Minority Views
Legislative Branch Oversight
INTRODUCTION
On February 21, 2025, former Proud Boys leader Enrique
Tarrio was arrested and charged with assaulting a woman on
Capitol grounds.\1\ Tarrio had previously been convicted of
seditious conspiracy for orchestrating the January 6, 2021,
attack on the Capitol and was sentenced to 22 years in prison.
However, he was released by President Donald Trump--along with
every other violent criminal who attacked the Capitol that day.
The security implications for the country, the Congress, and
the Committee on House Administration are extremely dangerous
and without precedent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Kyle Cheney, Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio arrested at
Capitol after scuffle with protester, Politico, (Feb. 21, 2025),
https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/21/proud-boys-leader-enrique-
tarrio-arrested-00205513.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One of the Committee's most critical responsibilities is to
oversee Capitol security and ensure the safety of Members,
staff, and visitors. Member offices--both in Washington, D.C.
and in districts around the country--have become increasingly
threatening environments. Since 2016, threats against Members
have increased over 1,000 percent, with investigations by the
United States Capitol Police (USCP) Threat Assessment Section
(TAS) increasing from 902 cases in 2016 to 9,474 cases in 2024.
This situation was exacerbated on January 20, 2025, when
President Donald Trump pardoned or otherwise granted clemency
to every individual charged or convicted for their role in the
January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol, including those
convicted of violently assaulting police officers. Many
individuals released from prison have returned to the Capitol
since their release. For example, Stewart Rhodes, founder of
the far-right extremist group the Oath Keepers, had been
serving an eighteen-year sentence for seditious conspiracy
related to his role in planning the attack. He returned to the
Capitol on January 22, 2025, held an impromptu press
availability in the Longworth House Office Building
basement,\2\ and participated in a press conference at the
Capitol with Enrique Tarrio on February 21, 2025, the day
Tarrio was arrested by USCP for allegedly striking a woman.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Michael Kunzelman and Lisa Mascaro, Oath Keepers founder Stewart
Rhodes visits Capitol Hill after Trump clemency, A.P., (Jan. 22, 2025),
https://apnews.com/article/capitol-riot-pardons-trump-
2e2275ff164550de29c34de8d12886ab.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
President Trump's actions make the Congressional community
less safe by undermining the rule of law, encouraging future
attacks, and emboldening violent extremists. It also re-
traumatizes Members and staff of both parties, along with
nonpartisan institutional staff. It is incumbent on this
Committee to provide rigorous oversight of and work with USCP
and the House Sergeant at Arms to ensure the threat is
adequately mitigated and Members and staff can perform their
duties free of intimidation or threats of violence. The
Committee Minority hopes the Majority will join in these
efforts.
The oversight and authorization activities of the Committee
on House Administration also extend beyond Capitol security to
all Legislative Branch operations. While there are policy
issues in which the Minority ardently disagrees with the
Majority, the Minority appreciates the Majority's partnership
in efforts to both strengthen and modernize the House,
particularly through the Subcommittee on Modernization and
Innovation. We are grateful that the Majority is continuing the
practice started by the Select Committee on the Modernization
of Congress in the 116th and 117th Congresses and continued by
the Subcommittee on Modernization in the 118th Congress to
treat the Subcommittee as a bipartisan entity with an even
number of Majority and Minority Members.
Due, in large part, to recent actions taken by both the
Executive and Judicial Branches, these efforts are occurring at
a critical moment for the House. The Trump Administration has,
over the course of its first month in office, improperly frozen
Congressionally appropriated funds and dismantled
Congressionally authorized federal agencies. Under Article I of
the U.S. Constitution, the Congress is the only authorizer and
appropriator of federal dollars, and it is imperative that the
House continue to expand and reinforce the tools at its
disposal to assert its authority.
