Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 9171]
The Committee on Appropriations submits the following
report in explanation of the accompanying bill making
appropriations for the Department of the Interior, the
Environmental Protection Agency, and Related Agencies for the
fiscal year ending September 30, 2027.
INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT
Page number
Bill Report
Title I--Department of the Interior........................ 2
16
Title II--Environmental Protection Agency.................. 83
62
Title III--Related Agencies................................ 108
80
Department of Agriculture.......................... 108
80
Department of Health and Human Services............ 127
92
Council on Environmental Quality and Office of
Environmental Quality.......................... 139
99
Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board..... 140
99
Institute of American Indian and Alaska Native
Culture and Arts Development................... 141
100
Smithsonian Institution............................ 141
100
National Gallery of Art............................ 144
102
John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts..... 146
102
Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars... 146
102
National Endowment for the Arts.................... 147
102
National Endowment for the Humanities.............. 147
103
Commission of Fine Arts............................ 149
105
National Capital Arts and Cultural Affairs......... 149
105
Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.......... 150
105
National Capital Planning Commission............... 150
106
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum............ 150
106
United States Semiquincentennial Commission........ 151
107
Title IV--General Provisions............................... 152
107
Title V--Other Matters..................................... 186
109
House of Representatives Reporting Requirements....
112
HIGHLIGHTS OF THE BILL
The Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies
Subcommittee has jurisdiction over a diverse group of agencies
responsible for managing Federal lands and national parks,
protecting the environment, reinforcing the Federal commitments
to honor our trust and treaty responsibilities to American
Indians and Alaska Natives, and supporting the arts and
humanities. The activities of these agencies are integral to
the operations of our government.
The bill provides a total of $38,900,000,000 in
discretionary budget authority for fiscal year 2027.
Within the level of funding provided, the bill fully funds
the Payments in Lieu of Taxes (PILT) program, as well as
Contract Support Costs and section 105(l) lease costs, and
prioritizes funding for Tribes, domestic energy production, and
wildland fire management activities.
The bill provides $3,211,709,000 for the Bureau of Indian
Affairs (BIA). Within this funding, the bill prioritizes Public
Safety and Justice activities and provides a total of
$774,836,000 for fiscal year 2027. The bill also provides
$1,547,961,000 for the Bureau of Indian Education (BIE) and
$8,688,408,000 for the Indian Health Service (IHS). In
addition, the bill provides a fiscal year 2028 advance
appropriations of $6,063,735,000 for the Indian Health Service.
The bill affirms the Administration's proposal to unify
firefighting activities across the Department of the Interior
and establish a U.S. Wildland Fire Service and provides
increases within the U.S. Wildland Fire Service and the U.S.
Forest Service to support wildland firefighter pay.
In order to fund these priorities at necessary levels, the
Committee has reduced funding for the majority of accounts in
the bill. This includes a reduction of $1,781,584,000, or 20
percent, reduction to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
below the fiscal year 2026 enacted level.
In addition to limiting spending, the bill continues
several important policy provisions from previous years to:
Prohibit funds for EPA to impose mandatory
reporting of greenhouse gas emissions from manure
management systems.
Prohibit funds to regulate the lead content
of ammunition or fishing tackle under the Toxic
Substances Control Act or any other Act.
Prohibit funds for EPA to implement
permitting requirements for livestock emissions under
the Clean Air Act.
Require the Administration to implement
policies that reflect the carbon neutrality of forest
biomass.
Restrict funding for acquisition of lands or
interests in lands from being used for declarations of
taking or complaints in condemnation.
Prohibit funds for computer networks unless
it blocks access to pornography.
Require the use of American iron and steel
in EPA safe drinking water projects.
Ensure that ancillary mining activities,
including exploration operations and construction of a
mine access road, are permitted with or without the
discovery of a valuable mineral deposit (a fix to the
Rosemont decision).
Advance forest and land management projects
by addressing the Cottonwood Environmental Law Center
v. United States Forest Service decision.
