Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 7894]
The Committee on Education and Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 7894) to make improvements to the Harry
S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Truman Scholarship Clean House Act''.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
Section 3 of the Harry S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C.
2002) is amended--
(1) by redesignating paragraphs (1) through (6) as paragraphs
(2) through (7), respectively; and
(2) by inserting before paragraph (2), as so redesignated,
the following:
``(1) `affiliated with', when used with respect to an
individual's relationship to a certain political party, means
that the individual--
``(A) is a registered member of that political party;
``(B) is a current or former holder of elected public
office from that political party;
``(C) is a current or former candidate for public
office from that political party;
``(D) is a current or former political appointee
associated with that political party;
``(E) is a current staffer of--
``(i) a holder of elected public office from
that political party;
``(ii) a candidate of that political party;
or
``(iii) a fundraising organization for such
members or candidates; or
``(F) is a current or former judicial appointee
nominated or otherwise selected by a holder of elected
public office from that political party.''.
SEC. 3. HARRY S TRUMAN SCHOLARSHIP FOUNDATION.
(a) Board of Trustees.--Section 5 of the Harry S Truman Memorial
Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C. 2004) is amended--
(1) in subsection (b)--
(A) in paragraph (1), by striking ``The Board shall
be composed of'' and all that follows through the end
of subparagraph (D); and
(B) by adding at the end the following:
``(2) The Board shall be composed of 13 members, as follows:
``(A) One member appointed by the Speaker of the House of
Representatives.
``(B) One member appointed by the minority leader of the
House of Representatives.
``(C) One member appointed by the majority leader of the
Senate.
``(D) One member appointed by the minority leader of the
Senate.
``(E) Eight members, not more than four of whom may be
affiliated with the same political party at the time of
appointment, to be appointed by the President with the advice
and consent of the Senate.
``(F) The Secretary of Education or the Secretary's designee,
who shall serve ex officio as a member of the Board, but shall
not be eligible to serve as Chairperson.'';
(2) by amending subsection (c) to read as follows:
``(c)(1) Except as provided in paragraph (2), the term of office of
each member of the Board (other than Secretary of Education or the
Secretary's designee serving ex officio) shall be six years.
``(2) As designated by the President at the time of appointment, of
the members first appointed under subsection (b)(2)(E) after the date
of enactment of this paragraph--
``(A) three shall be appointed for terms of two years;
``(B) three shall be appointed for terms of four years; and
``(C) two shall be appointed for terms of six years.
``(3) Any member of the Board appointed to fill a vacancy shall serve
for the remainder of the term for which the member's predecessor was
appointed, and shall be appointed in the same manner as the original
appointment for that vacancy was made.
``(4) No member of the Board (other than the Secretary of Education
or the Secretary's designee serving ex officio) may serve more than two
six-year terms, regardless of whether the terms are consecutive. A
member described in subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (2) who serves
an initial term of less than six years, may serve up to two additional
six-year terms following the expiration of such member's initial
term.''; and
(3) by adding at the end the following:
``(e) Seven members of the Board shall constitute a quorum.''.
(b) Transition and Implementation.--
(1) Dissolution of existing board of trustees.--Effective on
the date that is 90 days after the date of enactment of this
Act, the Board of Trustees of the Harry S Truman Scholarship
Foundation (as established under section 5 of the Harry S
Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C. 2004)) is dissolved
and all members of the Board are terminated.
(2) Appointment of new members.--As soon as practicable after
the effective date specified in paragraph (1), new members
shall be appointed to the Board of Trustees of the Harry S
Truman Scholarship Foundation in accordance with section 5 of
the Harry S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C. 2004),
as amended by subsection (a).
SEC. 4. SELECTION OF TRUMAN SCHOLARS.
Section 7 of the Harry S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C.
2006) is amended--
(1) in subsection (b)--
(A) by inserting ``the eligibility requirements
described in subsection (c) and'' before ``minimum
criteria''; and
(B) by inserting ``in accordance with subsection
(d)(4)'' before the period at the end;
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(c) A student is eligible to be nominated for a scholarship under
this Act if such student--
``(1) is--
``(A) a full-time undergraduate student enrolled at
an institution of higher education who will receive a
bachelor's degree in the academic year following the
academic year in which the student is applying for a
scholarship; or
``(B) a full-time senior level student from the
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico or from The Islands (as
defined in section 1801.2(b) of title 45, Code of
Federal Regulations (as in effect on the date of the
enactment of this subsection));
``(2) is enrolled in a course of study that qualifies the
student for admission to a graduate program leading to a career
in public service;
``(3) has a demonstrated record of academic excellence; and
``(4) is a citizen or national of the United States or a
permanent resident of the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana
Islands.
``(d) (1) The Foundation shall establish and maintain Regional Review
Panels for purposes of carrying out subsection (a).
``(2) Each Regional Review Panel shall be responsible for selecting
scholarship recipients from one or more States assigned to the Panel by
the Board.
``(3)(A) Each Regional Review Panel shall consist of not fewer than
five members, each of whom shall be appointed on an annual basis by an
affirmative vote of not less than two-thirds of the members of the
Board.
``(B) Not more than half of the members of a Regional Review Panel
may be affiliated with the same political party at the time of
appointment.
