Dissenting Views
[to accompany H.R. 7567]
BOOK 2 OF 2
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
April 21, 2026.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
______
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
63-525 WASHINGTON : 2026
BILL EMERSON HUMANITARIAN TRUST ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE III--BILL EMERSON HUMANITARIAN TRUST
* * * * * * *
SEC. 302. ESTABLISHMENT OF COMMODITY TRUST.
(a) In General.--To provide for a trust solely to meet
emergency humanitarian food needs in developing countries, the
Secretary of Agriculture (referred to in this title as the
``Secretary'') shall establish and maintain a trust of wheat,
rice, corn, or sorghum, any combination of the commodities, or
funds for use as described in subsection (c).
(b) Commodities or Funds in Trust.--
(1) In general.--The trust established under this
section shall consist of--
(A) wheat in the reserve established under
the Food Security Wheat Reserve Act of 1980 as
of the date of enactment of the Federal
Agriculture Improvement and Reform Act of 1996;
(B) wheat, rice, corn, and sorghum (referred
to in this section as ``eligible commodities'')
acquired in accordance with paragraph (2) to
replenish eligible commodities released from
the trust, including wheat to replenish wheat
released from the reserve established under the
Food Security Wheat Reserve Act of 1980 but not
replenished as of the date of enactment of the
Federal Agriculture Improvement and Reform Act
of 1996;
(C) such rice, corn, and sorghum as the
Secretary may, at such time and in such manner
as the Secretary determines appropriate,
acquire as a result of exchanging an equivalent
value of wheat in the trust established under
this section; and
(D) funds made available--
(i) under paragraph (2)(B);
(ii) as a result of an exchange of
any commodity held in the trust for an
equivalent amount of funds from the
market, if the Secretary determines
that such a sale of the commodity on
the market will not unduly disrupt
domestic markets; or
(iii) to maximize the value of the
trust, in accordance with subsection
(d)(3).
(2) Replenishment of trust.--
(A) In general.--Subject to subsection (h),
commodities of equivalent value to eligible
commodities in the trust established under this
section may be acquired--
(i) through purchases--
(I) from producers; or
(II) in the market, if the
Secretary determines that the
purchases will not unduly
disrupt the market; or
(ii) by designation by the Secretary
of stocks of eligible commodities of
the Commodity Credit Corporation.
(B) Funds.--Any funds used to acquire
eligible commodities through purchases from
producers or in the market to replenish the
trust shall be derived--
(i) with respect to fiscal years 2000
through [2023] 2031 from funds made
available to carry out the Food for
Peace Act (7 U.S.C. 1691 et seq.) that
are used to repay or reimburse the
Commodity Credit Corporation for the
release of eligible commodities under
subsections (c)(1) and (f)(2), except
that, of such funds, not more than
$20,000,000 may be expended for this
purpose in each of the fiscal years
2000 through [2023] 2031;
(ii) from funds authorized for that
use by an appropriations Act; or
(iii) from funds accrued through the
management of the trust under
subsection (d).
(c) Release of Eligible Commodities.--
(1) Releases for emergency assistance.--
(A) Definition of emergency.--
(i) In general.--In this paragraph,
the term ``emergency'' means an urgent
situation--
(I) in which there is clear
evidence that an event or
series of events described in
clause (ii) has occurred--
(aa) that causes
human suffering; and
(bb) for which a
government concerned
has not chosen, or has
not the means, to
remedy; or
(II) created by a
demonstrably abnormal event or
series of events that produces
dislocation in the lives of
residents of a country or
region of a country on an
exceptional scale.
(ii) Event or series of events.--An
event or series of events referred to
in clause (i) includes 1 or more of--
(I) a sudden calamity, such
as an earthquake, flood, locust
infestation, or similar
unforeseen disaster;
(II) a human-made emergency
resulting in--
(aa) a significant
influx of refugees;
(bb) the internal
displacement of
populations; or
(cc) the suffering of
otherwise affected
populations;
(III) food scarcity
conditions caused by slow-onset
events, such as drought, crop
failure, pest infestation, and
disease, that result in an
erosion of the ability of
communities and vulnerable
populations to meet food needs;
and
(IV) severe food access or
availability conditions
resulting from sudden economic
shocks, market failure, or
economic collapse, that result
in an erosion of the ability of
communities and vulnerable
populations to meet food needs.
(B) Releases.--
(i) In general.--Any funds or
commodities held in the trust may be
released to provide food, and cover any
associated costs, under title II of the
Food for Peace Act (7 U.S.C. 1721 et
seq.)--
(I) to assist in averting an
emergency, including during the
period immediately preceding
the emergency;
(II) to respond to an
emergency; or
(III) for recovery and
rehabilitation after an
emergency.
