Purpose and Summary
H.R. 5213, the No Federal Funds for Cashless Bail Act,
introduced by Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY), prohibits the
Attorney General from awarding Edward Byrne Memorial Justice
Assistance Grant (Byrne JAG) Program grants to states or units
of local government that substantially limit cash bail as a
condition for every individual charged with a criminal offense
that poses a clear threat to public safety and order.\1\ Such
offenses include a violent or sexual act, such as murder, rape,
sexual assault, carjacking, robbery, burglary, and assault.\2\
They also include offenses that promote public disorder, such
as looting, vandalism, destruction of property, rioting or
inciting to riot, or fleeing from a law enforcement officer.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H.R. 5213, Sec. 2(c), 119th Cong., 1st Sess.
\2\Id.
\3\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background and Need for the Legislation
So-called bail ``reform'' crafted and passed by far-left
policymakers is one of the most harmful and dangerous policies
for American communities. Over the past several years, left-
wing state legislatures have passed laws and rogue prosecutors
have implemented policies that either eliminate cash bail
altogether or significantly restrict the ability of state and
local judges to impose conditions on the pre-trial release of
accused criminals, such as supervised release. Many of these
mandates require the immediate release of suspected criminals
back into the local community. In 2021, Illinois became the
first state to eliminate the use of cash bail.\4\ Other states,
such as California, Maryland, New Jersey, and New York, have
modified their bail practices to significantly decrease the use
of cash bail.\5\ These laws and policies ignore public safety
interests and create a revolving door for criminals to
reoffend.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Grace Kinnicutt, What's in the SAFE-T Act? A Look at the 2021
Criminal Justice Reform and How It Has Evolved, The Capitol News (May
18, 2022).
\5\Lisel Petis, Navigating Bail Reform in America: A State-by-State
Overview, R Street Institute (Feb. 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail reform in New York
The New York state legislature passed bail ``reform''
legislation on April 1, 2019, which went into effect on January
1, 2020.\6\ The new policies prohibited judges from setting
cash bail for most misdemeanors and certain felonies, and
mandated the immediate release of individuals who committed
these offenses back into the community.\7\ These offenses
include ``burglary, stalking, assault without serious injury,
many drug offenses and some kinds of arson and robbery.''\8\ As
a result, defendants accused of these crimes are released back
on to New York streets while they await trial. The new law also
prevents judges from remanding defendants to pretrial detention
based on the danger they pose, and judges may only consider the
risk of a defendant fleeing from the jurisdiction when deciding
whether to use an ankle monitor during pretrial release.\9\ In
cases where judges have the ability to set bail, they are
required to consider the defendant's ability to pay and must
also choose the least restrictive means necessary to ensure
that defendants return for their court date.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\2019 N.Y. Laws ch. 59, Sec. 1, part JJJ, Sec. 2 (codified as
amended in scatted sections of N.Y. Crim. Proc. Law).
\7\Id.; See also Taryn A. Merkl, New York's Latest Bail Law Changes
Explained, Brennan Center for Justice (Apr. 16, 2020).
\8\CPL Sec. 510.10(2) (as amended by 2019 N.Y. Laws ch. 59, part
JJJ).
\9\Id.; See also William J. Bratton and Rafael A. Mangual, `Bail
Reform' Is Killing New Yorkers as Eric Adams Pushes for Change, Wall
St. J. (Feb. 16, 2022).
\10\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In April 2020, New York amended its bail laws to allow
judges to consider imposing cash bail for specific crimes,
including ``sex trafficking, grand larceny, second-degree
burglary, vehicular assault and any crime that results in a
death.''\11\ These new revisions also allowed judges to
consider a defendant's criminal history when setting an amount
for bail.\12\ Additionally, judges could set cash bail for
``persistent offenders,'' even if the alleged offenses are
nonviolent.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\2020 N.Y. Laws ch. 56, part UU (codified as amended in
scattered sections of N.Y. Crim. Proc. Law).
\12\Id.
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In January 2022, then-New York City Mayor Eric Adams asked
Governor Kathy Hochul to reconsider New York's bail reform
laws.\14\ Several months later, Governor Hochul changed bail
laws in the state budget to allow judges to set bail for repeat
offenders and those accused of crimes involving firearms.\15\
The 2022 revisions also allowed judges the ability to assess
whether defendants were accused of causing ``serious
harm.''\16\ New Yorkers, according to polling, ``overwhelmingly
support[ed]'' the measure.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Bernadette Hogan, Eric Adams says bail blockade by Gov. Hochul,
Albany won't stop crime plan, N.Y. Post (Jan. 27, 2022).
