Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4795]
The Committee on Education and Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 4795) to amend the Higher Education Act
of 1965 to prohibit an institution that participates in a
nonexpressive commercial boycott of Israel from being eligible
for certain funds under that Act, to require an institution
that participates in certain programs under that Act to certify
that students are not unreasonably obstructed from
participating in academic programs in Israel, and for other
purposes having considered the same, reports favorably thereon
with an amendment and recommends that the bill be as amended do
pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Protect Economic and Academic
Freedom Act of 2026''.
SEC. 2. INELIGIBILITY OF INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION PARTICIPATING
IN CERTAIN NONEXPRESSIVE COMMERCIAL BOYCOTTS.
Section 487(a) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C.
1094(a)) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(30)(A) The institution will not engage in a nonexpressive
commercial boycott of a major strategic partner of the United
States.
``(B) For purposes of this paragraph:
``(i) The term `major strategic partner' means, with
respect to the United States--
``(I) a country described in section 4 of
Public Law 113-296; or
``(II) an entity licensed or regulated by, or
organized under the laws of, such a country.
``(ii) The term `nonexpressive commercial boycott of
a major strategic partner--
``(I) means a commercial action (including
engaging in refusals to deal and terminating
business activities) that--
``(aa) is intended to limit
commercial relations with a major
strategic partner; and
``(bb) is not based on a valid
business reason; and
``(II) does not include actions described in
regulations issued to provide for the
exceptions described in section 1773(a)(2) of
the Anti-Boycott Act of 2018 (50 U.S.C.
4842(a)(2)).''.
SEC. 3. ELIGIBILITY FOR TITLE VI FUNDS.
Title VI of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1121 et
seq.) is amended by adding at the end the following new sections:
SEC. 639. INSTITUTIONAL CERTIFICATIONS.
``(a) Annual Requirement for Institutional Eligibility.--Not later
than July 31 of each calendar year beginning on or after the date of
enactment of the Protect Economic and Academic Freedom Act of 2026, an
institution of higher education participating or applying to
participate in any program under this title shall submit to the
Secretary the certification required under subsection (b). An
institution that does not submit such certification by July 31 of a
calendar year shall be ineligible to receive any funds under this title
in the first fiscal year that begins after such July 31, including any
funds under this title that would otherwise have been available to the
institution in such fiscal year for a grant awarded during a previous
fiscal year.
``(b) Certification.--An institution shall certify to the Secretary
that, for the period beginning on the date of such certification and
ending on July 31 of the following year, the institution will--
``(1) permit students and faculty of the certifying
institution to participate in academic programs, including
conferences, teaching exchanges, cultural exchanges, study
abroad programs, joint research, and other collaborative
educational activities, in a major strategic partner (as
defined in section 487(a)(30)) of the United States in the same
manner, and under the same terms and conditions, as students
and faculty of the institution are permitted to participate in
academic programs in other foreign countries; and
``(2) permit students and faculty of postsecondary
educational institutions in such a major strategic partner to
participate in academic programs offered by the certifying
institution, including conferences, teaching exchanges,
cultural exchanges, study abroad programs, joint research, and
other collaborative educational activities, in the same manner,
and under the same terms and conditions, as students and
faculty of other foreign postsecondary educational institutions
that are not in such a major strategic partner.
``SEC. 639A. SENSE OF CONGRESS.
``It is the sense of Congress that limitations on cooperative
efforts by institutions of higher education, consortia of such
institutions, or partnerships between nonprofit educational
organizations and institutions of higher education with a major
strategic partner (as defined in section 487(a)(30)) of the United
States do not serve the security, stability, and economic vitality of
the United States.''.
Purpose
H.R. 4795, Protect Economic and Academic Freedom Act of
2026, amends the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) to prohibit
an institution that participates in a nonexpressive commercial
boycott of Israel from receiving federal student aid under
Title IV of the HEA. The bill also requires an institution that
receives funds under Title VI to allow students and faculty to
participate in academic programs in Israel, and students and
faculty from Israel to participate in academic programs at the
institution, in the same manner in which the institution
provides such access to institutions in other countries and
students and faculty from other countries to the institution.
Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On November 14, 2023, the Subcommittee on Higher Education
and Workforce Development held a hearing titled ``Confronting
the Scourge of Antisemitism on Campus.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to discuss antisemitism on college campuses.
Testifying before the Subcommittee were Rabbi Moshe Hauer,
Executive Vice President, Orthodox Union, New York, New York;
Mr. Kenneth L. Marcus, Founder and Chairman, Brandeis Center,
Washington, D.C.; Ms. Stacy Burdett, Independent Consultant in
Antisemitism Prevention and Response, Silver Spring, Maryland;
and Ms. Sahar Tartak, Student, Yale University, New Haven,
Connecticut.
On December 5, 2023, the full Committee held a hearing
titled ``Holding Campus Leaders Accountable and Confronting
Antisemitism.'' The purpose of the hearing was to discuss
antisemitism on college campuses with key college presidents.
Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Claudine Gay,
President, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts; Ms.
Liz Magill, President, University of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Dr. Pamela Nadell, Professor of
History and Jewish Studies, American University, Washington,
D.C.; and Dr. Sally Kornbluth, President, Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Second Session--Hearing
On May 23, 2024, the full Committee held a hearing titled
``Calling for Accountability: Stopping Antisemitic College
Chaos.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine antisemitism
and responses to protest encampments on college campuses.
Testifying before the Committee were Mr. Michael Schill,
President, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois; Dr.
Jonathan Holloway, President, Rutgers, the State University of
New Jersey, New Brunswick, New Jersey; Mr. Frederick M.
Lawrence, Secretary and CEO, Phi Beta Kappa Society,
Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Gene Block, Chancellor, University of
California at Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California.
Second Session--Legislative Action
On November 26, 2024, Representative Virginia Foxx (R-NC)
introduced Protect Economic Freedom Act (H.R. 10257), which was
referred solely to the Committee on Education and the
Workforce.
119TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On May 7, 2025, the full Committee held a hearing titled
``Beyond the Ivy League: Stopping the Spread of Antisemitism on
American Campuses.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine
the rise in antisemitism on college campuses beyond the Ivy
League. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Wendy Raymond,
President, Haverford College, Haverford, Pennsylvania; Dr.
Robert Manuel, President, DePaul University, Chicago, Illinois;
Mr. David Cole, George J. Mitchell, Professor in Law and Public
Policy, Georgetown University Law Center, Washington, D.C.; and
Dr. Jeffrey Armstrong, President, California Polytechnic State
University, San Luis Obispo, California.
On July 15, 2025, the full Committee held a hearing titled
``Antisemitism in Higher Education: Examining the Role of
Faculty, Funding, and Ideology.'' The purpose of the hearing
was to examine the main drivers of antisemitism on college
campuses. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Robert M.
Groves, Interim President, Georgetown University, Washington,
D.C.; Dr. Felix V. Matos Rodriguez, Chancellor, The City
University of New York, New York, New York; Mr. Matt Nosanchuk,
Principal, Mattnos Strategies, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Richard K.
Lyons, Chancellor, University of California, Berkeley,
Berkeley, California.
119TH CONGRESS
Legislative Action
On September 29, 2025, Representative Foxx introduced H.R.
4795, Protect Economic and Academic Freedom Act of 2025, which
was referred solely to the Committee on Education and
Workforce. On June 25, 2026, the Committee considered H.R. 4795
in legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended,
to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 24-9.
Representative Foxx offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute that places the prohibition on engaging in a
nonexpressive commercial boycott directly within the program
participation agreement under Title IV of the HEA, removes the
separate annual certification requirement for institutions, and
removes the requirement that the Secretary of Education publish
a list of institutions that did not comply with the annual
certification requirement. The amendment passed by voice vote.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Antisemitism on college and university campuses has
increased significantly in recent years, particularly following
the October 7, 2023, terror attacks. During the 2024-2025
academic year, 2,334 antisemitic incidents were reported on
college and university campuses nationwide, the highest number
ever recorded.\1\ Antisemitic incidents on college campuses
increased by more than 700 percent between 2022 and 2025.\2\ In
addition, a 2025 survey found that 48.3 percent of non-Jewish
students reported witnessing or experiencing anti-Jewish
behavior on campus during the previous year, while 47.6 percent
endorsed at least one anti-Jewish attitude.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.hillel.org/antisemitism-on-college-campuses-
incident-tracking/.
