Committee Action
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On February 16, 2017, the Committee on Education and
Labor's Subcommittee on Workforce Protections held a hearing
titled ``Federal Wage and Hour Policies in the Twenty-First
Century Economy.'' The hearing explored how outdated Fair Labor
Standards Act (FLSA) rules and restrictions affecting
independent-contractor status hinder flexibility, innovation,
and job growth in the modern economy. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Ms. Christine Walters, Sole Proprietor, FiveL
Company, Westminster, MD; Mr. Andy Brantley, President and
Chief Executive Officer, College and University Professional
Association for Human Resources, Knoxville, TN; Ms. Rhea Lana
Riner, President, Rhea Lana's Franchise Systems Inc., Conway,
AR, on behalf of the International Franchise Association; and
Mr. Andrew Stettner, Senior Fellow, The Century Foundation,
Washington, DC.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On April 19, 2023, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``Examining Biden's War on
Independent Contractors.'' The hearing evaluated the advantages
of independent contracting, the economic risks of California's
AB 5 and similar reclassification proposals, and legislative
options to safeguard flexible work opportunities for workers
and businesses. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Ms.
Tammy McCutchen, Senior Affiliate, Resolution Economics, New
Market, TN; Ms. Kim Kavin, Freelance Writer and Editor, Morris
County, NJ; Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow,
Mercatus Center at George Mason University, Fairfax, VA; Ms.
Karen Anderson, Founder, Freelancers Against AB5, Dana Point,
CA; Ms. Laura Padin, Director of Work Structures, National
Employment Law Project, Washington, DC; and Mr. David Long,
Chief Executive Officer, National Electrical Contractors
Association, Washington, DC.
Second Session--Hearing
On April 11, 2024, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``Unlocking Opportunity:
Allowing Independent Contractors to Access Benefits.'' The
hearing explored allowing businesses to provide portable,
customizable benefits to independent contractors without
triggering employee reclassification. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Ms. Kristin Sharp, Chief Executive Officer,
Flex Association, Washington, DC; Ms. Gabriella Hoffman, Senior
Policy Analyst, Independent Women's Forum Center for Economic
Opportunity, Alexandria, VA; Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior
Research Fellow, Mercatus Center at George Mason University,
Fairfax, VA; and Dr. Katie Wells, Postdoctoral Fritz Fellow,
Tech and Society Initiative, Georgetown University, Washington,
DC.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On March 25, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections held a hearing titled ``The Future of Wage Laws:
Assessing the FLSA's Effectiveness, Challenges, and
Opportunities.'' The hearing examined whether the FLSA remains
effective in today's economy and explored reforms to modernize
outdated regulations. Testifying before the Subcommittee were
Ms. Tammy McCutchen, Senior Affiliate, Resolution Economics,
New Market, TN; Ms. Paige Boughan, Senior Vice President and
Director of Human Resources, Farmers and Merchants Bank,
Hampstead, MD, on behalf of the Society for Human Resource
Management; Mr. Jonathan Wolfson, Chief Legal Officer and
Policy Director, Cicero Institute, Richmond, VA; and Mr. Andrew
Stettner, Director of Economy and Jobs, The Century Foundation,
Washington, DC.
On May 20, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce Protections
held a hearing titled ``Empowering the Modern Worker.'' The
hearing examined how federal worker-classification rules and
benefit restrictions affect the nation's independent
contractors and considered legislative reforms to provide
modern workers both flexibility and security. Testifying before
the Subcommittee were Mr. Nathan Mehrens, Vice President,
Workforce Policy, American Trucking Associations, Washington,
DC; Ms. Kim Kavin, Freelance Writer and Editor, Morris County,
NJ; Dr. Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow, Mercatus
Center at George Mason University, Arlington, VA; and Ms. Laura
Padin, Director of Work Structures, National Employment Law
Project, Washington, DC.
First Session--Legislative Action
On February 13, 2025, Representative Kevin Kiley (R-CA)
introduced H.R. 1320, the Modern Worker Security Act with
Representative Mark Messmer (R-IN) as an original cosponsor. On
July 23, 2025, the Committee on Education and Workforce
considered H.R. 1320 in legislative session and reported it
favorably, as amended, to the House of Representatives by a
recorded vote of 19-16. The Committee adopted by voice vote an
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute (ANS) offered by
Representative Kiley that made minor technical changes to the
bill.
