
Policy Director, Cicero Institute, Richmond, VA; and Mr. Andrew
Stettner, Director of Economy and Jobs, The Century Foundation,
Washington, DC.
On May 20, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce Protections
held a hearing titled ``Empowering the Modern Worker.'' The
hearing examined how federal worker-classification rules and
benefit restrictions affect the nation's independent
contractors and considered legislative reforms to provide
modern workers with flexibility and security. Testifying before
the Subcommittee were Mr. Nathan Mehrens, Vice President,
Workforce Policy, American Trucking Associations, Washington,
DC; Kim Kavin, Freelance Writer and Editor, Morris County, NJ;
Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow, Mercatus Center
at George Mason University, Arlington, VA; and Ms. Laura Padin,
Director of Work Structures, National Employment Law Project,
Washington, DC.
First Session--Legislative Action
On February 13, 2025, Representative Kiley introduced H.R.
1319, the Modern Worker Empowerment Act, with Representatives
John H. Rutherford (R-FL), John R. Moolenaar (R-MI), Mark
Messmer (R-IN), and Andrew Ogles (R-TN) as original cosponsors.
On July 23, 2025, the Committee considered H.R. 1319 in
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 19-16. The
Committee considered the following amendments to H.R. 1319:
1. Representative Kiley offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute that made minor technical
changes to the bill. The amendment was adopted by voice
vote.
2. Representative Yassamin Ansari (D-AZ) offered an
amendment to exclude flexible work arrangements from
consideration in determining whether an individual is
an employee of another person. The amendment failed by
a vote of 16-19.
3. Representative Summer L. Lee (D-PA) offered an
amendment requiring a court rather than an arbitrator,
regardless of any contractual provision, to determine
whether an individual is an independent contractor
instead of an employee. The amendment failed by a vote
of 16-19.
4. Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) offered an
amendment stating that the phrase ``details of the way
the work is performed'' in the bill does not include
the exercise by the worker of discretion that is
ordinarily and customarily exercised by an employee in
an occupation. The amendment failed by a vote of 16-19.
5. Representative Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR) offered an
amendment prohibiting application of the bill in cases
related to unlawful child labor under the FLSA. The
amendment failed by a vote of 16-19.
Committee Views
Introduction
Independent contractors are self-employed individuals
contracted to perform work or provide services to a person or
business. In 2024, there were an estimated 72.7 million
independent workers in the United States.\1\ The independent
workforce encompasses a wide variety of workers and has been
growing rapidly.\2\ According to the Internal Revenue Service
and the Department of the Treasury, from 2001 to 2016, the
share of workers with independent contracting income grew by 22
percent.\3\ According to McKinsey's American Opportunity
Survey, from 2016 to 2022, the independent workforce jumped
from 27 percent of the working population to 36 percent.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.mbopartners.com/state-of-independence/.
\2\Examples include more than 120 professions such as translators,
youth sports coaches, golf caddies, certain healthcare workers,
financial advisors, cartoonists, musicians, tutors, writers, direct
sellers, delivery drivers, electricians, software developers, fitness
instructors, nannies, graphic designers, photographers, and
nutritionists.
\3\https://www.mercatus.org/research/policy-briefs/unleashing-
portable-benefits-solutions.
