Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 1897]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 1897) to amend the Endangered Species Act of
1973 to optimize conservation through resource prioritization,
incentivize wildlife conservation on private lands, provide for
greater incentives to recover listed species, create greater
transparency and accountability in recovering listed species,
streamline the permitting process, eliminate barriers to
conservation, and restore congressional intent, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``ESA Amendments Act
of 2025''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Endangered Species Act of 1973 definitions.
Sec. 3. Authorization of appropriations.
Sec. 4. Rule of construction.
Sec. 5. Renaming of Endangered Species Act of 1973 to Endangered
Species Recovery Act.
TITLE I--OPTIMIZING CONSERVATION THROUGH RESOURCE PRIORITIZATION
Sec. 101. Prioritization of listing petitions, reviews, and
determinations.
TITLE II--INCENTIVIZING WILDLIFE CONSERVATION ON PRIVATE LANDS
Sec. 201. Conservation Benefit Agreements.
Sec. 202. Conservation plans.
Sec. 203. NEPA exemption for incidental take permits.
TITLE III--PROVIDING FOR GREATER INCENTIVES TO RECOVER LISTED SPECIES
Sec. 301. Protective regulations under Endangered Species Act of 1973.
Sec. 302. 5-year review determinations.
Sec. 303. Judicial review during monitoring period.
Sec. 304. Designation of critical habitat.
Sec. 305. Treatment of State, Tribal, and local government data.
Sec. 306. Clarifying significant portion of range of species.
Sec. 307. Delisting criteria.
TITLE IV--CREATING GREATER TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN
RECOVERING LISTED SPECIES
Sec. 401. Requirement to publish basis for listings and critical
habitat designations online.
Sec. 402. Decisional transparency and use of State, Tribal, and local
information.
Sec. 403. Disclosure of expenditures under Endangered Species Act of
1973.
Sec. 404. Award of litigation costs to prevailing parties in accordance
with existing law.
Sec. 405. Analysis of impacts and benefits of determination of
endangered or threatened status.
Sec. 406. Notification of Congress of certain critical habitat
designations.
Sec. 407. Notification of Congress of certain releases of experimental
populations.
Sec. 408. Annual cost analysis by the Fish and Wildlife Service.
TITLE V--STREAMLINING PERMITTING PROCESS
Sec. 501. Limitation on reasonable and prudent measures.
Sec. 502. Successive consultations.
Sec. 503. Clarifying jeopardy.
Sec. 504. Clarifying action area.
Sec. 505. Judicial review.
Sec. 506. Expansion of exemption process and eligibility under section
7 of Endangered Species Act of 1973.
TITLE VI-- ELIMINATING BARRIERS TO CONSERVATION
Sec. 601. Permits for CITES-listed species.
Sec. 602. Utilize Convention standard for permits applicable to non-
native species.
TITLE VII--RESTORING CONGRESSIONAL INTENT
Sec. 701. Limiting agency regulations.
SEC. 2. ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973 DEFINITIONS.
(a) Foreseeable Future.--Section 3(20) Endangered Species Act of 1973
(16 U.S.C. 1532(20)) is amended by--
(1) striking ``The term'' and inserting ``(A) The term''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(B) For the purposes of applying subparagraph (A), the term
`foreseeable future' means the period of time extending into the future
within which the Secretary, based on the best scientific and commercial
data available, is able to determine that a factor described in
subparagraphs (A) through (E) of section 4(a)(1) is likely to occur
with respect to the species.''.
(b) Commercial Activity.--Section 3(2) Endangered Species Act of 1973
(16 U.S.C. 1532(2)) is amended by inserting ``or public display or
education aimed at the preservation or conservation of a species''
after ``organizations''.
(c) Conserve; Conserving; Conservation.--Section 3(3) of the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1532(3)) is amended by
striking ``and transplantation, and, in the extraordinary case where
population pressures within a given ecosystem cannot be otherwise
relieved, may include'' and inserting ``transplantation, and, at the
discretion of the Secretary,''.
(d) Habitat.--Section 3(5) of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16
U.S.C. 1532(5)) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(D)(i) For the purpose of designating critical habitat for a
threatened species or an endangered species under this Act, the term
`habitat'--
``(I) means the abiotic and biotic setting that currently or
periodically contains the resources and conditions necessary to
support 1 or more life processes of the threatened species or
endangered species; and
``(II) does not include an area--
``(aa) outside the current or historic range of the
threatened species or endangered species; or
``(bb) visited by only vagrant individual members of
the threatened species or endangered species.
``(ii) If the setting described in clause (i)(I) does not support all
of the life processes of the relevant threatened species or endangered
species, the threatened species or endangered species must be able to
access, from the setting, other areas necessary to support its
remaining life processes.''.
(e) Best Scientific and Commercial Data Available.--Section 3 of the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1532) is amended--
(1) by redesignating paragraphs (2) through (10) as
paragraphs (3) through (11), respectively; and
(2) by inserting after paragraph (1) the following:
``(2) The terms `best scientific and commercial data available' and
`best scientific data available'--
``(A) mean all relevant and objective scientific and
commercial information available at the time of the agency
action; and
``(B) include credible and reliable data, quantitative
analyses, conceptual and numerical models, and model results
that--
``(i) account for known or potential sources or
error;
``(ii) are applied using prevailing principles,
methods, tools, and professional standards of practice;
and
``(iii) are impartially gathered and objectively
applied without reliance on precautionary assumptions
in favor of a species or other assumptions or policy
prescriptions that bias the application.''.
(f) Environmental Baseline.--Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act
of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1536) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(q) Environmental Baseline Defined.--In this section, the term
`environmental baseline'--
``(1) means the condition of the species or the critical
habitat of the species in the area directly affected by the
agency action at the time of the proposed agency action,
without the consequences to the species or the critical habitat
of the species caused by the proposed action; and
``(2) includes--
``(A) the past and present effects of all Federal,
State, local, and private actions and other human
activities in the area directly affected by the agency
action;
``(B) the anticipated effects of each proposed
Federal project within the area directly affected by
the agency action for which a consultation under this
section has been completed;
``(C) the effects of State and private actions that
are contemporaneous with the consultation in process;
``(D) existing structures and facilities and the
past, present, and future effects of the physical
existence of such structures and facilities on the
species or the critical habitat of the species; and
``(E) the effects of Federal actions being carried
out at the time of the proposed agency action and
existing Federal facilities that are not within the
discretion of the Secretary to modify.''.
SEC. 3. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.
