Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 6409]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 6409) to amend the Clean Air Act to clarify
standards for emissions emanating from outside of the United
States, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon without amendment and recommends that
the bill do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Committee Action................................................. 3
Committee Votes.................................................. 4
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 6
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 6
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 6
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 6
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 6
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 6
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 6
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 7
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 7
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 7
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 7
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 7
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 8
Minority, Additional, or Dissenting Views........................ 10
Purpose and Summary
The purpose of H.R. 6409 is to clarify the treatment of
foreign emissions under section 179 of the Clean Air Act (CAA).
Background and Need for Legislation
CLEAN AIR ACT
Under the Clean Air Act (CAA) the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) establishes primary and secondary
National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for criteria
pollutants to protect public health. EPA has established NAAQS
for six criteria air pollutants: carbon monoxide, lead, sulfur
dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, ozone, and particulate matter. The
CAA directs EPA to set the primary standards for these
pollutants at a level that is ``requisite to protect public
health,'' allowing for an ``adequate margin of safety.'' EPA
also sets secondary standards to protect ``the public welfare''
from the effects of air pollutions impact on ecosystems and
vegetation.
After EPA establishes a NAAQS, state pollution control
agencies assume primary responsibility for implementing and
enforcing the standards. No later than one year after EPA
promulgates a new or revised NAAQS, each state must recommend
``initial designations'' to EPA regarding which areas are in
attainment based on air quality monitoring data and modeling.
EPA then designates whether an area is in attainment, non-
attainment, or unclassifiable (due to lack of data) for each
NAAQS. States with non-attainment areas are required to submit
and develop a State Implementation Plan (SIP) that demonstrates
how attainment within NAAQS will be achieved by identifying
specific programs, regulations, and emissions control programs
to limit emissions of air pollutants.
Emissions from outside of the U.S. have a significant
impact on the air quality of nonattainment areas in the U.S. In
a nonattainment area impacted by international emissions, a
state air agency may elect under section 179B to develop and
submit to EPA a demonstration intended to show that a
nonattainment area would attain, or would have attained, the
relevant NAAQS by the applicable statutory attainment date
``but for'' emissions emanating from outside the U.S.
Section 179B of the CAA allows EPA to approve a SIP if a
State establishes that in respect to an ozone nonattainment
area within the State, the State would have attained the ozone
NAAQS by the applicable attainment date, but for emissions
emanating from outside of the United States.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\42 U.S.C. 7511(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On December 18, 2020, EPA issued guidance regarding CAA
section 179B, which included recommendations to assist state,
local, and Tribal air agencies that intend to develop a CAA
section 179B demonstration.\2\ In 2025, the EPA announced its
rescission of guidance related to section 179B of the Clean Air
Act.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Env't. Prot. Agency (EPA), ``Guidance on the Preparation of
Clean Air Act Section 179B Demonstrations for Nonattainment Areas
Affected by International Transport of Emissions'' (posted online Dec.
18, 2020) https://19january2021snapshot.epa.gov/sites/static/files/
2020-12/
documents/
final_caa_179b_guidance_december_2020_with_disclaimer_ogc.pdf; See also
86 FR 1105, where the EPA formally issued the same notice of guidance
(Jan. 7, 2021).
\3\EPA, ``Administrator Zeldin Moves Forward with Ensuring U.S.
States Are Not Punished for Foreign Air'' (Apr. 7, 2025), https://
www.epa.gov/newsreleases/administrator-zeldin-moves-
forward-ensuring-us-states-are-not-punished-foreign-air).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FOREIGN EMISSIONS
A significant amount of air pollution for states in
nonattainment is the result of foreign emissions.\4\ States
have no ability or authority to control pollution levels
outside of the U.S. and should not be penalized for foreign
emissions beyond their control; H.R. 6409 would expand the
CAA's section 179 to cover designations and not just final SIP.
States shouldn't be forced to wait until they fully implement
SIP requirements to become eligible for lower emissions
controls if they can demonstrate that foreign emissions are
responsible for air pollution at the time of designation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Information on the Interstate Transport State Implementation
Plan Submissions for the 2015 Ozone National Ambient Air Quality
Standards Under Clean Air Act Section 110(A)(2)(D)(i)(I), Memorandum
from Peter Tsirigotis, Director, Office Of Air Quality Planning And
Standards (issued Mar. 27, 2018), https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/
files/201803/documents/
transport_memo_03_27_18_1.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6409 clarifies that emissions excluded by section 179
of the CAA include all foreign emissions emanating outside of
the United States regardless of whether such emissions result
from human activity.