\15\2022 N.Y. Laws ch. 56, part UU (codified as amended in
scattered sections of N.Y. Crim. Proc. Law, including CPL Sec. 510.10).
\16\Id.
\17\Zach Williams, Most New Yorkers back bail changes but don't
want Hochul as gov: poll, N.Y. Post (Apr. 25, 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After New York's bail ``reform'' law passed, recidivism
rates increased for individuals who had previous violent felony
offenses. A March 2023 study by researchers at John Jay College
of Criminal Justice found that approximately 72 percent of
violent felony offenders who were released without bail were
re-arrested.\18\ Before the law was passed, the recidivism rate
for previous violent felony offenders was 62 percent.\19\ The
study also found that ``mandatory release significantly
increased re-arrest across multiple outcomes for people with a
recent violent arrest and with a pending case at the time of
the current arraignment.''\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Rene Ropac and Michael Rempel, Does New York's Bail Reform Law
Impact Recidivism? A Quasi-Experimental Test in New York City, John Jay
College of Criminal Justice 16 (Mar. 2023); John Binder, Study: Over
72% of NYC Violent Crime Suspects Freed Without Bail Go On To Commit
More Crimes, Breitbart (Apr. 5, 2023).
\19\Id.
\20\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Repeat offenders continue to plague New York City. In April
2023, then-NYPD Commissioner Keechant Sewell said that
``recidivism is the undertow pulling against everything we are
doing to keep our city safe'' and ``it is counterproductive to
public safety and, frankly, is a perpetual carousel of police
resources.''\21\ As an example of how bad New York's recidivism
problem is, Sewell said that 327 individuals were arrested more
than 6,000 times for retail theft.\22\ Michael Lipetri, NYPD's
chief of crime control strategies, said that a man named
Nathaniel Linden had recently been indicted for burglarizing
six churches in November 2022, but was released right before
his trial.\23\ Just nine hours after being released, Linden
burglarized a dry cleaner business.\24\ Linden was then
released again, and allegedly burglarized several more
churches.\25\ Talking about Linden, Lipetri said, ``That's
recidivism. . . . That's what the commissioner is talking
about. This isn't a person who had a bad day. This is a person
who had a bad 40 years.''\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Craig McCarthy and Steve Janoski, Shootings, homicides down,
but not to pre-pandemic levels, NYPD says, N.Y. Post (Apr. 6, 2023).
\22\Id.
\23\Id.
\24\Id.
\25\Id.
\26\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In testimony before the Committee on April 17, 2023, Paul
DiGiacomo of the Detectives Endowment Association explained
that ``[t]here is a direct correlation for when the bail reform
laws were enacted to [sic] day one to the uptick in violent
crimes across New York City.''\27\ Democratic New York City
Councilmember Robert Holden similarly testified before the
Committee about the effect of liberal criminal justice
policies.\28\ He explained that ``failed progressive policies
reversed 30 years of law and order delivered to the city by the
hardworking men and women of the NYPD and professional
prosecutors that put victims' rights ahead of criminals.''\29\
Holden was clear about the remedy:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Victims of Violent Crime in Manhattan: Hearing Before the H.
Comm. on Judiciary, 118th Cong. 40 (Apr. 17, 2023).
\28\Id. at 28.
\29\Id. at 29.
To address these challenges, we need our State
legislators and district attorneys to prioritize public
safety and work together to strengthen our criminal
justice system rather than weaken it. The State
legislature has failed us by passing laws that have
weakened our criminal justice system and enabled
criminals to evade justice.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail reform in Illinois
In January 2021, the Illinois state legislature passed
sweeping criminal justice ``reform'' legislation and
implemented those changes on January 1, 2023.\31\ The Illinois
Safety, Accountability, Fairness and Equity-Today (SAFE-T) Act
abolished cash bail and required a higher burden of proof to
detain accused violent criminals until trial.\32\ The Act
amended the Illinois Constitution and eroded the constitutional
protections of the Illinois Victim Rights Act.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Pub. Act 101-0652, 101st Gen. Assemb. (Ill. 2021) (codified as
amended in scatted sections of the Illinois Compiled Statutes).
