Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8872]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 8872) to amend part A of title IV of the Social
Security Act to target funds to low-income families, strengthen
program integrity guardrails for State expenditure of funds,
require measurement of improper payments, and establish goals
for eliminating fraud and improper payments under the program
of block grants to States for temporary assistance for needy
families, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that
the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND...................................... 3
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 3
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 3
C. Legislative History................................. 5
D. Designated Hearings................................. 5
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL..................................... 6
A. Reasons for Change.................................. 6
B. Explanation of Provisions........................... 9
C. Effective Date...................................... 9
III. VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE...................................... 10
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL.................................. 12
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 12
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 12
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 12
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE.. 13
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 13
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 13
C. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 13
D. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 13
E. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 13
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED....... 13
VII. DISSENTING VIEWS............................................ 25
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Preventing Waste, Fraud, and Abuse in
TANF Act''.
SEC. 2. STRENGTHENING PROGRAM INTEGRITY THROUGH IMPROPER PAYMENTS
REVIEW.
(a) In General.--Section 404 of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C.
604) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(l) Applicability of Payment Integrity Law.--The Payment Integrity
Information Act of 2019 shall apply to a State with respect to the
State program funded under this part in the same manner in which such
Act applies to a Federal agency.''.
(b) Report to Congress.--Within 1 year after the date of the
enactment of this Act, the Secretary of Health and Human Services shall
submit to the Congress a written report that contains a plan to reduce
or eliminate improper payments made by States under part A of title IV
of the Social Security Act within 10 years.
SEC. 3. TARGETING FUNDS TO FAMILIES IN NEED.
Section 404 of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 604) is further
amended by adding at the end the following:
``(m) Establishing a Threshold for Families in Need.--A State to
which a grant is made under section 403(a)(1) shall use the grant only
to provide assistance or services to a family whose income is less than
twice the poverty guidelines updated periodically in the Federal
Register under section 673(2) of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act
of 1981 (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)).''.
SEC. 4. DEADLINES FOR THE OBLIGATION AND EXPENDITURE OF FUNDS.
Section 404(e) of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 604(e)) is
amended to read as follows:
``(e) Deadlines for Obligation and Expenditure of Funds by States.--
``(1) In general.--Except as provided in paragraph (2), a
State to which funds are paid, after the effective date of this
subsection, under section 403(a)(1) for a fiscal year shall
obligate the funds not later than the end of the succeeding
fiscal year, and shall expend the funds not later than the end
of the 2nd succeeding fiscal year.
``(2) Exception for limited amount of funds set aside for
future use.--
``(A) In general.--Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of
this subsection, a State to which funds are paid under
section 403(a)(1), after the effective date of this
subsection, for a fiscal year may reserve not more than
15 percent of the funds for future use in the State
program funded under this part, subject to subparagraph
(B) of this paragraph.
``(B) Limitation.--The total amount held in reserve
by a State under subparagraph (A) of this paragraph
shall not exceed an amount equal to 50 percent of the
total amount paid to the State under section 403(a)(1)
for the then preceding fiscal year.
``(C) Notice of intent to reserve funds.--A State
that intends to reserve funds under subparagraph (A)
shall notify the Secretary of the intention not later
than the end of the period in which the funds are
available for obligation without regard to subparagraph
(A) of this paragraph.''.
SEC. 5. PROHIBITION ON STATE DIVERSION OF FEDERAL FUNDS TO REPLACE
STATE SPENDING.
(a) In General.--Section 404 of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C.
604) is further amended by adding at the end the following:
``(n) Limitation on Use of Federal Funds to Replace State General
Revenue Funds.--A State shall use Federal funds received under this
part only to supplement funds that, in the absence of the Federal
funds, would be made available from State and local sources for
programs assisted under this part, and not to supplant the funds.''.
(b) State Certification.--Section 402(a) of such Act (42 U.S.C.
602(a)) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(9) Certification of state supplementation.--A
certification by the chief executive officer of the State that
the funds provided to the State under this part will not be
used to supplant State or non-Federal funds for services and
activities that promote the purposes of this part.''.
SEC. 6. EFFECTIVE DATE.
The amendments made by this Act shall take effect on October 1, 2027.