``(4) In selecting students to be scholarship recipients under this
Act, each Regional Review Panel--
``(A) shall select students based on--
``(i) the extent and quality of community service and
government involvement of the student;
``(ii) the leadership record of the student;
``(iii) the academic performance of the student,
including with respect to and writing and analytical
skills; and
``(iv) the suitability and appropriateness of the
student's proposed graduate program of study for a
career in public service;
``(B) shall not select any student who--
``(i) served as a leader, officer, director, or
organizer of a student organization recognized by the
institution of higher education at which the student is
enrolled at time of an incident or conduct that led to
the suspension or expulsion of such organization from
such institution;
``(ii) has been suspended or expelled by an
institution of higher education due to a violation of
such institution's code of conduct or other
disciplinary action by such institution; or
``(iii) has been convicted by any Federal, State, or
local court of competent jurisdiction of a felony; and
``(C) may not disfavor or otherwise apply adverse
considerations to a student because the student intends to
pursue a particular type of graduate degree, including with
respect to a Master of Business Administration degree or Doctor
of Medicine degree.''.
SEC. 5. TERMINATION OF TRUMAN SCHOLARSHIP.
Section 9 of the Harry S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C.
2008) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by inserting ``in accordance with
subsection (c) and'' after ``provided in this Act''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(c)(1) In accordance with paragraph (2), a student awarded a
scholarship under the provisions of this Act may not continue to
receive the payments provided in this Act if, at any point after the
date on which the scholarship is received, the student--
``(A) with respect to a report or request required by the
Foundation--
``(i) fails to submit such a report or request; or
``(ii) provides false, misleading, or materially
incomplete information on any such report or request;
``(B) fails to begin use of the scholarship within four years
of the date of receipt of a bachelor's degree, unless granted
an extension in writing by the Foundation;
``(C) serves as a leader, officer, director, or organizer of
a student organization recognized by the institution of higher
education at which the student is enrolled at time of an
incident or conduct that leads to the suspension or expulsion
of such organization from such institution;
``(D) is suspended or expelled by the institution of higher
education at which the student is enrolled due to a violation
of the institution's code of conduct or other disciplinary
action by the institution; or
``(E) is convicted by any Federal, State, or local court of
competent jurisdiction of a felony.
``(2)(A) The Foundation may not stop the payments provided in this
Act without first affording the student--
``(i) reasonable notice, which shall include the reason for
stopping such payments identified under subsection (a) or
subsection (c)(1) and any additional relevant information, as
determined by the Foundation; and
``(ii) opportunity for a hearing.
``(B) If the Foundation, after reasonable notice and opportunity for
hearing, finds that a student does not meet the conditions of receiving
payment in accordance with subsection (a) or subsection (c)(1), the
Foundation shall--
``(i) stop the payments provided in this Act for such
student; and
``(ii) provide written notice to such student, which shall
include the reason for stopping such payments identified under
subsection (a) or subsection (c)(1) and any additional relevant
information, as determined by the Foundation.
``(d) A student whose payments are stopped pursuant to subsection (a)
or subsection (c)(1) or an individual who fails to be employed in
public service for three out of the first seven years of employment
following completion of the graduate degree for which the individual
used such payments shall repay to the Foundation an amount equal to the
sum of--
``(1) the total amount of payments provided in this Act to
such student; and
``(2) interest at the rate of 6 percent per annum on the
total amount described in paragraph (1).
``(e) The Foundation shall ensure all scholarship recipients are
notified of the conditions that apply to receiving payments provided in
this Act as described in this section, prior to the date of the first
such payment.''.
SEC. 6. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY OF FOUNDATION.
(a) In General.--Section 12 of the Harry S Truman Memorial
Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C. 2011) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by striking ``who shall be appointed
by the Board'' and inserting ``who shall be appointed by an
affirmative vote of not less than two-thirds of the members of
the Board''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(c) The Executive Secretary shall serve a term of 4 years and may
be reappointed to up to two additional terms of four years in
accordance with subsection (a).''.
(b) Appointment.--Not later than 90 days after a quorum of the
members of the Board of Trustees of the Harry S Truman Scholarship
Foundation have been appointed in accordance with section 3(b)(2) of
this Act, the Board shall appoint an Executive Secretary of the
Foundation in accordance with section 12 of the Harry S Truman Memorial
Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C. 2011), as amended by subsection (a).
(c) Service of Incumbent.--The individual serving as Executive
Secretary of the Harry S Truman Scholarship Foundation as of the date
of enactment of this Act may only continue serving in such position
until the earlier of--
(1) the date on which the Board of Trustees of the Foundation
appoints a new Executive Secretary in accordance with
subsection (b); or
(2) the expiration of the 90 day period beginning on the date
that a quorum of the members of the Board have been appointed
in accordance with section 3(b)(2).
SEC. 7. TRANSPARENCY PROVISIONS.
Section 13 of the Harry S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C.
2012) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(c)(1) The Foundation shall preserve in unaltered format, and make
available on a publicly accessible website of the Foundation, the
following materials of the Foundation:
``(A) Press releases.
``(B) Program announcements.
``(C) Biographies of scholarship recipients.
``(2) The materials described in paragraph (1) may not be deleted,
hidden, or password-protected.