In addition, the Supreme Court in Loper Bright Enterprises
v. Raimondo\3\ overruled the Chevron doctrine, which, for
nearly four decades, required federal courts to defer to a
federal agency's reasonable interpretation of ambiguous
statutory provisions the agency administers. As a result,
Congress now must draft legislation with more specificity and
make policy at a more granular level. This will require
increased capacity in the House, including continued
development of advanced drafting tools and the addition of
supplementary subject matter experts to House offices.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Loper Bright Enterprises, et al. v. Gina Raimondo, Secretary of
Commerce, et al.; Relentless, Inc. et al. v. Department of Commerce, et
al., 603 U.S. ___ (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Minority looks forward to working with the Majority to
ensure Members of the House have the resources needed to carry
out their Constitutional duties, including conducting oversight
of the Executive Branch, drafting sufficiently detailed
legislation, appropriating federal funds, authorizing federal
programs and agencies, and providing constituent services.
HOUSE OFFICERS AND OPERATIONS
CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER (CAO)
The Chief Administrative Officer provides vital
administrative, operational, and technical support to House
offices. It is staffed by a wide range of professionals,
including skilled craftsmen, cybersecurity experts,
accountants, audio/visual experts, and more. The Minority
agrees with many of the Majority's CAO oversight priorities. In
addition, the Minority intends to prioritize the following:
Oversee the CAO's new Human Capital Office,
including its efforts to diversify the House workforce
to better reflect the demographic makeup of the nation,
facilitate diversity working groups and mentoring
programs, and follow through on its commitment to
perform the duties formerly within the purview of the
Office of Diversity and Inclusion.
Oversee after action reviews of the 119th
Congressional transition--including New Member
Orientation--and plan the 120th Congressional
transition, implementing lessons learned.
Oversee services provided to district
offices, including the implementation of enterprise-
wide district office WiFi.
Oversee and provide direction on the House's
continued development of its Artificial Intelligence
(AI) policy and use cases, with a particular focus on:
the impact on the legal rights currently protecting
Member and constituent data; Speech or Debate
protection implications; the importance of data quality
and integrity; transparency and ethics; and prevention
of so-called ``Habsburg AI,'' a phenomenon wherein
outputs become less accurate and more biased over time.
Continue oversight of vendor compliance with
the House's AI Policy (HITPOL 8), particularly
regarding the safeguarding of sensitive data.
Oversee the continued rollout of the updated
HouseNet website, including ensuring URLs are correct
and the search function is improved.
Oversee the House's relationship with the
General Services Administration (GSA) and ensure
Members can effectively serve their constituents
through district offices in GSA-owned buildings while
controlling for relevant separation of powers issues.
Oversee operations of the House Child Care
Center, including continued efforts to expand access,
reduce wait list times, and identify efficiencies to
mitigate the need for tuition increases.
Expand the Congressional Staff Academy and
CAO Coach Program, including by adding coaches and
classes tailored to committee staff and administration/
management of Congressional offices.
Oversee award and implementation of new food
services contract(s).
Continue efforts to improve customer service
and communications across all CAO functions and
business units.
Continue oversight of House technology
upgrades, including MyExpenses and MyDelivery.
Support the transition of the per diem pilot
program into a permanent support program for official
travel.
Review proposed reforms to the Office of
Finance and Payroll and Benefits, including potential
implementation of the Select Committee on the
Modernization of Congress recommendation to shift to
bimonthly pay periods.
Oversee the House Retention through
Educational Advancement Program (REAP) (formerly known
as the Student Loan Repayment Program), including
implementation of new reimbursable expenses, such as
educational/professional development expenses,
credentialing, and certain private student loans.
Facilitate implementation of open House
Office of Inspector General recommendations.
Review and oversee information technology
services provided, maintained or hosted by House
Information Resources (HIR), including the Technology
Partner Program and IT support for international
travel.
Continue oversight of Business Continuity/
Disaster Recovery and failsafe procedures to guarantee
continuity of operations.
Continue oversight of House cybersecurity
practices, including network security and threat
prevention.
Provide oversight of the House Disaster
Recovery Program.
Oversee web services activities, including
new Member website development, with a focus on
accessibility, particularly of external vendor-managed
websites, which lag significantly behind House managed
websites.
Oversee continued efforts to move toward
cloud computing.
Work with the Office of Cyber Security, law
enforcement partners, and the House's IT vendors to
stay apprised of and defend against emerging threats to
the House network.
Collaborate with CAO Vendor Management and
other relevant teams to improve transparency,
efficiency, and effective communication between
stakeholders in the House's acquisitions and contract
negotiation processes.