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
H.R. 8872, as amended, the ``Preventing Waste, Fraud and
Abuse in TANF Act,'' as ordered reported by the Committee on
Ways and Means on May 21, 2026, makes changes to part A of
title IV of the Social Security Act to strengthen program
integrity, improve payment oversight, and better target
Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) funds to
families in need. Introduced by Rep. Mike Carey (R-OH), this
bill applies the Payment Integrity Information Act of 2019 to
state TANF programs and requires the Secretary of Health and
Human Services to submit a report to Congress with a plan to
reduce or eliminate improper payments under TANF within 10
years. This bill establishes a federal income threshold
limiting the use of TANF funds to assistance or services for
families with incomes below 200 percent of the federal poverty
guidelines. This bill also establishes deadlines for states to
obligate and expend TANF funds, while preserving state
flexibility to reserve a limited amount of funds for future
use. This bill further requires federal TANF funds to
supplement, and not supplant, state and local funds for
services and activities that promote the purposes of TANF.
B. Background and Need for Legislation
In 1996, Congress created TANF as part of bipartisan
welfare reform. Today, TANF provides $16.5 billion each year to
states, tribes, and territories to provide assistance to low-
income families and promote self-sufficiency through work. TANF
has not been reauthorized since 2005, but continues to receive
funding through annual appropriations bills and continuing
resolutions. While TANF's flexibility allows states to design
programs that meet the needs of their residents, the Committee
has identified serious gaps in accountability and program
integrity that have emerged over the last two decades.
Specifically, concerns have emerged about how states are
using ``non-assistance'' TANF funds, which constitute nearly 80
percent of total spending. Non-assistance spending is used for
a wide variety of state activities including pre-k, child care,
child welfare, administration, and sometimes for pet projects
unrelated to moving families from welfare to work. The
Committee has found that problems in current law open the door
for diversion of non-assistance funds away from the core
purpose of moving individuals from welfare to work. TANF also
lacks basic financial guardrails creating an environment ripe
for waste, fraud, and abuse. These concerns were exemplified by
headlines from Mississippi where an independent audit of the
state's Department of Human Services found $77 million in
misspent funds from 2017 to 2020, resulting in criminal
convictions for embezzlement by multiple state officials. The
Mississippi case is emblematic of a systemic problem. There is
widespread consensus that rampant state misuse of funds is
undermining efforts to help vulnerable families.
In September 2023, Committee Chairman Jason Smith (R-MO)
and Work and Welfare Subcommittee Chairman Darin LaHood (R-IL),
requested that the Government Accountability Office (GAO)
conduct a comprehensive investigation into state use of TANF
non-assistance funds as part of the Committee's ongoing
oversight work to strengthen the program.\1\ In response to the
request, GAO published five reports and testified about their
fundings at a Work and Welfare Subcommittee hearing.\2\ The
Work and Welfare Subcommittee has also held several hearings to
review the TANF program and examine loopholes in current law
that make the program vulnerable to fraud, and abuse. The GAO
reports are briefly summarized below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Smith, LaHood Call on Government Watchdog to Investigate Uses of
TANF Funds, House Ways and Means Committee Press Release, September 25,
2023.
\2\``Government Watchdog Findings: Temporary Assistance for Needy
Families (TANF) Program In Need of Reform, Better State Accountability,
and Fraud Protection,'' Subcommittee on Work and Welfare, April 8,
2025.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
``Enhanced Reporting Could Improve HHS
Oversight of State Spending''--GAO found states are not
reporting complete information about TANF expenditures,
and most states lacked transparent reporting on
subgrantees. In addition, states carried over
significant balances of unspent TANF funds, more than
doubling from $4 billion in FY 2015 to $9 billion in FY
2022. (GAO-25-107235)
``Additional Actions Needed to Strengthen
Fraud Risk Management''--GAO identified 21 fraud risks
in nine categories including billing fraud, misuse of
award funds, and diversion. (GAO-24-107290)
``HHS Could Facilitate Information Sharing
to Improve States' Use of Data on Job Training and
Other Services''--GAO found states lacked data on
demographic characteristics, participation, and
outcomes for individuals and families served by non-
assistance TANF funds. (GAO-25-107226)
``HHS Needs to Strengthen Oversight of
Single Audit Findings''--GAO reviewed independent state
audit findings and identified 36 states with,
collectively 155 TANF findings, of which 99 were repeat
findings and went unaddressed in multiple years. (GAO-
25-107291)
``Child Welfare: States' Use of TANF and
Other Major Federal Funding Sources''--States spend a
significant amount of TANF non-assistance funds on
child welfare services ($3.3 billion in federal and
state funds in FY 2022 or 10% of total spending),
however there is a lack of data on children served,
services provided, and impact on child well-being.