(ii) Procedure.--A release under
clause (i) shall be carried out in the
same manner, and pursuant to the same
authority as provided in title II of
that Act.
(C) Insufficiency of other funds.--The funds
and commodities held in the trust shall be made
immediately available on a determination by
[the Administrator] the Secretary that funds
available for emergency needs under title II of
that Act (7 U.S.C. 1721 et seq.) for a fiscal
year are insufficient to meet emergency needs
during the fiscal year.
[(D) Waiver relating to minimum tonnage
requirements.--Nothing in this paragraph
requires a waiver by the Administrator of the
Agency for International Development under
section 204(a)(3) of the Food for Peace Act (7
U.S.C. 1724(a)(3)) as a condition for a release
of funds or commodities under subparagraph
(B).]
(2) Processing of eligible commodities.--Eligible
commodities that are released from the trust
established under this section may be processed in the
United States and shipped to a developing country when
conditions in the recipient country require processing.
(3) Exchange.--The Secretary may exchange an eligible
commodity for another United States commodity of equal
value, including powdered milk, pulses, and vegetable
oil.
(4) Use of normal commercial practices.--To the
maximum extent practicable consistent with the
fulfillment of the purposes of this section and the
effective and efficient administration of this section,
the Secretary shall use the usual and customary
channels, facilities, arrangements, and practices of
trade and commerce to carry out this subsection.
(d) Management of Trust.--
(1) In general.--The Secretary shall provide for the
management of eligible commodities and funds held in
the trust in a manner that is consistent with
maximizing the value of the trust, as determined by the
Secretary.
(2) Eligible commodities.--The Secretary shall
provide--
(A) for the management of eligible
commodities in the trust established under this
section as to location and quality of eligible
commodities needed to meet emergency
situations;
(B) for the periodic rotation or replacement
of stocks of eligible commodities in the trust
to avoid spoilage and deterioration of the
commodities;
(C) subject to the need for release of
commodities from the trust under subsection
(c)(1), for the management of the trust to
preserve the value of the trust through
acquisitions under subsection (b)(2); and
(3) Funds.--
(A) Exchanges.--If any commodity held in the
trust is exchanged for funds under subsection
(b)(1)(D)(ii), the funds shall be held in the
trust until the date on which the funds are
released in the case of an emergency under
subsection (c).
(B) Investment.--The Secretary may invest
funds held in the trust in any short-term
obligation of the United States or any other
low-risk short-term instrument or security
insured by the Federal Government in which a
regulated insurance company may invest under
the laws of the District of Columbia.
(e) Treatment of Trust Under Other Law.--Eligible commodities
in the trust established under this section shall not be--
(1) considered a part of the total domestic supply
(including carryover) for the purpose of subsection (c)
or for the purpose of administering the Food for Peace
Act (7 U.S.C. 1691 et seq.); and
(2) subject to any quantitative limitation on exports
that may be imposed under section 7 of the Export
Administration Act of 1979 (50 U.S.C. App. 2406).
(f) Use of Commodity Credit Corporation.--
(1) In general.--Subject to the limitations provided
in this section, the funds, facilities, and authorities
of the Commodity Credit Corporation shall be used by
the Secretary in carrying out this section, except that
any restriction applicable to the acquisition, storage,
or disposition of eligible commodities owned or
controlled by the Commodity Credit Corporation shall
not apply.
(2) Reimbursement of the trust.--
(A) In general.--The Commodity Credit
Corporation shall be reimbursed by the
Secretary for the release of eligible
commodities from funds made available to carry
out the Food for Peace Act (7 U.S.C. 1691 et
seq.) and the funds shall be available to
replenish the trust under subsection (b).
(B) Basis for reimbursement.--The
reimbursement shall be made on the basis of the
lesser of--
(i) the actual costs incurred by the
Commodity Credit Corporation with
respect to the eligible commodity; or
(ii) the export market price of the
eligible commodity (as determined by
the Secretary) as of the time the
eligible commodity is released from the
trust.
(C) Source of funds.--The reimbursement may
be made from funds appropriated for subsequent
fiscal years.
(g) Finality of Determination.--Any determination by the
Secretary under this section shall be final.
(h) Termination of Authority.--
(1) In general.--The authority to replenish stocks of
eligible commodities to maintain the trust established
under this section shall terminate on September 30,
[2023] 2031.
(2) Disposal of eligible commodities.--Eligible
commodities remaining in the trust after September 30,
[2026] 2031, shall be disposed of by release for use in
providing for emergency humanitarian food needs in
developing countries as provided in this section.
----------
FARM SECURITY AND RURAL INVESTMENT ACT OF 2002
* * * * * * *
TITLE III--TRADE
* * * * * * *
SEC. 3107. MCGOVERN-DOLE INTERNATIONAL FOOD FOR EDUCATION AND CHILD
NUTRITION PROGRAM.