(a) In General.--Section 15 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16
U.S.C. 1542) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a)--
(A) by striking ``subsection (b), (c), and (d)'' and
inserting ``subsections (b) and (c)'';
(B) in paragraph (1)--
(i) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal year
1991,''; and
(ii) by inserting ``, and $287,978,000 for
each of fiscal years 2026 through 2031'' after
``fiscal year 1992'';
(C) in paragraph (2)--
(i) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal years
1989 and 1990,''; and
(ii) by inserting ``, and $105,400,000 for
each of fiscal years 2026 through 2031'' after
``fiscal years 1991 and 1992''; and
(D) in paragraph (3)--
(i) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal years
1989 and 1990,''; and
(ii) by inserting ``and $2,600,000 for each
of fiscal years 2026 through 2031'' after
``fiscal years 1991 and 1992,'';
(2) in subsection (b), by inserting ``and $600,000 for each
of fiscal years 2026 through 2031'' after ``1992''; and
(3) in subsection (c)--
(A) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal years 1988,
1989, and 1990,''; and
(B) by inserting ``and $9,900,000 for each of fiscal
years 2026 through 2031,'' after ``fiscal years 1991
and 1992,''.
(b) Technical Amendment.--Section 15(b) of the Endangered Species Act
of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1542(b)) is amended by striking ``sections 7 (e),
(g), and (h)'' and inserting ``subsections (e), (g), and (h) of section
7''.
SEC. 4. RULE OF CONSTRUCTION.
Nothing in this Act or the amendments made by this Act may be
construed to enlarge or diminish the authority, jurisdiction, or
responsibility of a State (as that term is defined in section 3 of the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1532)) to manage, control, or
regulate fish and wildlife on lands and waters, including Federal lands
and waters, within the State.
SEC. 5. RENAMING OF ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973 TO ENDANGERED
SPECIES RECOVERY ACT.
(a) Renaming.--The first section of the Endangered Species Act of
1973 (16 U.S.C. 1531 note; Public Law 93-205) is amended by striking
``may be cited as the `Endangered Species Act of 1973''' and inserting
``may be cited as the `Endangered Species Recovery Act'''.
(b) References.--Any reference in a law, map, regulation, document,
paper, or other record of the United States to the ``Endangered Species
Act of 1973'' shall be deemed to be a reference to the ``Endangered
Species Recovery Act''.
TITLE I--OPTIMIZING CONSERVATION THROUGH RESOURCE PRIORITIZATION
SEC. 101. PRIORITIZATION OF LISTING PETITIONS, REVIEWS, AND
DETERMINATIONS.
(a) In General.--Section 4 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16
U.S.C. 1533) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(j) National Listing Work Plan.--
``(1) In general.--Not later than the date described in
paragraph (2), the Secretary shall submit to Congress a
national listing work plan that establishes, for each covered
species, a schedule for the completion during the 5-fiscal year
period beginning on October 1 of the first fiscal year after
the date of the submission of the work plan of--
``(A) findings as described in subsection (b)(3)(B);
``(B) any proposed or final determination under
subsection (a)(1) required by a court order, court
decree, or court-approved settlement agreement; and
``(C) any proposed or final designation of critical
habitat under subsection (a)(3) required by a court
order, court decree, or court-approved settlement
agreement.
``(2) Submission to congress.--
``(A) In general.--The Secretary shall submit to
Congress--
``(i) together with the budget request of the
Secretary for the first fiscal year that begins
not less than 365 days after the date of the
enactment of this subsection, the initial work
plan required under paragraph (1); and
``(ii) together with the budget request of
the Secretary for each fiscal year thereafter,
an updated work plan under paragraph (1).
``(B) Additional inclusions.--The Secretary shall
include with each budget request referred to in
subparagraph (A) a description of the amounts to be
requested to carry out the work plan for the fiscal
year covered by the budget request, including any
amounts requested to address potential future listings
of species considered on an emergency basis in that
fiscal year.
``(3) Priority.--
``(A) In general.--In developing a work plan under
this subsection, the Secretary shall assign to each
species included in the work plan a priority
classification of Priority 1 through Priority 5, such
that, as determined by the Secretary, the following
apply:
``(i) Priority 1 represents species of the
highest priority, to be designated as
critically imperiled and in need of immediate
action.
``(ii) Priority 2 represents species with
respect to which the best scientific and
commercial data available support a clear
decision regarding the status of the species.
``(iii) Priority 3 represents species with
respect to which studies regarding the status
of the species are being carried out--
``(I) to answer key questions that
may influence the findings of a
petition to list the species submitted
under subsection (b)(3); and
``(II) to resolve any uncertainty
regarding the status of the species
within a reasonable timeframe.
``(iv) Priority 4 represents species for
which proactive conservation efforts likely to
reduce the effects of the factors described in
subparagraphs (A) through (E) of subsection
(a)(1) on the species are being developed or
carried out, within a reasonable timeframe and
in an organized manner, by Federal agencies,
States, landowners, or other stakeholders.
``(v) Priority 5 represents species--
``(I) for which there exists little
information regarding--
``(aa) the effects of the
factors described in
subparagraphs (A) through (E)
of subsection (a)(1) on to the
species; or
``(bb) the status of the
species; or
``(II) that would receive limited
conservation benefit in the foreseeable
future by listing the species as a
threatened species or endangered
species under this section.
``(B) Use of methodology.--The Secretary shall
establish and assign priority classifications under
subparagraph (A) in accordance with the notice of the
Director of the United States Fish and Wildlife Service
titled `Methodology for Prioritizing Status Reviews and
Accompanying 12-Month Findings on Petitions for Listing
Under the Endangered Species Act' (81 Fed. Reg. 49248;
published July 27, 2016), or any successor document.
``(C) Extensions for certain priority
classifications.--
``(i) Priority 3.--With respect to a species
classified as Priority 3 under subparagraph
(A)(iii), if the Secretary determines that
additional time would allow for more complete
data collection or the completion of studies
relating to the species, the Secretary may
retain the species under the work plan for a
period of not more than 5 years after the
deadline under paragraph (4).
``(ii) Priority 4.--With respect to a species
classified as Priority 4 under subparagraph
(A)(iv), if the Secretary determines that
existing conservation efforts continue to meet
the conservation needs of the species, the
Secretary may retain the species under the work
plan for a period of not more than 5 years
after the deadline under paragraph (4).
``(iii) Priority 5.--With respect to a
species classified as Priority 5 under
subparagraph (A)(v), the Secretary may retain
the species under the work plan for a period of
not more than 5 years after the deadl
Background and Need for Legislation
The Endangered Species Act (ESA, or Act)\1\ was enacted in
1973 ``to provide a means whereby the ecosystems upon which
endangered species and threatened species depend may be
conserved, to provide a program for the conservation of such
endangered species and threatened species, and to take such
steps as may be appropriate to achieve the purposes of the
treaties and conventions set forth'' in the Act.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. L. No. 93-205; 16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.
\2\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The last time Congress significantly amended the ESA was in
1988.\3\ Despite those revisions, the ESA's main provisions
remain intact and govern species conservation efforts today.
H.R. 1897 reauthorizes the ESA for five years and makes
significant changes for the betterment of both the species and
people directly impacted by its regulations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Pub. L. No. 100-478.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill codifies the Trump administration's 2019 framework
for interpreting ``foreseeable future,'' a term that the ESA
uses in the definition of a ``threatened species'' but does not
separately define.\4\ When the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
(USFWS) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
(NOAA) consider the ``foreseeable future'' in relation to a
species, the 2019 interpretation provides that that period can
extend ``only so far into the future'' as USFWS and NOAA
(collectively, the Services) ``can reasonably determine that
both the future threats [to the species] and the species''
responses to those threats are likely.''\5\ Codifying this
original framework, which was ambiguously amended in 2024,
returns clarity and consistency to the process of determining
whether a species qualifies as threatened.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\90 Fed. Reg. 52607.