\4\https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/sustainable-
inclusive-growth/future-of-america/freelance-side-hustles-and-gigs-
many-more-americans-have-become-independent-workers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent contractors are not employees and are therefore
not covered by statutes such as the FLSA.\5\ Independent
workers are not considered employees because they are in
business for themselves rather than working as employees who
are economically dependent on an employer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Since 1938, the FLSA has defined the term ``employee'' as ``any
individual employed by an employer,'' the term ``employer'' as ``any
person acting directly or indirectly in the interest of an employer in
relation to an employee,'' and the term ``employ'' as ``to suffer or
permit to work.'' 29 U.S.C. Sec. 203.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
California's Assembly Bill 5
In 2019, Governor Gavin Newsom (D-CA) signed Assembly Bill
No. 5 (AB5) into law, which changed the classification of many
workers in the state and now stands as the country's strictest
legal criteria for classifying a worker as an independent
contractor.\6\ AB5 adopts an ``ABC'' test to determine whether
a worker should be classified as an employee or an independent
contractor. When hiring an individual as an independent
contractor, the business must be able to prove the individual
meets all three conditions: (a) the worker is free from the
control of the hiring entity, (b) the work being performed is
outside of the hiring entity's usual course of business, and
(c) the worker is engaged in an independent trade, occupation,
or business of the same nature of work being performed. If the
hiring entity cannot prove all three of these conditions, the
individual is considered an employee.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/assessing-
impact-worker-reclassification-employment-outcomes-post.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB5 has severely restricted independent work and expanded
the definition of ``employee'' in California. Because of the
turmoil it was going to cause in the state's economy, a
subsequent California law deemed 109 categories of workers
exempt from AB5, including doctors, real estate agents, and
engineers.\7\ However, these exemptions have only partially
mitigated the damage done by AB5. Ms. Karen Anderson, founder
of Freelancers Against AB5, stated in her testimony at the
April 2023 Subcommittee on Workforce Protections hearing, to
this day, despite the so-called exemptions for certain
professions added in September 2020 via the cleanup bill
AB2257, the law continues to wreak havoc on legitimate
independent contractors and small-business owners.''\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\https://www.natlawreview.com/article/ab-2257-enacts-significant-
changes-to-ab-5-
classification-workers-independent; https://www.ymsllp.com/blog/2020/
december/workers-what-to-know-about-california-s-ab5/.
\8\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
anderson_testimony.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Analyzing employment outcomes in response to AB5,
researchers found that self-employment and overall employment
decreased following the law's enactment.\9\ The findings
indicate that AB5 did not result in either more workers
becoming employees or fewer workers classified as independent
contractors, despite lawmakers' intentions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/assessing-
impact-worker-reclassification-employment-outcomes-post.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A new national study found that when states adopt an ABC
test like the one required in California and when compared to
states that use a common-law standard, W-2 employment falls by
4.7 percent, self-employment drops by 6.4 percent, and overall
employment declines by 4.8 percent. According to the author of
the study, Dr. Liya Palagashvili from the Mercatus Center,
``these results are causal--that is, the ABC test directly
caused these declines.''\10\ This study included results from
nine states that have enacted ABC tests which set such high
bars for maintaining independent contractor status, many
workers left the state.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
palagashvili_testimony.pdf at 3.
\11\https://liyapalagashvili.substack.com/p/new-study-from-gig-to-
gone-abc-tests.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent Contractor Regulations
In January 2021, the Department of Labor (DOL) under the
first Trump administration published a final rule on the
classification of employees and independent contractors under
the FLSA.\12\ This rule clarified and simplified the economic
realities worker classification test under the FLSA by
emphasizing two ``core'' factors that guided worker
classification determinations: (1) the nature and degree of the
worker's control over the work and (2) the worker's opportunity
for profit or loss. This approach clarified DOL's
interpretation of worker classification status under the FLSA,
provided more certainty for workers and employers, and promoted
economic growth.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Independent Contractor Status Under the Fair Labor Standards
Act, 86 Fed. Reg. 1168 (Jan. 7, 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In October 2022, the Biden DOL published a proposed rule
regarding employee or independent contractor classification
under the FLSA, replacing the 2021 Trump administration final
rule.\13\ The proposed rule included a six-factor economic
realities test to determine whether a worker is ``economically
dependent'' on a company under a totality of the circumstances.
In December 2022, then-Ranking Member Virginia Foxx (R-NC) and
Sen. Mike Braun (R-IN) led a bicameral comment letter to DOL
opposing the proposed rule, signed by 21 House Members and 26
Senators.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Employee or Independent Contractor Classification Under the
Fair Labor Standards Act, 87 Fed. Reg. 62,218 (proposed Oct. 13, 2022).