Prohibit Federal agencies from using the
social cost of carbon in any rulemaking, guidance
document, or environmental decision-making process.
Unleash America's vast energy resources by
reinstating leases for critical minerals.
And the bill adds new provisions to:
Close the Office of Navajo and Hopi Indian
Relocation.
Block multiple U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service rulings from the prior Administration used to
stifle access to land and energy production.
Block funding for the Presidio Trust.
REPROGRAMMING GUIDELINES
The following are the procedures governing reprogramming
actions for programs and activities funded in the Department of
the Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies Appropriations
Act. The agencies funded in this Act are reminded that these
reprogramming guidelines are in effect and must be complied
with.
Definitions. ``Reprogramming'' as defined in these
procedures, includes the reallocation of funds from one budget
activity, budget line-item, or program area to another within
any appropriation funded in this Act.
For construction, land acquisition, and forest legacy
accounts, a reprogramming constitutes the reallocation of
funds, including unobligated balances, from one construction,
land acquisition, or forest legacy project to another such
project. For fiscal year 2027, a reprogramming also includes
the list of Federal land acquisition projects required to be
submitted to the House and Senate Committees on Appropriations
pursuant to Section 428(a)(2) of this Act.
A reprogramming shall also consist of any significant
departure from the program described in the agency's budget
justifications. This includes all proposed reorganizations or
other workforce actions detailed below which affect a total of
10 staff members or 10 percent of the staffing of an affected
program or office, whichever is less, even without a change in
funding. Any change to the organization table presented in the
budget justification shall also be subject to this requirement.
Agencies are reminded that this bill continues longstanding
General Guidelines for Reprogramming that require agencies
funded by this Act to submit reorganization proposals for the
Committees' review prior to their implementation. It is noted
that such reprogramming guidelines apply to proposed
reorganizations, workforce restructure, reshaping, transfer of
functions, or bureau-wide downsizing and include closures,
consolidations, and relocations of offices, facilities, and
laboratories. In addition, no agency shall implement any part
of a reorganization that modifies regional or state boundaries
for agencies or bureaus that were in effect as of the date of
enactment of this Act unless approved, consistent with the
General Guidelines for Reprogramming procedures specified
herein. Any such reprogramming request submitted to the
Committee shall include a description of anticipated benefits,
including anticipated efficiencies and cost-savings, as well as
a description of anticipated personnel impacts and funding
changes anticipated to implement the proposal.
General Guidelines for Reprogramming.--
(a) A reprogramming should be made only when an
unforeseen situation arises, and then only if
postponement of the project or the activity until the
next appropriation year would result in actual loss or
damage.
(b) Any project or activity, which may be deferred
through reprogramming, shall not later be accomplished
by means of further reprogramming, but instead, funds
should again be sought for the deferred project or
activity through the regular appropriations process.
(c) Except under the most urgent situations,
reprogramming should not be employed to initiate new
programs or increase allocations specifically denied or
limited by Congress, or to decrease allocations
specifically increased by the Congress.
(d) Reprogramming proposals submitted to the
Committee for approval will be considered as
expeditiously as possible, and the Committee reminds
the agencies that in order to process reprogramming
requests, adequate and timely information must be
provided.
Criteria and Exceptions.--A reprogramming must be submitted
to the Committee in writing prior to implementation if it
exceeds $1,000,000 annually or results in an increase or
decrease of more than 10 percent annually in affected programs
or projects, whichever amount is less, with the following
exceptions:
(a) With regard to the Tribal priority allocations of
the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and Bureau of Indian
Education (BIE), there is no restriction on
reprogrammings among these programs. However, the
Bureaus shall report on all reprogrammings made during
a given fiscal year no later than 60 days after the end
of the fiscal year.
(b) With regard to the EPA, the Committee does not
require reprogramming requests associated with the
States and Tribes Partnership Grants or up to a
cumulative total of $5,000,000 from carryover balances
among the individual program areas delineated in the
Environmental Programs and Management account, with no
more than $1,000,000 coming from any individual program
area. No funds, however, shall be reallocated from
individual Geographic Programs.