Collaborate with the CAO to train
institutional staff on unique needs of Member and
committee offices.
HOUSE SERGEANT AT ARMS (HSAA)
The House Sergeant at Arms is the chief law enforcement
official and protocol officer in the House. They are
responsible for maintaining security on the House floor and the
House side of the Capitol. The Minority agrees with many of the
Majority's House Sergeant at Arms oversight priorities. In
addition, the Minority intends to prioritize the following:
Oversee continued implementation of the
Residential Security Program initiated during the 117th
Congress, including potential expansion thereof to
account for rising costs of home security systems,
monitoring services, and installation of security
features recommended by USCP.
Advocate for substantial expansion of the
Residential Security Program's $1,000 cybersecurity
allocation, focusing on enhanced data privacy
protection and dark web monitoring capabilities for
Members and their families.
Support enhancement of the Law Enforcement
Coordination program to improve real-time communication
between Capitol Police, local law enforcement, and
Members' offices during district events and public
appearances.
Support expanded District Office Security
Program funding to support enhanced visitor screening
equipment and protocols.
Continue to review the effectiveness of the
District Office Security and Law Enforcement
Coordinator Programs and recommend reforms based on
lessons learned.
Review the HSAA role on the Capitol Police
Board and study potential reforms to the Board.
Partner with the HSAA to identify, pilot,
and procure new technologies that enhance security and
modernize service offerings.
Monitor implementation of security
recommendations made by various security experts in the
aftermath of the January 6, 2021, attack, including
those made by Lt. General Russel Honore's task force,
the USCP Office of Inspector General, Government
Accountability Office, and Architect of the Capitol
Office of Inspector General.
Oversee efforts to improve emergency
preparedness training for Members and staff, both in
Washington, DC and in their respective districts.
CLERK OF THE HOUSE
The Clerk of the House has many responsibilities related to
the legislative process in the House, including calling
Members-elect to order at the beginning of a Congress,
certifying the passage of all bills and joint resolutions,
receive messages from the President and Senate, and more. The
Minority agrees with many of the Majority's Clerk oversight
priorities. In addition, the Minority intends to prioritize the
following:
Monitor the development and implementation
of the Committee Votes Portal to ensure it captures
comprehensive markup data, hearing transcripts, and
amendment processes while maintaining accessibility for
both Congressional staff and the public.
Advocate for expanded integration between
House and Senate legislative systems, focusing on
standardizing data formats and improving the efficiency
of concurrent resolution processing between chambers.
Support the continued development and use of
the Comparative Print Suite.
Review the Clerk's current IT configuration
and redundancy posture.
Oversee the House Document Repository.
Oversee the House Office of Employment
Counsel (OHEC).
Oversee lobbying disclosure process,
including ways to make data more easily accessible for
the general public.
Review standards for the electronic exchange
of legislative information among the chambers of
congress and Legislative Branch agencies.
Coordinate on matters under the jurisdiction
of the House Fine Arts Board and the Capitol
Preservation Board.
Continue review of functions and
administrative operations assigned to the Clerk.
Continue efforts to increase legislative
capacity within the Office of the Clerk, along with
other relevant institutional offices.
Oversee installation of additional
electronic voting stations on the House Floor.
Review of semi-annual financial and
operational status reports; recommend changes in
operations to improve services and increase
efficiencies.
Review the printing needs of the Clerk to
evaluate the potential for eliminating duplication.
Review the application programming interface
incorporated in the Clerk's website.
Oversee preparation of congressionally
authorized publications.
Oversee participation in the Congressional
Data Task Force.
Continued oversight of official reporter
participation in field hearings.
HOUSE OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
The House Office of Inspector General provides
recommendations for improving House financial, administrative,
and technology operations by performing independent and
nonpartisan audit, advisory, and investigative services. The
Committee Minority agrees, in general, with the Committee
Majority's oversight priorities for the House Office of
Inspector General and looks forward to providing direction on
audits and management advisories on a bipartisan basis. The
Minority also looks forward to selecting a new permanent House
Inspector General.