\14\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
bicameral_dol_ic_nprm_comments.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In January 2024, DOL published its final rule replacing the
Trump administration's 2021 independent contractor rule. The
rule includes a six-factor economic realities test to determine
whether a worker is ``economically dependent'' on a company
under a totality of the circumstances. The rule delineates six
economic factors to determine the employment status of an
individual: (1) opportunity for profit or loss depending on
managerial skill, (2) investments by the worker and the
company, (3) degree of permanence of the work relationship, (4)
nature and degree of control, (5) extent to which the work
performed is an integral part of the company's business, and
(6) skill and initiative.\15\ The final rule also says that no
one factor is ``dispositive, and the weight to give each factor
may depend on the facts and circumstances of the particular
relationship.'' Finally, additional unnamed factors may be
considered, but the rule fails to clarify what those factors
may be.\16\ Organizations including The Coalition for Workforce
Innovation\17\ and Fight For Freelancers,\18\ as well as
others,\19\ have challenged the Biden rule in federal courts,
many arguing the rule is too vague, exceeds DOL's authority,
and violates the Administrative Procedure Act.\20\ Instead, DOL
will use longstanding principles included in a 2008 DOL fact
sheet, a 2019 opinion letter regarding virtual marketplaces,
and relevant court rulings. The bulletin essentially returns to
the worker classification guidance that DOL used during the
first Trump administration.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Employee or Independent Contractor Classification Under the
Fair Labor Standards Act, 89 Fed. Reg. 1638, 1742-1743 (Jan. 10, 2024).
\16\Id. at 1742 (``these six factors are not exhaustive'';
``additional factors may be considered'').
\17\Coalition for Workforce Innovation v. Su, No. 22-40316 (E.D.
Texas filed Mar. 5, 2024).
\18\Warren v. DOL, No. 2:24-cv-00007-RWS (N.D. Ga. filed Jan. 16,
2024).
\19\https://news.bloomberglaw.com/daily-labor-report/punching-in-
keeping-tabs-on-lawsuits-
challenging-dols-ic-rule-28.
\20\https://www.jacksonlewis.com/insights/employers-still-need-
abide-2024-independent-
contractor-rule-despite-dol-hints-dropping-it.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On May 1, 2025, DOL issued a field assistance bulletin
providing guidance on how to determine employee or independent
contractor status under the FLSA.\21\ The bulletin directs
agency investigators to discontinue applying the 2024 Biden
administration final rule on worker classification when
determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent
contractor.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\https://www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/WHD/fab/fab2025-1.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hearing on Independent Contractors
On May 20, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce Protections
held a hearing on ``Empowering the Modern Worker.'' Witnesses
testified about independent work, worker classification
challenges, and the recent ``regulatory whiplash'' as Mr.
Nathan Mehrens, Vice President for Workforce Policy at the
American Trucking Associations, termed it, describing
compliance challenges associated with regulations that
oscillate widely across administrations. He also stated,
``Congress should act to protect and strengthen the
[independent contractor] model by seizing opportunities, such
as the Modern Worker Empowerment Act, to enhance our workforce
and empower the next generation of safe and qualified
transportation workers.''\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Empowering the Modern Worker: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on
Workforce Protections of the H. Comm. on Educ. & Workforce, 119th Cong.
(2025) (statement of Nathan Mehrens, Vice President of Workforce Pol'y,
Am. Trucking Ass'ns, at 4, 6).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent Contractors Prefer Their Current Status
Surveys consistently show that independent contractors do
not wish to become employees. In its 2023 ``Contingent and
Alternative Employment Arrangements'' survey, the U.S. Bureau
of Labor Statistics found that 80.3 percent of self-employed
workers prefer their work arrangements over W-2 employment. The
individuals surveyed were workers who indicated that
independent contracting was their primary source of income.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\https://www.mercatus.org/research/state-testimonies/nevadas-
portable-benefits-bill-
legalizing-access-benefits-self-employed.
-----------------
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 1319, the Modern Worker Empowerment Act, would amend
core workplace laws to redefine the test for determining
whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor.