``(3) Any edits made to the materials described in paragraph (1)
after such materials were initially published shall be clearly
identified and, in a case in which an edit has been made to such
materials, a copy of the original, unaltered materials shall remain
available to the public on a website of the Foundation.
``(4) The requirements of this subsection shall apply to any
materials published by the Foundation before, on, or after the date of
enactment of this subsection.''.
SEC. 8. EFFECTIVE DATE AND APPLICABILITY.
(a) Applicability.--This Act and the amendments made by this Act
shall apply only with respect to scholarships awarded under the Harry S
Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C. 2002) on or after the date
of enactment of this Act.
(b) Treatment of Previously Awarded Scholarships.--Nothing in this
Act or the amendments made by this Act shall be construed to invalidate
or revoke, or alter the terms and conditions of, a scholarship that was
awarded under the Harry S Truman Memorial Scholarship Act (20 U.S.C.
2002) before the date of enactment of this Act. The Harry S Truman
foundation shall take such steps as may be necessary to continue to
fund and administer such previously awarded scholarships.
Purpose
H.R. 7894, Truman Scholarship Clean House Act, amends the
Harry S. Truman Memorial Scholarship Act to root out political
bias in the Truman Scholarship program and ensure that every
scholarship applicant--no matter their political persuasion--
has a fair chance to win.
Committee Action
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On December 3, 2025, the Subcommittee on Higher Education
and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``Public Funds,
Private Politics: Examining Bias in the Truman Scholarship
Program.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine
ideological bias in the Harry S. Truman Scholarship program.
Testifying before the Subcommittee were Dr. Frederick Hess,
Senior Fellow and Director, Education Policy Studies, American
Enterprise Institute, Washington, District of Columbia; Ms.
Jennifer Kabbany, Editor-in-Chief, The College Fix, Vista,
California; Ms. Ashley Harrington, Senior Policy Counsel, NAACP
Legal Defense Fund, Washington, District of Columbia; and Mr.
Adam Kissel, Visiting Fellow, Center for Education Policy,
Heritage Foundation, Washington, District of Columbia.
Legislative Action
On March 12, 2026, Representative Elise Stefanik (R-NY)
introduced H.R. 7894, Truman Scholarship Clean House Act. The
bill was referred solely to the Committee on Education and
Workforce. On March 17, 2026, the Committee considered H.R.
7894 in legislative session and reported it favorably, as
amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of
19-13.\1\ The Committee considered the following amendments to
H.R. 7894:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/7894/
all-actions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Representative Randy Fine (R-FL) offered an
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute that made a
technical change. The amendment was adopted by voice
vote.
2. Ranking Member Robert C. ``Bobby'' Scott (D-VA)
offered an amendment to prohibit the Truman Board of
Trustees from changing the name of the scholarship and
to delay implementation until 2029. The amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 13-18.
3. Ranking Member Scott offered an amendment to
prohibit any Member of Congress who votes in favor of
the legislation, as well as any individual serving in a
presidentially appointed position under the Trump
administration, from eligibility for a covered position
on the Truman Scholarship Board. The amendment failed
by a recorded vote of 13-18.
4. Ranking Member Scott offered an amendment to
strike the allowance for Master of Business
Administration and Doctor of Medicine graduates to be
eligible for the Truman Scholarship program. The
amendment failed by voice vote.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
The Truman Scholarship was established by Congress in 1975
to honor President Truman's legacy of public service. The
program awards scholarships worth $30,000 to about 60 college
juniors annually who ``demonstrate outstanding potential for
and who plan to pursue a career in public service.''\2\ These
funds are to be used for graduate study in an American
university in fields such as government, military, or non-
profit service. Along with the monetary award, being a Truman
Scholar comes with extensive access to mentoring, special
programming, and networking opportunities.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Truman Scholars, 20 U.S.C. Sec. 2005 (1975); and Harry S. Truman
Memorial Scholarship Act, S. 3548, 93rd Cong., 2nd sess. (1974).
\3\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/partner-organizations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These activities are largely funded by the federal
government. As the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) has
reported, ``The program relies primarily on taxpayer funds,
from both interest revenue generated by a publicly financed
endowment established by Congress and an annual
appropriation.''\4\ The FY 2026 appropriation is $2.97
million.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Do-the-Rhodes-
and-Truman-Scholarships-Have-Any-Room-for-the-Right.pdf?x85095.
\5\https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/7148/
text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Truman Foundation claims that it ``supports scholars
from a wide range of perspectives, interests, and geographic
areas.''\6\ Former Truman winners include a bipartisan list of
public figures, such as Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch, former
Governor Janet Napolitano (D-AZ), and former Mayor Bill de
Blasio (D-NY). Alumni also include current Members of Congress
such as Representatives Gabe Amo (D-RI), Dusty Johnson (R-SD),
Greg Stanton (D-AZ), and Sen. Andy Kim (D-NJ).\7\
However, recent studies have found overwhelming evidence
that the Truman Foundation, which administers the program,
selects liberal students far more often than conservative ones.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://www.truman.gov/sites/default/files/2024-03/
Truman_CBJ%202025_Final.pdf.