(c) With regard to the National Park Service (NPS),
the Committee does not require reprogramming requests
associated with the park base within the Park
Management activity in the Operation of the National
Park System Account. The NPS is required to brief the
Committee on spending trends for the park base not
later than 60 days following the enactment of this Act.
Assessments.--``Assessment'' as defined in these procedures
shall refer to any charges, reserves, or holdbacks applied to a
budget activity or budget line-item for costs associated with
general agency administrative costs, overhead costs, working
capital expenses, or contingencies.
(a) No assessment shall be levied against any
program, budget activity, subactivity, budget line-
item, or project funded by the Interior, Environment,
and Related Agencies Appropriations Act unless such
assessment and the basis therefore are presented to the
Committee in the budget justifications and are
subsequently approved by the Committee. The explanation
for any assessment in the budget justification shall
show the amount of the assessment, the activities
assessed, and the purpose of the funds.
(b) Proposed changes to estimated assessments, as
such estimates were presented in annual budget
justifications, shall be submitted through the
reprogramming process and shall be subject to the same
dollar and reporting criteria as any other
reprogramming.
(c) Each agency or bureau which utilizes assessments
shall submit an annual report to the Committee, which
provides details on the use of all funds assessed from
any other budget activity, line-item, subactivity, or
project.
(d) In no case shall contingency funds or assessments
be used to finance projects and activities disapproved
or limited by Congress or to finance programs or
activities that could be foreseen and included in the
normal budget review process.
(e) New programs requested in the budget should not
be initiated before enactment of the bill without
notification to, and the approval of, the Committee.
This restriction applies to all such actions regardless
of whether a formal reprogramming of funds is required
to begin the program.
Quarterly Reports.--All reprogrammings between budget
activities, budget line-items, program areas, or the more
detailed activity levels shown in this bill, including those
below the monetary thresholds established above, shall be
reported to the Committee within 60 days of the end of each
quarter and shall include cumulative totals for each budget
activity or budget line-item, or construction, land
acquisition, or forest legacy project.
Legacy.--Lands shall not be acquired for more than the
approved appraised value, as addressed in section 301(3) of
Public Law 91-646, unless such acquisitions are submitted to
the Committee for approval in compliance with these procedures.
Land Exchanges.--Land exchanges, wherein the estimated
value of the Federal lands to be exchanged is greater than
$1,000,000, shall not be consummated until the Committee has
had 30 days in which to examine the proposed exchange. In
addition, the Committee shall be provided advance notification
of exchanges valued between $500,000 and $1,000,000.
Budget Structure.--The budget activity or line-item
structure for any agency appropriation account shall not be
altered without advance approval of the Committee.
OTHER COMMITTEE DIRECTION
Acreage Treated.--The Committee recognizes the Department
of the Interior and the U.S. Forest Service's intention to
moving beyond acreage treated as a performance metric towards
outcome-focused measurements that accurately reflect the impact
of the agencies' forest restoration work on wildfire risk
reduction and ecosystem resilience. The Committee believes that
utilizing proven, existing, commercially available advanced
decision support tools and analytics are important for
accomplishing this task and evaluating the real-world outcomes
of forest treatments and ensuring Federal investments yield the
highest returns in terms of risk mitigation and ecosystem
health. The Committee directs the U.S. Forest Service, in
coordination with the Department of the Interior, to provide
the Committee an update not later than 45 days following the
enactment of this Act regarding how the agencies will report on
outcomes beyond acres treated and what decision support tools,
especially those that are already commercially available, are
needed to accomplish this task.