COMMITTEE VIEWS
INTRODUCTION
Independent contractors are self-employed individuals
contracted to perform work or provide services to a person or
business. The independent workforce encompasses a wide variety
of workers\1\ and has been growing rapidly. According to the
Internal Revenue Service and the Treasury Department, from 2001
to 2016, the share of workers with independent contracting
income grew by 22 percent.\2\ According to McKinsey's American
Opportunity Survey, from 2016 to 2022, the independent
workforce jumped from 27 percent of the employed population to
36 percent.\3\ There are now an estimated 73.3 million
independent workers in the United States.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\These include over 120 professions such as translators, youth
sports coaches, golf caddies, certain healthcare workers, financial
advisors, cartoonists, musicians, tutors, writers, direct sellers,
delivery drivers, electricians, software developers, fitness
instructors, nannies, graphic designers, photographers, and
nutritionists, among others.
\2\https://www.mercatus.org/research/policy-briefs/unleashing-
portable-benefits-solutions.
\3\https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/sustainable-
inclusive-growth/future-of-america/freelance-side-hustles-and-gigs-
many-more-americans-have-become-independent-workers.
\4\https://mycreditsummit.com/gig-economy-statistics/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent contractors are not ``employees'' and are
therefore not covered by statutes such as the Fair Labor
Standards Act (FLSA), the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA),
or the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).\5\ Only
employees are subject to certain wage-and-hour rules and may
access benefits offered to employees such as an employer-
sponsored retirement account, child care allowance, leave (paid
or unpaid), life insurance, or health insurance, among others.
Independent contractors are not eligible to participate in
employer-sponsored retirement and health benefit plans under
ERISA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Since 1938, the FLSA has defined the term ``employee'' as ``any
individual employed by an employer,'' the term ``employer'' as ``any
person acting directly or indirectly in the interest of an employer in
relation to an employee,'' and the term ``employ'' as ``to suffer or
permit to work.'' 29 U.S.C. Sec. 203.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
PORTABLE BENEFITS FOR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS
The term ``portable'' or ``flexible'' benefits generally
refers to state-level policies or private-sector actions that
allow independent contractors to maintain their nontraditional
work arrangements while also accessing some benefits that are
offered to traditional employees, i.e., those covered as
employees by the FLSA, the FMLA, ERISA, and other labor and
employment statutes. Many portable benefits models attach the
benefits to the worker rather than the employer, thus making
the benefits ``portable.''
A 2020 survey of rideshare drivers showed that 67 percent
of drivers prefer to get benefits with their independent
contractor status intact instead of receiving benefits through
traditional employment. Eighty-six percent of drivers say the
reason they work in app-based driving is to have scheduling
flexibility. Eighty-six percent of respondents also said they
would not be able to drive if they were not offered a flexible
schedule. Lastly, 70 percent of drivers said they would not
continue driving if they were forced into a traditional
employee arrangement.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://www.uber.com/newsroom/driver-poll/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In February 2023, the Mercatus Center published a policy
brief titled ``Flexible Benefits for a Flexible Workforce:
Unleashing Portable Benefits Solutions for Independent Workers
and the Gig Economy.''\7\ Among other findings, the brief
concluded that attempts by states to reclassify independent
contractors as employees are not desirable because of the
changing workforce and because so many workers engage in
independent work (roughly one in 10 workers do so as their
primary source of income, and one in three use it to supplement
their income). The brief stated:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\https://www.mercatus.org/research/policy-briefs/unleashing-
portable-benefits-solutions.
[R]eclassification policy is a tool of the past
attempting to solve the challenges of the future.
Access to portable benefits is the only sustainable
solution in the long run if the nature of work
continues to change and flexible and diverse forms of
work become the new norm. It is the best solution to
help workers who choose to become entrepreneurs and
self-employed small business owners.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id.
The brief also offers policy reforms to remove legal
barriers across federal and state jurisdictions. It focuses on
three design principles: 1) participation in portable benefits
programs should be voluntary; 2) contributions should come from
multiple sources, i.e., customers, organizations, businesses,
and workers themselves; and 3) benefits accounts should be tied
to the individual as opposed to a business.