\7\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/truman_letter.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVIDENCE OF POLITICAL BIAS IN THE TRUMAN PROGRAM
The College Fix recently analyzed Truman winners' political
orientation at the time their scholarship was awarded. Their
investigation found that, in the last 10 years, liberal winners
outnumbered conservatives by a 14:1 ratio. As The College Fix
reported, ``Of the 599 awards doled out since 2015--only 26
winners leaned right. In contrast, 354 awardees were involved
in left-leaning causes. The rest, 219, could not be ascertained
based on their public-facing bios.''\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\https://www.thecollegefix.com/bulletin-board/the-college-fix-
investigates-truman-scholarships/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
AEI has found similar results. Between 2021 and 2023, the
Truman Foundation selected 182 Truman winners. AEI could
identify only six recipients who expressed interest in a
traditionally conservative-leaning cause when their scholarship
was awarded. Not a single winner professed interest in causes
such as protecting the rights of the unborn or defending the
Second Amendment; only three winners mentioned interest in
religious liberty. By contrast, the Truman Foundation selected
at least 74 winners professing interest in a traditionally
progressive cause such as ``immigration rights,'' diversity,
equity and inclusion, LGBT issues, and climate change.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/do-the-rhodes-and-
truman-scholarships-have-any-room-for-the-right/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Truman winners remain overwhelmingly liberal even several
years after being awarded the scholarship. The College Fix
reviewed the current public activities of Truman Scholars from
the 2017 and 2018 cohorts and found that at least 98 of the 122
winners retain a clear connection to liberal politics, such as
working for Democrat Members of Congress, advocating for
progressive causes, or teaching classes with a liberal focus.
By contrast, not a single winner could be identified who is
currently active in conservative politics.\10\ The College Fix
developed a similar analysis of 2015 and 2016 winners; they
identified only one winner who is obviously a conservative
today.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\https://www.thecollegefix.com/80-of-federally-funded-truman-
scholars-involved-in-liberal-causes-within-a-decade-of-winning/.
\11\https://www.thecollegefix.com/75-of-truman-scholars-involved-
in-left-wing-politics-a-decade-later-analysis-finds/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This skew has numerous downstream effects. For one,
colleges may be more hesitant to nominate conservative students
or invest resources in supporting their application if the
university knows there is little likelihood the student will
win. Each university may nominate only four candidates annually
for the Truman.\12\ Consequently, even fair-minded universities
may give preference to liberal students who universities
perceive to have a greater chance of winning the award.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\https://www.truman.gov/apply/applying/bulletin-information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, students at conservative-leaning institutions
are effectively disqualified from competing for the
scholarship. Jeffrey Thornhill, the Truman advisor at the
conservative-leaning Patrick Henry College, recently said,
``Nine or so years ago we nominated a candidate who was not
selected. It is a lot of work for an unlikely outcome.''\13\
Despite being explicitly organized around public service and
preparing students for careers in government, public policy,
and law, Patrick Henry College has had zero Truman Scholars
since 1990.\14\ Until 2025, Hillsdale College had never had a
Truman winner.\15\ Liberty University has never had a Truman
winner,\16\ nor have Covenant College,\17\ Biola
University,\18\ Wheaton College in Illinois,\19\ Pepperdine
University,\20\ or Cedarville University.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\https://www.thecollegefix.com/colleges-experts-disagree-on-why-
taxpayer-funded-truman-
fellowships-skew-liberal/.
\14\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_name=&
year=&state=All&institution=Patrick+Henry+College+%28642%29.
\15\https://hillsdalecollegian.com/2025/04/junior-becomes-
hillsdales-first-truman-scholar/.
\16\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_name=
&year=&state=All&institution=Liberty+University+%281182%29.
\17\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_name=&year=&state=All&institution=Covenant+Coll
ege+%28266%29.
\18\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_name=&year=
&state=All&institution=Biola+University+%28143%29.
\19\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_ name=&year=
&state=All&institution=Wheaton+College-IL+%281061%29.
\20\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_name=
&year=&state=All&institution=Pepperdine+University+%28647%29.
\21\https://www.truman.gov/meet-our-scholars/scholar-
listing?first_name=&last_name=&year=
&state=All&institution=Cedarville+University+%28198%29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For the few conservatives who do win the Truman, the alumni
programming and alumni networking opportunities have
significantly less value than for liberal winners. An anonymous
Truman Scholar said in 2024:
Because the scholars are overwhelmingly progressive,
scholars who don't fit that mold tend to disengage.
This is especially true when opponents of progressive
policies are labeled as racists or bigots . . . Most of
the programming at Truman events is aimed at
progressive scholars, because they are the majority
participating. Even when you want to do bipartisan
programming, it is hard because there are almost no
engaged Republicans who can be tapped . . . If you are
a new Truman Scholar who wants to work on LGBTQ issues
in your state, you have a wealth of past scholars to
tap for assistance, same with climate change, immigrant
rights, sustainable cities, bail reform, or any number
of other progressive causes. As a conservative, I have
never looked to the Truman network for help on any of
the things I am working on.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\https://www.aei.org/education/an-insiders-take-on-the-truman-
scholarships-ideological-bias/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE COMMITTEE'S OVERSIGHT EFFORTS ON THE TRUMAN PROGRAM
In 2024, then-Committee on Education and the Workforce
Chairwoman Virginia Foxx, Labor, HHS, Education, and Related
Agencies Appropriations Subcommittee Chairman Robert Aderholt
(R-AL), and Higher Education and Workforce Development (HEWD)
Subcommittee Chairman Burgess Owens (R-UT) issued a letter to
Truman Foundation Executive Secretary Terry Babcock-Lumish
inquiring about ideological bias in the program.\23\ The letter
posed the following four questions:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
5.20.24_truman_letter.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) What measures are you taking to ensure the Truman
Scholarship truly ``supports scholars from a wide range
of perspectives?''