The bill would significantly narrow the scope of workplace laws
and make it more difficult for workers who have been
potentially misclassified as independent contractors to seek
the protections of federal employment and labor laws.
The bill is opposed by the AFL-CIO; Mechanical Contractors
Association of America; National Employment Law Project;
National Nurses United; National Partnership for Women and
Families; National Women's Law Center Action Fund; Owner-
Operator Independent Drivers Association; and The Association
of Union Constructors.
UNDERLYING LAW
This bill would amend two core workplace laws: the Fair
Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA)\1\ and the National Labor
Relations Act (NLRA).\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. L. No. 75-718, 52 Stat. 1060 (1938) (codified at 29 U.S.C.
Sec. 201 et seq.).
\2\Pub. L. No. 74-198, 49 Stat. 449 (1935) (codified at 29 U.S.C.
Sec. 151 et seq.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair Labor Standards Act
FLSA is the core federal workplace standards law governing
the minimum wage,\3\ overtime,\4\ oppressive child labor,\5\
discrimination in pay on the basis of sex,\6\ and the right of
nursing mothers to take paid breaks at work for the purpose of
expressing breast milk.\7\ It is enforced by the Wage and Hour
Division (WHD) of the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL), as well
as by workers themselves who bring cases in court.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Id. Sec. 6.
\4\Id. Sec. 7.
\5\Id. Sec. 12.
\6\Id. Sec. 6(d).
\7\Id. Sec. 18D.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In FLSA, the term ``employ'' includes ``to suffer or permit
to work.''\8\ When establishing this broad definition of
employment, Congress consciously sought to expand the
employment relationship to hold accountable employers who would
not otherwise be liable for violations under a common-law
control test.\9\ Courts test the applicability of the FLSA
definition using the ``economic realities'' test, which looks
underneath whatever terms the parties to a relationship use to
describe it and focuses instead on the reality of the
relationship, based on the totality of the circumstances, to
determine whether the putative employee is economically
dependent on the potential employer.\10\ Ultimately, the
application of the economic realities factors is guided by the
overarching principle that the FLSA should be ``construed
liberally to apply to the furthest reaches consistent with
congressional direction.''\11\ The FLSA definition of
employment is the ``broadest definition that has ever been
included in any one act.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id. Sec. 3(g).
\9\Bruce Goldstein et al., Enforcing Fair Labor Standards in the
Modern American Sweatshop: Rediscovering the Statutory Definition of
Employment, 46 UCLA L. Rev. 983, 991 (1999).
\10\Tony & Susan Alamo Found. v. Sec'y of Labor, 471 U.S. 290, 301
(1985) (reiterating that the test of employment under the FLSA is
economic reality); Goldberg v. Whitaker House Co-op, Inc., 366 U.S. 28,
33 (1961).
\11\Mitchell v. Lublin, McGaughy & Assocs., 358 U.S. 207 (1959).
\12\United States v. Rosenwasser, 323 U.S. 360, 363 (1945) (quoting
81 Cong. Rec. 7,657 (1938) (remarks of Sen. Hugo Black)). The FLSA's
definition of ``employ'' is a standard of ``striking breadth'' that
``stretches the meaning of `employee' to cover some parties who might
not qualify as such under a strict application of traditional agency
law principles.'' Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co v. Darden, 503 U.S. 318, 323
(1992).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
National Labor Relations Act
The NLRA is the foundational federal law governing labor
relations. Administered by the National Labor Relations Board
(NLRB), the NLRA protects the rights of employees to organize
and collectively bargain with their employers for improved
working conditions and benefits, among other things.
Under the NLRA, the question of whether a worker is an
employee or an independent contractor is governed by a common
law test of control.\13\ Among the factors courts and the NLRB
apply when examining whether workers are employees within the
meaning of the NLRA are ``the extent of control the employer
has over the work; . . . whether the worker is engaged in a
distinct occupation or business . . . ; whether the kind of
occupation is usually done under the direction of the employer
or by a specialist without supervision; [and] whether the
employer is or is not in business.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See FedEx Home Delivery v. NLRB, 849 F.3d 1123, 1125 (D.C. Cir.
