Purpose and Summary
H.R. 5625, the Cashless Bail Reporting Act, introduced by Rep. Mark Harris (R-NC), requires the Attorney General to make publicly available a list of each state and unit of local government that permits the release pending trial on personal recognizance or upon execution of an unsecured appearance bond of a person charged with certain offenses.\1\ Those offenses include those involving a violent or sexual act, such as murder, rape, sexual assault, carjacking, robbery, burglary, and assault.\2\ The bill would also require the list to include offenses that promote public disorder, such as looting, vandalism, destruction of property, rioting or inciting to riot, or fleeing from a law enforcement officer.\3\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\H.R. 5625, 119th Cong. (2025). \2\Id. \3\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Background and Need for the Legislation Bail is the amount of money that a criminal defendant must post in order to be released from custody prior to his or her trial. It is not a criminal fine and bail is not used as a punishment. It exists to ensure that the defendant will appear at all required appearances, including all pretrial hearings and the trial. If a defendant makes all required appearances, the bail is returned to them, even if he or she found guilty by the court, at the conclusion of the trial. The Supreme Court has long held that bail is constitutional. In 1979, the Court explained that ``presumption of innocence has no application to a determination of the rights of a pre-trial detainee during confinement before his trial has begun.''\4\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\Bell v. Wolfish, 441 U.S. 520, 533 (1979). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In addition to requiring bail, judges have the authority to release defendants on personal recognizance without requiring a payment of money. Defendants must promise that they will appear for all hearings and for trial. Usually, defendants are released on recognizance (ROR) if they have a steady job, family or close ties to the local community, and little or no criminal history. Pre-trial release may also be conditioned on certain behavior and activities of the defendant. The defendant, for instance, may be prohibited from contacting or associating with certain individuals or from visiting certain locations. Sometimes, defendants are required to submit to random drug testing. Defendants may also be restricted from leaving their home at certain hours. In most states, defendants who are unable to come up with the total amount of their bail may arrange for their release through a bail bondsman. Typically, the defendant puts up a percentage of the total bond, usually 10 percent, and the bondsman will guarantee the remaining amount to the court should the defendant not appear for any court hearing or trial.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\The American Bar Association, ``How Courts Work,'' (Jul. 16, 2020), https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_education/resources/ law_related_education_network/how_courts_work/bail. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Bail ``Reform'' at the State Level Most recently, Illinois, California, Maryland, New Jersey, and New York have modified their bail practices to eliminate or de-emphasize the use of monetary bail systems. Many of these ``reforms'' have resulted in increases in property and violent crimes. For example, after New York's bail law passed, recidivism rates increased for individuals who had previous violent felony offenses. A March 2023 study by researchers at John Jay College of Criminal Justice found that approximately 72 percent of violent felony offenders who were released without bail were re-arrested.\6\ Before the bail reform law was passed, the recidivism rate for previous violent felony offenders was 62 percent.\7\ The study also found that ``mandatory release significantly increased re-arrest across multiple outcomes for people with a recent violent arrest and with a pending case at the time of the current arraignment.''\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\John Binder, Study: Over 72% of NYC Violent Crime Suspects Freed Without Bail Go On To Commit More Crimes, Breitbart (Apr. 5, 2023), https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2023/04/05/of-nyc-violent-crime- suspects-freed-without-bail-go-on-to-commit-more-crimes/; See also Rene Ropac and Michael Rempel, Does New York's Bail Reform Law Impact Recidivism? A Quasi-Experimental Test in New York City, John Jay College of Criminal Justice 16 (Mar. 2023). \7\Id. \8\Id. at 19. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In New Jersey, one Assemblyman regretted his decision to support bail reform so much that he took it upon himself to warn the Democrat Speaker of the California State Assembly against a similar reform. The Assemblyman wrote in 2017 that bail reform in New Jersey had been an ``absolute disaster'' and that ``the public safety needs of citizens in New Jersey has suffered far greater than could have been imagined.''\9\ The New Jersey Assemblyman asserted that ``dangerous and career criminals are released daily and within hours of arrest'' and that these criminals ``are simply not afraid of committing crimes against citizens and as a result our [New Jersey] crime rate has increased at least 13% since January [2017]. This law is victimizing law-abiding citizens every day.''\10\ He further stated that ``the cost of incarcerating those held awaiting trial were greatly exaggerated'' and that the bail reform ``transferred the cost of `free' bail to the taxpayer rather than the offender.''\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\Letter from Bob Andrzejczak, Assemblyman, First Legislative District, to Anthony Rendon, Speaker, California State Assembly (Jul. 3, 2017). \10\Id. \11\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- There are numerous examples of violent criminals who post no or artificially low bonds due to state or local policies and subsequently reoffend. Most notably, in Waukesha, Wisconsin, Darrell Brooks was released on a $1,000 bond after running over a woman with a vehicle.\12\ He was released on bail despite having a lengthy criminal history, including a charge for aggravated battery and an outstanding warrant in Nevada after skipping bail for a sex-related crime.\13\ On November 21, 2021, Brooks drove his car through a Christmas parade injuring over fifty individuals and killing six, one of whom was an eight-year-old child.\14\ Brooks faced eight counts of intentional homicide, six counts of hit-and-run involving death, two felonies for skipping bail, two counts of domestic abuse charges, and sixty-one counts of recklessly endangering safety for each injured person at the Christmas parade.\15\ He pled guilty and is currently serving six consecutive life sentences plus more than 700 additional years in prison.\16\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\Jorge Velasco, Waukesha Suspect Charged With Homicide After 8- Year-Old Boy Dies From Injuries, Daily Caller (Nov. 29, 2021). \13\Id. \14\Id. \15\Adam Sabes, Darrell Brooks slapped with 71 new charges, Fox News (Jan. 12, 2022). \16\Eliott C. McLaughlin, et al., Darrell Brooks receives 6 consecutive life sentences plus more than 700 additional years in prison for Waukesha Christmas parade attack, CNN (Nov. 17, 2022). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Cashless Bail Reporting Act The Cashless Bail Reporting Act requires the Attorney General to make publicly available a list of each state and unit of local government that permits the release pending trial on personal recognizance or upon execution of an unsecured appearance bond of a person charged with certain offenses.\17\ Those offenses include those involving a violent or sexual act, such as murder, rape, sexual assault, carjacking, robbery, burglary, and assault.\18\ They also include offenses that promote public disorder, such as looting, vandalism, destruction of property, rioting or inciting to riot, or fleeing from a law enforcement officer.\19\ Americans should be able to see what jurisdiction have enacted dangerous and irresponsible policies related to bail when making decisions about where to live, work, or travel. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \17\H.R. 5625, 119th Cong. (2025). \18\Id. \19\Id. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------