(2) How do you ensure that Truman Finalist Selection
Committee members and Regional Review Committee members
do not discriminate against conservative students?
(3) In a recent news article, you were quoted as
saying that ``the Truman Scholars selected are
reflective of the pool of candidates before us. If
students are not nominated or do not apply, we cannot
select them.'' Between 2021 and 2023, what percentage
of your applicant pool advocated primarily for
conservative causes?
(4) What steps are you taking to recruit a more
ideologically diverse pool of nominees?
Rather than acknowledging the troubling evidence or
pledging any reforms, Babcock-Lumish denied any problem and
insisted AEI's research to the contrary is ``severely
misleading,'' ``specious,'' ``verging on arbitrary,'' and
``needlessly divisive.'' She insisted that ``during the
application and interview process, we have no knowledge of
applicants'' ideological orientations,'' that ``we do not and
would not ask applicants to choose a side,'' and that ``we are
focused on candidates looking for practical solutions to
improve their communities, our nation, and our world.'' She
also reiterated that the ``Truman Scholars selected are
reflective of the pool of candidates before us. If students are
not nominated or do not apply, we cannot select them.''\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/truman_letter.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After the release of the 2024 AEI report, the Truman
Foundation did not publish biographies for its 2025 winners,
which was AEI's sole data source for its previous studies.\25\
Instead, in 2025, the Truman Foundation shared only the names
and universities of winners. The Truman Foundation also hid\26\
the biographies of past winners; those files are now password-
protected\27\ and inaccessible\28\ to the public.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\https://www.truman.gov/2025Scholars.
\26\https://www.truman.gov/press-release-2022-truman-scholars.
\27\https://www.truman.gov/2024PressRelease.
\28\https://www.truman.gov/2023PressRelease.
\29\https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-truman-foundation-must-embrace-
civic-seriousness/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, The College Fix used publicly available sources
(such as LinkedIn) to analyze the political orientations of the
2025 Truman winners. In 2025, the Truman Foundation again
selected liberal winners at a 12:1 ratio over conservatives.
The 2025 winners include an ``abortion doula,'' an ``abolition
feminist,'' and multiple students who use ``they/them'' or
other nonstandard pronouns.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\https://www.thecollegefix.com/pervasive-leftward-bias-taxpayer-
funded-truman-scholars-overwhelmingly-liberal-for-11th-year-in-a-row/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On December 3, 2025, HEWD Subcommittee Chairman Owens held
a hearing titled, ``Public Funds, Private Politics: Examining
Bias in the Truman Scholarship Program.'' During the hearing,
witness Dr. Hess of AEI testified that, based on his estimates,
the ideological composition of the Regional Review Panels who
interview and select students skews approximately four-to-one
Democrat to Republican.
Mr. Kissel of the Heritage Foundation noted that the Truman
Foundation's website is clearly left-coded. For example, the
website provides examples of ``substandard'' essay responses
that include essays from students who aspire to active duty in
the Marines, students who have a deep appreciation for the
United States, and students whose Christian faith informs their
interest in public service. As of Mr. Kissel's testimony, there
were no corresponding examples of ``excellent'' essays from
students who aspire to military service, appreciate the United
States, or are Christians.
On March 12, 2026, Rep. Elise Stefanik introduced H.R.
7894, Truman Scholarship Clean House Act. The bill fires the
existing board of directors and executive secretary, institutes
numerous safeguards to ensure political bias is rooted out, and
establishes a student code of conduct winners must meet.
Conclusion
Given the Truman Foundation's continued pattern of liberal
bias and refusal to take Congressional concerns seriously,
Congress should advance Truman Scholarship reforms to ensure
every interested student has equal access to the award.
President Truman's legacy of public service is honored when
every applicant has a fair chance, when personal merit matters
more than ideology, and when taxpayer funds are not used to
boost one particular political party.
Section-by-Section Summary
Section 1. Short title
The Act may be cited as the Truman
Scholarship Clean House Act.
Section 2. Definitions
Defines ``affiliated with'' when used with
respect to an individual's relationship with a certain
political party.
Section 3. Harry S. Truman Scholarship Foundation
Fires the existing Board of Trustees
effective 90 days after passage of the Act.
Establishes a term limit of two six-year
terms for Truman Board of Trustees members.
Establishes that seven members of the Board
shall constitute a quorum.
Section 4. Selection of Truman Scholars
Codifies existing regulations that
scholarships may only be awarded to U.S. citizens or
nationals.