(GAO-245-107467)
In the 118th and 119th Congress, Republican Committee
Members introduced a set of seven TANF bills focused on
targeting TANF to families in need, helping low-income families
find and keep a job, and reducing waste, fraud, and abuse.
Those bills are combined into a larger, comprehensive five-year
TANF reauthorization led by Rep. Darin LaHood (R-IL) and
Senator Steve Daines (R-MT), the Jobs and Opportunity with
Benefits and Services (JOBS) for Success Act of 2025 (H.R.
3156/S. 1567).
H.R. 8872, the ``Preventing Waste, Fraud and Abuse in TANF
Act,'' combines four of the Committee's TANF bills focused on
program integrity. Combined, these policies will put into place
basic financial guardrails which apply to most other federal
programs, to reign in state misuse of funds and reduce fraud
and improper payments. One of the major benefits of TANF is the
flexibility provided to states to deliver assistance to their
citizens need. However, this must be balanced with protecting
taxpayer dollars. The bill is intended to preserve state
flexibility with common sense federal requirements.
C. Legislative History
Background
H.R. 8872 was introduced on May 19, 2026, and was referred
to the Committee on Ways and Means. H.R. 8872 combines four
Committee bills (listed below) which were introduced in the
118th and 119th Congress:
H.R. 2242, ``Eliminate Fraud and Improper
Payments in TANF Act''
H.R. 2397, ``Target TANF to Families in Need
Act''
H.R. 2359, ``Improve Transparency and
Stability for Families Act''
H.R. 2584, ``Protect TANF Resources for
Families Act''
Committee Hearings
The Committee on Ways and Means held the following
hearing(s) concerning the policy in H.R. 8872:
On April 8, 2025, the House Ways and Means Subcommittee on
Work and Welfare held a hearing on ``Government Watchdog
Findings: Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
Program In Need of Reform, Better State Accountability, and
Fraud Protection.''
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 8872, the
``Preventing Waste, Fraud and Abuse in TANF Act'', on May 21,
2026, and favorably reported the bill, as amended, to the House
of Representatives (with quorum being present).
D. Designated Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.R. 8872, the
``Preventing Waste, Fraud and Abuse in TANF Act'':
``Where is all the Welfare Money Going? Reclaiming TANF
Non-Assistance Dollars to Lift Americans Out of Poverty,''
hearing held on July 12, 2023, ``States' Misuse of Welfare
Funds Leaves Poor Families Behind,'' hearing held on September
26, 2024, and ``Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
Program In Need of Reform, Better State Accountability, and
Fraud Protection,'' hearing held on April 8, 2025.
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Reasons for Change
Section 1. The Committee believes the title accurately
reflects the content of the bill.
Section 2. TANF is one of the few federal programs not
required to report an annual federal improper payment rate
under the Program Integrity Information Act of 2019 (PIIA)(P.L.
116-117). PIIA generally requires federal agencies to identify
programs at risk of significant improper payments and report on
their corrective actions. During a Subcommittee hearing in
2025, one witness testified that the lack of federal
requirements to measure improper payments contributed to a
``nobody's watching'' atmosphere that makes TANF vulnerable to
fraud and misuse. Improper payment reviews include identifying
fraud in federal programs as well as administrative errors such
as payments made in the wrong amount, payments to an ineligible
recipient, and duplicate payments.
Since 2022, GAO has recommended Congress grant the
Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) authority to
require states to report data necessary to estimate TANF
improper payments. The Office of Management and Budget
identified TANF as a risk-susceptible program, however HHS has
not reported an improper payment estimate for TANF. HHS stated
in its FY 2021 Agency Financial Review that it did not report
an improper payment estimate because statutory limitations
prohibit collection of the necessary data. Since 2020, the
Administration for Children and Families (ACF) requested the
authority to measure improper payments for TANF in its
congressional justifications to the President's Budget for
fiscal years 2020, 2021, 2024, and 2025, spanning President
Trump's first term and President Biden's term. Specifically,
ACF requested congressional authorization to collect
information from states to develop an improper payment rate for
TANF.