OFFICE OF WHISTLEBLOWER OMBUDS
The Office of Whistleblower Ombuds is a nonpartisan office
that promulgates best practices and provides training for
whistleblower intake in House offices. The Committee Minority
looks forward to overseeing this important office established
during the previous Democratic Majority and encourages the
House community to engage with it for trainings and best
practices in working with whistleblowers.
NEW MEMBER ORIENTATION
The Committee looks forward to planning orientation for
Members-elect on a bipartisan basis so that newly elected
Members can perform their constitutional duties immediately
upon taking their oath of office.
LEGISLATIVE BRANCH AGENCIES
ARCHITECT OF THE CAPITOL (AOC)
The Architect of the Capitol is responsible for maintaining
and preserving the buildings and grounds that make up the
Capitol complex, along with the Supreme Court. The AOC also
plays a role in the physical security of the Capitol and sits
on the Capitol Police Board. The Minority agrees with many of
the Majority's AOC oversight priorities. In addition, the
Minority intends to prioritize the following:
Oversee the newly appointed Architect's
efforts to reform the agency culture and build out his
senior leadership team.
Oversee AOC hiring practices, with an
emphasis on improving diversity across the AOC,
including the C-Suite.
Oversee continued restoration, repairs and
security improvements necessitated by the January 6,
2021, attack at the Capitol.
Review AOC efforts to improve discipline
program and accountability systems, including those
applicable to exempt personnel.
Maintain rigorous oversight of the final
phase of the Cannon House Office Building renovation.
Continue planning for the Rayburn House
Office Building renovation, including identifying
potential swing space.
Review plans and proposals for future
projects in the House Office Buildings and on the House
side of the Capitol.
Oversee implementation of utility system
Minority Views
Democratic Members of the Committee appreciate that
oversight of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has become
increasingly complex in the last decade, due to expansion of
care purchased from private-sector providers and the
realization of the consequences of more than twenty years of
global conflict. Sadly, the increases in defense spending for
the Global War on Terror, which some estimates put as high as
$3.5 trillion, was never appropriately calculated as being part
of the necessary spending increase for veterans' healthcare and
benefits.
Our Republican colleagues cannot wish this fact away. Using
the mechanisms of congressional oversight to undermine VA as an
institution or to denigrate VA civil servants will achieve very
little tangible improvements in healthcare or benefits
delivery. Further, if the majority is so concerned with
containing spending at VA and addressing inefficiencies, they
should be just as willing to focus oversight on non-VA entities
that receive significant taxpayer funding, to include for-
profit healthcare providers and healthcare companies,
information technology contractors, and pharmaceutical and
durable medical equipment companies. To date, the majority has
shown little appetite for this oversight, and their proposed
oversight plan for the 119th Congress indicates more of the
same. For these reasons, the Democratic Members of the
Committee provide these minority views.
BUDGETING
Throughout its oversight plan, the majority makes numerous
references to waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement of VA's
budgetary resources. It is no secret that VA's budget has grown
significantly since the start of the Global War on Terror. This
should be expected, given the increase in veterans becoming
eligible for VA healthcare and benefits, along with the needs
of the aging population of veterans from earlier conflicts. In
addition, VA's successful, expedited implementation of the
Honoring Our PACT Act of 2022 (P.L. 117-168) has expanded VA
healthcare and benefits to millions of veterans exposed to
toxins and hazardous substances.
Committee Democrats strongly disagree with the Republican
oversight plan's characterization of the Veterans Health
Administration's (VHA) ongoing budget shortfall for fiscal year
(FY) 2025 as a ``[failure] to manage its resources properly''
and ``budgetary mismanagement.''\1\ Nothing could be further
from the truth.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\In mid-July 2024, VA informed the Committee of expected funding
shortfalls for both the Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) and VHA.