Bighorn Sheep.--The Committee is aware that the U.S. Forest
Service and the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) use the Western
Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies' occupied bighorn
habitat maps, telemetry data, and recent bighorn observations
in conducting Risk of Contact analyses and that risk of contact
models are currently being run on a State-wide basis where
sufficient data exists. The Committee directs the agencies to
complete Risk of Contact analyses using the Western Association
of Fish and Wildlife Agencies' data. The Committee expects the
agencies to continue to share findings transparently and
promptly with other Federal land management agencies, State and
local governments, State wildlife agencies, and State and
Federal animal health professionals, including the Agricultural
Research Service, permittees, and stakeholders. The Committee
further directs the U.S. Forest Service and BLM to engage the
Agricultural Research Service and the aforementioned
cooperating agencies and participants to ensure the best
professional scientific understanding of where and if disease
transmission occurs, and the degree of that risk, before making
further management decisions that impact permittees.
Bird Collisions on Federal Property.--The Committee
encourages all agencies funded by this Act to continue to
advance best practices to enhance protections for avian species
and continues direction provided in House Report 117-400
regarding bird collisions.
Cost of Litigation and Lack of Transparency.--The Committee
is concerned that many of the legitimate goals of the U.S.
Forest Service, EPA, and the Department of the Interior
jurisdiction are undermined by litigation filed in an effort to
shift land management decisions from the agencies to the
courts, regardless of merit. It is apparent that many activist
groups are using the Federal court system to stop any
activities they do not support.
The Committee is also concerned with litigation costs
funded with agency discretionary appropriations and settlements
fun
Minority Views
The fiscal year 2027 Interior, Environment and Related
Agencies (Interior) Appropriations bill falls short in meeting
the needs of the American people. The bill fails to address
Americans facing rising utility bills, it fails to protect our
environment, and it fails to protect endangered species.
Furthermore, this bill further shifts responsibilities for key
government functions onto State budgets which are already
reeling from illegal funding freezes, cuts to federal grant
programs, and changes to federal programs such as Medicaid.
The bill would raise utility bills prices, hamper the EPA's
ability to fight climate crisis, shortchange our National Parks
and would benefit polluters and big corporations.
The bill cuts funding for the EPA by twenty percent,
including cuts of $713 million from State and Tribal Assistance
Grants and $1 billion from science and environmental programs.
The cuts in this bill to state water infrastructure are
compounded by the fact that this is the first year that states
will not have access to the additional funding provided by the
Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. The bill cuts EPA
enforcement by nearly half, paving the way for corporations to
pollute and violate the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, and
hazardous waste laws. These cuts would be the latest blow
following the Trump administration weakening restrictions on
forever chemicals in our drinking water, on pesticides in our
farming soil, and on particulate matter in the air we breathe.
Despite the promises this administration has made to the
Make America Healthy Again movement, it is clear this bill
would enable the administration to continue to prioritize
chemical manufactures, polluters, fossil fuel companies, and
other big industry over the health and safety of the American
people.
The bill includes new fees on offshore wind companies,
slashes funding for renewable energy programs, and remains
silent on the administration's multi-faceted assault of
renewable energy companies and its payoffs to companies to
abandon offshore wind totaling nearly $2 billion to date.
American households will pay the price for these policies
through higher energy prices.
This administration continues its attacks on institutions
which support the arts and humanities across the country,
regardless of the effect its decisions will have on people and
communities. The administration has illegally terminated
thousands of grants at both the National Endowment for the Arts
(NEA) and the National Endowment for Humanities (NEH). It fired
nearly 80 percent of NEH staff and revoked funding for the
State Humanities Councils. Congress must assert its support for
the Arts and Humanities and reject this administration's
sidelining of these key institutions. Instead, this bill cuts
each endowment by $72 million or 35%, to the detriment of
communities across the country, as well as cutting the National
Gallery of Art and the Smithsonian Institution.
The bill cuts the National Park Service facilities
operation and maintenance by $163 million. Meanwhile, the
administration is currently taking funds provided by National
Parks entrance fees which are used for maintenance projects to
instead pay for political pet projects. Reportedly, tens of
millions of dollars are being awarded through no-bid contracts
to companies with whom the President is friendly. The
administration is also taking $15 million in funds from the
National Endowment for the Humanities, funding which normally
supports programs in towns across America, to pay for a
Triumphal Arch at the entrance of Arlington National Cemetery,
over the objection of veterans. This bill does nothing to stop
this improper use of taxpayer funds.