\5\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 1897 also amends the shared definition of
``conserve,'' ``conserving,'' and ``conservation'' to allow for
the regulated take of threatened species at the discretion of
the Secretary.\6\ Currently, the definition allows for
regulated take only ``in the extraordinary case where
population pressures within a given ecosystem cannot be
otherwise relieved.''\7\ Federal courts have interpreted this
standard to prohibit most regulated take of threatened
species,\8\ raising tensions with the public, which has no
means of controlling listed species populations, even when they
are well above recovery goals. Another change to the definition
allows for regulated take ``at the discretion of the
Secretary,'' therefore granting additional flexibility to the
Services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\H.R. 1897 uses the ESA's definition of the term ``Secretary,''
which is defined in 16 U.S.C. Sec. 1532 as ``mean[ing], except as
otherwise herein provided, the Secretary of the Interior or the
Secretary of Commerce as program responsibilities are vested pursuant
to the provisions of Reorganization Plan Numbered 4 of 1970; except
that with respect to the enforcement of the provisions of this Act and
[the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild
Fauna and Flora, signed on March 3, 1973, and the appendices thereto]
which pertain to the importation or exportation of terrestrial plants,
the term also means the Secretary of Agriculture.''
\7\16 U.S.C. Sec. 1532.
\8\David Willms, ``Unlocking the Full Power of Section 4(d) to
Facilitate Collaboration and Greater Species Recovery,'' The Codex of
the Endangered Species Act, Volume II, available at https://
republicans-naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/
Codex_II_Chapter_3.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, the bill codifies a definition of ``habitat'' to
improve critical habitat designations. The bill's definition
ensures that an area can be considered critical habitat only if
that area provides the resources and conditions necessary for
all the life processes of the relevant species, except under
specific circumstances. In cases when an area does not support
all the life processes, the species must be able to access from
the designated area other areas that can support the remaining
processes. The definition also clarifies that areas outside the
current or historical range of the species or only visited by
vagrant individual members of the species cannot be designated
critical habitat. This definition conforms the statute to the
2018 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Weyerhaeuser Company v.
United States Fish and Wildlife Service, which stated that an
area must logically be considered ``habitat'' for that area to
meet the definition of ``critical habitat'' under the ESA.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Erin H. Ward & Pervaze A. Sheikh, ``Final Rules Amending ESA
Critical Habitat Regulations,'' Congressional Research Service, https:/
/crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11740.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another definition H.R. 1897 codifies is that of ``Best
Scientific and Commercial Data Available.'' This change will
ensure that ESA decision-making is impartial and applied
objectively without the use of precautionary assumptions that
unscientifically skew analysis. This codification is a response
to a 2023 case in which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit ruled that NOAA distorted the
science driving regulations for the Maine lobster industry and
their interaction with whales.\10\ The Court found that the
National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) improperly relied on
dubious assumptions and worst-case scenarios when determining
the risk that the industry posed to right whales. H.R. 1897
requires the Services to comply with this ruling.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Maine Lobstermen's Association v. National Marine Fisheries
Service, No. 22-5238 (D.C. Cir. 2023), available at https://
law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/cadc/22-5238/22-5238-
2023-06-16.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill also codifies into law a definition of
``environmental baseline.'' When conducting interagency
consultations on federal actions, the Services use the
environmental baseline to help determine the effects those
actions have on listed species and critical habitat. The bill
codifies three environmental baseline criteria that are based
upon current regulations: (1) the past and present effects of
all federal, state, and local actions and other human
activities on the area directly affected by the agency action;
(2) the anticipated effects of each proposed federal project
within the area directly affected by the agency action for
which a consultation has been completed; and (3) the effects of
state and private actions that are contemporaneous with the
consultation in process.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\89 Fed. Reg. 24268.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill then adds two new environmental baseline criteria.
As a fourth criterion, it adds ``existing structures and
facilities and the past, present, and future effects of the
physical existence of such structures and facilities on the
species or the critical habitat of the species.'' This change
reflects the fact that the environmental baseline should act as
a snapshot of a species' health at the time of the
consultation. Too often, however, the Services have used the
environmental baseline to create a hypothetical environment
that ignores existing infrastructure. This change will require
the Services to use a more complete picture of current impacts
to species. The bill adds a fifth criterion that requires
consideration of federal actions and facilities that are not
within the Secretary's discretion to modify. This change is
intended to cover actions like the delivery of water from
federal projects to senior water rights holders.
Title I of the bill amends Section 4 of the ESA to codify
agencies' existing efforts to reduce current backlogs in
listing petitions and critical habitat designations through a
``National Listing Work Plan.''\12\ These changes would lower
the risk of litigation in the listing process and allow the
Services to allocate those resources toward the species most in
need of protection. The bill requires the Services to submit,
each fiscal year, a work plan to Congress that covers listing
actions for the next five fiscal years. The work plan must
include information on listing petitions, listing
determinations, and critical habitat designations. In the work
plans, the Services must assign each species a priority
classification, with priority one being the highest and
priority five being the lowest. For example, a priority one
species would be classified as critically imperiled and in need
of immediate action, whereas a priority five species is a
species for which little information exists regarding threats
and its status.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\``National Listing Workplan,'' U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service,
https://www.fws.gov/project/
national-listing-workplan.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Private lands play a significant role in managing and
recovering endangered and threatened species. Renowned 19th
century conservationist Aldo Leopold said it best:
``conservation will ultimately boil down to rewarding the
private landowner who conserves the public interest.''\13\ In
2023, USFWS reported that ``two-thirds of federally listed
species have at least some habitat on private land, and some
species have most of their remaining habitat on private
land.''\14\ According to the Audubon Society, more than 80
percent of the grassland and wetlands that provide essential
bird habitat are in private ownership.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\S.L. Flader, et al., The River of the mother of God: and other
Essays by Aldo Leopold, University of Wisconsin Press, Madison (1992).
\14\``ESA Basics: 50 Years of Conserving Endangered Species,'' U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service, February 1, 2023, https://www.fws.gov/sites/
default/files/documents/endangered-species-act-basics-february-
2023.pdf.
\15\C.B. Wilsey, et al., North American Grasslands and Birds
Report, National Audubon Society, New York (2019), https://nas-
national-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/audubon_north_
american_grasslands_birds_report-final.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To incentivize private landowners to invest in wildlife
conservation on their property, Title II of the legislation
amends the ESA to provide them with greater regulatory
certainty. H.R 1897 codifies into law Conservation Benefit
Agreements (CBA), which allow private landowners to commit to
implementing voluntary actions designed to reduce threats to a
species that is a candidate to be listed under the ESA. In
return, if the species is listed, landowners party to the
agreement would be able to continue their operations.