At the time, VBA was facing a projected shortfall of $2.883 billion for
the current fiscal year (FY 2024), and VHA was facing a potential
shortfall of $11.971 billion for FY 2025. While Congress acted quickly
to address the VBA shortfall, it has yet to address VHA's shortfall. On
October 30, 2024, VA notified the Committee that it had reviewed its
calculations at the conclusion of FY 2024 and determined that it would
not have experienced a shortfall in VBA and in fact had carryover
funding in addition to the funding provided by the supplemental. VA
also determined at the close of FY 2024 that its projected shortfall in
FY 2025 for VHA would not be as significant as originally projected in
July 2024. VA provided Congress its revised estimate for the FY 2025
VHA shortfall on Monday, November 25, 2024. VA is now projecting a
shortfall of $6.6 billion for VHA for FY 2025.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VHA still needs $6.6 billion in additional funding for the
current fiscal year, to support a higher rate of growth for
care purchased from private-sector providers than previously
projected, to complete medical facility equipment purchases
that have been put off due to past budgetary constraints, to
lease additional VHA clinical space, and to fill clinical staff
vacancies. VHA also needs relief for cost pressures occurring
in the pharmacy and prosthetics programs that were not
anticipated when VA originally proposed its FY 2025 budget, in
FY 2023.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\In 2009, through the Veterans Health Care Budget Reform and
Transparency Act (P.L. 111-81), Congress authorized VA to receive
advance appropriations for medical care programs. Since then, Congress
has appropriated funds for the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) one
year in advance of the FY in which they will be used. Therefore, funds
for FY 2025 were originally requested in FY 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
There is always room to refine budget estimates and
tracking of expenditures. We should also seek greater
efficiency and effectiveness in the programs we fund. However,
Committee Republicans must accept that VA has used its
authority under the PACT Act to expedite veterans' eligibility
for VA healthcare and benefits, rather than dragging it out
over eight years. This means veterans who were exposed to
toxins no longer need a service-connected disability to enroll
in VA healthcare, and it has allowed many veterans who were
already enrolled to transition to higher-level priority groups.
Our nation is finally making good on its promise to pay for the
cost of war. The majority also must acknowledge the exploding
cost of providing healthcare in this country, including the
rising cost of prescription drugs and medical devices, and
ensure VHA has the budgetary resources it needs to deliver
world-class healthcare to veterans.
COST OF WAR TOXIC EXPOSURE FUND
The Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund, established by the
PACT Act, represents Congress's commitment to ensuring VA has
the necessary resources to deliver the care and benefits
promised to veterans. Any attempts to modify that fund, whether
in scale or in purpose, as the majority has proposed, risks
undermining VA's ability to properly treat and compensate
veterans for toxic exposure. House Veterans' Affairs Committee
Democrats refuse to renege on our promise.
If modification to the fund is to be made, it must be done
with great care and coordination with stakeholders both in
Congress and outside; i.e., veterans service organizations
(VSOs) and other stakeholders. And there must be consensus
among all those involved that the alteration does not
fundamentally impede progress on addressing toxic exposure. In
the 118th Congress, the majority introduced legislation
addressing this issue that met none of those criteria.
More specifically, the legislation proposed by the majority
last Congress would convert Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund
spending from mandatory to discretionary, cap expenditures into
the fund below levels VA and the Congressional Budget Office
(CBO) currently predict are necessary, and sunset the fund
after 20 years. This risks us returning to a time when
veterans' programs were forced to compete with other domestic,
discretionary spending for prioritization.
Additionally, caps will impair VA's ability to expand the
rolls of those to which it is providing healthcare and
benefits. The addition of any significant new cohorts of
veterans, or new toxic exposure presumptive illnesses, could
quickly outstrip the statutory rate of growth in the Cost of
War Toxic Exposure Fund as proposed by the majority's previous
bill.
The legislation proposed by the majority also narrows the
``purposes'' of the Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund, further
restricting what it may be used for, and adds several new
reporting requirements. This is done because the majority views
the Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund as a ``slush fund'', and
feels VA is using it for expenditures not permitted by the law.
And while we strongly support oversight of federal spending in
general, and Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund spending
specifically, we disagree with the majority's characterization
of the Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund and feel that VA has
strong internal controls over spending from the fund.
Regarding the ``TEF Tax'' in CBO scoring: CBO estimating a
mandatory score for legislation that would have had previously
only had a discretionary one, did not prove to be an impediment
to passing legislation last Congress, as the majority purports.
Rather, House protocols imparted by the majority's leadership
that are extraneous to the rules of the House, required
offsetting of both mandatory and discretionary spending. It is
our anticipation that the majority will continue with this
practice in the 119th Congress. As such, CBO ascribing any
portion of a bill's score as mandatory and attributable to the
Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund is inconsequential, as the
entire cost of a bill (mandatory and discretionary) must be
offset.