Finally, the bill includes 51 poison pill riders that
negatively impact endangered species, the environment, and
energy development.
Ranking Member Pingree offered an amendment which would
have blocked construction of the Triumphal Arch, respecting the
ideal that Arlington National Cemetery should honor those who
sacrificed for our country, not sitting politicians.
Rep. Lee offered an amendment which would have stopped the
administration's bias against renewable energy in the
permitting process. This amendment would have leveled the
playing field for renewable energy, a key step in lowering
utility costs for consumers.
Rep. Levin offered an amendment which would have prohibited
offshore drilling off sections of Florida and California. The
administration continues to push for additional offshore oil
drilling in areas of the country where there is wide public
opposition, while simultaneously undermining renewable energy
development which States had been counting on. We are also
gravely concerned about the expansion of drilling at a time
when the administration is rolling back the reforms instituted
in the wake of the deepwater horizon oil spill, including the
remerging the bureaus responsible for leasing and environmental
oversight and has proposed revising the Blowout Preventer and
Well Control Rule.
Other democratic amendments which were rejected by the
majority included efforts to prohibit public funding for
President Trump's White House ballroom, increase funding for
EPA State Revolving Funds, restore funding for EPA
Environmental Justice initiatives, strike all partisan policy
provisions from the bill, and specifically target riders
removing Endangered Species Act protections for species such as
the grizzly bear and gray wolf.
These amendments are examples which provided opportunities
to work together to address some of our serious concerns and
move towards a more bi-partisan bill. Unfortunately, the
majority rejected these amendments.
We were pleased by the commitment made by Chairman Simpson
during the debate of an amendment offered by Ranking Member
DeLauro to ensure the committee is able to execute its
oversight responsibilities over the Forest Service, which is
currently undergoing a significant reorganization effort. We
look forward to working in a bi-partisan fashion to ensure
priorities essential to all of our districts, such as invasive
species research, are not harmed.
It is disappointing that this bill fails to meet the moment
by providing insufficient funding levels for critical programs,
including numerous partisan policy riders and by failing to
address the most controversial actions of the administration
which directly affect the Agencies funded in this bill.
In its current form, this bill fails to meet the needs of
the American people for affordable energy prices, clean water
and air, and for a government that prioritizes the needs of its
citizens over political vanity projects. If implemented, the
American people would see the negative effects of this bill
when they pay their water bills, electric bills, and their
state and local taxes. Given these shortcomings, we cannot
support this bill as it stands. Despite our objections to the
bill in its current form, we will work with Chairman Simpson
through this year's appropriations process to produce a
responsible bill that both parties can support.
Rosa L. DeLauro.
Chellie Pingree.
FULL COMMITTEE VOTES
Pursuant to the provisions of clause 3(b) of rule XIII of
the House of Representatives, the results of each roll call
vote on an amendment or on the motion to report, together with
the names of those voting for and those against, are printed
below:
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF BUDGET AUTHORITY
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives and section 308(a)(1)(A) of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the following table compares
the levels of new budget authority provided in the bill with
the appropriate allocation under section 302(b) of the Budget
Act.
BUDGETARY IMPACT OF THE FY 2027 INTERIOR, ENVIRONMENT, AND RELATED
AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS BILL PREPARED IN CONSULTATION WITH THE
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE PURSUANT TO SECTION 308(A) OF THE
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET ACT OF 1974
[In millions of dollars]
COMPARISON WITH BUDGET RESOLUTION
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives and section 308(a)(1)(A) of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the following table compares
the levels of new budget authority provided in the bill with
the appropriate allocation under section 302(b) of the Budget
Act.
[In millions of dollars]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
302(b) Allocation This Bill
---------------------------------------------------------------
Budget Budget
Authority Outlays Authority Outlays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Comparison of amounts in the bill with Committee
allocations to its subcommittees: Subcommittee
on Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies:
Discretionary............................... .............. .............. 41,850 156,829
Mandatory................................... .............. .............. 64 169
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1Includes outlays from prior-year budget authority.