H.R. 6409 would provide greater certainty around CAA 179
and avoid unnecessary and unfair penalties in areas that would
have attained NAAQS standards ``but for'' international
contributions.
Committee Action
On June 11, 2025, the Subcommittee on Environment held a
hearing on H.R. 6409. The title of the hearing was ``Short-
Circuiting Progress: How the Clean Air Act Impacts Building
Necessary Infrastructure and Onshoring American Innovation.''
The Subcommittee received testimony from:
James W. Boylan, Chief, Air Protection
Branch, Georgia Environmental Protection Division;
Chad Whiteman, Vice President, Environment
and Regulatory Affairs, U.S. Chamber of Commerce;
Paul Noe, Vice President, Public Policy,
American Forest & Paper Association;
John Walke, Director, Federal Clean Air &
Senior Attorney, National Resources Defense Council.
On September 16, 2025 the Subcommittee on Environment held
a hearing on H.R. 6409. The title of the hearing was ``From
Gridlock to Growth: Permitting Reform Under the Clean Air
Act.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Clint Woods, Commissioner, Indiana
Department of Environmental Management;
Mark Gebbia, Vice President, Environmental
and Permitting, Williams;
Ashley Kunz, Senior Director, Environmental
Health and Safety, Micron;
Danny Seiden, President and CEO, Arizona
Chamber of Commerce and Industry;
Kerri Powell, Senior Attorney for Community
Health and Air Program Leader, Southern Environmental
Law Center;
Ali Mirzakhalili, Air Quality Division
Administrator, Oregon Department of Environmental
Quality.
On December 10, 2025, the Subcommittee on Environment met
in open markup session and forwarded H.R. 6409, without
amendment, to the full Committee by a record vote of 14 yeas
and 11 nays. On January 21, 2026, the full Committee on Energy
and Commerce met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 6409,
without amendment, favorably reported to the House by a record
vote of 25 yeas and 22 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held (a) hearing(s) and made findings
that are reflected in this report.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and
Tax Expenditures
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 6409 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to amend
Section 179 of the Clean Air Act to include all foreign
emissions emanating outside of the United States regardless of
whether such emissions result from human activity. The bill
also excludes such emissions from being used to determine
whether an area is in attainment of a National Ambient Air
Quality Standards as part of New Source Review permitting
process.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 6409 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
related hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 6409:
On June 11, 2025, the Subcommittee on Environment held a
hearing on H.R. 6409. The title of the hearing was ``Short-
Circuiting Progress: How the Clean Air Act Impacts Building
Necessary Infrastructure and Onshoring American Innovation.''
The Subcommittee received testimony from:
James W. Boylan, Chief, Air Protection
Branch, Georgia Environmental Protection Division;
Chad Whiteman, Vice President, Environment
and Regulatory Affairs, U.S. Chamber of Commerce;
Paul Noe, Vice President, Public Policy,
American Forest & Paper Association;
John Walke, Director, Federal Clean Air &
Senior Attorney, National Resources Defense Council.
On September 16, 2025 the Subcommittee on Environment held
a hearing on H.R. 6409. The title of the hearing was ``From
Gridlock to Growth: Permitting Reform Under the Clean Air
Act.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Clint Woods, Commissioner, Indiana
Department of Environmental Management;
Mark Gebbia, Vice President, Environmental
and Permitting, Williams;
Ashley Kunz, Senior Director, Environmental
Health and Safety, Micron;
Danny Seiden, President and CEO, Arizona
Chamber of Commerce and Industry;
Kerri Powell, Senior Attorney for Community
Health and Air Program Leader, Southern Environmental
Law Center;
Ali Mirzakhalili, Air Quality Division
Administrator, Oregon Department of Environmental
Quality.
Committee Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 6409 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits or limited tariff benefits.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short title
This section provides the short title, the ``Foreign
Emissions and Nonattainment Clarification for Economic
Stability Act'' or the ``FENCES Act''.
Section 2. Emissions beyond control
Section 2 clarifies the scope of emissions covered by
section 179 by inserting ``regardless of whether such emissions
result from human activity'' after ``but for emissions
emanating from outside the United States'' in several sections.