Committee Democrats remain committed to delivering on the
promise of the PACT Act, both for current veterans and future
generations. The PACT Act was not intended to be ``one and
done,'' but rather a mechanism for addressing current and
future needs. We will not support legislation that reneges on
that promise. The Committee has yet to receive input from other
committees that would have jurisdiction over legislation on
this topic. And we have not received any testimony from VSOs
and other stakeholders as to the implications of this proposed
legislation. As such, Committee Democrats encourage the
majority to step back from their efforts to radically alter the
Cost of War Toxic Exposure Fund, and recommit to seeking
consensus both within Congress and with stakeholders, on how to
address what issues, if any, have arisen out of the Cost of War
Toxic Exposures Fund.
IMPROPER PAYMENTS
House Veterans' Affairs Committee Democrats generally agree
with the majority's desire to conduct thorough and necessary
oversight into VA improper payments, be they overpayments,
underpayments or payments to ineligible beneficiaries.
Irrespective of governing philosophy or spending priorities,
being a good steward of taxpayer dollars is a goal for every
Member of Congress. And given the sheer volume of benefits and
healthcare claims processed by VA, any percentage of error no
matter how small, will be magnified and could have a
significant real-dollar impact.
As such, it is incumbent that we work with VA to minimize
improper payments, making restitution to beneficiaries when
necessary. Similarly, VA should work diligently at collecting
debts where appropriate. However, care must be taken to avoid
penalizing veterans and other beneficiaries who may have been
receiving greater than warranted payments through no fault of
their own. We have seen in recent years several instances of
systemic VA issues leading to significant amounts of
overpayments. However, veterans and beneficiaries should not be
punished for VA errors, doubly so for those who may be low
income or elderly.
TIMELINESS OF PROCESSING OF BENEFITS CLAIMS
Committee Democrats also agree that the Disability
Assistance and Memorial Affairs Subcommittee should continue to
focus on the accurate and timely processing of benefits claims,
including upon appeal to both the Board of Veterans Appeals and
the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. Veterans deserve no
less. Additionally, we agree that robust oversight should be
conducted into the information technology systems that are
utilized to process claims and manage caseloads. These systems
are in dire need of updating, have lagged far behind IT
development in other functions at VA, and are plagued with bugs
and prone to failure, which impairs the ability of employees to
fully function.
Nevertheless, under the Biden-Harris Administration VA and
its dedicated employees processed record numbers of disability
claims, awarded a higher percentage of those claims, and
delivered record amounts of disability compensation and other
benefits to veterans and other beneficiaries. And that has
happened in record time, avoiding the large claims backlogs of
the past.
Committee Democrats also appreciate the majority's mention
of the new ``Presumptive Decision Process'' created by the PACT
Act. This new expedited process for evaluating and approving
new presumptions of service-connected disability is a powerful
and important new tool. We stand ready to work with the
majority to ensure that the incoming Administration is
utilizing it to the fullest. We must continue to address the
legacy of toxic exposure among servicemembers and their
families, both domestically and abroad. And we must not let
concerns about cost deter us from our sacred obligation to
provide for our servicemembers when they become veterans.
BENEFITS DISPARITIES
What is glaringly absent from the majority's plans for the
Disability Assistance and Memorial Affairs Subcommittee in the
coming Congress however, is any mention of work to address the
alarming levels of disparities in benefits awards among
veterans of color, women veterans and LGBTQIA+ veterans.
Numerous reports by the Government Accountability Office, VA
Office of the Inspector General, and VA's Center for Minority
Veterans have all documented the existence of systemic
disparities among these groups of veterans. VA also has been
undertaking a root-cause analysis to identify why they persist.
Accordingly, it is vital that the Committee and the DAMA
Subcommittee continue to investigate the existence of these
disparities, and work with VA to eliminate them. Claims
processing should be without bias, and VA should strive to
deliver for all veterans.
COMMUNITY CARE
In its oversight plan, the majority expresses considerable
concern about veterans' access to ``community care'' providers;
i.e., private-sector healthcare providers who furnish care at
VA's expense. Completely absent from the majority's plan are
any plans to oversee the cost or quality of care veterans
receive from these providers.