Currently, these agreements exist only through executive action
and secretarial orders, giving the Services great discretion in
how they take these agreements into account when making listing
decisions. To improve certainty, the bill requires the Services
to take the conservation benefit of these agreements into
account when making listing decisions.
Title II also contains provisions intended to streamline
and provide certainty in the permitting process for incidental
take permits (ITP) and associated voluntary conservation
agreements under Section 10 of the ESA, such as Habitat
Conservation Plans (HCP). ITPs are issued to private, non-
federal entities undertaking otherwise lawful projects that
might result in the taking of a listed species. To issue an ITP
under current law, the Services must confirm that several
criteria have been met, including that issuing such a permit
``will not appreciably reduce the likelihood of the survival
and recovery of the species in the wild.''\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\16 U.S.C. Sec. 1539.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
HCPs are species conservation agreements into which private
entities can enter with the Services after a species has
already been listed under the ESA. Like CBAs, HCPs allow
private entities to continue operations through an ITP if their
conservation measures are followed. These agreements can take
as long as a decade to be approved by the Services, and in some
cases, the Services have reneged on HCPs or leveraged other
federal and state regulatory processes to facilitate additional
restrictions.
To streamline and provide certainty in the permitting
process, Title II binds all parties, including the Services, to
an HCP's requirements. It also explicitly prohibits the
Services from using other federal or state regulatory processes
to require additional conservation measures beyond what is
included in the HCP. Under Title II, federal agencies are
required to adopt the measures included in the HCP for any
authorization related to the action that is the subject of the
HCP. ITPs issued under Section 10 are also exempted from the
duplicative requirements to conduct Section 7 consultation and
a National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) review.
Title III of H.R. 1897 reasserts congressional intent by
providing regulatory incentives and opportunities in the ESA
process. Section 9 of the ESA prohibits the ``take'' of an
endangered species. Take is defined as to ``harass, harm,
pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture or collect, or
to attempt to engage in any such conduct.''\17\ The Act,
however, does not automatically apply the same prohibitions to
threatened species. Instead, Section 4(d) gives the Services
the discretion to grant some exceptions to the take
prohibitions for threatened species.\18\ While NOAA has used
this flexibility,\19\ USFWS manages threatened species as
endangered species, counter to congressional intent.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\16 U.S.C. Sec. 1532.
\18\16 U.S.C. Sec. Sec 1533.
\19\88 Fed. Reg. 40742.
\20\Megan E. Jenkins & Camille Wardle, ``Revisions of the
Regulations for Prohibitions to Threatened Wildlife and Plants,'' The
Center for Growth and Opportunity at Utah State University, October 17,
2018, https://www.thecgo.org/research/revision-of-the-regulations-for-
prohibitions-to-threatened-wildlife-and-plants/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
USFWS began issuing 4(d) rules in 1974, but in 1975 the
agency finalized what has become known as the ``blanket 4(d)
rule'' (blanket rule).\21\ The blanket rule allows USFWS to
extend all Section 9 prohibitions to threatened species unless
a specific 4(d) rule for the species was drafted that exempted
certain activities from those prohibitions. By regulating
threatened species as endangered species, the blanket rule
removes conservation incentives for impacted parties because no
regulatory burdens are relaxed when species are downlisted. In
2019, the Trump administration finalized a rulemaking that
rescinded USFWS's ability to issue blanket rules,\22\ but the
Biden administration reinstated that authority in 2024.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\David Willms, ``Unlocking the Full Power of Section 4(d) to
Facilitate Collaboration and Greater Species Recovery,'' The Codex of
the Endangered Species Act, Volume II, available at https://
republicans-naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/
Codex_II_Chapter_3.pdf.
\22\84 Fed. Reg. 44753.
\23\89 Fed. Reg. 23919.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title III of the bill changes this dynamic by requiring the
Services to include the following whenever they issue a 4(d)
rule that contains take prohibitions: (1) objective,
incremental recovery goals for the species in question; (2)
decreasing stringency of the prohibitions as such recovery
goals are met; and (3) provision for state management of the
species once all recovery goals are met in preparation for the
species being delisted. H.R. 1897 also requires the Services to
account for the conservation and economic effects in their
regulations governing take of threatened species, codifying a
recent decision by the U.S. District Court for the Western
District of Texas in Kansas Natural Resources Coalition v. U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service.
These steps improve accountability and transparency and
incentivize states and private landowners to take conservation
actions that restore habitat for and help recover listed
species, given the tangible regulatory relief that will follow.
The bill adopts a similar approach for the recovery of species
listed as endangered. Specifically, the bill requires the
Services to propose objective and incremental recovery goals
for endangered species. Those goals would form the bases for
4(d) rules when species are downlisted to threatened species
status.
H.R. 1897 also affords each state the opportunity to
propose recovery strategies for threatened species and species
that are candidates for listing in that state. The bill
requires the Services to review a proposed recovery strategy
and determine whether (1) the state would be able to implement
the strategy and (2) whether that strategy would be effective
in conserving the species in question. If it is determined that
both of those tests are satisfied, the strategy is approved,
and it would become the regulation governing the species in
that state.
Additionally, Title III amends Section 4(g), which requires
the Services to monitor, in cooperation with the states, the
status of a species for no less than five years after it is
delisted to ensure that it does not require relisting. The bill
adds language that prohibits judicial review of the delisting
of a species during the five-year, post-delisting monitoring
period. There are many examples of species that have been
successfully delisted through rigorous scientific decisions,
such as wolves and grizzly bears, only to have courts overrule
those decisions.
The legislation gives private landowners the regulatory
certainty to invest in habitat conservation on their lands.
Specifically, the bill prohibits the Services from designating
critical habitat on private lands that are already implementing
habitat conservation and restoration actions designed to
conserve the species in question and approved by the Services.
This provision mirrors languag
Committee Action
H.R. 1897 was introduced on March 6, 2025, by Rep. Bruce
Westerman (R-AR). The bill was referred to the Committee on
Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the Subcommittee
on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries. On March 25, 2025, the
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries held a hearing on
the bill. On December 17, 2025, the Committee on Natural
Resources met to consider the bill. The Subcommittee on Water,
Wildlife and Fisheries was discharged from further
consideration of H.R. 1897 by unanimous consent. Rep. Harriet
Hageman (R-WY) offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute designated Westerman_036 ANS. The Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute, as amended, was agreed to by voice
vote. Rep. Harriet Hageman (R-WY) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Hageman_108.
The amendment was agreed to by voice vote. Rep. Paul Gosar (R-
AZ) offered an amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute designated Gosar_070. The amendment was agreed to by
a roll call vote of 23 yeas to 18 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Rep. Pete Stauber (R-MN) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Stauber #1.