Without measuring improper payments, Congress and HHS have
limited ability to determine whether TANF dollars are being
paid accurately, whether errors are caused by fraud or
administrative mistakes, and what corrective actions are needed
to improve program integrity. The Committee believes applying
PIIA to state TANF programs will strengthen oversight of
improper payments and help identify waste, fraud, and abuse in
the program. The Committee believes requiring the Secretary of
HHS to submit a plan to reduce or eliminate improper payments
within 10 years will improve accountability and provide
Congress with a clearer path for addressing improper payments
in TANF.
Section 3. Federal law establishes the framework for
spending under TANF; however, states have broad flexibility to
set their own income and asset eligibility limits. Current law
does not target TANF to families in poverty or establish a
federal income eligibility limit for the program. All other
major federal welfare programs, such as Medicaid and
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance (SNAP), establish eligibility
limits to target resources to families based on income.
Instead, states establish eligibility for TANF cash assistance
with maximum earnings thresholds for individuals to qualify.
Eligibility varies across the country, but in nearly all states
eligibility for cash assistance is at or below 100% of the
federal poverty line.
However, TANF non-assistance spending, which constitutes
nearly 80% of state spending, is not subject to the same state
income eligibility limits as cash assistance. Federal TANF non-
assistance funds used on benefits, services, and activities
that meet one of the four purposes of TANF do not have
requirements related to eligibility, nor are states are
required to report caseload counts or demographic data for
children and families receiving non-assistance TANF. This has
led to TANF being used to support programs and projects that
are not targeted to needy families. Examples include:
Detroit Free Press: How Michigan Families get Welfare
for Private Colleges--Michigan spends about $100
million annually in welfare money on college aid,
including millions that benefit families earning more
than $100,000.
Governing Magazine: How Are States Using Welfare
Funding? Often, Not to Help People Work.--Flexibility
in the program has led ``states to shift money over to
programs that have, at best, a tenuous relationship to
work.'' Arizona, for example, spent almost half of its
TANF funds last year on child welfare.
Michigan Live: ``State offers additional $1.2 million
for water heater replacements in Flint''--The Michigan
Department of Health and Human Services announced
additional funding for the third-year program, which is
restricted to homes with at least one child living at
the address or one resident who is at least 60 years
old. MDHHS said in a news release that the funding to
continue the program comes from the federal TANF
program and state general funds.
Louisiana Budget Project: ``Fund diversions erode
Louisiana's safety net''--Welfare dollars made
available through the TANF block grant have been used
to plug holes in the state budget.
NC Policy Watch: ``Read fine print: How the state
Senate spends federal the dollars in its budget''--
North Carolina recently began to swap out a portion of
state funding for federal aid. Supplanting--rather than
supplementing--state dollars is troubling when waiting
lists and unmet needs persist.''
Maine, Bangor Daily News: ``What LePage really plans
to do with $100M meant for Maine families in
poverty''--A BDN Maine Focus review of the department's
spending plans, interviews with nonprofit service
providers in line to receive funds, and an examination
of state documents show that DHHS is largely using TANF
to cover long-term state spending obligations.
In 2023, the Biden Administration proposed a rule with a
similar policy to limit TANF to families under 200% of poverty
related to the first two purposes of TANF.\3\ In their
justification, the proposed rule expressed concern that TANF
non-assistance funds were increasingly being used for families
with income significantly above the poverty line. The rule
identified that ``41 states were spending TANF on services to
families at 300 and 400% of the poverty line.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\``Strengthening Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
as a Safety Net and Work Program,'' Proposed Rule, Administration for
Children and Families, HHS. Federal Register 88 FR 67697, October 2,
2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee believes establishing a federal income
threshold will ensure TANF funds are targeted to low-income
families and prevent diversion of funds. This federal limit
applies to both assistance and non-assistance spending and
continues to provide states flexibility to tailor income
guidelines and further target federal resources as the state
deems appropriate for services and supports funded with TANF
dollars.