2017).
\14\Id. (internal citations omitted).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE BACKGROUND THREAT OF MISCLASSIFICATION
Estimates vary but suggest that at least 10%-20% of
employers are currently misclassifying their employees as
independent contractors instead of employees.\15\ A DOL study
put the number as high as 30%.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Nat'l Emp. L. Proj., Independent Contractor Misclassification
Imposes Huge Costs on Workers and Federal and State Treasuries (Oct.
2020), https://s27147.pcdn.co/wp-content/uploads/Independent-
Contractor-Misclassification-Imposes-Huge-Costs-Workers-Federal-State-
Treasuries-Update-October-2020.pdf.
\16\Lalith De Silva et al., Planmatics, Inc., Independent
Contractors: Prevalence and Implications for Unemployment Insurance
Programs, Prepared for the US Department of Labor Employment and
Training Administration (2000), http://wdr.doleta.gov/owsdrr/00-5/00-
5.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent contractors are excluded from core workplace
protections, including minimum wage, overtime, health and
safety, and labor organizing. Given the value of these
protections on top of the supplemental pay and benefits often
associated with employment, workers lose significant value when
they are misclassified as independent contractors. The Economic
Policy Institute (EPI) examined some of the occupations most
prone to misclassification and found that being erroneously
classified as an independent contractor was costly for such
workers. For example, a misclassified truck driver annually
loses $21,533-$38,965; a janitorial and cleaning worker,
$7,228-$10,214; and a call center worker, $8,155-$11,539.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Adewale A. Maye et al., Misclassifying Workers as Independent
Contractors Is Costly for Workers and States, Econ. Pol. Inst. (Jan.
22, 2025), https://www.epi.org/publication/misclassifying-workers-2025-
update/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Misclassification enriches employers at the expense of
workers and the broader public. Law-breaking employers can save
an estimated 30% in labor costs and taxes.\18\ A 1996 study put
the loss to federal tax revenues at $1.6 billion in 1984 ($5.0
billion today).\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Nat'l Emp. L. Proj., supra note 10, at 1.
\19\Gen. Accounting Off., GAO/T-GGD-96-130, Issues in Classifying
Workers as Employees or Independent Contractors (June 20, 1996),
https://www.gao.gov/assets/t-ggd-96-130.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SHORTCOMINGS OF THE LEGISLATION
This bill would amend the FLSA and the NLRA to establish a
single test to determine whether an individual is an
independent contractor or employee. Under the bill's test, an
individual would be classified as an independent contractor
rather than an employee if the following apply:
(1) the putative employer does not have ``significant
control over the details of the way the work is
performed'' (but may exert control ``over the final
result of the work performed''); and
(2) the worker ``has the opportunities and risks
inherent with entrepreneurship, such as the discretion
to exercise managerial skill, business acumen, or
professional judgement.''
The legislation would also specifically exclude the
following factual circumstances, which could otherwise be
useful evidence of control, from being considered in any
determination of employee status:
(1) Whether the putative employer requires a worker
to follow legal, statutory, or regulatory requirements;
(2) Whether the putative employer requires a worker
to adhere to health and safety standards above the
legal floor;
(3) Whether the putative employer requires a worker
to carry any type of insurance; and
(4) Whether the putative employer requires a worker
to meet performance standards in the contract, like
deadlines.
This bill would significantly narrow the scope of the NLRA
and FLSA and make it more difficult for potentially
misclassified workers to argue that they are entitled to NLRA
and FLSA rights.
Roadmap for Abuse
The bill would give businesses across the economy a simple
two-step formula for misclassifying all sorts of workers. Step
one: identify any jobs where workers have room in the course of
their workday to exercise discretion and make decisions about
the way they execute their work. Steptwo: require anyone who
wants to be retained to do those jobs to go through the formalities of
establishing, at least on paper, a business.