FIVE-YEAR OUTLAY PROJECTIONS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII and section
308(a)(1)(B) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the
following table contains five-year projections associated with
the budget authority provided in the accompanying bill as
provided to the Committee by the Congressional Budget Office.
[In millions of dollars]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Outlays
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Projection of outlays associated with the
recommendation:
2027............................................. 122,620
2028............................................. 12,634
2029............................................. 4,747
2030............................................. 1,363
2031 and future years............................ 852
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1Excludes outlays from prior-year budget authority.
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII and section
308(a)(1)(C) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the
Congressional Budget Office has provided the following
estimates of new budget authority and outlays provided by the
accompanying bill for financial assistance to State and local
governments.
[In millions of dollars]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Budget Authority Outlays
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Financial assistance to State and 5,777 11,673
local governments for 2027.......
------------------------------------------------------------------------
11Excludes outlays from prior-year budget authority.
STATEMENT OF GENERAL PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following is a statement of
general performance goals and objectives for which this measure
authorizes funding:
The Committee on Appropriations considers program
performance, including a program's success in developing and
attaining outcome-related goals and objectives, in developing
funding recommendations.
PROGRAM DUPLICATION
No provision of this bill establishes or reauthorizes a
program of the Federal Government known to be duplicative of
another Federal program, a program that was included in any
report from the Government Accountability Office to Congress
pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program
related to a program identified in the most recent Catalog of
Federal Domestic Assistance.
COMMITTEE HEARINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following hearings were used to
develop or consider the Department of the Interior,
Environment, and Related Agencies Appropriations Bill, 2027:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Date Title of Hearing Witnesses
------------------------------------------------------------------------
March 5, 2026................... Member Day........ The Honorable Dina
Titus (NV-01)
.................. The Honorable
Debbie Wasserman
Schultz (FL-25)
.................. The Honorable
Aumua Amata
Coleman Radewagen
(AS-At Large)
March 17, 2026.................. American Indian Darrell G. Seki
and Alaska Native Sr., Chairman,
Public Witness Red Lake Band of
Day 1 (Morning Chippewa Indians
Session).
.................. Michael Fairbanks,
Chairman, White
Earth Nation
.................. Virgil Wind, Chief
Executive, Mille
Lacs Band of
Ojibwe
.................. Bruce Savage,
Chairman, Fond du
Lac Band of Lake
Superior Chippewa
.................. Austin Lowes,
Chairman, Sault
Ste. Marie Tribe
of Chippewa
Indians
.................. Winnay Wemigwase,
Chairperson,
Little Traverse
Bay Bands of
Odawa Indians
.................. John Johnson,
President, Lac du
Flambeau Band of
Lake Superior
Chippewa Indians
.................. Jason Schlender,
Executive
Administrator,
Great Lakes
Indian Fish and
Wildlife
Commission
.................. Whitney Gravelle,
President, Bay
Mills Indian
Community/Board
Member, Chippewa
Ottawa Resource
Authority
.................. Aja DeCoteau,
Executive
Director,
Columbia River
Inter-Tribal Fish
Commission
.................. Ashton Picard,
Vice-Chairman,
Nez Perce Tribe
.................. Donna Thompson,
Chairwoman, Fort
Hall Business
Council of the
Shoshone-Bannock
Tribes
.................. Chief Allan,
Chairman, Coeur
d'Alene Tribe
.................. Dr. Toni Tsatoke-
Mule, Executive
Director, Kiowa
Education Agency,
Kiowa Tribe
.................. Brian Harris,
Chief, Catawba
Nation
.................. Vivian Korthuis,
Chief Executive
Officer,
Association of
Village Council
Presidents
.................. Kristina Andrew,
Third Chief,
Curyung Tribal
Council
.................. Stephen Roe Lewis,
Governor, Gila
River Indian
Community