STATE EFFORTS TO EXPAND PORTABLE BENEFITS
States have responded to the rising demand for independent
workers to access benefits while maintaining their flexible
schedules. Pennsylvania, Utah, Alabama, Tennessee, Kentucky,
Washington and several others have either enacted some form of
portable benefits program at the state level, announced a
public-private partnership, or debated a proposal in the
legislature.
Pennsylvania
In 2024, Pennsylvania and DoorDash conducted a statewide
portable benefits savings pilot program in which DoorDash
workers (Dashers) in the state accessed benefits through
Stride, a financial technology company, from April through
September 2024.\9\ The pilot program was later extended until
March 2025.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/stride-launches-first-
ever-independent-worker-contributions-program-for-portable-benefits-
302106507.html.
\10\https://commonwealthfoundation.org/research/portable-benefits-
for-gig-workers/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eligible expenses covered under the pilot program included
retirement, health, and paid time off. Once a Dasher earned
$1,000, he or she became eligible for portable benefits,
allowing him or her to take the benefits to future work
arrangements. According to DoorDash survey data, 23 percent of
Dashers utilized the pilot program, and 89 percent of those
utilizing the program viewed it as beneficial overall.
An NDP Analytics report on the pilot program stated:
The portable benefits program enhances Dashers'
financial security and well-being in various ways.
About 87% of enrollees in the portable benefits pilot
program had saved more than 50% of the deposits as of
early October [2024]. The share of enrollees who save
(87%) is much more than the number of Americans
expecting a tax refund who say they plan to save it
(28% of taxpayers). With the monetary benefits, Dashers
can afford to take time off that would benefit their
mental and physical health and work productivity.
Estimates show that nearly 23% of the civilian labor
force in the U.S. lacks access to paid sick leave, with
higher shares among the lowest-paid workers, part-time
workers, and female cohorts. Based on DoorDash's pilot
program, Dashers, on average, could build up a $400
fund within a year from the contributions. . . . 37% of
all adults in the U.S. struggle with a theoretical $400
unexpected expense.\11\
\11\https://ndpanalytics.com/wp-content/uploads/Portable-Benefits-
Report-December-2024.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Utah
In March 2023, Governor Spencer Cox (R-UT) signed into law
the ``Portable Benefits Plan,'' or S.B. 233, which passed the
legislature almost unanimously.\12\ The law allows for
voluntary participation in a variety of portable benefits
plans, clarifies that contributions to a portable benefits plan
may not be used as a criterion for determining worker
classification as an independent contractor or employee, and
specifies that portable benefits plans are not evidence of an
employment relationship or business liability.\13\ S.B. 233
stands as the first voluntary portable benefits law enacted at
the state level. Following Utah's enactment of S.B. 233, a
Libertas Institute report recommended that Utah build on the
work of S.B. 233 and strengthen the incentives for
participation in portable benefits plans through tax incentives
for firms and individuals who contribute to these plans.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\https://le.utah.gov/2023/bills/static/SB0233.html.
\13\https://le.utah.gov/2023/bills/static/SB0233.html.
\14\http://libertas.org/policy-papers/FlexibleBenefitsReport.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alabama
On April 10, 2025, Alabama enacted SB 86, which provides a
safe harbor for portable benefits available to independent
contractors and makes portable benefits tax deductible for both
contributing businesses and recipients.
Tennessee
On March 20, 2025, Tennessee enacted H.B. 494, which
authorizes marketplace platforms to provide medical and other
insurance benefits to independent contractors. This bill
empowers businesses to offer and fund portable benefit
accounts, giving entrepreneurs greater transparency and control
over their health care.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\https://americansforprosperity.org/press-release/americans-for-
prosperity-tennessee-
applauds-the-passage-of-property-rights-protection-act-and-flexible-
benefit-accounts/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kentucky
In 2024, Kentucky enacted H.B. 465 allowing portable
benefits plans. H.B. 465 generally allows public or private
entities to contribute funds to portable benefits plans for
independent workers without changing their classification to
employee.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\https://apps.legislature.ky.gov/record/24rs/hb465.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Washington State
Washington enacted benefits programs specifically for app-
based workers such as Uber and Lyft drivers. Washington's H.B.