Consider how the misclassification formula established by
this bill would work in relation to a real wage theft case. For
example, the firm Jan-Pro operated a scheme in which jobs
cleaning buildings were made available only after workers
formed LLCs and became franchisees:
The Georgia-based company operates as a multilevel
franchising scheme, selling cleaning businesses to
``Regional Master Franchisees'' throughout the nation
who in turn sign ``unit franchisee'' agreements with
the people who perform the actual janitorial work.
These master franchisee middlemen pay janitors only
after deducting 4% for Jan-Pro. The janitors are also
required to pay a ``franchisee fee'' to be allowed to
work, from which the master franchisees pass on 10% to
Jan-Pro.
In a lawsuit first filed in Massachusetts in 2008,
low-wage cleaners accused Jan-Pro of preying on
immigrant workers by inducing them to buy cleaning
franchises while taking a hefty cut of their earnings
as ``royalties'' and misclassifying them as independent
contractors.\20\
\20\Maria Dinzeo, Judge Finds Jan-Pro Janitors Misclassified as
Contractors, Owed Expenses, Courthouse News Serv. (Aug. 3, 2022),
https://www.courthousenews.com/judge-finds-jan-pro-janitors-
misclassified-as-contractors-owed-expenses/.
The economic reality, underneath the formalities of the
supposed business-to-business relationship, was that the
workers took cleaning jobs assigned by Jan-Pro's middlemen and
provided services integral to the business of Jan-Pro, which
sold cleaning services. That reality could be disregarded,
however, under this bill's two-step test:
Step one: A janitor, such as someone working
through Jan-Pro, might be given broad assignments to
clean spaces, with the expectation of a final result
that would be deemed clean. If the janitor is not
micromanaged in the execution of the cleaning work and
thus is left with discretion over matters such as the
order of operations among tasks (whether to tackle the
floors or the waste baskets first, for example), the
means to use when addressing stubborn stains, or the
array of cleaning products to apply to a space, then
under this bill a cleaning company could argue against
an employment relationship by painting these options as
revealing a lack of ``significant control over the
details'' of the work.
Step two: On paper, these workers had signed
franchise agreements and opened businesses, embracing
``the opportunities and risks inherent with
entrepreneurship.''
Electing this bill's two-step option need not compromise a
business's ability to deliver a quality final product or
service. Such a business could station an employee onsite to
judge whether a space is satisfactorily clean and order do-
overs or additional tasks from the janitor--acting for all
intents and purposes as a supervisor of janitorial employees.
The get-out-of-jail-free card in this case is to relabel the
supervision as reviewing janitors' performance against
``performance standards'' and exerting control over ``the final
result of the work performed.''
Widespread Threat
Many workers routinely and customarily exercise discretion
over the details of the way their work is performed. A small
list of examples might include the following:
truck drivers who chart their own path on the
road in order to deliver packages;
bartenders who manage the atmosphere of a bar
by selecting background music, decide whether to ban
unruly customers, and mix cocktails according to their
own recipes;
chefs who are given an overall budget for
ingredients and freedom to design daily menus; and
dietary aides in health care facilities who
customize meals for patients' specific needs.
Given the many jobs in which the exercise of discretion is
just a fact of life, the bill would put workers throughout the
economy at risk of losing employment and labor law protections.
Converting Jobs to Gigs
Adding to the threat is the growing trend of offering work
through app-based on-demand gig platforms. On their face, gig
platforms seem little different from temp firms, labor brokers,
and other labor market intermediaries. Nevertheless, platforms
such as Uber, Lyft, and their ilk have loomed large in
discussions and debates about the future of work.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\ See, e.g., Shao Chang, Gig Economy and the Future of Work, The
Flaw (July 11, 2022), https://theflaw.org/articles/gig-economy-and-the-
future-of-work-uber-lyfts-race-to-the-bottom-an-opportunity-to-
redefine-work/; Dara Khosrowshahi, Logan Green & John Zimmer, Uber,
Lyft Ready to Do Our Part for Drivers, S.F. Chron. (June 12, 2019),
https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/Open-Forum-Uber-
Lyft-ready-to-do-our-part-for-13969843.php; Brett Collins et al., Is
Gig Work Replacing Traditional Employment?: Evidence from Two Decades
of Tax Returns, Russell Sage Found. (Mar. 2019), https://
www.russellsage.org/reports/gig-work-replacing-traditional-employment-
evidence-two-decades-tax-returns; Robert Maxim & Mark Muro, Rethinking
Worker Benefits for an Economy in Flux, The Avenue (Brookings Inst.)