\2\Ibid.
\3\https://adl.org/resources/press-release/adls-2026-campus-
antisemitism-report-card-reveals-
significant-progress.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BACKGROUND ON THE BOYCOTT, DIVESTMENT,
AND SANCTIONS (BDS) MOVEMENT
The BDS movement is a loose grouping of actors from various
countries that advocate for or engage in economic measures
targeting Israel or Israel-related individuals, organizations,
and businesses.\4\ The Arab League imposed a boycott of Jews in
Mandatory Palestine beginning in 1945, three years before the
establishment of the State of Israel. The modem BDS movement
was founded in 2001 during the United Nations' World Conference
Against Racism in Durban, South Africa.\5\ In July 2005, a
coalition of Palestinian organizations adopted the BDS movement
to call for the use of boycotts, divestment campaigns, and
sanctions as a means of pressuring Israel to change its
policies toward Palestinians.\6\ Specifically, the movement has
``the call'' for Israel to end its occupation and colonization
of all Arab lands and dismantle the wall constructed by Israel
along the border between Israel and the West Bank, and within
the West Bank, to protect Israelis from Palestinian violence;
recognize the fundamental rights of the Arab Palestinian
citizens of Israel to full equality and respect; and protect
and promote the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to
their homes and properties as stipulated in UN Resolution
194.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/
20191203_R44281_lc95dd528315abe4cb3528c526eae
77488759f52.pdf.
\5\https://www.ajc.org/campusbds.
\6\Ibid.
\7\https://www.bdsmovement.net/call.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BDS campaigns frequently demand the ``divestment'' of
university, municipal, church, union, and other investment
portfolios from companies that advocates claim ``aid Israel's
occupation,'' as well as call for the ``boycott'' of Israeli
products, professionals, professional associations and academic
institutions, and artistic performances.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\https://www.adl.org/resources/backgrounder/boycott-divestment-
and-sanctions-campaign-bds.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In recent years, BDS-related activism has gained
significant traction on American college and university
campuses, particularly following the October 7, 2023, terror
attacks. Student organizations, faculty groups, and unions have
increasingly used BDS campaigns to pressure universities to
alter investment practices and adopt policies aligned with the
movement's objectives. This movement became substantially more
widespread during the 2023-2024 academic year, as
demonstrations, encampments, and divestment campaigns engulfed
higher education.
Title VI of the HEA and the BDS Movement
Title VI of the HEA authorizes programs and funding for the
Department of Education (ED) to award grants in support of
international and foreign language studies.\9\ Part A of Title
VI authorizes National Resource Centers that award four-year
competitive grants to institutions of higher education to
establish and maintain an infrastucture for providing
international studies and modern foreign language
instruction.\10\ Title VI programs have been a source of
antisemitism in general, and the BDS movement specifically, on
college campuses.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R46508.
\10\https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R46508.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Georgetown's Title VI National Resource Center on the
Middle East and North Africa (NRC-MENA) provides an
illustrative example. The NRC-MENA operates the Center for
Contemporary Arab Studies (CCAS), which has become a platform
to promote antisemitism and the BDS movement. Three of CCAS'
five ``core'' staff actively support the BDS movement.\11\
Additionally, in December 2023, CCAS signed an agreement for
Georgetown to host the Middle East Studies Association (MESA).
Today, MESA effectively functions as an anti-Israel advocacy
group that has adopted a resolution endorsing BDS. Under the
agreement, CCAS granted MESA space on its main campus at no
cost.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Fida Adely; Marwa Daoudy; Rochelle A. Davis. https://
palestineandpraxis.weebly.com/.