2076, enacted in 2022, requires rideshare companies to provide
rideshare drivers with paid sick leave, unemployment financial
assistance, paid family leave, and a statewide minimum earnings
guarantee, all while maintaining the rideshare drivers' status
as independent contractors.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\https://thehill.com/homenews/3256469-washington-passes-first-
ever-state-law-creating-
minimum-pay-for-ride-sharing-companies/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
WORKFORCE HEARING ON INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS
On May 20, 2025, the Subcommittee on Workforce Protections
held a hearing on ``Empowering the Modern Worker.'' Experts on
issues affecting independent workers testified about
independent contractor challenges. Dr. Liya Palagashvili from
the Mercatus Center noted that access to portable benefits was
a win for workers that did not undermine traditional
employment:
Importantly, legalizing access to benefits does not
lead to more workers being classified as independent
contractors. My analysis of Utah's 2023 Portable
Benefits Bill shows that after the bill was enacted, W-
2 employment continued to grow at the same pace as
before the law, and the growth rate of self employment
also remained unchanged. The portable-benefits law had
no negative impact on labor market composition, but it
did give more workers security without sacrificing
autonomy. This demonstrates that portable benefits
complement, rather than compete with, traditional
employment benefits. Congress can take steps to
accelerate portable benefits by allowing independent
workers to open portable benefits accounts and by
enabling clients and platforms to make voluntary
contributions to those accounts.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Empowering the Modern Worker: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on
Workforce Protections of the H. Comm. on Educ. & Workforce, 119th Cong.
(2025) (statement of Liya Palagashvili, Senior Research Fellow,
Mercatus Ctr. at George Mason Univ., at 4).
Regarding the Pennsylvania portable benefits pilot program,
Dr. Palagashvili stated during the hearing, ``One of the
takeaways that we see from the program is that workers are
using the money mostly for time off and emergency savings. That
makes sense given the data that most app-based workers are
full-time W-2 employees, so they don't use it to buy health
insurance contributions, and so forth.'' She continued, ``89
percent of the program participants said they're happy with the
program. It's been very beneficial to them . . . . 91 percent
of the program participants said that they would want to remain
independent.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\Id. (Palagashvili testimony).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
MODERN WORKER SECURITY ACT
On February
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 1320, the Modern Worker Security Act, would provide
that, during any assessment of a worker's status as an employee
or independent contractor for purposes of any federal law, a
court or agency will not consider whether the putative employer
provided compensation in the form of what the bill calls a
``benefit.'' Instead of addressing any actual problem for
workers and their families, the bill would advance a misguided
agenda to distract public attention from poverty-level
compensation and likely misclassification by unscrupulous
companies.
This bill is opposed by the AFL-CIO, National Employment
Law Project, National Partnership for Women and Families,
National Women's Law Center Action Fund, and The Association of
Union Constructors.
KEY ISSUES
Benefits Related to Employment
Traditional full-time employment often entails a
compensation package with both regular pay and other non-wage
compensations, such as health insurance, vision and/or dental
insurance, life insurance, and a retirement savings plan, which
are frequently summed up as ``benefits.''\1\ Some are required
under state or federal law, and some are provided
voluntarily.\2\ Among the reasons for such benefits is that
employers have greater purchasing power than individuals in the
market for insurance and other services, and employers'
purchase of such benefits is accorded tax preferences, making
it cheaper for employers to provide non-cash compensations that
workers value highly.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Employee Benefits: The Complete Guide for Businesses, Extensis
HR (June 21, 2024), https://extensishr.com/resource/blogs/employee-
benefits/.
\2\Id.
\3\Ellen O'Brien, Employers' Benefits from Workers' Health
Insurance, 81 Milbank Q.5 (2003).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent contractors--people who are in business for
themselves--take on the risks and burdens associated with any
business, including the costs of health insurance and a
retirement savings plan that would otherwise be covered in part
or whole by employers as benefits for their employees.
Independent contractors can assemble all manner of products
from the private market to cover retirement, health insurance,
casualty insurance, and the like.\4\ Public policy can also
assist people in business for themselves to level up their
access to such benefits. The Health Insurance Marketplace
established pursuant to the Patient Protection and Affordable
Care Act\5\ is one obvious example.\6\ Some states allow
independent contractors to be eligible for universal benefit
programs, such as California's CalSavers program, a state
retirement savings program open to independent contractors,
unemployed jobseekers, and employees of small employers that do
not offer retirement savings benefits.\7\ Another example is
New York's Paid Family Leave Program, which secures income and
benefit continuity during time off to bond with a newly born,
adopted, or fostered child, care for a family member with a
serious health condition, or assist loved ones when a spouse,
domestic partner, child, or parent is deployed abroad on active
military service.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Benefits Basics for Self-Employed Workers, Fidelity (Oct. 31,
2024), https://www.fidelity.com/leaming-center/personal-finance/
benefits-for-freelancers.