(Mar. 30, 2018), https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2018/03/29/
rethinking-worker-benefits-for-an-economy-in-flux/; N.Y. Times Ed. Bd.,
No, Robots Aren't Killing the American Dream, N.Y. Times (Feb. 20,
2017), https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/20/opinion/no-robots-arent-
killing-the-american-dream.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill seems tailor-made to exempt on-demand platform
companies from accountability. The platforms typically classify
workers as independent contractors and portray themselves as
mere market platforms, even though many of them set the rates
to be charged; retain the right to penalize workers by
expelling them from the platform; make fewer total gigs or
choice gigs available for any reason; and use algorithms to
distribute opportunities and benefits in order to maximize
platform profits and align worker availability with the
platform's needs.\22\ So long as the work itself is not
directly micromanaged, the platforms could continue to exercise
the full range of authority they already enjoy and, under this
bill, be shielded from any employment or labor law
accountability.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\ The Gig Trap: Algorithmic, Wage and Labor Exploitation in
Platform Work in the US, Hum. Rts. Watch (May 12, 2025), https://
www.hrw.org/report/2025/05/12/the-gig-trap/
algorithmic-wage-and-labor-exploitation-in-platform-work-in-the-us;
Marshall Steinbaum, The Antitrust Case Against Gig Economy Labor
Platforms, LPE Proj. (Apr. 7, 2022), https://lpeproject.org/blog/the-
antitrust-case-against-gig-economy-labor-platforms/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The model is steadily expanding into occupations such as
hospitality,\23\ package delivery,\24\ and even nursing.\25\
Under this bill, any reasonable amount of discretion in the
work along with the ability to choose whether or not to work a
gig any particular day could block workers from access to NLRA
or FLSA protections, even if the affected workers have no
ability to determine or negotiate their own rates of pay or are
subject to a range of requirements not typically imposed by
businesses on other businesses. The result is likely to be
insufficient income and poor working conditions\26\ and, given
the incentives to escape legal obligations simply through
adopting a contract model, a shift to gig-style arrangements in
other industries.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\See, e.g., Bartender Gig Apps That Make Finding Work Easy,
ShiftNOW (Mar. 29, 2024), https://www.shiftnow.com/blog/bartender-gig-
apps; FAQ Page, ShiftNOW, https://www.shiftnow.com/support/shifters
(``A Shifter is an independent contractor, not an employee of ShiftNOW
or the businesses on our platform. Please note that, given your
independent contractor status, ShiftNOW cannot provide Shifters with
proof of employment.'') (last visited May 16, 2025).
\24\See, e.g., Theo Wayt, Delivering in the Dark, Amazon's Gig
Drivers Face Guns and Death, The Info. (Sept. 6, 2023), https://
www.theinformation.com/articles/delivering-in-the-dark-
amazons-gig-drivers-face-guns-and-death; Alana Semuels, I Delivered
Packages for Amazon and It Was a Nightmare, The Atlantic (June 25,
2018), https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/
archive/2018/06/amazon-flex-workers/563444/.
\25\See, e.g., Nursing Is Not a Side Job. Protect Patients. Reject
``Gig'' Nursing., Nat'l Nurses United, https://
www.nationalnursesunited.org/gig-nursing (last visited Oct. 14, 2023).
\26\Ben Zipperer et al., National Survey of Gig Workers Paints a
Picture of Poor Working Conditions, Low Pay, Econ. P