\32\Id.; See also Grace Kinnicutt, What's in the SAFE-T Act? A Look
at the 2021 Criminal Justice Reform and How It Has Evolved, The Capitol
News (May 18, 2022).
\33\Craig Wall, Republican lawmakers seek to repeal criminal
justice bill, claiming it makes `crime even worse', ABC 7 News (Jan.
20, 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The SAFE-T Act states that ``all defendants shall be
presumed eligible for pretrial release'' unless prosecutors
present clear and convincing evidence to deny the suspect
pretrial release, such as proof that the suspect committed the
crime and poses a threat to the physical safety of a specific,
identifiable person.\34\ Under the SAFE-T Act, the judge does
not have the option of setting bail as the defendant will
presumptively be released pending trial.\35\ As a result,
defendants are released back into the community while they
await trial. Additionally, prosecutors are required to submit a
request for detention within forty-eight hours if the offender
committed a crime that poses a ``significant threat to public
safety.''\36\ James Glasgow, a Democrat prosecutor for the
suburbs outside of Chicago, stated it was nearly impossible to
provide the evidence needed within forty-eight hours because
``it takes time to review body and surveillance cameras and
crime labs take time to process evidence.''\37\ Glasgow further
stated, ``when it's protecting the health, safety and welfare
of the law-abiding citizens, we have to be able to do
that.''\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\725 ILCS 5/110-6.1 (as amended by Pub. Act 101-0652).
\35\Id.
\36\Grace Kinnicutt, What's in the SAFE-T Act? A Look at the 2021
Criminal Justice Reform and How It Has Evolved, The Capitol News (May
18, 2022).
\37\Id.
\38\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Democrats portray the bail system as a failure, but the
data shows release with no conditions, or abolishing cash bail,
is significantly less effective than cash bail at achieving
compliance.\39\ A 2023 study in California found that 70
percent of suspects released on zero-dollar bail were re-
arrested.\40\ Additionally, when compared to those who paid
bail, suspects released on zero-dollar bail were twice as
likely to be re-arrested for new felonies, and three times more
likely to be re-arrested for violent crimes.\41\ Even former
Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot realized eliminating bail was
disastrous.\42\ Mayor Lightfoot commented
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\Sean Kennedy, The Cost of Eliminating Cash Bail is Too High,
Chi. Sun Times (Mar. 12, 2023).
\40\Julie Watts, Updated $0 Bail Study: Suspects Released on $0
Bail Had Twice The Felony Rearrests, Three Times the Violent Crime
Arrests, CBS News (Feb. 20, 2023).
\41\Id.
\42\Houston Keene, Ousted Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot Urges Dems
to `Speak the Truth' on Violent Crime Amid Spike, N.Y. Post (Apr. 22,
2023).
I know that there are people in my city that are
wreaking havoc every day and need to be off the
streets. The police department is spending all this
time and resources to arrest, put a case on, and the
judges and the prosecutors say, you know what? We're
going to let you out on electronic monitoring to wreak
havoc again.\43\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\43\Id.
On December 29, 2022, an Illinois court found that the
pretrial release portions of the SAFE-T Act violated the
separation of powers clause of the Illinois Constitution.\44\
The court blocked the abolishment of cash bail in sixty-five
counties across Illinois, but allowed the end of cash bail to
go into effect in thirty-seven other counties.\45\ On July 18,
2023, the Illinois Supreme Court overturned the decision and
ruled the SAFE-T Act provision ending cash bail was
constitutional, which made Illinois the first state in the
nation to eliminate cash bail.\46\ Following the decision, one
Democrat state's attorney in Illinois stated, ``this ruling is
disappointing and the Act terribly detrimental to public
safety, we must abide by the decision and will continue to do
our best to serve the people.''\47\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\Rowe v. Raoul, No. 22-CH-16 (Ill. Cir. Ct. Kankakee Cnty. Dec.
28, 2022) (Cunnington J,); See also CBS Chicago Team, Judge Rules Bail
Reform, Pretrial Release Provisions of SAFE-T Act Unconstitutional, CBS
News Chi. (Dec. 29, 2022).
\45\Rowe v. Raoul, No. 22-CH-16 (Ill. Cir. Ct. Kankakee Cnty. Dec.
28, 2022).