\12\https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/kw4w8wuxj9ecwpevss7gp/How-
Campuses-Became-Hotbeds-the-Rise-of-Radical-Antisemitism-on-College-
Campuses.pdf?rlkey=
tsuha6vybakp5oqlxhto1euth&e=2&st=08c027lp&dl=0.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CCAS also runs an education outreach program that is
partially supported by its NRC-MENA grant. In February 2025,
CCAS co-hosted an event titled ``Palestine in the
Classroom''\13\ CCAS' K-14 education outreach director, Susan
Douglass, is an avowed BDS supporter. The Alwaleed Bin Talal
Center for Muslim-Christian Understanding (Center) is part of
Georgetown's School of Foreign Service and is also part of NRC-
MENA at Georgetown.\14\ The Center's faculty consistently
advance narratives that whitewash Islamism and demonize Israel,
all while educating the next generation of government servants,
producing reference works used across academia, and serving as
consultants to policymakers, media, corporate executives, and
others.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\https://ccas.georgetown.edu/resources/k-14-outreach/events-for-
educators/.
\14\https://ccas.georgetown.edu/about/national-resource-center-
mena/.
\15\https://isgap.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/FTM-GEORGETOWN-
REPORT-2025-05-23-1.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BDS Campaigns and Resolutions on College Campuses
During the 2023-2024 academic year, at least 86 BDS
resolutions were considered across undergraduate, graduate, and
professional student organizations and faculty unions.\16\
Seventy-seven passed and nine were voted down. In November
2025, Cornell University's graduate student union adopted a BDS
resolution that called for resistance ``by any means
necessary.''\17\ Within the University of California (UC)
system, United Auto Workers 4811, a union that represents
thousands of academic workers, vowed to wage a campaign to
pressure UC campuses to adopt BDS.\18\ At Northwestern
University, faculty members and Northwestern's provost were
openly willing to appease encampment organizers in their
efforts to demand the university boycott Sabra hummus because
of the brand's perception as an Israeli product.\19\ At
Haverford College, administrators caved to the antisemitic
blood libel demands of Students for the Liberation of Palestine
to ``Say No to Blood Donuts,'' refusing to serve previously
ordered donuts from Federal Donuts, a Jewish-Israeli owned
chain, at Commencement in 2024.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\https://www.adl.org/resources/report/anti-israel-activism-us-
campuses-2023-2024.
\17\https://www.timesofisrael.com/cornell-grad-student-union-
approves-bds-resolution-backing-resistance-by-any-means/.
\18\https://www.fairnesscenter.org/cases/yaniv-v-uaw-4811/.
\19\Text Message from Nour Kteily, Professor of Mgmt. and Org., Nw.
U. Kellog Sch. Of Mgmt., to Kathleen Hagerty, Provost, Nw. U (Apr. 27,
2024 3:18 AM) (on file with Comm.).
\20\https://www.inquirer.com/education/haverford-president-email-
tim-walberg-20250626.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BDS campaigns have been accompanied by allegations of
harassment, intimidation, exclusion, and discrimination
directed at students who identify as Jewish or express support
for Israel.\21\ In April 2024, at a BDS hearing at the
University of Albany, a student looked around and stated,
``Those who do not support this (BDS) should feel unsafe on
campus. I will make sure you do not feel safe.''\22\ In March
2024, anti-Israel protesters at Vanderbilt University shoved a
security guard as they protested the university's removal of a
proposed amendment to align the school's student government
with the demands of the BDS movement.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
10.30.24_committee_on_education_and_
the_workforce_republican_staff_report_-
_antisemitism_on_college_campuses_exposed.pdf.
\22\Ibid.
\23\https://www.adl.org/resources/report/anti-israel-activism-us-
campuses-2023-2024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BDS Legal Status
The core of the constitutional debate around BDS is whether
anti-BDS legislation regulates economic conduct or political
speech protected under the First Amendment.\24\ Opponents
contend that these boycotts are considered protected expressive
conduct and collective political action, a classification
established by Supreme Court cases involving nonviolent
boycotts.\25\ Conversely, proponents of anti-BDS legislation
assert that such laws regulate commercial conduct and not
political speech, with the state merely acting as a proprietor
in contracting decisions.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\https://legalclarity.org/anti-bds-bill-and-state-laws-
constitutional-challenges/.
\25\Ibid.
\26\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Supreme Court has heard numerous arguments on the
balance between regulating boycott activity and free speech. In
NAACP v. Claiborne Hardware Co. (1982),\27\ the Supreme Court
held that states may not prohibit peaceful political activities
associated with a boycott, including speech, assembly, and
advocacy. However, Claiborne did not establish a constitutional
right to engage in all forms of boycott activity and instead
distinguished between protected expressive conduct and economic
activity that may be regulated by the government.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\NAACP v. Claiborne Hardware Co., 458 U.S. 886 (1982).