\5\Pub. L. No. 11-148 (2010).
\6\See generally FAQs: Health Insurance Marketplace and the ACA,
KFF.org, https://www.kff.org/faqs/faqs-health-insurance-marketplace-
and-the-aca/ (last visited Aug. 21, 2025).
\7\The CalSavers Retirement Savings Trust Act, Cal. Gov't Code
Sec. 100000 et seq.
\8\New York State Paid Family Leave, Paid Family Leave NY, https://
paidfamilyleave.ny.gov/ (last visited May 15, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Misclassification
The value of non-cash compensations factors significantly
when businesses elect to misclassify their workers as
independent contractors rather than employees. The Economic
Policy Institute (EPI) examined some of the occupations most
prone to misclassification and found that being erroneously
classified as an independent contractor was costly for such
workers. For example, a misclassified truck driver annually
loses $21,533-$38,965; a janitorial and cleaning worker,
$7,228-$10,214; and a call center worker, $8,155-$11,539.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Adewale A. Maye et al., Misclassifying Workers as Independent
Contractors Is Costly for Workers and States, Econ. Pol'y Inst. (Jan.
22, 2025), https://www.epi.org/publication/misclassifying-workers-2025-
update/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Misclassification enriches employers at the expense of
workers and the broader public. Law-breaking employers can save
an estimated 30% in labor costs and taxes.\10\ A 1996 study put
the loss of federal revenues at $1.6 billion in 1984 ($5.0
billion today).\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Nat'l Emp. L. Proj., Independent Contractor Misclassification
Imposes Huge Costs on Workers and Federal and State Treasuries 1 (Oct.
2020), https://s27147.pcdn.co/wp-
content/uploads/lndependent-Contractor-Misclassification-Imposes-Huge-
Costs-Workers-Federal-State-Treasuries-Update-October-2020.pdf.
\11\Gen. Accounting Off., GAO/T-GGD-96-130, Issues in Classifying
Workers as Employees or Independent Contractors (June 20, 1996),
https://www.gao.gov/assets/t-ggd-96-130.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The practice appears to be widespread. Although estimates
vary, at least 10%-20% of employers are currently
misclassifying their employees as independent contractors
instead of employees.\12\ A Department of Labor study put the
number as high as 30%.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Nat'l Emp. L. Proj., supra note 10.
\13\Lalith De Silva et al., Planmatics, Inc., Independent
Contractors: Prevalence and Implications for Unemployment Insurance
Programs, Prepared for the US Department of Labor Employment and
Training Administration (2000), http://wdr.doleta.gov/owsdrr/00-5/00-
5.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Legal Tests of Employment Status
To determine whether a worker has been properly classified
as an independent contractor or is instead an employee for the
purposes of a given law, courts and agencies typically consider
a list of factors or questions. In this analysis, the courts
and agencies probe the totality of the circumstances of the
relationship between the business and the worker in order to
arrive at a conclusion under the relevant law. For most federal
laws, such as the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA)\14\ and
the Internal Revenue Code (IRC),\15\ the core question is a
common law test of control.\16\ The Fair Labor Standards Act
(FLSA)\17\ includes a broader set of arrangements under its
``economic realities'' test.\18\ These tests share a common
principle: no list of factors is exhaustive, and no single
factor alone determines the outcome of what is typically a
holistic assessment of the facts of any particular case.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Pub. L. No. 74-198, 49 Stat. 449 (1935) (codified at 29 U.S.C.
Sec. 151 et seq.).
\15\U.S. Code, tit. 26.
\16\See FedEx Home Delivery v. NLRB, 849 F.3d 1123, 1125 (D.C. Cir.
2017); Topic No. 762, Independent Contractor vs. Employee, IRS.gov,
https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc762 (last visited July 31, 2025).
\17\Pub. L. No. 75-718, 52 Stat. 1060 (1938) (codified at 29 U.S.C.