The amendment was agreed to by voice vote. Ranking Member Jared
Huffman (D-CA) offered an amendment to the Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute designated Huffman #1. The amendment was
not agreed to by a roll call vote of 16 yeas to 25 nays, as
follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Rep. Emily Randall (D-WA) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Randall #4.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 17 yeas
to 24 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Rep. Adam Gray (D-CA) offered an amendment to the Amendment
in the Nature of a Substitute designated Gray_019. The
amendment was agreed to by voice vote. Rep. Adelita Grijalva
(D-AZ) offered an amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute designated Grijalva #2. The amendment was not agreed
to by a roll call vote of 17 yeas to 24 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Rep. Debbie Dingell (D-MI) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Dingell #5.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 16 yeas
to 25 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
The bill, as amended, was ordered favorably reported to the
House of Representatives by a roll call vote of 25 yeas to 16
nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
held on March 25, 2025.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title; table of contents
Names the bill the ``ESA Amendments Act of 2025.''
Section 2. Endangered Species Act of 1973 Definitions
Foreseeable Future: Defines the previously
undefined term ``foreseeable future,'' which is used in current
law as a key factor in determining whether a species should be
considered a threatened species. This codifies the definition
the Trump administration adopted in the 2019 rulemaking,
``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Regulations
for Listing Species and Designating Critical Habitat.''
Commercial Activity: Clarifies that public display
or education for conservation purposes does not constitute a
commercial activity under the ESA.
Conserve; Conserving; Conservation: Clarifies the
ability of the Secretary to permit regulated take of listed
species for conservation purposes by eliminating the
prerequisite of an ``extraordinary case'', which has proven
unimplementable.
Habitat: Clarifies that areas that cannot support
listed species' full biological requirements are not classified
as critical habitat.
Best Scientific and Commercial Data Available:
Amends the definition of ``best scientific and commercial data
available'' to ensure that data used in ESA decision-making is
impartial and is objectively applied without the use of
precautionary assumptions in favor of the species.
Environmental Baseline: Defines the term
``environmental baseline'' in the Section 7 consultation
process to include existing infrastructure, ensuring that
operating assumptions in ESA decision-making reflect current
reality, rather than an ideal fiction. The definition also
includes the effects of ongoing federal actions and federal
facilities that are not within the Secretary's discretion to
modify.
Section 3. Authorization of Appropriations
Reauthorizes the ESA through fiscal year (FY) 2031
at levels consistent with the fiscally responsible House FY
2026 appropriations bills and the Majority Leader's Floor
Protocols for the 119th Congress.
Section 4. Rule of Construction
Clarifies that nothing in this bill modifies any
state's primacy over management of fish and wildlife on lands
and waters within that state.
Section 5. Renaming the Endangered Species Act of 1973 to Endangered
Species Recovery Act
Renames the ESA the ``Endangered Species Recovery
Act'' and requires all references in federal documents to
reflect this change.
TITLE I: OPTIMIZING CONSERVATION THROUGH RESOURCE PRIORITIZATION
Establishes a science-based ESA listing work plan
structure that provides greater flexibility in the timing of
acting on petitions to list a species as threatened or
endangered based on the severity of threats to the species,
ongoing conservation efforts for the species, and level of
scientific information on the species' status.
Replaces the unscientific requirement for the
Services to act within 12 months on listing petitions with the
listing work plan framework.
TITLE II: INCENTIVIZING WILDLIFE CONSERVATION ON PRIVATE LANDS
Codifies CBAs, which promote voluntary
conservation and prevent regulatory overreach if the Services
ultimately list the relevant species.
Exempts CBA approvals from the Section 7
consultation process and NEPA.
Prevents the federal government from seeking
mitigation measures beyond what a Habitat Conservation Plan or
other approved permit already requires.
Exempts from the Section 7 consultation process
the issuance of voluntary consultation agreements under Section
10 of the ESA.
Exempts from NEPA incidental take permits issued
consistent with Section 10 voluntary conservation plans.
TITLE III: PROVIDING FOR GREATER INCENTIVES TO RECOVER LISTED SPECIES
Requires the Services to account for the
conservation and economic effects of their regulations
governing take of threatened species.
Requires the Services to establish objective,
incremental recovery goals for threatened species, decrease
regulatory burdens as populations improve, and provide for
state management of species once all recovery goals are met.
Allows states to develop and submit recovery
strategies to the Services for candidate or threatened species.
Permits state-developed recovery plans to become the management
regulations if the Services determine such plans would
effectively conserve the species.
Requires objective, incremental recovery goals for
endangered species to be developed in preparation for when the
species is upgraded to threatened status.
Imposes on the Services a 30-day deadline to
initiate a rulemaking process adjusting a species' status under
the ESA once their own science recommends such adjustment.
Prohibits judicial review within the five-year
monitoring period after a species is delisted, preventing years
of successful conservation work from being undone in a
courtroom by radical environmental groups and activist judges.
Codifies provisions from the 2025 proposed rule,
``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Regulations
for Listing Species and Designating Critical Habitat,'' that
guide the Services in determining whether a critical habitat
designation is necessary, analyzing the impacts of a critical
habitat designation, and establishing criteria for delisting
species.
Requires the Services to consider data submitted
by state, tribal, or county governments when making listing and
critical habitat determinations.
Clarifies that when the Services determine a
species is threatened or endangered only in a ``significant
portion of its range,'' the Secretary must list the species
with respect to only that portion of its range.
Promotes private property rights and voluntary
conservation efforts by preventing critical habitat
designations on private lands when landowners implement land
management plans to conserve listed species. This mirrors
existing provisions from the Sikes Act (16 U.S.C. Sec. 670a).
Provides clear statutory guidelines on the process
and sole criteria that may serve as the basis for delisting
decisions, rectifying the Services' historical practices that
have resulted in species remaining listed despite no longer
meeting the requirements to be listed as threatened or
endangered.
TITLE IV: CREATING GREATER TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN
RECOVERING LISTED SPECIES
Requires the Services to publish online the
scientific and commercial data used as the basis for listings
and critical habitat determinations. Provides exceptions for
data that states or the Department of War do not want to be
made publicly available. Requires the Services to provide to
states affected by a forthcoming species listing all data
justifying the listing.
Requires the Chairman of the CEQ, in consultation
with the Secretary of the Interior and the Secretary of
Commerce, to disclose all costs associated with ESA-related
lawsuits to Congress.
Places a $200,000 cap on the awarding of attorneys
fees in a single ESA-related adjudication and prohibits an
entity from receiving attorneys fees more than three times in a
12-month period.
Requires that when two or more parties are co-
plaintiffs in an ESA-related lawsuit they be considered
collectively in determining whether they are eligible for
attorneys fees.
Requires an analysis of the economic impacts,
national security impacts, and human health and safety impacts
of each listing. This analysis is required to be conducted in
coordination with the states, local governments, and tribes
impacted by the determination.
Requires the Services to submit to the House
Committee on Natural Resources and the Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works a notification of any proposed
designation of critical habitat or any experimental population
area over 50,000 acres. The notification must include an
inventory and evaluation of the natural resource uses and
values of the area, analysis of how those uses may be
incompatible with or in conflict with the proposed designation,
and statements regarding the consultation that took place with
federal, state, and local governments with respect to the
proposed designation.