Section 4. Unlike other grant programs, there are no
requirements to spend TANF funds within a certain time period,
therefore states may reserve unused TANF dollars without fiscal
year limit. This makes it difficult to track state spending
from an audit and accounting perspective and contributes to
large amounts of unspent funds. In 2024, 39 states held roughly
$8 billion in unspent TANF funds nationwide. For example, New
York carried over more than $1.7 billion, Pennsylvania carried
$1.3 billion, while Tennessee, a state with one of the highest
child poverty rates in the country, carried $675 million in
unspent TANF funds.
According to a January 2025 report from GAO, unspent TANF
funds have more than doubled since 2015. Unspent TANF funds
means critical dollars are not reaching needy families and
makes it easier for states to divert ``leftover'' TANF to fill
state budget gaps.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
The Committee believes establishing deadlines for the
obligation and expenditure of TANF funds will encourage states
to put federal welfare dollars to timely use for families in
need. The Committee believes allowing states to reserve a
limited amount of funds for future use will preserve
appropriate state flexibility while preventing excessive
accumulation of unused TANF funds.
Section 5. As a block grant, TANF provides states
flexibility to design programs and direct spending. Under
current law, there is no prohibition preventing states from
using federal TANF funds to replace state or local funds for
TANF-related social services. As a result, states are able to
divert federal TANF dollars to fill budget gaps or supplant
existing state spending, reducing the amount of funding
available to help families in poverty. A January 2025 GAO
report, found that a lack of safeguards in TANF contributes to
``opaque accounting practices''' that allows states to use TANF
as a slush fund and plug budget shortfalls.
Nearly all federal grant programs include standard ``non-
supplantation'' language. This ensures that states maintain
their effort to fund services at the state and local level and
that federal dollars supplement those efforts. TANF is the
exception. The Committee believes requiring TANF funds to
supplement, and not supplant, state and local funds will help
ensure federal TANF dollars add to, rather than replace,
support for TANF-related services and activities in states. The
Committee believes requiring state certification of compliance
in their TANF plan will strengthen accountability for state use
of federal TANF funds.
Section 6. The Committee believes the effective date
provides states and HHS with time to implement the bill's
requirements.
B. Explanation of Provisions
Section 1. Provides the short title of the bill,
``Preventing Waste, Fraud and Abuse in TANF Act.''
Section 2. Applies the requirements of the Payment
Integrity Information Act of 2019 to state TANF programs in the
same manner such Act applies to federal agencies. Requires the
Secretary of HHS to submit a report to Congress within one year
of enactment containing a plan to reduce or eliminate improper
payments made by states under TANF within 10 years.
Section 3. Establishes a federal income threshold to ensure
TANF funds are used only to provide support and services to
families in need. Restricts TANF eligibility to families with
incomes below 200% of the federal poverty level. In 2025, this
was equivalent to income below $51,640 for a family of three.
This preserves state flexibility, but provides an outer
boundary to ensure federal funds are targeted to families at or
near the poverty line. Applies the income threshold to both
assistance and non-assistance services funded through the
federal TANF block grant.
Section 4. Requires states to obligate TANF funds not later
than the end of the succeeding fiscal year and expend such
funds not later than the end of the second succeeding fiscal
year. It permits a state to reserve not more than 15% of TANF
funds paid to the state for a fiscal year for future use in the
state TANF program, and limits the total amount held in reserve
by a state to not more than 50% of the total amount paid to the
state under TANF for the preceding fiscal year.
Section 5. Requires federal TANF funds to supplement, not
supplant, state and local spending. This prohibits states from
using federal TANF funds to replace state or local funds that
otherwise would be available for similar services. Requires the
chief executive officer of each state to certify that federal
TANF funds will not be used to supplant state or non-federal
funds for services and activities that promote TANF purposes as
part of the state's TANF plan.
Section 6. Provides an effective date of October 1, 2027.
C. Effective Date
The bill would become effective on October 1, 2027.
III. VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE
In compliance with the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the following statement is made concerning the
vote of the Committee on Ways and Means during the markup
consideration of H.R. 8872, the ``Preventing Waste, Fraud, and
Abuse in TANF Act,'' on May 21, 2026.
The vote on the amendment offered by Mr. Davis to the
amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 8872, which
would require the Department of Health and Human Services to
answer Congressional questions about the Trump Administration's
revenge freeze of TANF funding in five states before
implementing the bill was not agreed to by a roll call vote of
18 yeas to 23 nays (with a quorum being present).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)................ ........ X ......... Mr. Neal........ X ......... .........