In a related case, Rumsfeld v. Forum for Academic and
Institutional Rights, Inc. (2006),\28\ the Supreme Court ruled
that a law school treating military recruiters differently from
other recruiters was not inherently expressive and thus that
differential treatment was not protected by the First
Amendment. The Supreme Court stated,
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/547/47/#tab-
opinion-1962043.
. . . law schools `expressed' their disagreement with
the military by treating military recruiters
differently from other recruiters. But these actions
were expressive only because the law schools
accompanied their conduct with speech explaining it . .
. An observer who sees military recruiters interviewing
away from the law school has no way of knowing whether
the law school is expressing its disapproval of the
military, all the law school's interview rooms are
full, or the military recruiters decided for reasons of
their own that they would rather interview someplace
else . . . The expressive component of a law school's
action is not created by the conduct itself but by the
speech that accompanies it.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/547/47/#tab-
opinion-1962043.
The Supreme Court ruled that there was a ``substantial
government interest'' in requiring equal treatment of military
recruiters on college campuses and ruled against the law
school.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/547/47/#tab-
opinion-1962043.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This distinction between expressive activity and other
activity was central to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Eighth Circuit's decision in Arkansas Times LP v. Waldrip
(2022),\31\ which upheld Arkansas Act 710. That law prohibits
state entities from contracting with private companies unless
the contract includes a certification that the company ``is not
currently engaged in, and agrees for the duration of the
contract not to engage in, a boycott of Israel.''\32\ The court
rejected the argument that the statute violated the First
Amendment by restricting participation in boycotts of Israel.
In doing so, the court explained that Claiborne protected the
expressive activities accompanying a boycott, not the
commercial decision itself to refuse to do business with a
particular entity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Arkansas Times LP v. Waldrip, 37 F.4th 1386 (8th Cir. 2022).
\32\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The court emphasized that states retain broad authority to
regulate economic activity and concluded that the Arkansas law
targeted discriminatory commercial conduct rather than
political expression. The Eighth Circuit further reasoned that
Arkansas's law did not prohibit individuals or organizations
from criticizing Israel, advocating for a boycott, or
protesting the law itself. Rather, the statute prohibited
certain contracting entities from engaging in economic
decisions that discriminate against Israel. Because such
purchasing and contra
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 4795, the Protect Economic and Academic Freedom Act of
2025, sponsored by Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-NC) amends the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (HEA) to make institutions of higher
education (IHEs) ineligible for participation in any programs
authorized under HEA title IV (Title IV) if they engage in a
``nonexpressive commercial boycott'' of Israel.\1\ The bill
also makes IHEs ineligible for participation in any programs
under HEA title VI if they do not permit their students and
faculty to participate in foreign exchange programs with
Israel, or permit Israeli students and academics to participate
in their academic programs and exchanges.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H.R. 4795 Sec. 2, 119th Cong. (2025).