Establishes that each interviewing panel
shall consist of at least five members, each of whom
shall be appo
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 7894, the Truman Scholarship Clean House Act,
sponsored by Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY), amends the Harry S
Truman Memorial Scholarship Act to make significant changes to
the operation of the Harry S. Truman Scholarship Foundation
(``Truman Foundation'') and the processes by which recipients
of the Harry S. Truman Memorial Scholarship (``Truman
Scholars'') are selected. 19 million students enrolled in
American higher education are facing a system that is becoming
increasingly harder to access and afford. This is due in part
to actions recently taken by this Committee.\1\ Given that
context, the Majority has decided to focus the Committee's time
and attention on a small program that provides graduate school
scholarships to approximately 60 students yearly, to pursue
careers in public service. The Majority does this under the
rationale that the Truman Scholarship is riddled with political
bias disfavoring conservative students and academic subjects of
study.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. Law. No. 119-21 Sec. Sec. 81001, 82001 (2025).
\2\Infra notes 3-32 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 7894 is a bundle of policy ``solutions'' looking for a
problem. The Committee has no credible evidence of wrongdoing
or bias on behalf of the Foundation, relying instead on flimsy
non-academic papers and ``exposes'' by entities with
established conservative ties. It is not clear if the bill's
policies would even bring about the Majority's desired
solutions if passed into law. What is clear is that the bill
would give President Trump power to remake the Scholarship as
he saw fit. Based on the President's established track record
of remaking political institutions with little regard to his
authority or the law, this Committee should not empower him
further.
BACKGROUND INTO TRUMAN SCHOLARSHIP ``OVERSIGHT''
Starting in the 118th Congress, the Majority has conducted
oversight of the Truman Foundation based on allegations of
left-wing bias. Because these allegations are the driving force
behind all Committee action in regard to the Truman Foundation,
it is important to analyze and dismiss them before addressing
the substance of H.R. 7894.
On May 20th, 2024 then Committee Chair Virginia Foxx (R-
NC), Higher Education and Workforce Development (HEWD)
Subcommittee Chair Burgess Owens (R-UT), and Rep. Robert
Aderholt (R-AL), Chair of the Subcommittee on Labor, Health and
Human Services, Education, and Related Agencies of the
Committee on Appropriations, sent a letter to Dr. Terry
Babcock-Lumish, Executive Secretary of the Truman
Foundation.\3\ The letter leveled accusations of bias at the
Foundation, alleging it displayed a ``stark partisan tilt''.\4\
These accusations were based wholly on analysis conducted by
scholars at the American Enterprise Institute, a right-wing
think tank.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Letter from Rep. Virginia Foxx, H. Comm. on Educ. & the
Workforce Chair., et al., to Dr. Terry Babcock-Lumish, Exec. Sec'y, The
Harry S. Truman Scholarship Foundation (May 20, 2024), https://
edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/5.20.24_truman_letter.pdf.
\4\Id.
\5\Over the last two Congresses, Committee Republicans have called
AEI scholars and fellows as witnesses at least eight different full
Committee or subcommittee hearings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In that AEI report, Frederick Hess and Joe Pitts alleged
that the Rhodes Scholarship Program (privately funded) and
Truman Scholarship Program (in part publicly funded) evinced
left-wing bias in their recipient selection processes.\6\ In
their report, Hess & Pitts conducted analysis of 182 Truman
Scholar biographies from 2021-2023 and the Scholars' policy
issue interests. The biographical analysis proved nothing; the
majority of Truman Scholars could not be classified under AEI's
standards as either progressive or conservative from a reading
of their biographies.\7\ Further, their analysis found that 90
percent of Scholars reported no affiliation with partisan
officials, candidates, or organizations in their
biographies.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Letter from Rep. Virginia Foxx, supra note 3; Frederick M. Hess
& Joe Pitts, Do the Rhodes and Truman Scholarships Have Any Room for
the Right? Am. Enterprise Inst., May 2024, https://www.aei.org/wp-
content/uploads/2024/05/Do-the-Rhodes-and-Truman-Scholarships-Have-Any-
Room-for-the-Right.pdf?x85095.
\7\Hess & Pitts, supra note 6, at 3 (``After examining the
biographies, we concluded that there weren't enough data on affiliation
with partisan officials, candidates, or organizations to support
credible analysis. While scholars were vastly more likely to report
left-leaning associations than right-leaning ones, more than 90 percent
didn't report any such affiliation.'').
\8\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Researchers with no pre-conceived notions regarding the
Truman Foundation might have stopped there. However, Hess &
Pitts continued to a strained policy issue analysis classifying
policy issues that Truman Scholars expressed interest in as
``progressive,'' ``centrist,'' or ``conservative.''\9\
Progressive issues included: LGBT+ advocacy; racial justice and
diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI); climate and the
environment; and immigration rights. Centrist issues included
mental health, cybersecurity and technology, national and
international security and sexual violence prevention.