Requires publication on data.gov of data on the
costs of ESA recovery efforts, including the costs of
experimental populations defined under Section 10(j) of ESA.
TITLE V: STREAMLINING PERMITTING PROCESS
Amends Section 7 of the ESA to prevent the
Services from compelling mitigation as a part of the RPM
process, restoring decades of regulatory precedent. This
provision will ensure the Services cannot weaponize the RPM
process, which Congress intended to be used only to recommend
small modifications without substantially increasing the cost
of projects. Reduces regulatory duplication by separating the
Section 7 consultation process from the MMPA.
Amends Section 7 to require the Services to
determine if longstanding modifications to federal projects
adopted as part of ESA consultation materially benefit listed
species. They must be discontinued if the Services determine
they are not benefiting the relevant species.
Amends Section 7 to require the Services to
conduct consultations based on effects that are caused by the
action itself and that are reasonably certain to occur.
Amends Section 7 to ensure that consultations are
confined to the area directly affected by the agency action. In
addition, requires in instances when a Section 7 consultation
finds a project is likely to result in jeopardy or adverse
modification that the Secretary shall suggest only RPAs that
are feasible for the federal action agency and applicant. The
RPAs must also impose the fewest economic and other relevant
costs for the applicant.
Prohibits judicial review of biological opinions
after 150 days from the date on which the opinion is issued.
Allows access to the ESA Committee during a
Section 7 consultation if proposed RPAs would impair national
security or have significant adverse national or regional
economic impacts.
TITLE VI: ELIMINATING BARRIERS TO CONSERVATION
Streamlines the permitting of international
movement of non-native species by eliminating redundant ESA
permits for species listed under CITES.
Clarifies that CITES ``not detrimental to the
survival of the species'' standard governs permitting
requirements for non-native species.
TITLE VII: RESTORING CONGRESSIONAL INTENT
Amends Section 11(f) of the ESA to clarify that
the Services do not have authority to prohibit otherwise lawful
activities by issuing regulations, independent of existing
statutory authority in Section 11 and Section 8A of the ESA,
that are designed to reduce the mere potential of impacting
listed species.
Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
Performance Goals and Objectives
As required by clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this bill is to amend the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 to optimize conservation through
resource prioritization, incentivize wildlife conservation on
private lands, provide for greater incentives to recover listed
species, create greater transparency and accountability in
recovering listed species, streamline the permitting process,
eliminate barriers to conservation, and restore congressional
intent.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority,
and Tax Expenditures
In compliance with clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee adopts as its
own the estimate of new budget authority, entitlement
authority, or tax expenditures or revenues contained in the
cost estimate prepared by the Director of the Congressional
Budget Office pursuant to Section 402 of the Congressional
Budget Act of 1974.
Congressional Budget Office Estimates
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Earmark Statement
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of the Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to Section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Existing Programs
Directed Rule Making. This bill does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to Section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of Section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Preemption of State, Local or Tribal Law
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of
the United States of America in Congress assembled, That this
Act [may be cited as the ``Endangered Species Act of 1973'']
may be cited as the ``Endangered Species Recovery Act''.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
* * * * * * *
[Sec. 13. Conforming amendments.]
Sec. 13. Disclosure of expenditures.
* * * * * * *
definitions
Sec. 3. For the purposes of this Act--
(1) The term ``alternative courses of action'' means all
alternatives and thus is not limited to original project
objectives and agency jurisdiction.
(2) The terms ``best scientific and commercial data
available'' and ``best scientific data available''--
(A) mean all relevant and objective scientific and
commercial information available at the time of the
agency action; and
(B) include credible and reliable data, quantitative
analyses, conceptual and numerical models, and model
results that--
(i) account for known or potential sources or
error;
(ii) are applied using prevailing principles,
methods, tools, and professional standards of
practice; and
(iii) are impartially gathered and
objectively applied without reliance on
precautionary assumptions in favor of a species
or other assumptions or policy prescriptions
that bias the application.
[(2)] (3) The term ``commercial activity'' means all
activities of industry and trade, including, but not limited
to, the buying or selling of commodities and activities
conducted for the purpose of facilitating such buying and
selling: Provided, however, That it does not include
exhibitions of commodities by museums or similar cultural or
historical organizations or public display or education aimed
at the preservation or conservation of a species.
[(3)] (4) The terms ``conserve,''``conserving,'' and
``conservation'' mean to use and the use of all methods and
procedures which are necessary to bring any endangered species
or threatened species to the point at which the measures
provided pursuant to this Act are no longer necessary. Such
methods and procedures include, but are not limited to, all
activities associated with scientific resources management such
as research, census, law enforcement, habitat acquisition and
maintenance, propagation, live trapping, [and transplantation,
and, in the extraordinary case where population pressures
within a given ecosystem cannot be otherwise relieved, may
include] transplantation, and, at the discretion of the
Secretary, regulated taking.
[(4)] (5) The term ``Convention'' means the Convention on
International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and
Flora, signed on March 3, 1973, and the appendices thereto.
[(5)] (6)(A) The term ``critical habitat'' for a threatened
or endangered species means--
(i) the specific areas within the geographical area
occupied by the species, at the time it is listed in
accordance with the provisions of section 4 of this
Act, on which are found those physical or biological
features (I) essential to the conservation of the
species and (II) which may require special management
considerations or protection; and
(ii) specific areas outside the geographical area
occupied by the species at the time it is listed in
accordance with the provisions of section 4 of this
Act, upon a determination by the Secretary that such
areas are essential for the conservation of the
species.
(B) Critical habitat may be established for those species now
listed as threatened or endangered species for which no
critical habitat has heretofore been established as set forth
in subparagraph (A) of this paragraph.
(C) Except in those circumstances determined by the
Secretary, critical habitat shall not include the entire
geographical area which can be occupied by the threatened or
endangered species.
(D)(i) For the purpose of designating critical habitat for a
threatened species or an endangered species under this Act, the
term ``habitat''--
(I) means the abiotic and biotic setting that
currently or periodically contains the resources and
conditions necessary to support 1 or more life
processes of the threatened species or endangered
species; and
(II) does not include an area--
(aa) outside the current or historic range of
the threatened species or endangered species;
or
Dissenting Views
H.R. 1897, as amended, would fundamentally weaken the
authority and effectiveness of the Endangered Species Act
(ESA). This bill would codify and expand upon the harmful 2019
Trump administration ESA rules\1\ that weakened protections for
threatened and endangered species and their critical habitat.
