Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title. This section would provide that the bill may be cited as the ``FAA SMS Compliance Review Act of 2026''. Section 2. Expert compliance review of FAA Safety Management System. This section would require the FAA, within 60 days of enactment, to establish a review panel comprised of independent experts. The panel would review FAA orders and policies regarding the agency's implementation of an internal SMS. This section would require the panel to evaluate the FAA's compliance with SMS orders and policies, the safety enhancements achieved through the FAA's prior SMS implementation as required by FAA order 8000.369 and successor orders through FAA order 8000.369c, and the effectiveness of FAA's SMS with regard to four components: safety policy, safety risk management, safety assurance, and safety promotion. Additionally, the panel would assess the extent to which FAA safety culture promotes or fosters SMS consistent with ICAO's Safety Management Manual and the effectiveness of the FAA's internal audit process in determining the performance of the FAA's existing SMS. The panel would measure the extent to which SMS, safety policy, safety risk management, safety assurance, and safety promotion are communicated to, understood by, and incorporated in training for FAA personnel. It would also analyze the effectiveness of the FAA SMS and the FAA Voluntary Safety Reporting System across the agency's various lines of business as structured prior to January 1, 2026, including but not limited to the ATO, the AVS, and the ARP. Additionally, the panel would determine whether the United States should advocate for changes to ICAO's Annex 19--Safety Management, or any other matter the FAA believes would benefit the public interest in aviation safety. This section would require the review panel to contain two representatives from NASA with expertise in SMS; five appropriately qualified aviation labor union representatives, including airline pilot unions, the FAA's air traffic controller union, and an aviation safety inspector union; no less than five independent experts in SMS who have not served as political appointees in the FAA and have a minimum of 10 years' experience with SMS; three air carrier employees involved in the administration of SMS; two representatives employed by airframe and aviation parts manufacturers under 14 CFR part 21 involved in the administration of a SMS; one representative of the aerospace industry involved in the administration of SMS; one representative of the U.S. Mission to ICAO, as a non-voting member; and one representative from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) as a non-voting member. This section would require the review panel to include up to five employees of the FAA--at least three being subject matter expects in implementing SMS at the FAA--to serve in an advisory capacity. This section would require the review panel to issue recommendations to the FAA, based on its review of the SMS, to inform the FAA's implementation of a comprehensive, integrated SMS for lines of business within the FAA. This section would require the submission, no later than 180 days after the panel's first meeting, of the report to the FAA and the appropriate committees of Congress, endorsed by two-thirds of the review panel. The report would include the findings and recommendations endorsed by a majority of the review panel's appointed members. It would permit dissenting views from review panel members to be appended to the report. It would require the report, no later than 5 days after receipt, to be published on the FAA's website along with dissenting views, if any. The review panel would be terminated upon submission of the report. This section would grant the review panel the authority to enter onto FAA premises for access to and inspection of records or other purposes, access and inspect de-identified records in the possession of the FAA necessary for the review panel's work, and interview employees of the FAA, if a majority of appointed review panel members consider the action necessary and appropriate. It would limit members of the review panel who are not officers or employees of the Federal Government to reviewing de-identified information provided to the FAA under 14 CFR part 193 and would ensure that access to classified information is limited to those with the appropriate level of security clearance. Additionally, it would require non-Federal employees on the review panel to enter into an agreement with the Administrator to prohibit the disclosure of any non-public information identified in the report. It would assert that officers or Federal employees serving on the review panel are not required to execute a non-disclosure agreement. It would also protect information obtained or reviewed by the review panel, along with proprietary information and trade secrets. This section would exempt the review panel from the Federal Advisory Committee Act. This section would require the Administrator, within 180 days after the report is submitted and every 90 days thereafter, to report on the status of ongoing actions in response to the review panel's recommendations. This section would allow the Administrator, no later than 6 months after submission of the panel recommendations, to publish on the FAA website and submit to the appropriate committees of Congress any disagreements with the panel recommendations and a detailed explanation of the determination. Lastly, this section would define the terms: ``Administrator'', ``appropriate committees of Congress'', ``FAA'', ``ICAO'', and ``SMS''. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW In compliance with paragraph 12 of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate, the Committee states that the bill as reported would make no change to existing law. [all]