Conservative issues included free markets, religious freedom,
pro-life advocacy, and gun rights.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Id. at 3-5. Hess & Pitts coded the scholars' policy issue
interests by 12 categories, four belonging to each ideological
framework. They emphasized that each policy issue category was
``uncontested'' and therefore is unarguably belonging to its respective
ideological framework.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hess & Pitts found ``[O]f the 182 Truman scholars, 74 cite
interest in at least one progressive issue, while just six note
interest in a conservative issue.''\10\ This was seen by them
as a damning indictment of the Truman Scholarship as being
overrun with progressive scholars. That analysis fails to
mention by their own standards, if a survey of 182 scholars
showed that 80 scholars expressed interest in partisan policy
issues, that leaves 102 of scholars who expressed interest in
policy issues that could not be classified as either
progressive or conservative. To put this in terms our Majority
colleagues might better understand, the percentage of scholars
who expressed either centrist or non-partisan policy issue
interests (56%) is greater than the current percentage of House
Republicans' majority in Congress (50.58%).\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Id.at 4.
\11\Based on the Clerk of the House's tally of 218 Republicans, 212
Democrats, 1 Independent, and 4 vacancies. If the Independent who
caucuses with the Republicans is included, their majority is 50.81%.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A sober conclusion could be drawn that Truman Scholars on
the whole were mostly interested in centrist or non-partisan
policy issues. Hess & Pitts instead called on the Truman
Foundation to recruit a more diverse scholar pool that ``true
to the nation's breadth of perspectives, views, and values''
and on institutions to reevaluate their engagement with the
Foundation if matters do not improve.\12\ This request was then
parroted in the May 20th letter from Reps. Foxx, Owens and
Aderholt.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Hess & Pitts, supra note 6, at 5.
\13\Letter from Rep. Virginia Foxx, supra note 3, at 1-2 (``. . .
the Truman Scholarship should, at a bare minimum, be reflective of the
country's breadth of values, viewpoints, and interests.'') (no internal
citations omitted).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to the May 20th letter highlighting the AEI
study,\14\ Executive Secretary of the Foundation, Dr. Terry
Babcock-Lumish responded with a comprehensive critique of the
AEI analysis for its broad characterization of issues as
conservative or progressive.\15\ She also called the findings
misleading because the researchers did not acknowledge all
applicants, only those students who were selected.\16\ Dr.
Babcock-Lumish claimed that the Foundation has no knowledge of
applicants' ideological orientations unless they explicitly
share them.\17\ She criticized the researcher's methods
flagging that categorizing an issue as conservative,
progressive, or neutral is subjective.\18\ She added that in
the report ``[e]ven within issues, there is no allowance made
for students who wish to take a conservative approach to a
topic already deemed `progressive.'''\19\ Dr. Babcock-Lumish
also noted that AEI ignored the fact that applicants work in
apolitical settings where they are required to avoid partisan
politics. Therefore, most applicants are neither obviously
progressive nor obviously conservative. For example, she noted
that ``a Naval Academy midshipman interested in studying the
environmental impacts of the nuclear fleet would be
characterized as progressive for the purposes of AEI's
report.''\20\ Similarly, at a December 3, 2025 HEWD
Subcommittee Hearing on the Truman Foundation, Ranking Member
Bobby Scott (D-VA) challenged the report's classification of
certain policy issues as inherently progressive:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Id.
\15\Letter from Dr. Terry Babcock-Lumish, Exec. Sec'y, The Harry S.
Truman Scholarship Foundation, to Rep. Virginia Foxx, Chair., H. Comm.
on Educ. & the Workforce, et al. (May 31, 2024), https://
edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/truman_letter.pdf.
\16\Id. at 1.
\17\Id.
\18\Id.
\19\Id.
\20\Id. at 2.
Mr. Scott. Well, you consider left leaning if you
have an interest in racial justice?
Mr. Hess. Yes, right. DEI in particular was coded
as----
Mr. Scott. Racial justice? That's not a universal
kind of idea, but that's a left leaning, disqualifying
fact. Do you need to balance that off with people that
oppose racial justice?
Mr. Hess. No, sir.
. . .
Mr. Scott. Okay. Climate change is a left leaning
idea, is that right?
Mr. Hess. That's how we coded it sir, that's right.
Mr. Scott. Okay. Now, how many college students fail
to recognize the scientific fact of climate change?
Mr. Hess. I don't----
Mr. Scott. What portion of college students fail to
recognize the scientific fact of climate change?
Mr. Hess. I don't know.
Mr. Scott. What portion of college faculty--
prospective, college faculty can get hired if they say
they don't believe in science?
Mr. Hess. [no response.]
Mr. Scott. Not many.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Public Funds, Private Politics: Examining Bias in the Truman
Scholarship Program: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Higher Educ. &
Workforce Development of the H. Comm. on Educ. & Workforce, 119th Cong.
(2025) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ddGJVRQSOeY&t=5224s.
Committee Oversight of the Truman Foundation was also
driven by ``reporting'' from The College Fix, a conservative
leaning news website. In June 2024, The College Fix published
an ``expose'' on the Truman Scholarship and political
ideology.\22\ Using a combination of winners' official
biographies, self-reported work histories on LinkedIn, and
social media profiles and posts, the author's found that of the
599 recipients since 2015, only 26 leaned right, 354 leaned
left.\23\ Politics could not be determined for 219 of the 599
recipients.\24\ Moreover, of 380 scholars with political
affiliations, 93% were ``affiliated'' with left leaning
politics.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\The College Fix, The College Fix investigates: Truman
Scholarships, (June 10, 2024), https://www.thecollegefix.com/bulletin-
board/the-college-fix-investigates-truman-scholarships/.