Mr. Buchanan.................. ........ ......... ......... Mr. Doggett..... X ......... .........
Mr. Smith (NE)................ ........ X ......... Mr. Thompson.... X ......... .........
Mr. Kelly..................... ........ X ......... Mr. Larson...... X ......... .........
Mr. Schweikert................ ........ X ......... Mr. Davis....... X ......... .........
Mr. LaHood.................... ........ X ......... Ms. Sanchez..... X ......... .........
Mr. Arrington................. ........ X ......... Ms. Sewell...... X ......... .........
Mr. Estes..................... ........ X ......... Ms. DelBene..... X ......... .........
Mr. Smucker................... ........ X ......... Ms. Chu......... X ......... .........
Mr. Hern...................... ........ X ......... Ms. Moore (WI).. X ......... .........
Mrs. Miller (WV).............. ........ ......... ......... Mr. Boyle....... ........ ......... .........
Dr. Murphy.................... ........ X ......... Mr. Beyer....... X ......... .........
Mr. Kustoff................... ........ X ......... Mr. Evans....... X ......... .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick............... ........ X ......... Mr. Schneider... X ......... .........
Mr. Steube.................... ........ X ......... Mr. Panetta..... X ......... .........
Ms. Tenney.................... ........ X ......... Mr. Gomez....... X ......... .........
Mrs. Fischbach................ ........ X ......... Mr. Horsford.... X ......... .........
Mr. Moore (UT)................ ........ X ......... Ms. Plaskett.... X ......... .........
Ms. Van Duyne................. ........ X ......... Mr. Suozzi...... X ......... .........
Mr. Feenstra.................. ........ X .........
Ms. Malliotakis............... ........ X .........
Mr. Carey..................... ........ X .........
Mr. Yakym..................... ........ X .........
Mr. Miller (OH)............... ........ X .........
Mr. Bean...................... ........ X .........
Mr. Moran..................... ........ ......... .........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In compliance with the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the following statement is made concerning the
vote of the Committee on Ways and Means during the markup
consideration of H.R. 8872, the ``Preventing Waste, Fraud, and
Abuse in TANF Act,'' on May 21, 2026.
The vote on the amendment offered by Ms. DelBene to the
amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 8872, which
would prohibit a pregnancy center from receiving TANF funds if
a State Medical Board finds they have provided misleading or
deceptive medical information or services or endangered the
health of women was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 19
yeas to 23 nays (with a quorum being present).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)................ ........ X ......... Mr. Neal........ X ......... .........
Mr. Buchanan.................. ........ ......... ......... Mr. Doggett..... X ......... .........
Mr. Smith (NE)................ ........ X ......... Mr. Thompson.... X ......... .........
Mr. Kelly..................... ........ X ......... Mr. Larson...... X ......... .........
Mr. Schweikert................ ........ X ......... Mr. Davis....... X ......... .........
Mr. LaHood.................... ........ X ......... Ms. Sanchez..... X ......... .........
Mr. Arrington................. ........ X ......... Ms. Sewell...... X ......... .........
Mr. Estes..................... ........ X ......... Ms. DelBene..... X ......... .........
Mr. Smucker................... ........ X ......... Ms. Chu......... X ......... .........
Mr. Hern...................... ........ X ......... Ms. Moore (WI).. X ......... .........
Mrs. Miller (WV).............. ........ ......... ......... Mr. Boyle....... X ......... .........
Dr. Murphy.................... ........ X ......... Mr. Beyer....... X ......... .........
Mr. Kustoff................... ........ X ......... Mr. Evans....... X ......... .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick............... ........ X ......... Mr. Schneider... X ......... .........
Mr. Steube.
Dissenting Views
When we help Americans who are struggling pay for food,
utilities, or healthcare, Republicans are quick to label it
``welfare'' and accuse recipients of fraud. But when the
Department of Justice reaches into taxpayers' pockets and
steals $1.8 billion for a slush fund to pay the President and
his allies, including convicted criminals who beat police
officers guarding the Capitol on January 6th, they are silent.