Sec. 201 et seq.).
\18\United States v. Rosenwasser, 323 U.S. 360, 363 (1945) (quoting
81 Cong. Rec. 7,657 (1938) (remarks of Sen. Hugo Black)). The FLSA's
definition of ``employ'' is a standard of ``striking breadth'' that
``stretches the meaning of `employee' to cover some parties who might
not qualify as such under a strict application of traditional agency
law principles.'' Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co v. Darden, 503 U.S. 318, 323
(1992).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FIGHTING A PHANTOM PROBLEM
The Majority claims that this bill is needed to enable
independent contractors to access the same kinds of non-cash
compensations that many traditional employees enjoy. ``While
independent contractors might in some cases have access to
traditional W2 employee style benefits separately through
another job [or] through a spouse, many currently cannot access
benefits as an independent contractor,'' explained bill sponsor
Rep. Kevin Kiley (R-CA) during the markup of this bill. ``And
if they do, they in some cases actually risk being reclassified
as a result, which might even make it, uh, no longer viable,
uh, to pursue their line of work.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\H. Comm. on Educ. & Wrkf. Dems., Markup: HR. 1319, HR. 1320,
HR. 4366, HR. 4312, HR. 4307, at 2:20 (YouTube, July 23, 2025), https:/
/www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zyO0krKLNk (statement of Rep. Kevin Kiley
introducing Amendment in Nature of a Substitute for H.R. 1320).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The problem with this statement is that it does not match
reality. If there is any federal law that prohibits companies
from offering non-cash compensations to independent
contractors, the Majority has not, to date, mentioned it in any
hearing on this topic. If such a law exists, this bill does not
name it, much less repeal or amend it.
In fact, there is no danger that payment in the form of
non-cash compensations would transform legitimate contractual
arrangements into employment relationships. Neither the NLRA
nor FLSA employment test includes any mention of the form in
which compensation is provided. IRS Form SS-8, used to elicit
information about supposed contractual arrangements for an IRS
determinatiod of possible misclassification, does include a
question about whether non-cash compensation was provided; it
is one among 61 questions, several of which have sub-
questions.\20\ Even so, this question is not, by itself,
dispositive:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Form SS-8 (rev. Dec. 2023), IRS.gov, https://www.irs.gov/pub/
irs-pdf/fss8.pdf (last visited July 31, 2025).
Some factors may indicate that the worker is an
employee, while other factors indicate that the worker
is an independent contractor. There is no ``magic'' or
set number of factors that ``makes'' the worker an
employee or an independent contractor and no one factor
stands alone in making this determination. Also,
factors which are relevant in one situation may not be
relevant in another. The keys are to look at the entire
relationship and consider the extent of the right to
direct and control the worker.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Independent Contractor (Self-Employed) or Employee?, IRS (June
2, 2025), https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-
employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee.
Under the IRS's test, then, a firm and self-employed
contractor entering into a truly arms-length contractual
arrangement should have ample evidence of the legitimacy of
that arrangement and nothing to fear from agreeing that some
portion of the contractual compensation be delivered as a non-
cash benefit.
This is the second Congress during which the Majority has
offered this legislation. Despite two hearings and now one
markup, the Majority has yet to offer any evidence whatsoever
that paying an independent contractor through non-cash
compensations has ever changed or will ever change a legitimate
business-to-business contracting arrangement into an employment
relationship.
BENEFITING BOSSES, NOT WORKERS
To address this problem that is not a problem, the Majority
proffers a solution that solves nothing. The Majority describes
this bill as though it does something straightforward: enable
independent contractors to receive from their clients the same
sort of non-cash benefits, such as health insurance, that
employees receive from their employers. Setting aside that
nothing currently bars such unorthodox compensation
arrangements, the only real benefit that this bill would secure
is to hand businesses a roadmap to misclassifying workers,
getting away with it, and calling it an act of generosity.
``Benefits'' Beyond Benefits
This bill redefines the word ``benefit'' to something much
broader than the term's ordinary meaning. The word benefit in
the employment context ordinarily invokes expensive non-cash
compensations such as health insurance and pensions.
Accordingly, the bill's definition of benefit does include some
familiar employment-related benefits: workers' compensation,
disability coverage, health insurance coverage, and retirement
savings. That much, at least, would cover the improbable
scenario of a finn extending its health insurance policy, say,
to cover an independent contractor in addition to the firm's
employees.