\23\Id.
\24\Id.
\25\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The College Fix's analysis is plagued by many of the same
assumptions made by AEI. In many of the years of its decades of
analysis, the number of scholars whose politics could not be
determined was greater than the number of liberal and
conservative coded scholars combined.\26\ While they claimed to
see liberal scholars everywhere, the College Fix also seemed to
go out of its way to deny that conservative scholars existed.
In describing one member of the 2021 cohort, they said, ``One
of the award winners, an economics student at Michigan State,
interned at the conservative American Enterprise Institute and
interned with the White House Council of Economic Advisors
during the Donald Trump administration, but his political
affiliation remains unclear.''\27\ In 2022, a year the website
said the Truman cohort was ``dominated'' by Democrats and
progressives, 5 scholars had worked in Democratic offices, 3
had worked in Republican offices.\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\The College Fix, CollegeFixTrumanData:FINAL, (last accessed
June 28, 2026), https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/
16QuIsOOA_AH5UwZh_fKmQORWb_nIrz22-pvOGE9VbTU/edit?gid=0#gid=0.
\27\Christian Schneider, Prestigious federal scholarship once again
all but excludes self-described conservatives, The College Fix, Apr.
20, 2021, https://www.thecollegefix.com/prestigious-federal-
scholarship-once-again-all-but-excludes-self-described-conservatives/
(emphasis added).
\28\Christian Schneider, Prestigious $30K federal scholarships
doled out almost exclusively to progressive students, The College Fix,
Apr. 19, 2022, https://www.thecollegefix.com/prestigious-30k-federal-
scholarships-doled-out-almost-exclusively-to-progressive-students/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Majority's oversight of the Truman Foundation is a
continuation of its narrative alleging there is a conservative
bias on campus. They claim the lack of ``viewpoint diversity''
on campus inhibits the ability of conservative students to
express their views. Evidence suggests that notwithstanding
such a viewpoint imbalance, conservative thought continues to
flourish on college campuses. The Majority's analysis
consistently fails to acknowledge that conservative speech on
campus is propped up by a vast network of outside organizations
that support such speech,
. . . ranging from financial resources for campus
recruiting, conference travel, and summer fellowships
to opportunities to bring speakers onto campus and
templates for media blitzes . . . .
[C]onservative organizations not only channel
activism, but also create a career funnel that helps
young activists find paid internships and occupational
opportunities within the conservative sector. In
contrast, students in the progressive channel are
unable to build upon external sponsorships, but must
navigate in more of a do-it-yourself environment, both
in terms of political activism and future career
prospects.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\Daniel Meyer, Campus Activism in Polarized Times, 87 Higher
Educ. 813-818 (2023) (reviewing The Channels of Student Activism: How
the Left and Right Are Winning (and Losing) in Campus Politics Today by
Amy Binder and Jeffrey Kidder).
By their own accounts, there are over 2,000 College
Republicans chapters on American college campuses,\30\ over
2,000 chapters of Young Americans for Freedom,\31\ over 800
college chapters of Turning Point USA,\32\ and over 200
chapters of the Federalist Society at U.S. law schools.\33\
This is just the most public tip of the iceberg of
infrastructure and private capital dedicated to incubating
conservative thinkers and leaders on campus and vaulting them
into positions of political influence in Washington, D.C. and
state capitals around the country.\34\ Claims of a campus free
speech crisis simply perpetuate the need to continue to
subsidize more conservative voices on campus who then claim as
part of their activism, that there is a free speech crisis on
campus.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\College Republican National Committee, About CRNC, https://
www.crnc.org/about (last visited Mar. 30, 2024). This is distinct from
College Republicans of America, the Political Action Committee founded
former college republicans designed ``to empower, train, and develop
the next generation of Republican leaders. By providing resources,
training, networking opportunities, and incentives for students to
volunteer in our various initiatives, CRA enables our young Republicans
to advocate for conservative principles, support Republican candidates,
effect change in our communities, conserve our environment, secure
employment, and shape public policy.'' https://www.uscollegegop.com/.
\31\Young America's Foundation, Home Page, https://yaf.org/ (last
visited Mar. 30, 2024) (``Young America's Foundation is the leading
organization for young conservatives. With more than 60 years of
experience and contacts on more than 2,000 campuses, we help students
like you find support, promote conservatism, and take action.'').
\32\Turning Point USA, College Program--Turning Point USA, https://
www.tpusa.com/college (last visited Mar. 30, 2024) (``Turning Point USA
College educates students about the importance of limited government,
freedom, and capitalism. This department has 48 full-time field
representatives that exist to educate, support, train, and empower
students through grassroots activism and peer-to-peer conversations . .
. . With nearly over 800+ college chapters, this program is the largest
and most impactful--successfully rebranding the movement to make it fun
and engaging to young people.'').
\33\The Federalist Society, Student Division, The Federalist
Society, https://fedsoc.org/divisions/student (last visited Mar. 30,
2024) (``Student Division programming fosters a network of conservative
and libertarian students eager to challenge the legal establishment as
lawyers, faculty, judges, and policy makers.''); The Federalist
Society, About Us, https://fedsoc.org/about-us#FAQ (last visited Apr.
1, 2024) (``Everyone is welcome to the programs