\2\H.R. 4795 Sec. 3, 119th Cong. (2025).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although the legislative text does not mention it by name,
Rep. Foxx said at the bill's introduction that it was aimed at
the official Boycott-Divest-Sanctions (BDS) movement\3\ No IHE
in the United States has expressed administrative support for
the BDS movement, making the first half of this bill a solution
in search of a problem. Further the solution it proposes may
violate long established principles regarding Congressional
power under the Spending Clause and First Amendment activity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Press Release, Rep. Virginia Foxx, Foxx, Gottheimer Introduce
Bill to Hold Higher Education Accountable for BDS Activity (July 30,
2025), https://foxx.house.gov/news/
documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=400167 (``[The legislation] prohibits
colleges and universities from receiving federal student aid if they
engage in commercial and academic boycotts dictated by those in the
boycott-sanction-divest (BDS) movement.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Even though the BDS movement in America has little to no
institutional momentum behind it, there are increasing
instances of faculty members, student and faculty groups, and
scholarly associations taking stances to limit engagement with
students, faculty, and academics in Israel in response to the
war in Gaza.\4\ H.R. 4795 makes the receipt of HEA title VI
funds--funds designed to support international higher
education--contingent on schools having open dialogue with
students and faculty across the world. Requiring IHEs to
certify they will not impede the ability of students and
faculty to engage in academic programs, cultural exchanges,
etc. with Israeli students and faculty is a policy rationally
related to the underlying use of these funds. This could have
been the building block for a bipartisan unanimous bill, but
the Majority decided to include in the bill a section on the
BDS movement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\See e.g., Elisabeth Bumiller, Israeli Academics Find Themselves
Isolated Despite Gaza Cease-Fire, NY Times (Nov. 9, 2025), https://
www.nytimes.com/2025/11/09/world/middleeast/boycotts-israel.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE BDS MOVEMENT IS EXPRESSIVE ACTIVITY IMPLICATED BY THE FIRST
AMENDMENT
BDS is a trans-national political movement and committee
founded in 2005 to exert pressure on Israel to change its
policies in regard to Palestinians.\5\ Specifically, BDS has
called for ``[e]nding [Israel's] occupation and colonization of
all Arab lands and dismantling the Wall; recognizing the
fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel
to full equality; and respecting, protecting and promoting the
rights of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and
properties as stipulated in UN Resolution 194.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Palestinian BDS National Committee, What it BDS?, (last visited
Aug. 1, 2026), https://bdsmovement.net/what-bds.
\6\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As opposed to a traditional boycott of a company, BDS'
boycott discipline includes, ``withdrawing support from
Israel's apartheid regime, complicit Israeli sporting,
cultural, and academic institutions, and all Israeli and
international companies engaged in violations of Palestinian
human rights.''\7\ Many mainstream Jewish groups do not support
the aims of BDS and equate such efforts with calling for the
destruction of Israel. Some Jewish groups have denounced the
aims of BDS but also recognized that BDS supporters have the
constitutional right to espouse their views and anti-BDS laws
are counter to the First Amendment.\8\ It is worth noting that
the BDS movement, which has support among a few IHEs in other
countries, has never gained traction at American universities.
While there have been faculty senates and student assemblies
that have passed resolutions in support of BDS, those
resolutions are non-binding on the institutions of higher
education. These votes are often immediately followed by
statements from administrators that the institution has no plan
to boycott, divest, or sanction anything related to Israel.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Id.
\8\J Street, J Street policy principles on the Global BDS Movement
and boycotts, divestment and sanctions efforts, (last visited Aug. 1,
2026), https://jstreet.org/boycott-divestment-and-sanctions-bds/ (``J
Street is opposed to federal and state-level legislation that would
criminalize individuals' and non-governmental organizations' BDS
activities, penalize BDS supporters or impose BDS-related litmus tests
on individuals. This type of misguided legislative overreach is the
wrong way to fight BDS. By alienating and angering the liberal
audiences that BDS seeks to engage and recruit, it actually empowers
the BDS Movement. This legislation can too easily violate
constitutional free speech protections, and is fundamentally
inconsistent with our democratic principles as Americans and as Jews.
We urge lawmakers and Jewish communal leaders to engage Americans who
are sympathetic to BDS in serious and open conversation and debate,
rather than seeking to silence them by aggressively penalizing their
actions and positions.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite the lack of IHE administration support for BDS,
approximately 38 states legislatures--mostly conservative--have
passed laws opposing BDS efforts. This is the appropriate
context in which to consider H.R. 4795. Under this bill, IHEs
would have to certify as part of the program participation
agreement (PPA) they are required to enter into to receive
Title IV aid, that they ``will not engage in a nonexpressive
commercial boycott of a major strategic partner of the United
States.''\9\ This language mirrors that of many state laws.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\H.R. 4795 Sec. 2, 119th Cong. (2025).
\10\E.g., Martin v. Wrigley, 540 F. Supp. 3d 1220, 1229 (N.D. Ga.
2021) (``Like the decisions reviewing anti-boycotting statutes in
Jordahl, Amawi, Koontz, and Waldrip, this Court concludes that O.C.G.A.