Section 2 also amends the CAA adding a new section 179C
that provides that, with respect to any nonattainment area
classified as severe or extreme for ozone or as serious for
particulate matter, sanctions for implementation plan
deficiencies under section 179 or fees for failure to attain
the air quality standard under section 185 will not apply if
the State demonstrates it would have avoided the deficiencies
or attained the standard but for: (i) emissions emanating from
outside the nonattainment area, (ii) emissions from an
exceptional event, or (iii) emissions from mobile sources that
are beyond the control of the State to reduce or eliminate. The
inapplicability of sanctions and fees under this section does
not affect any obligations under the Act to implement measures
to attain national ambient air quality standards.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (new matter is
printed in italics and existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
CLEAN AIR ACT
TITLE I--AIR POLLUTION PREVENTION AND CONTROL
* * * * * * *
Part D--Plan Requirements for Nonattainment Areas
Subpart 1--Nonattainment Areas in General
* * * * * * *
SEC. 179B. INTERNATIONAL BORDER AREAS.
(a) Implementation Plans and Revisions.--Notwithstanding any
other provision of law, an implementation plan or plan revision
required under this Act shall be approved by the Administrator
if--
(1) such plan or revision meets all the requirements
applicable to it under the Act other than a requirement
that such plan or revision demonstrate attainment and
maintenance of the relevant national ambient air
quality standards by the attainment date specified
under the applicable provision of this Act, or in a
regulation promulgated under such provision, and
(2) the submitting State establishes to the
satisfaction of the Administrator that the
implementation plan of such State would be adequate to
attain and maintain the relevant national ambient air
quality standards by the attainment date specified
under the applicable provision of this Act, or in a
regulation promulgated under such provision, but for
emissions emanating from outside of the United States
(regardless of whether such emissions result from human
activity).
(b) Attainment of Ozone Levels.--Notwithstanding any other
provision of law, any State that establishes to the
satisfaction of the Administrator that, with respect to an
ozone nonattainment area in such State, such State would have
attained the national ambient air quality standard for ozone by
the applicable attainment date, but for emissions emanating
from outside of the United States (regardless of whether such
emissions result from human activity), shall not be subject to
the provisions of section 181(a)(2) or (5) or section 185.
(c) Attainment of Carbon Monoxide Levels.--Notwithstanding
any other provision of law, any State that establishes to the
satisfaction of the Administrator, with respect to a carbon
monoxide nonattainment area in such State, that such State has
attained the national ambient air quality standard for carbon
monoxide by the applicable attainment date, but for emissions
emanating from outside of the United States (regardless of
whether such emissions result from human activity), shall not
be subject to the provisions of section 186(b)(2) or (9).
(d) Attainment of PM-10 Levels.--Notwithstanding any other
provision of law, any State that establishes to the
satisfaction of the Administrator that, with respect to a PM-10
nonattainment area in such State, such State would have
attained the national ambient air quality standard for carbon
monoxide by the applicable attainment date, but for emissions
emanating from outside the United States (regardless of whether
such emissions result from human activity), shall not be
subject to the provisions of section 188(b)(2).
(e) Designations.--Notwithstanding any other provision of
law, an area within a State may not be designated as a
nonattainment area with respect to any new or revised primary
or secondary national ambient air quality standard for a
pollutant if such State establishes to the satisfaction of the
Administrator that such area would be in attainment with such
national ambient air quality standard for such pollutant but
for emissions emanating from outside of the United States
(regardless of whether such emissions result from human
activity).
SEC. 179C. APPLICABILITY OF SANCTIONS AND FEES IF EMISSIONS BEYOND
CONTROL.
(a) In General.--Notwithstanding any other provision of this
Act, with respect to any nonattainment area that is classified
under section 181 as a Severe Area or an Extreme Area for ozone
or under section 188 as a Serious Area for particulate matter,
no sanction or fee under section 179 or 185 shall apply with
respect to a State (or an area or source therein) on the basis
of a deficiency described in section 179(a), or the failure to
attain a national ambient air quality standard for ozone or
particulate matter by the applicable attainment date, if the
State demonstrates that the State would have avoided such
deficiency, or such standard would have been attained, but for
one or more of the following:
(1) Emissions emanating from outside the
nonattainment area.
(2) Emissions from an exceptional event (as defined
in section 319(b)(1)).
(3) Emissions from mobile sources to the extent the
State demonstrates that--
(A) such emissions are beyond the control of
the State to reduce or eliminate; and
(B) the State is fully implementing such
measures as are within the authority of the
State to control emissions from the mobile
sources.
(b) No Effect on Underlying Standards.--The inapplicability
of sanctions or fees with respect to a State (or an area or
source therein) pursuant to subsection (a) does not affect the
obligation of a State, area, source, or other entity under
other provisions of this Act to establish and implement
measures to attain a national ambient air quality standard for
ozone or particulate matter.