Democrats strongly support eliminating fraud, waste, and
abuse, which is why last Congress we introduced the TANF State
Expenditure Integrity Act (H.R. 2108 in the current Congress).
H.R. 2108 would directly address the most egregious and costly
fraud in the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program
(TANF) and return the funds to the children they were intended
to help. We asked Republicans to work with us to enact it. Last
Congress, the Majority refused, so we reintroduced it this
Congress.
Unlike our proposal, H.R. 8872, which was introduced less
than 48 hours before our markup, is not about fraud. The Acting
Chair confirmed that at our Committee markup. Rep. Judy Chu
offered an amendment with our proposal to require HHS to search
for and punish TANF fraud, which the House Parliamentarian has
twice referred solely to the Ways and Means Committee, and the
Acting Chair ruled that the Committee could not consider the
amendment because it was outside the scope of this Committee's
jurisdiction. We strongly disagree with the position that the
full scope of preventing fraud in TANF, including mandatory
administrative appropriations to support oversight and
investigations, is not part of the Committee's jurisdiction.
Unfortunately, because the Majority blocked Rep. Chu's
amendment, the only part of H.R. 8872 that is about fraud is
its misleading title.
During this Congress and enabled by the Majority, President
Trump's HHS has repeatedly demonstrated that their goal is not
to prevent fraud, but rather to use unsubstantiated fraud
allegations as a pretext to withhold funding to states whose
Governors the President dislikes. In fact, the Trump
Administration has enabled fraud, canceling the penalty the
previous Administration levied against Mississippi for criminal
TANF fraud. And the President has pardoned at least 21
individuals who were convicted of stealing $1.6 billion from
Medicare and Medicaid, which is more than the total TANF grant
in 48 states. The President's pardons wiped out over $2 billion
in restitution to people harmed by fraud, just like HHS wiped
out the penalty for stealing from poor children in Mississippi.
After wiping out penalties for real fraud, HHS froze $10
billion in critical social services funding to 5 states with
Democratic governors, claiming fraud but not producing a shred
of evidence for it. Federal courts forced HHS to return the
money before families were harmed, in part because of the
limits on HHS authority that H.R. 8872 would undermine. HHS has
also repeatedly attempted to use unsubstantiated fraud
allegations as a pretext to access taxpayer and beneficiary
data in order to share it with ICE for warrantless arrests of
immigrants and U.S. citizens alike.
H.R. 2108, the Democratic bill Republicans have blocked for
more than 2 years, would require the Department of Health and
Human Services (HHS) to address the real fraud in TANF--state
payments to contractors or sub-grantees who either misled the
state or conspired with the state to fraudulently use public
funds for purposes unrelated to helping struggling families and
poor children. Mississippi, for example, diverted $90 million
in TANF funding to wealthy and well-connected people like
former quarterback Brett Favre, who used it to build a
volleyball stadium and invest in stocks. The Mississippi case
has resulted in multiple criminal prosecutions, but the
Majority's only response to it was to invite Mr. Favre to
testify before our Committee and excuse his behavior. The
children of Mississippi have not been compensated.
Far from fighting fraud, H.R. 8872 would give HHS a new
tool to cut or freeze funding for states on the Trump enemies
list in order to force policy changes or extort sensitive
individual beneficiary data. Since the statistical calculation
under the Program Integrity Act (PIA) was not designed for
flexible block grants like TANF, the bill's vague instruction
to ``apply'' it would give HHS wide latitude to decide what the
calculation is, what data is required, and to design it to
justify payment freezes or data grabs that have so far been
blocked by courts. The Congressional Budget Office estimates
that H.R. 8872 would produce no budgetary savings.
The Chair did rule that amendments to prevent misuse of
TANF funds to give pregnant women incorrect medical information
and to require HHS to answer simple questions about their prior
actions to prevent states from accessing funding for child
care, work supports, adult protective services, and other key
social services were relevant to the bill's subject. Those
amendments to protect taxpayers and pregnant women were
rejected by the Majority.
H.R. 8872 fits the pattern of this Congress--President
Trump and his Republican allies in Congress rail against fraud
but intervene to enrich themselves or to protect rich, well-
connected fraudsters at taxpayer expense. We urge the Majority
to work with us to hold real criminals and fraudsters
accountable.
Sincerely,
Richard E. Neal,
Ranking Member.
[all]