Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8646] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for Ag-riculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies for fiscal year 2027. CONTENTS Page Title I--Agricultural Programs................................... 2 Title II--Farm Production and Conservation Programs.............. 51 Title III--Rural Development Programs............................ 61 Title IV--Domestic Food Programs................................. 74 Title V--Foreign Assistance and Related Programs................. 81 Title VI--Related Agencies and Food and Drug Administration...... 83 Title VII--General Provisions.................................... 116 OVERVIEW The Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Subcommittee has jurisdiction over the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) except for the Forest Service, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and the Farm Credit Administration (FCA). The Subcommittee's responsibility covers matters of importance to Americans every day of the year. The funding levels provided in this appropriations bill continue to demonstrate how seriously this Committee takes its responsibility to fund the highest priority programs and activities while helping to address the nation's debt, deficit, and economic challenges. The Committee does not include funding to begin new programs and does not provide funding for climate hubs or climate corps activities. The bill maintains critical funding to ensure we have the safest food, drugs, and devices in the world and puts America's farmers, ranchers, and rural communities first. In this report, ``the Committees'' refers to the Committees on Appropriations of the House of Representatives and the Senate. TITLE I AGRICULTURAL PROGRAMS Processing, Research, and Marketing Office of the Secretary (INCLUDING TRANSFERS OF FUNDS) The following table reflects the amount provided by the Committee for each office and activity: [Dollars in thousands] ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Committee provision ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Office of the Secretary.................................... $6,000 Office of Homeland Security................................ 15,259 Office of Tribal Relations................................. 5,190 Office of Partnerships and Public Engagement............... 2,000 Office of the Assistant Secretary for Administration....... 1,300 Departmental Administration................................ 17,015 Office of the Assistant Secretary for Congressional 3,500 Relations and Intergovernmental Affairs................... Office of Communications................................... 4,997 ------------ Total, Office of the Secretary......................... $55,261 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ For the Office of the Secretary, the Committee provides an appropriation of $55,261,000. Similar to prior years, the Committee does not include direct funding for activities that are currently funded through other resources, such as the Working Capital Fund, or that have historically been funded through other means. Within the funds provided for Office of Partnership and Public Engagement, USDA is encouraged to continue the policy center. Assistance for Specialty Crop Producers.--The Committee directs USDA to distribute payments under the Assistance for Specialty Crop Farmers Program announced on February 13, 2026, and any subsequent assistance program initiated by the Secretary under the authority of the Commodity Credit Corporation Charter Act, to producers of a specialty crop, as defined in section 3 of the Specialty Crops Competitiveness Act of 2004 (7 U.S.C. 1621 note; Public Law 108-465), consistent with the terms and conditions as the Marketing Assistance for Specialty Crops, except that the Secretary is encouraged to use a consistent payment factor for all producers. Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) Report.--The Committee directs the Secretary to provide a report on November 15, 2026, and May 15, 2027 on planned uses of funding under the authorities of Section 4 and Section 11 of the CCC Charter Act. CCC Obligations and Commitments.--The Secretary is directed to notify the Committees in writing 15 days prior to any announcement on the use or cancelation of funds from the CCC or the obligation, commitment, transfer, or cancelation of any emergency funds from the CCC. Communication from USDA.--A collaborative working relationship between the Committee and USDA is necessary to ensure efficient and effective implementation of Congress' funding decisions. USDA is directed to continue notifying the Committee of major changes to existing policies and any significant developments in its operations before providing non-governmental stakeholders such information, before making the changes public, and before implementing them. Credit Subsidy Rates.--In preparation for the appropriations process for fiscal year 2028, the Committee directs USDA to transmit to the Committee the estimated credit subsidy rates for fiscal year 2028 for each program for which amounts are provided in the Act for gross obligations for the principal amount of direct or guaranteed loans no later than March 1, 2027. Critical Inputs.--The Committee reiterates the importance of securing the agricultural supply chain. The Committee awaits the reports requested in H.Rpt. 119-172 and S.Rpt. 119-37 and directs the Secretary, in conjunction with other Federal partners, to develop a long-term strategy to decrease the dependency on the People's Republic of China for critical agricultural inputs, such as but not limited to amino acids, vitamins, fertilizers, and pesticides. The Committee notes concern about the nation's limited infrastructure to produce these essential critical inputs and expects the Secretary to develop a procurement plan that results in purchases directly from domestic manufacturers and to conduct modeling studies to determine the appropriate amount needed for stockpiling as part of the long-term strategy. The Committee directs the Secretary to submit a report on these activities within 90 days of enactment of this Act, including any impediments or challenges to completing this strategy. Customer Service.