(c) Periodic Renewal of Demonstration.--For subsection (a) to
continue to apply with respect to a State (or an area or source
therein), the State involved shall renew the demonstration
required by subsection (a) at least once every 5 years.
* * * * * * *
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 6409, the ``Foreign Emissions and
Nonattainment Clarification for Economic Stability (FENCES)
Act,'' which seeks to amend the Clean Air Act (CAA) to allow
states to ignore international pollution and remove the ability
of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to impose
sanctions on states that fail to make progress toward reducing
air pollution. The bill would give states that are not even
trying to improve air quality a free pass, without any
incentive to fix the problem. States are already not penalized
for pollution they cannot control--like pollution from foreign
sources or other states--so the CAA changes proposed by this
bill are completely unnecessary.
BACKROUND
The Clean Air Act (CAA) is one of the most successful
public health laws in U.S. history because it has delivered
significant environmental and health benefits while fostering
innovation and economic development. When enacting the CAA
Congress recognized that there may be circumstances that worsen
air quality, at no fault of the states. That is why the CAA
gives EPA flexibility to work with states experiencing elevated
levels of pollution from sources outside of their control, to
ensure that exposure is limited and that states can grow their
economies.
SUMMARY OF THE FENCES ACT
The FENCES Act is a misguided attempt to prevent states
from being held accountable for poor air quality, if they also
happen to experience pollution that originated internationally.
Section 2(a) and (b) of H.R. 6409 amend CAA Section 179B
and adds a new CAA Section 179B(e) that would require EPA to
ignore international emissions when determining whether an area
is in attainment with the National Ambient Air Quality
Standards (NAAQS). If areas experience any transboundary
pollution, the bill would force EPA to designate these areas
with poor air quality as in attainment, even when pollution
levels exceed what the standard says is safe to breathe. The
majority claims this provision would prevent states from being
punished for emissions that they did not cause. However, the
CAA already includes pathways for states to exclude pollution
that originated internationally from the NAAQS accounting
process. Therefore, this provision is not needed.
Furthermore, as heard in witness testimony, requiring EPA
to artificially classify areas with pollution levels exceeding
the NAAQS as in attainment would block the state from issuing
permits for new facilities in that area. The CAA requires new
sources to show their activities will not drive an area with
safe levels of pollution into nonattainment. If this bill were
signed into law, every new source--no matter how well
controlled--would exacerbate an area's actual poor air quality,
and would be unable to secure a permit.\1\ This would actively
harm states and their economic growth. On the other hand,
states can and do approve preconstruction permits for
facilities in nonattainment areas, provided they use advanced
controls and emissions offsets to improve air quality. These
requirements do not exist to punish states, but rather to
ensure that the health of the American public is protected.
This is just one example of how the CAA balances the need to
protect public health and sustain economic growth.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Testimony of John D.
Walke, Federal Clean Air Director, Natural Resources Defense Council,
Hearing on Short-Circuiting Progress: How the Clean Air Act Impacts
Building Necessary Infrastructure and Onshoring American Innovation,
119th Cong. (June 11, 2025); House Committee on Energy and Commerce,
Testimony of Ali Mirzakhalili, Air Quality Division Administrator,
Oregon Department of Environmental Quality, Hearing on From Gridlock to
Growth: Permitting Reform Under the Clean Air Act, 119th Cong. (Sept.
16, 2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2(c) adds a new CAA Section 179C to give areas in
severe or extreme nonattainment for ozone or particulate matter
(PM) a free pass on pollution that comes from outside the
state, from exceptional events, and mobile sources that are
beyond their regulatory control. The section waives sanctions
and fees for states, giving those that are not even trying to
improve air quality a dangerously broad exemption from
accountability without any incentive to fix the problem. By
including ``emissions from outside the nonattainment area'' on
this list, a state could be exempted from all fees and
sanctions for failing to meet CAA requirements due to pollution
originating within the same state, which would be controlled by
the same air regulators. This provision is a gift to polluters
at the cost of public health.
CONCLUSION
H.R. 6409 would harm public health, while actively
hampering American innovation. The FENCES Act would cause
complete permitting gridlock in areas with pollution that
exceed an air quality standard. It will also allow states to
knowingly violate air quality standards without any
consequences or incentives to remedy the problem. This will
make Americans sicker and harm our economy thanks to increases
in lost workdays and school absences. With H.R. 6409, House
Republicans are trying to use accounting gimmicks to make areas
with poor air quality appear much better to benefit corporate
polluters, at the expense of the health of Americans across the
country.
For these reasons, we opposed H.R. 6409.
Frank Pallone, Jr.,
Ranking Member.
[all]