(a) Definition of Agricultural Commodity.--In this section,
the term ``agricultural commodity'' means an agricultural
commodity, or a product of an agricultural commodity, that--
(1) is produced in the United States; or
(2)(A) is produced in and procured from--
(i) a developing country that is a recipient
country; or
(ii) a developing country in the same region
as a recipient country; and
(B) at a minimum, meets each nutritional, quality,
and labeling standard of the recipient country, as
determined by the Secretary.
(b) Program.--Subject to subsection (l), the Secretary may
establish a program, to be known as ``McGovern-Dole
International Food for Education and Child Nutrition Program'',
requiring the procurement of agricultural commodities and the
provision of financial and technical assistance to carry out--
(1) preschool and school food for education programs
in foreign countries to improve food security, reduce
the incidence of hunger, and improve literacy and
primary education, particularly with respect to girls;
and
(2) maternal, infant, and child nutrition programs
for pregnant women, nursing mothers, infants, and
children who are 5 years of age or younger.
(c) Eligible Commodities and Cost Items.--Notwithstanding any
other provision of law--
(1) any agricultural commodity is eligible to be
provided under this section;
(2) as necessary to achieve the purposes of this
section, funds appropriated under this section may be
used to pay--
(A)(i) the cost of acquiring agricultural
commodities;
(ii) the costs associated with packaging,
enrichment, preservation, and fortification of
agricultural commodities;
(iii) the processing, transportation,
handling, and other incidental costs up to the
time of the delivery of agricultural
commodities free on board vessels in United
States ports;
(iv) the vessel freight charges from United
States ports or designated Canadian
transshipment ports, as determined by the
Secretary, to designated ports of entry abroad;
(v) the costs associated with transporting
agricultural commodities from United States
Dissenting Views
I am submitting these Dissenting Views to outline the
concerns expressed by myself and my Democratic colleagues
regarding the ``skinny'' farm bill that advanced out of the
House Committee of Agriculture in the early hours of Thursday,
March 5, 2026. Our message is simple: the approach and policies
championed by the Republican majority have done and will do a
grave disservice to America's family farmers and the families
they feed.
Farm bills are not written in a vacuum, and the 2026 Farm
Bill was written in the shadow of the hyper-partisan Big
Beautiful Bill that House Republicans used to decimate the
nutrition title (Title IV) of the farm bill with a $187 billion
cut to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP).
These funds were taken out of Title IV and used to finance tax
breaks primarily aimed for the highest income earners and fund
myriad other priorities, including a nearly $70 billion
investment in farm safety net programs. Many Democrats would
have supported the latter, had Republicans not taken food out
of the mouths of hungry Americans to pay for it. Effectively,
the starting point for negotiating the 2026 Farm Bill was not
the 2018 Farm Bill, but a disassembled, emaciated shell of a
farm bill made of leftovers of the reconciliation process.
Hence, one of Democrats' chief concerns with the 2026 Farm
Bill was and continues to be its failure to recognize and
mitigate the food assistance cuts done via the Big Beautiful
Bill. Food is increasingly expensive thanks to the President's
trade wars and Republican economic policies, a fact even
Republicans openly admit when the media isn't watching. Many
American families are struggling, and thanks to Republican
nutrition cuts, there is now less help available to millions of
children, people with disabilities, veterans and older adults
who cannot afford food.
To make things worse, cuts of this magnitude have negative
downstream effects for America's farmers and blue-collar
workers, including truck drivers, warehouse workers and food
processors. This $187 billion cut to SNAP--the largest cut to
food assistance in American history--effectively takes $25
billion out of the farm economy by reducing the purchasing
power of low-income Americans who spend money on the food our
farmers grow. At a time when farmers need to expand all
markets, curtailing domestic consumption is not only misguided,
but it also flies in the face of the president's call to expand
domestic consumption of U.S. agricultural products.
Part of the $187 cut to SNAP comes from an unfunded mandate
included in the Big Beautiful Bill, which increases current
administrative cost-share for states to 75 percent while
creating a new financial obligation for states to pay for food
assistance benefits themselves. States like Minnesota are
already increasing property taxes as local governments search
for new revenue to replace the millions--and in some cases
billions--of dollars that the federal government is no longer
providing. This is not a solely Democratic issue. The
bipartisan National Governors Association has sounded the alarm
about the negative effect this Republican policy will have on
both blue and red states and have asked for more time to try to
prepare to meet this new unfunded mandate from Washington. At
the bare minimum, a farm bill worthy of broad Democratic
support must acknowledge and address these glaring problems.
The 2026 Farm Bill includes many additional shortcomings
beyond its failure to address the Republican's abandonment of
America's hungry.