Sec. 50-5-85 imposes a condition on those who contract with the state
of Georgia that implicates the contractors' First Amendment rights.);
but see Arkansas Times LP v. Waldrip as Tr. of Univ. of Arkansas Bd. of
Trs., 37 F.4th 1386, 1394 (8th Cir. 2022) (``Under Arkansas's canons of
statutory interpretation, we think the Arkansas Supreme Court would
read Act 710 as prohibiting purely commercial, non-expressive conduct.
It does not ban Arkansas Times from publicly criticizing Israel, or
even protesting the statute itself. It only prohibits economic
decisions that discriminate against Israel. Because those commercial
decisions are invisible to observers unless explained, they are not
inherently expressive and do not implicate the First Amendment.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The problem with H.R. 4795, and by extension many of the
state laws aimed at BDS, is that they are attempting to use
power derived from the Spending Clause of the Constitution to
police First Amendment-protected speech. H.R. 4795 claims its
target is ``nonexpressive'' activity, and as such it does not
impact First Amendment speech. But the sponsors continuously
reiterate their policy target is the BDS movement, a movement
which is clear and open about the ideas it hopes to express via
a boycott of Israel. It is clear that the boycott envisioned by
BDS, is an expressive activity, one designed to express a
political opinion and compel political activity. H.R. 4795 just
calling it ``nonexpressive'' is a fig leaf courts will likely
ignore, recognizing the bill implicates free speech. Congress
cannot make a law abridging the freedom of speech, either
directly, or in this case indirectly.
Further, H.R. 4795 would likely fail the ``unconstitutional
conditions'' doctrine, an established principle in case law
that ``once the government has established a benefit, it may
not deny that benefit to a person `on a basis that infringes
his constitutionally protected interests.'''\11\ It is clear
that under H.R. 4795, Congress would be attempting to force
IHEs to adopt a particular view on an issue of public concern.
And as Title IV's purpose as federal student aid has little to
no nexus with the issue at hand, it is likely Courts will apply
``heightened scrutiny to conditions that `seek to leverage
funding' in a way that burdens constitutional rights `outside
the contours of the program itself.'''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Victoria L. Killion, Cong. Rsch. Serv., R46827, Funding
Conditions: Constitutional Limits on Congress's Spending Power (2021),
https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R46827.
\12\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
TITLE VI FUNDING SHOULD NOT FLOW TO SCHOOLS THAT HAMPER INTERNATIONAL
COOPERATION
The second provision of H.R. 4795 would require schools
that apply for funding under HEA title VI to certify that they
permit their students and faculty to engage with students and
faculty of Israeli institutions of higher education.\13\ The
Congressional Research Service (CRS) broadly describes the
purpose of the programs authorized under title VI as ``to
develop Americans'' ability to understand and interact with
people from other societies, to improve diplomacy and global
cooperation, and to help U.S. companies compete in
international business.''\14\ These goals, unlike those of HEA
Title IV, are directly related to the underlying requirement
H.R. 4795 seeks to impose. It is wholly reasonable that IHEs
that are applying for funding to further student's
understanding of international cooperation would be expected
not to sanction the boycotting of any nation. Such a condition
on Title VI funds is constitutional, and many Committee
Democrats support this provision, but could not support a bill
that also included the broader Title IV conditioning discussed
previously.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\H.R. 4795 Sec. 3, 119th Cong. (2025).
\14\https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R46508/
R46508.1.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEMOCRATIC AMENDMENTS OFFERED DURING MARKUP OF H.R. 4795
Committee Democrats did not offer any amendments during
consideration of H.R. 4795.
CONCLUSION
As mentioned earlier, to the extent that H.R. 4795 is aimed
at the BDS movement in the United States, it is a solution in
search of a problem. The BDS movement predates the Oct. 7, 2023
attack on Israel, and while it may have limited student and
faculty support it has never been endorsed by the
administration of any domestic university. Regardless, the
Majority can bring up bills like H.R. 4795 recognizing that
movements that have to rely on the First Amendment to protect
their right to speak are never popular. Further, they can take
a policy that many members may agree with, requiring that
schools that receive HEA funding for international education be
open to international dialogue, and hold it hostage in an
attempt to get members to support other policy they oppose.
While they are well within their rights, this is not productive
lawmaking, and does nothing to stem animus and division on
college campuses or help students feel safe.
[all]