--The Committee continues to support USDA's efforts to improve customer service. The Committee directs the Secretary to develop standards to improve customer service and incorporate the standards into the performance plans required under 31 U.S.C. 1115 and expects the report on these efforts as requested in H.Rpt. 119-172. Further, the Committee notes that the AskUSDA contact center is not currently operational and encourages the Department to evaluate options to reestablish the center through a pilot program and report back to the Committee within 90 days of enactment of this Act. Digital Identity Solutions.--The Committee notes the growing need to modernize online identity verification solutions across government to protect against fraud and strengthen digital identity nationwide through multi-layered, high assurance verification that delivers a more secure, seamless experience while saving taxpayer dollars. The Committee encourages USDA to utilize solutions that support high-assurance identity proofing and authentication independently certified to meet or exceed National Institute of Standards and Technology Identity Assurance Level 2 guidelines to achieve the highest possible pass rates, fraud prevention, and cost reduction. Food Classification and Nutrient-Dense Foods.--The Committee notes that FDA and USDA published a joint Request for Information (90 FR 35305) seeking data to develop a uniform definition of ultra-processed foods. The Committee encourages FDA and USDA to ensure that any food classification system or definition is evidence-based, accounts for the full nutritional profile of foods, and does not inadvertently misclassify nutrient-dense foods, such as yogurt, that provide shortfall nutrients such as calcium, vitamin D, potassium, and fiber, as well as high-quality protein. The Committee encourages the agencies to consult with stakeholders throughout this process and be mindful of any impact on food prices and food availability as well as to consider the potential impact on Federal nutrition programs and on vulnerable populations. The Committee further encourages that medical foods, foods for special dietary uses, and infant formula be excluded from any such framework, and that the agencies engage in notice-and- comment rulemaking before implementing any food classification or definition. Fruit Fly Quarantine Areas.--The Committee is aware of quarantines in California as a result of detections of Oriental fruit fly and Queensland fruit fly. The Committee recognizes the importance of the Animal Plant and Health Inspection Service (APHIS) Plant Protection and Quarantine in safeguarding crops and forests against the entry, establishment, and spread of pests. However, with very few treatment options available for crops located within the California quarantine areas, farmers have faced devastating losses. The Committee urges APHIS to take the necessary steps to resolve the infestation so that the quarantine may be lifted. Further, USDA is directed through all agencies, including those within Farm Production and Conservation (FPAC), to evaluate available financial assistance for producers impacted by the quarantines and provide a report of its findings as requested in H.Rpt. 119- 172. Within the report, USDA is encouraged to provide recommendations on program changes that would make them more accessible and beneficial to producers negatively impacted by quarantines. Grain Terminals.--The Committee notes the regularly recurring contract negotiations between West Coast grain terminal operators and the International Longshore and Warehouse Union and recognizes the importance of reaching agreements that work for both parties. Failure to reach agreements could result in an interruption in grain terminal services that would negatively impact the nation's grain exports. The Committee urges all parties to continue negotiating the respective service contracts in good faith to ensure equitable outcomes for both grain terminal operators and their workers when these contracts come up for their customary periodic renegotiation. Growing the Domestic Cattle Herd.--The Committee urges USDA, alongside American ranchers and relevant State and Federal agencies, to develop a strategy to grow the domestic cattle herd. Breeding efforts to grow herd sizes carry high risk for ranchers and operators, especially in the first three years. Growing the domestic herd is key to reducing consumer prices for beef, but ranchers need financial incentives and certainty to invest in breeding. Input Costs.--The Committee recognizes the rising cost of critical inputs like fertilizer and directs the Secretary to conduct an assessment of the factors driving high fertilizer costs, including regulations and industry concentration and whether current price reporting is sufficient for market transparency. The Secretary shall provide a report within 180 days of enactment of this Act on these factors and recommend potential actions to reduce input costs for American farmers. Loan and Grant Programs.--The Committee directs that if an estimate of loan activity for any program funded in Titles II and III of this bill indicates that a limitation on authority to make commitments for a fiscal year will be reached before the end of that fiscal year, or in any event when 75 percent of the authority to make commitments has been utilized, the Secretary shall promptly notify the Committees through OBPA. The Committee directs USDA, through OBPA, to provide quarterly reports to the Committees on the status of obligations and funds availability for the loan and grant programs provided in this bill. National Finance Center.