The Republican farm bill includes a liability shield for
giant chemical and pesticide corporations, depriving
individuals--farmers and ordinary folk alike--of seeking legal
recourse should they suffer ill health effects due to the use
of or exposure to certain chemical products, including
pesticides. While farmers need tools to manage pests and
produce bountiful crops which they use to feed our communities
and the world, we must never place corporate profits over the
health and wellbeing of the American citizenry.
In addition to shielding pesticide companies, the bill
undermines or entirely waives key environmental laws. It
exempts pesticide discharges into waterways from the Clean
Water Act and Clean Air Act; forest management plans from
updating requirements under the Endangered Species Act; and
allows 10,000-acre commercial timber projects to move forward
without any public participation or environmental analysis. The
bill even mandates a return to the ``10 a.m. policy,'' blocking
the use of beneficial fire to naturally remove flammable debris
in the forests. The Forest Service's own website calls the 10
a.m. policy ``a strategy of the past that unfortunately helped
create the wildfire crisis of today.'' This bill codifies it.
The 2026 Farm Bill also cuts over $1 billion from the
Environmental Quality Incentive Program (EQIP), which I am
comfortable describing as the farm bill's marquee land
conservation program. EQIP is underfunded and oversubscribed.
That's why Democrats made $19.5 billion in new investments in
EQIP and other conservation programs in the Inflation Reduction
Act (IRA). And while these funds were shifted to the farm bill
through budget reconciliation, the Republicans now are using it
as their own private piggy bank. This cut erodes the
investments made by the IRA and makes EQIP less accessible to
farmers who would enroll in the program to improve the health
of their land.
Additional concerns include language that preempts ballot
initiatives passed in California and Massachusetts that set
standards for pork products sold to local consumers. These
ballot initiatives--approved by the residents of those states--
created premium markets for hog farmers. The preemption of
these state initiatives hurts hog farmers who have already
invested capital to bring their farms into compliance with said
initiatives to sell into those premium markets.
The 2026 Farm Bill is also controversial for what it does
not do. As noted at the markup, the Republican majority missed
a huge opportunity to expand domestic markets by passing
permanent year-round E15. Year-round E15 would create a
consistent market for America's farmers--a market that is
sorely needed after export markets have dried up and trade
relationships have frayed because of President Trump's ill-
conceived tariffs.
When Democrats offered an amendment to add year-round E15,
Republicans used their majority to block debate. Why? Because
they did not want to draw attention to their failure to get the
job done. At the very least, year-round E15 deserved a robust
debate at the markup. Anything less is a disservice to American
farmers who would benefit from an Agriculture Committee that
fights fiercely for them--even if it offends the sensibilities
of another House Committee.
The 2026 Farm Bill also does not provide additional farm
relief for the family farmers suffering from tariffs and trade
wars. Everyone agrees that the $11 billion for row crops and
less than $1 billion offered to specialty crops in the Trump
administration's farm aid package is woefully inadequate. The
American Farm Bureau estimates that recent losses amount to
over $50 billion. It was frankly shocking to see an amendment
to provide an additional $17 billion in farm aid dismissed by
Republicans so nonchalantly. Farmers, at no fault of their own,
are caught between nations as the president chaotically and
without any apparent forethought levies and cancels and changes
tariff rates. They need and deserve our help.
Many other concerns with the bill persist, including the
fact that the 2026 Farm Bill simply rubberstamps preexisting
programs at 2018 budget levels, without any adjustment for
inflation or new investments that farmers and rural communities
desperately need.
House Democrats warned innumerable times against the
majority taking a partisan approach to enacting farm policy but
have been ignored every step of the way. We were ignored in
2024, and we were ignored this year. There are some good
provisions in this bill just as there were some good provisions
in H.R. 1. But broad political support for those good
provisions is jeopardized by the hyper-partisanship Republicans
seem to be promoting not just with agricultural policy but with
every piece of legislation in the House.
Republicans have taken great glee in breaking the farm-
environment-nutrition coalition that has been behind the
successful completion of decades of farm bills and agriculture
policy. But that shortsighted approach, combined with their
hyper-partisanship, has resulted in the longest delay ever in
getting a full five-year, twelve-title farm bill reauthorized.
This bill demonstrates that delaying the enactment of crucial
farm policy is a price Republicans are willing to pay for their
partisanship.
Ultimately, results speak for themselves. Whether it is a
farm bill, farm aid or E15/biofuels policy, the American people
are looking for results. House Agriculture Democrats remain
willing to work with anyone to improve the lives of America's
farmers and the communities they feed. Hopefully, Republicans
can relearn the lesson that results and long-lasting, good
policy does not come from ideological purity but by reaching
out across the aisle and building broad coalitions. If not,
American farmers could be left wanting for some time.
Sincerely,
Angie Craig,
Ranking Member.
[all]