\46\Rowe v. Raoul, 2023 IL 129248 (Jul. 18, 2023); See also
Michelle Gallardo, SAFE-T Act Provision Ending Cash Bail
Constitutional, Illinois Supreme Court Rules, ABC News (Jul. 18, 2023).
\47\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The consequences of this far-left policy were felt within
the first week of the implementation of the Safe-T Act. During
a Committee forum in Chicago in September 2023, John Garrido, a
retired Lieutenant with the Chicago Police Department,
testified that several individuals committed violent crimes and
were released almost immediately.\48\ He explained:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\48\Victims of Violent Crime in Chicago: Forum of the H. Comm. on
Judiciary, 118th Cong. 12 (Sep. 26, 2023).
On the first day of no cash bail last week,
individuals charged with violent crimes were released
without any restrictions. Two people were charged with
robbery, and a guy was accused of punching a Chicago
police officer in the face, and they went home without
restrictions, and there was no request by the
prosecutor for a detention hearing. Another offender
was sent home without any restrictions after being
accused of attacking four police officers and sending
two to the hospital. Yet again, the prosecutor's office
did not ask for any detention hearing.\49\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\49\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Byrne JAG Grant Funding to States
In FY 2023, Congress appropriated $771 million for Edward
Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program.\50\ In
FY 2024, that number increased to $924 million and in FY 2025
that number decreased to $499 million.\51\ In FY 2026,
appropriations increased to $964 million.\52\ That program
awards grants to states and territories for a variety of state
and local criminal justice initiatives including pretrial
services. For example, these grant funds can be used for the
following purposes:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\50\Cong. Research Serv., IF10691, The Edward Byrne Memorial
Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program (Apr. 25, 2024).
\51\Cong. Research Serv., IF10691, The Edward Byrne Memorial
Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program (Apr. 24, 2025).
\52\Cong. Research Serv., IF10691, The Edward Byrne Memorial
Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program (Mar. 16, 2026).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. law enforcement;
2. prosecution and courts;
3. prevention and education;
4. corrections and community corrections;
5. drug treatment;
6. planning, evaluation, and technology improvement;
7. crime victim and witness assistance (other than
compensation);
8. mental health and related law enforcement and
corrections programs, including behavioral programs and
crisis intervention teams; and
9. state crisis intervention court proceedings and
related programs or initiatives, including mental
health, drug, and veterans courts, and extreme risk
protection order programs.\53\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\53\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The No Federal Funds for Cashless Bail Act
The No Federal Funds for Cashless Bail Act prohibits the
Attorney General from awarding Byrne JAG grants to states or
units of local government that substantially limit cash bail as
a potential condition for every individual charged with a
criminal offense that poses a clear threat to public safety and
order.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short Title. The ``No Federal Funds for Cashless
Bail Act.''
Section 2. Prohibition on Grants for Certain Entities. This
section prohibits the Attorney General from awarding Edward
Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (Byrne JAG) grants to
states or units of local government that substantially limit
cash bail as a potential condition for every individual charged
with a covered offense. This section defines a covered offense
as ``(1) an offense involving a violent or sexual act, such as
murder, rape, sexual assault, carjacking, robbery, burglary,
and assault; and (2) an offense that promote public disorder,
such as looting, vandalism, destruction of property, rioting or
inciting to riot, or fleeing from a law enforcement officer.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
OMNIBUS CRIME CONTROL AND SAFE STREETS ACT OF 1968
* * * * * * *
TITLE I--JUSTICE SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT
* * * * * * *
Part E--Bureau of Justice Assistance Grant Programs
Subpart 1--Edward Byrne Memorial Justice
Assistance Grant Program
* * * * * * *
SEC. 502. APPLICATIONS.
[(A)] (a) In General.--To request a grant under this
subpart, the chief executive officer of a State or unit of
local government shall submit an application to the Attorney
General within 120 days after the date on which funds to carry
out this subpart are appropriated for a fiscal year, in such
form as the Attorney General may require. Such application
shall include the following:
(1) A certification that Federal funds made available
under this subpart will not be used to supplant State
or local funds, but will be used to increase the
amounts of such funds that would, in the absence of
Federal funds, be made available for law enforcement
activities.
(2) An assurance that, not fewer than 30 days before
the application (or any amendment to the application)
was submitted to the Attorney General, the application
(or amendment) was submitted for review to the
governing body of the State or unit of local government
(or to an organization designated by that governing
body).