It would extend the timeframe for listing species through a new
five-tier priority system while fast-tracking delisting and
barring judicial review of delisting decisions. It would
narrowly redefine key terms--including ``foreseeable future,''
``habitat,'' ``best scientific and commercial data available,''
and ``environmental baseline''--to limit the scope of the ESA
and interfere with science-based decision-making by prohibiting
``precautionary assumptions in favor of a species.'' The bill
would eliminate blanket protections for threatened species,
prohibit mitigation in reasonable and prudent measures, exempt
Conservation Benefit Agreements and incidental take permits
from the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and ESA
Section 7 consultation, dramatically expand the ``God Squad''
exemption process to allow economic considerations to override
project-specific species protections, cap attorney fees to
discourage citizen enforcement, and restrict agency regulatory
authority. Additional amendments would impose burdensome
congressional notification requirements for critical habitat
designations and experimental population releases, thereby
disincentivizing the use of conservation tools such as species
reintroduction programs and science-based critical habitat
designations. These changes would hinder federal agencies'
ability to protect species from extinction, regardless of how
imperiled a species may be or what the best available science
indicates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Congressional Research Service (CRS), Final Rules Changing
Endangered Species Act Regulations, (Updated August 27, 2019), Report
IF10944.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Human-related impacts, including habitat destruction,
invasive species, disease, pollution, overexploitation, and
climate change, threaten many species of wildlife and plants.
One million species globally are threatened with extinction.\2\
In the United States, 34% of plants and 40% of animals are at
risk of extinction, and 41% of our ecosystems are at risk of
range-wide collapse.\3\ The loss of biodiversity and ecosystems
worldwide could cost the global economy $2.7 trillion annually
by 2030.\4\ In light of this extinction crisis, the ESA is a
critical tool for preventing extinction and putting imperiled
species on the road to recovery. It is ``the most comprehensive
legislation for the preservation of endangered species enacted
by any nation.''\5\ Over 99% of species listed under the ESA
have avoided extinction, and the law has been responsible for
the recovery of iconic species such as the Bald Eagle, Gray
Whale, Steller Sea Lion, Brown Pelican, and American
Alligator.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\IPBES (2019): Global assessment report on biodiversity and
ecosystem services of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on
Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. E. S. Brondizio, J. Settele, S. D,
and H. T. Ngo (editors). IPBES secretariat, Bonn, Germany. 1148 pages.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3831673.
\3\NatureServe, Biodiversity in Focus: United States Edition
(2023). https://www.natureserve.org/biodiversity-in-focus.
\4\Johnson, Justin Andrew, et al. (2021). The Economic Case for
Nature: A Global Earth-Economy Model to Assess Development Policy
Pathways. World Bank, Washington, DC. http://hdl.handle.net/10986/
35882.
\5\Tennessee Valley Authority v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153, 180 (1978).
\6\Defenders of Wildlife analysis; see also Center for Biological
Diversity, ``On Time, On Target: How the Endangered Species Act Is
Saving America's Wildlife'' (2016). Also see: ``Species Delisted.''
USFWS. https://ecos.fws.gov/ecp/report/species-delisted Last Visited on
January 14, 2026.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Delays Listings and Fast-Tracks Delisting: This bill would
create a new National Listing Work Plan with a 5-tier priority
classification system that could extend the timeframe for
listing some species from the mandatory 12-month deadline to up
to 10 years. Species classified as Priority 3, 4, or 5 may be
retained on the work plan for up to five additional years
beyond regular deadlines--with Priority 5 species potentially
languishing indefinitely if the Secretary determines they would
receive ``limited conservation benefit'' from listing. The bill
provides no recourse if the Secretary misclassifies a species
as a lower-priority species, allowing administrative misconduct
to delay listing decisions legally. Meanwhile, the bill would
fast-track delisting by requiring a rulemaking to be initiated
within 30 days of a five-year review determination and then
barring any judicial review of delisting decisions during the
entire post-delisting monitoring period, which can last five
years or more. These changes would make it harder for species
to be listed and easier for them to be delisted prematurely,
with little recourse to challenge either action. Research
demonstrates that species listed earlier, before populations
reach crisis levels, recover faster and at lower cost.\7\ This
bill would move in the opposite direction.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, ``Report to Congress on the
Recovery of Threatened and Endangered Species, Fiscal Years 2019-
2020.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Establishes Harmful Definitions: This bill is filled with
harmful definitions that depart from decades of established,
working legal standards. It would redefine ``best scientific
and commercial data available'' to prohibit ``precautionary
assumptions in favor of a species or other assumptions or
policy prescriptions that bias the application.'' This
provision would weaponize scientific uncertainty to prevent
protective action. The bill would redefine ``foreseeable
future'' to limit it to periods in which threats can be
demonstrated to be ``likely to occur,'' undermining the
Services' ability to address long-term threats like climate
change. It would redefine ``habitat'' to exclude areas outside
the current or historic range or visited by ``only vagrant
individual members,'' preventing designation of habitat that
could serve as climate refugia or corridors for species
movement. It would codify a narrow ``environmental baseline''
definition that includes ``existing structures and facilities''
and their ``past, present, and future effects,'' treating
ongoing harm as the baseline against which new impacts are
measured.
Guts Critical Habitat Protections: The bill would exclude
unoccupied habitat from critical habitat designation--
regardless of whether species historically occupied these areas
or whether such habitat is essential for species recovery. It
would substantially expand the circumstances under which the
Secretary may determine critical habitat designation is ``not
prudent,'' including when species are threatened by factors
other than habitat destruction or when species ``primarily
occur'' outside U.S. jurisdiction. Most significantly, the bill
would prohibit critical habitat designation on ``any privately
owned or controlled land'' that is subject to a land management
plan the Secretary determines will maintain species
populations. Private land supports approximately two-thirds of
threatened and endangered species,\8\ so excluding these lands
from critical habitat designation puts these species at serious
risk. Yet the bill would exclude such lands if the Secretary
declares the relevant land management plan as ``similar in
nature'' to an Integrated Natural Resources Management Plan--a
standard far weaker than the current critical habitat
framework.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, ``Report to Congress on the
Recovery of Threatened and Endangered Species, Fiscal Years 2019-
2020.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sets Burdensome Congressional Notification Requirements: An
amendment accepted in markup (Sections 406-408) would impose
extensive new bureaucratic requirements on critical habitat
designations and experimental population releases covering
areas greater than 50,000 acres. For each such action, the
Secretary would be required to submit detailed notifications to
Congress including inventories and evaluations of natural
resources uses, economic impact analyses on individuals, local
communities, and the United States, identification of all users
and how they would be affected, analyses of conflicts with
existing uses, documentation of all consultations with federal,
state, and local entities, and statements on effects to state
and local government interests and regional economies. These
requirements duplicate analyses already conducted under NEPA
and existing ESA procedures, adding delay and administrative
burden without improving conservation outcomes. The 50,000-acre
threshold appears specifically designed to disincentivize
large-scale recovery efforts such as the Mexican gray wolf
experimental population in Arizona and New Mexico. The
amendment would also require annual cost analyses of all ESA
expenditures, including those for experimental populations, to
be published on data.gov--further evidence of an intent to
build a political case against successful recovery programs
rather than improve species conservation.