The bill does not, however, limit its scope to the benefits
for which employer purchasing power and tax preferences make a
meaningful difference. The bill's definition of benefit
includes several items that depart significantly from the
ordinary meaning of employment-related benefits:
Section 2(b)(1) provides that the term
benefit includes ``a benefit, including a protection''
(neither of which is further defined) provided by a
business in a means that is portable (that is, in a
form ``that the [independent contractor] may maintain
without regard to whether the [independent contract]
continues'' to be engaged in a work for the business).
Section 2(b)(2) provides that the term
benefit includes the usual employment-related benefits,
with a parenthetical list mentioning not just the usual
benefits but also a few oddballs: skills training,
professional development, paid leave, and short-term
savings.
Section 2(b)(3) expands the definition
further to include ``a contribution, financial or
otherwise, with respect to a benefit'' of'' the sort
described in section 2(b)(1)-(2) ``made on behalf of''
a worker.
The definition is on its face so capacious that it could
contain virtually any compensation at all provided to a worker
in a supposed independent contracting relationship, belying the
sales pitch of the bill as enabling independent contractors to
gain access to expensive benefits traditionally associated with
employment, such as health insurance.
The ``Benefit'' of Required Training
Of particular concern is the inclusion of ``skills
training'' and ``professional development'' in the definition
of benefit. Courts applying the FLSA economic realities test
often distinguish between true independent contractors and
those who are actually employees by examining the worker's
preexisting skillset. A distinguishing trait of a true
independent contractor is the possession of ``specialized'' and
``unique training'' enabling the contractor to do work ``that
no other worker could perform.''\22\ By contrast, if a worker
receives the training required for the rendering of services
primarily from the entity needing that work from the worker,
the worker is likely an employee of the entity.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Werner v. Bell Family Med. Ctr., Inc., 529 F. App'x 541, 544
(6th C.tr.2013).
\23\See, e.g., Acosta v. Off Duty Police Servs., 915 F.3d 1050,
1056 (2019) (finding evidence of employment status where security
guards performed simple tasks subject to short-term training provided
by putative employer); Keller v. Miri Microsystems LLC, 781 F.3d 799
(Mar. 26, 2015) (finding evidence supportive of employment status where
satellite dish installers performed work that did not require
specialized skills and where firm required training to ensure
performance within a company's specifications).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This bill would remove any consideration of training or
professional development from all federal employment tests. In
doing so, the bill would upend decades of established law and
fundamentally rewrite the distinction between employees and
independent contractors. Businesses would be encouraged to
misclassify unskilled workers as independent contractors, given
that the businesses could comfortably provide the necessary
training without any worry of it being considered as evidence
of the economic reality of the relationship.
This is, in fact, the second bill put forward by the
Majority this Congress that would give employers a free pass
from wage and hour protections with respect to required
training. Earlier this year, this Committee marked up H.R.
2262, the Flexibility for Workers Education Act, which would
carve out time spent participating in education or training
related to employment from the calculation of a worker's
compensable time for the purposes of minimum wage and overtime.
That bill would enable employers to schedule training essential
to the job and get away with not paying their employees for the
time.
Whereas H.R. 2262 would enable businesses to provide
required training and not pay for their employees' time, this
bill would enable businesses to call such training a valuable
benefit that they are graciously allowed to extend to their
putative contractors. True independent contractors in business
for themselves, marketing their services and unique skills, can
set their own rates and, accordingly, factor the cost of their
own professional development in their rate and likely deduct
the cost as a business expense. They do not need a
misclassification grift disguised as a gift.
Lipstick on a Piggybank
This bill's definition of benefit could encompass something
as simple as a direct deposit of cash in a savings account.
Cash ticks all the boxes in section 2(b) of the bill:
Portability: No benefit is as portable as
cash.
Short-term savings: Cash in a savings
account is a classic form of short-term savings.
Paid leave: For people legitimately in
business for themselves, the standard advice for
setting a freelance rate (in other words, the amount of
cash compensation to require in a contract) typically
counsels contracting at an amount that accommodates
reasonably anticipated vacation and sick time.\24\ Cash
segregated from the base rate and provided under the
header of ``paid leave'' could