(3) An assurance that, before the application (or any
amendment to the application) was submitted to the
Attorney General--
(A) the application (or amendment) was made
public; and
(B) an opportunity to comment on the
application (or amendment) was provided to
citizens and to neighborhood or community-based
organizations, to the extent applicable law or
established procedure makes such an opportunity
available.
(4) An assurance that, for each fiscal year covered
by an application, the applicant shall maintain and
report such data, records, and information
(programmatic and financial) as the Attorney General
may reasonably require.
(5) A certification, made in a form acceptable to the
Attorney General and executed by the chief executive
officer of the applicant (or by another officer of the
applicant, if qualified under regulations promulgated
by the Attorney General), that--
(A) the programs to be funded by the grant
meet all the requirements of this subpart;
(B) all the information contained in the
application is correct;
(C) there has been appropriate coordination
with affected agencies; and
(D) the applicant will comply with all
provisions of this subpart and all other
applicable Federal laws.
(6) A comprehensive Statewide plan detailing how
grants received under this section will be used to
improve the administration of the criminal justice
system, which shall--
(A) be designed in consultation with local
governments, and representatives of all
segments of the criminal justice system,
including judges, prosecutors, law enforcement
personnel, corrections personnel, and providers
of indigent defense services, victim services,
juvenile justice delinquency prevention
programs, community corrections, and reentry
services;
(B) include a description of how the State
will allocate funding within and among each of
the uses described in subparagraphs (A) through
(G) of section 501(a)(1);
(C) describe the process used by the State
for gathering evidence-based data and
developing and using evidence-based and
evidence-gathering approaches in support of
funding decisions;
(D) describe the barriers at the State and
local level for accessing data and implementing
evidence-based approaches to preventing and
reducing crime and recidivism; and
(E) be updated every 5 years, with annual
progress reports that--
(i) address changing circumstances in
the State, if any;
(ii) describe how the State plans to
adjust funding within and among each of
the uses described in subparagraphs (A)
through (G) of section 501(a)(1);
(iii) provide an ongoing assessment
of need;
(iv) discuss the accomplishment of
goals identified in any plan previously
prepared under this paragraph; and
(v) reflect how the plan influenced
funding decisions in the previous year.
(b) Technical Assistance.--
(1) Strategic planning.--Not later than 90 days after
the date of enactment of this subsection, the Attorney
General shall begin to provide technical assistance to
States and local governments requesting support to
develop and implement the strategic plan required under
subsection (a)(6). The Attorney General may enter into
agreements with 1 or more non-governmental
organizations to provide technical assistance and
training under this paragraph.
(2) Protection of constitutional rights.--Not later
than 90 days after the date of enactment of this
subsection, the Attorney General shall begin to provide
technical assistance to States and local governments,
including any agent thereof with responsibility for
administration of justice, requesting support to meet
the obligations established by the Sixth Amendment to
the Constitution of the United States, which shall
include--
(A) public dissemination of practices,
structures, or models for the administration of
justice consistent with the requirements of the
Sixth Amendment; and
(B) assistance with adopting and implementing
a system for the administration of justice
consistent with the requirements of the Sixth
Amendment.
(3) Authorization of appropriations.--For each of
fiscal years 2017 through 2021, of the amounts
appropriated to carry out this subpart, not less than
$5,000,000 and not more than $10,000,000 shall be used
to carry out this subsection.
(c) Ineligibility.--
(1) Covered offense defined.--In this subsection, the
term ``covered offense'' means a criminal offense that
poses a clear threat to public safety and order,
including--
(A) an offense involving a violent or sexual
act, such as murder, rape, sexual assault,
carjacking, robbery, burglary, and assault; and
(B) an offense that promote public disorder,
such as looting, vandalism, destruction of
property, rioting or inciting to riot, or
fleeing from a law enforcement officer.
(2) Prohibition.--With respect to the fiscal year
beginning on the first October 1 occurring after the
date of enactment of the No Federal Funds for Cashless
Bail Act, and each fiscal year thereafter, the Attorney
General may not award, renew, or extend a grant under
this subpart to a State or unit of local government
that has in effect a policy or law that substantially
limits cash bail as a potential condition for every
individual charged with a covered offense in the State
or the area under the jurisdiction of the unit of local
government.
* * * * * * *