The growth in VHA's community care budget since the first
Trump Administration implemented new wait-time and drive-time
access standards in 2019 is alarming. In fiscal year 2018, the
year before these new access standards were implemented, VHA
spent about $10 billion on community care. Last year, in FY
2024, VHA's community care expenditures totaled about $37
billion.
In March 2024, VHA released a ``Red Team'' report,
detailing the challenges the agency faces in increased
community care utilization and spending. The ``Red Team'' was
assembled by VA's Under Secretary for Health and consisted of a
bipartisan panel of nationally recognized healthcare experts
who assessed VHA's existing strategies and made recommendations
to improve management of VA's community care program. The Red
Team found that while community care is an important strategy
for serving veterans when needed services are not readily
available in VA's direct care system, the costs of such
referrals has risen so dramatically in recent years that they
threaten the funding needed to support VA's direct care system.
During the 118th Congress, the majority failed to convene a
single oversight hearing that examined the cost or quality of
care veterans are receiving through VA's community care
program. Across numerous Congresses, Republicans have stymied
Democratic efforts for greater oversight and accountability of
community care providers, while continuing to advocate for
policies that would push more veterans care outside of VA. For
instance, real-time information about the timeliness and
quality of community care is generally not available to
veterans who are deciding where to get their care, and academic
research shows that private-sector care is often no more timely
or otherwise accessible, nor of superior quality to that of the
care offered by VA.
PARITY OF BENEFITS FOR GUARD AND RESERVE MEMBERS
The majority outlines several goals related to improving
education benefits and outcomes for returning veterans;
however, they fail to offer support for the Guard and Reserve
GI Bill Parity Act, which is the top education priority for
several of the largest VSOs. This legislation would ensure
fairness for Guard/Reserve members when earning Post 9/11 GI
Bill benefits.
In the post-9/11 era, the Reserve Component (defined as the
Army and Air National Guards, and the Army, Navy, Marine, Air
Force, and Coast Guard Reserves) have become an integral part
of the United States' national defense plans as an Operational
Reserve, a change from their traditional role as a Strategic
Reserve. However, personnel and benefits policy has not kept
pace with changes in operational roles. This is putting unfair
strain on servicemembers, employers, and families.
There are increasing instances of servicemembers from the
Active and Reserve Components serving next to each other, doing
the same job, running the same risks, but receiving different
pay and benefits. With the Reserve Component engaged in more
training and operations, which carry inherent risk due to its
role as an Operational Reserve, we are seeing an increase in
major accidents and fatalities among Reserve Component service
members.
This legislation has the support of the Student Veterans of
America, Veterans of Foreign Wars, The American Legion, the
National Guard Association of the United States, and Veterans
Education Success, among others. This legislation has
bipartisan support in the House and Senate and has passed on
the House floor in the 117th Congress with an overwhelming
bipartisan roll call vote.
ACCOUNTABILITY
We agree with the majority that the Committee should focus
oversight efforts on issues pertaining to VA's workforce.
However, we disagree with the majority's assertion that
doubling down on their previously failed, unconstitutional
tactics of stripping away due process rights from VA employees
will provide meaningful change in the organization. We believe
VA could benefit from improvements to supervisor training,
performance management, and a more robust human resources
function, but no organization can be improved by mass firing
and demoralization.
We expect the majority will move quickly to pass their
flawed Restore VA Accountability Act (``Restore Act''), their
latest attempt to authorize removal of VA employees without due
process. As the majority concedes in its Oversight Plan for the
119th Congress, its previous attempts during the first Trump
Administration to dismantle the VA workforce were challenged in
the courts and ultimately found to be unconstitutional
subversions of the due process rights afforded to federal
employees. There is evidence that throughout the Trump
administration, the 2017 law was used disproportionately to
fire thousands of lower-level employees, and only rarely to rid
VA of managers or senior leaders who engaged in misconduct and
poor performance. Litigation arising from the problematic 2017
law resulted in settlements with employees totaling over $150
million, a cost footed by taxpayers. We expect the authorities
in the Restore Act to be similarly challenged and scrutinized
by the courts, resulting in more taxpayer dollars being wasted
on the majority's attempts to undermine the federal workf