Leaves Threatened Species in Uncertainty: This bill would
put threatened species in peril by effectively eliminating the
blanket 4(d) rule, which currently guarantees the same
comprehensive and immediate protection afforded to endangered
species. The bill would rewrite Section 4(d) to require
species-specific protective regulations that consider
``conservation and economic effects'' and include ``objective,
incremental recovery goals'' with protections that ``decrease
as such recovery goals are met.'' Without the blanket rule as a
default, an already under-resourced Fish and Wildlife Service
(FWS) would need to draft special rules for every threatened
species--or newly listed threatened species could have zero
protections until a rule is finalized. The bill further pushes
threatened species management onto states through a new
process, without requiring clear, objective, science-based
recovery goals at the state level. States already have the
authority to manage ESA-listed species under Section 6(c), but
have not used it. This change would create a confusing
patchwork of inconsistent state regulations.
Weakens Interagency Consultation: The bill would undermine
the Section 7 consultation process in multiple ways. It would
explicitly prohibit mitigation and offsets from reasonable and
prudent measures (RPMs), eliminating a critical tool for
minimizing the impact of federal actions on listed species. It
would create an automatic sunset provision requiring agencies
to discontinue RPMs and reasonable and prudent alternatives
(RPAs) after 10 years if they do not ``materially increase the
likelihood of and reduce the time for recovery''--even if those
measures are successfully maintaining species populations. It
would narrow the ``effects of the action'' that may be
considered to only those that are ``caused by the action itself
and are reasonably certain to occur,'' excluding effects that
are ``remote in time,'' ``geographically remote,'' or reached
through a ``lengthy causal chain.'' It similarly would limit
the ``action area'' to areas ``directly affected'' that are not
``speculative or remote.'' Together, these provisions would
prevent the Services from considering cumulative, indirect, or
downstream effects and would eliminate conservation measures
that are working.
Dramatically Expands ``God Squad'' Exemptions: An amendment
accepted in markup (Section 506) would dramatically expand the
Endangered Species Committee process--commonly known as the
``God Squad''--to sidestep the ESA and allow projects to cause
jeopardy to a species (push a species closer to extinction)
based on economic considerations. Currently, the Committee may
grant an exemption only if it determines that there are no
reasonable and prudent alternatives to the agency action, and
it has been used only twice since the ESA was enacted. The
amendment would allow applicants to seek exemptions whenever a
reasonable and prudent alternative ``may impair national
security'' or ``result in significant adverse national or
regional economic impacts.'' This would fundamentally transform
the exemption process from a last resort for truly
irreconcilable conflicts into a routine escape valve for any
project facing conservation requirements deemed economically
inconvenient.\9\ The amendment would require consultation with
the National Security Council and National Economic Council,
inserting political considerations into what should be science-
based wildlife management decisions. Congress deliberately set
a high bar for exemptions because extinction is irreversible--
this amendment would allow economic calculations to override
species survival, contrary to the ESA's fundamental purpose.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\The Endangered Species Committee, commonly known as the ``God
Squad'', has only been convened a handful of times in the ESA's 50-year
history, reflecting Congress's intent that exemptions be reserved for
truly extraordinary circumstances. Also see: Greenwire. ``Trump
resurrects `God Squad' to bend the ESA''. January 23, 2025. Last
accessed on January 14, 2026.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Undermines Voluntary Conservation: The bill would codify
Conservation Benefit Agreements (CBAs) but exempt them from
both Section 7 consultation and NEPA review and would make CBA
information exempt from FOIA disclosure. It would impose strict
timelines that will burden agency resources--30 days for
completeness determinations and 120 days for approval or
rejection. The bill would also exempt incidental take permits
under this CBA process from Section 7 consultation and NEPA
review, removing essential environmental review safeguards from
decisions that directly affect imperiled species.
Increases Barriers to Citizen Enforcement: The bill would
create extensive new reporting requirements for ESA-related
agency litigation while simultaneously making it harder for
citizens to enforce the law. It would cap attorney fees at $125
per hour--well below market rates--and limit total per-case
fees to $200,000. It would restrict fee recovery to ``eligible
parties'' meeting net worth thresholds ($2 million for
individuals, $7 million for organizations with 500 or fewer
employees) and bar parties that have sought fee recovery in
three or more cases in the preceding 12 months. These
restrictions would make it economically unviable for
conservation organizations to bring meritorious cases enforcing
the ESA, while well-funded industry groups face no such
barriers when challenging protective decisions. The bill
further would limit judicial review by routing all challenges
to biological opinions exclusively to the U.S. Court of Appeals
for the D.C. Circuit, with a 150-day filing deadline--
increasing costs and barriers for parties outside Washington,
D.C. and eliminating traditional venue options.
Strips Agency Authority: The bill would limit the
Secretary's regulatory authority to only Section 11
(enforcement) and Section 8A (the Convention), adding a rule of
construction that this authority ``may not be construed to be
an independent source of authority to promulgate regulations''
to enforce other provisions of the ESA. This would threaten
existing species-specific regulations, including ship strike
rules protecting North Atlantic right whales, turtle excluder
device requirements, and other critical safeguards developed
over decades to address specific threats to imperiled species.
Provides Inadequate Funding: The bill would authorize
approximately $288 million per year for FWS and $105 million
per year for the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) for
fiscal years 2026-2031 (Section 3). These authorization levels
are inadequate to implement the ESA effectively, let alone to
carry out the extensive new requirements the amended bill would
impose, including species-specific 4(d) rules for all
threatened species, new work plans, expanded economic analyses,
and litigation reporting.
Weakens International Protections: The bill would exempt
non-native species listed under both the ESA and CITES Appendix
I or II from ESA permit requirements and create a weaker ``not
detrimental'' standard for non-native species permits. These
changes would complicate efforts to combat wildlife trafficking
and undermine U.S. leadership in international species
conservation at a time when global cooperation is essential to
address the extinction crisis.
Symbolically Renames the ESA: The Hageman amendment
(Section 5) would rename the Endangered Species Act of 1973 to
the ``Endangered Species Recovery Act.'' While seemingly
innocuous, this change signals the bill's intent to reframe the
ESA away from its core purpose of preventing extinction and
protecting imperiled species toward a narrower focus on
``recovery''--even as other provisions in the bill make actual
recovery more complicated to achieve by delaying listings,
weakening protections, and eliminating conservation tools. The
renaming is ironic given that the legislation would gut the
very mechanisms that have enabled species recovery over the
past 50 years.
At a time of accelerating biodiversity loss, H.R. 1897, as
amended, would roll back the ESA's core protections, restrict
agency authority, and codify harmful Trump policies. The bill's
proponents claim it will provide regulatory relief and
incentivize conservation, but in practice, it would delay
protections for at-risk species, make recovery more difficult
and costly, create new legal uncertainties for all
stakeholders, and undermine the citizen enforcement that has
been essential to the ESA's success. The Republican attempts to
undermine the ESA\10\ would hinder federal agencies' ability to
protect species from extinction, no matter how close to
extinction a species may be or what the best available science
says about its status, recovery, or management. Members of the
House should strongly oppose this legislation.
\10\For additional information on the recurring arguments,
misconceptions, and attacks on the ESA--please refer to the memoranda
from hearings during both of the 118th and 119th Congress: July 18,
2023, Oversight hearin