--The National Finance Center (NFC) is the largest designated Federal Government Payroll Shared Service Provider, and it provides integrated payroll and personnel services for over 640,000 Federal employees. To ensure that thousands of Federal employees' pay and human resources services are not interrupted or adversely impacted by major organizational changes, the Committee continues requirements under current law relating to NFC payroll and shared services operations, missions, personnel, and functions. The Committee also directs USDA to provide quarterly reports on full-time equivalent (FTE) levels for each of the current NFC divisions, operations, and functions, as well as each of the Office of the Chief Financial Officer (OCFO) and Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO) divisions, operations, and functions currently co-located with the NFC. The reports also are to include a detailed breakdown of the FTEs for each and any of these same divisions, functions, or operations for the NFC and the co-located OCFO and OCIO functions compared to those during fiscal year 2017 and 2018. The Committee is aware of the National Academy of Public Administration (Academy) recommendations regarding the stabilization and modernization of the NFC. The Academy notes that timing and budget pressures place a significant burden on NFC, and absent a dedicated appropriation, problems can persist. The Committee supports the efforts of NFC to modernize its IT infrastructure, resulting in higher recruitment of skilled workers and long-term cost savings. The Committee urges the Secretary to use dedicated credit card rebates transferred to the Working Capital Fund, as approved by section 725, to bolster IT and other support systems at the NFC. Additionally, the Committee encourages the Secretary to provide resources for agency costs associated with transitioning to NFC services. Native Plants.--The Committee continues to support the use of locally adapted native plant materials in the undertaking of land management activity on Federal lands under the jurisdiction of USDA. Notification Requirements.--The Committee reminds USDA that the Committee uses the definitions for transfer, reprogramming, and program, project, and activity (PPA) as defined by the Government Accountability Office (GAO). As noted in the fiscal year 2026 Joint Explanatory Statement, a PPA is an element within a budget account. PPAs are identified by reference to include the most specific level of budget items identified in the Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Act, 2026, accompanying Committee reports, explanatory statements, and budget justifications. The Committee notes that the most specific level of budget items in USDA budget justifications is not limited to tables titled ``Project Statement''. Organic Waste Rendering.--The Committee is concerned that recent organic waste diversion efforts across the government have focused too heavily on consumer and post-consumer wastes and have failed to consider a `whole animal' approach to adequately address true food loss and food waste materials generated throughout modern agriculture and aquaculture. The Committee encourages the USDA to advocate for standardized definitions of `food loss' and `food waste' using an approach that recognizes food loss beginning at the point of agricultural production, not merely at the point of consumer purchase or discard. Such definitions should account for losses occurring across the full production chain, including livestock at any stage of production, wild fish at the point of capture, and aquaculture species at harvest. Outcome-Based Reviews.--The Committee supports: (1) the conduct of outcome-based program and operational reviews consistent with the Government Performance and Results Modernization Act of 2010; (2) the review of existing regulations, internal policies, and administrative requirements to identify outdated, duplicative, or unnecessarily burdensome provisions; and (3) the identification of opportunities for cost savings, administrative streamlining, and improved program delivery. Not later than 180 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Secretary of Agriculture shall submit a report to the Committee on USDA capacity to strengthen performance management, regulatory review, and oversight practices to better align spending with measurable outcomes. Persistent Poverty Areas.--The Committee supports targeted investments in impoverished areas. The Committee directs USDA to develop and implement measures to increase the share of investments in persistent poverty counties, distressed communities, and other impoverished areas. The Committee directs USDA to submit a report that includes the total amount of Federal investment targeted toward such areas; a list of the programs under which the amount of Federal investments to such areas were increased in fiscal year 2026; the percent change in the amount of funds that were targeted to such areas from fiscal year 2025; and, to the extent practicable, an assessment of the economic impact of departmental programs in these areas. Program, Project, or Activity.--For the purposes of sections 716 and 721 of this Act, ``program, project, or activity'' means the most detailed subdivision of an appropriation and should reflect the more detailed of (a) amounts identified in any tables in this report; (b) amounts, including increases or decreases, specified in any parts of this Act or this report; (c) activities or directives specified in this Act or this report; or (d) tables included in budget justification materials. Quarterly Reports.--The Committee directs the Secretary to submit a unified quarterly report detailing staffing levels and obligated balances across the Department. Staffing data should provide detail by agency, including current levels and end-of- year goals, and the source of appropriations, notated by the authority citation, supporting each staffing level. Obligation data should include year-to-date obligations and current balances at the mission area, agency, and program level, broken down by source of appropriation and the number of FTEs supported by each PPA. Rural News Media and Advertising Campaigns.--The Committee recognizes the critical role local media, including non-daily newspapers, television, and radio, plays in delivering messages to small or rural communities. The Secretary is encouraged to utilize local news media in rural areas for USDA advertising campaigns to reach citizens in these communities with key messages. Spending Plans.--The bill continues a provision in Title VII that requires USDA to submit spending plans to the Committee within 30 days of enactment of this Act. Previous versions of