Background
Before European contact, Native peoples maintained unique educational systems rooted in community and designed to meet the needs of their environments and cultures.\1\ The arrival of Europeans to North America and the Pacific Islands ushered in an era of attempted assimilation of Native peoples into European-American ways of life.\2\ Systemic attempts to eliminate Native languages, beliefs, and cultures, and end resistance to colonization, began as early as the 17th and 18th centuries, with the founding of some of the country's oldest educational institutions.\3\\4\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\K. Tsianina Lomawaima & Teresa McCarty, To Remain an Indian: Lessons in Democracy from a Century of Native American Education (2006). \2\See generally Cohen's Handbook of Federal Indian Law, 22.03[1][a] (2012 ed. & 2019 Supp.). \3\Indian Education: A National Tragedy, A National Challenge, S. Comm. on Labor and Public Welfare, Special Subcomm. on Indian Educ., S. Rep. No. 91-501 (1969) (highlighting examples such as King James IV of Scotland (James I of England) calling for Anglican clergy to fund the education of the ``children of these Barbarians in Virginia'' in 1617). See also Harvard University Charter of 1650 (1650), https:// guides.library.harvard.edu/c.php?g=880222&p=6323072 (``[for purposes of, among other things] the education of the English and Indian youth of this country, in knowledge and godliness''); Royal Charter establishing the College of William & Mary in Virginia (1693), https:// scrc-kb.libraries.wm.edu/royal- charter#Transcription+of+the+Royal+Charter (establishing the college so that, among other things, ``the Christian faith may be propagated amongst the Western Indians''). \4\Dartmouth College Charter (1769), https:// www.library.dartmouth.edu/digital/digital- collections/dartmouth-college-charter/read (establishing the ``design of spreading Christian knowledge among the savages of our American wilderness'' by means of ``education and instruction of youth of the Indian tribes . . . which shall appear necessary and expedient for civilizing and christianizing children of pagans''); see Colin Calloway, The Indian History of an American Institution: Native Americans at Dartmouth (2010); see also Stephen W. Haycox, Alaska: An American Colony 146 (2002). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Assimilationist practices and policies through compelled education were not limited to formal institutions. For example, in the 1780s, Russian fur trading companies in Alaska took Native boys hostage, sent them to training schools, and forced them into servitude as navigators, interpreters, and seamen.\5\ In other cases, training schools were founded by religious institutions and later funded by the federal government. In 1878, Presbyterian missionaries established a day school in Sitka, Alaska, at a former military barracks. The Sheldon Jackson School, so called after its founder, sought to ``house and educate . . . `with the intent to encourage Native Americans to adopt Euro-American culture.'''\6\ Jackson was later named as the Department of the Interior's first General Agent of Education in Alaska in 1885, and in this position, created ``contract schools'' in which the federal government contracted with religious missionary associations to establish schools in remote villages across Alaska.\7\ Whether carried out in formal educational settings or in day, industrial, training, contract, or other schools, the forced ``education'' of Native children has a long history in the United States that implicates a number of institutions, including the federal government, all with the same mission: ``kill the Indian in him, and save the man.''\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\Svetlana G. Fedorova, The Russian Population in Alaska and California Late 18th Century--1867 242-243 (Richard A. Pierce et al., ed. & trans., 1973). Following admission to statehood, some former Russian schools in Alaska continued to operate through church parishes. Id. at 266. \6\Nat'l Park Serv. National Historic Landmark Nomination, Sheldon Jackson School (2001) at 5. \7\Stephen W. Haycox, Sheldon Jackson in Historical Perspective: Alaska Native Schools and Mission Contracts, 1885-1894, 28 The Pac. Hist. 1, 18-28 (1984). \8\See Captain R.H. Pratt, The Advantages of Mingling Indians with Whites, in Americanizing the American Indians: Writings by the ``Friends of the Indian,'' 1880-1900 (Francis Paul Prucha ed., 1973). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- FEDERAL SUPPORT FOR FORCED ASSIMILATION THROUGH EDUCATION OF NATIVE CHILDREN By the early 1800s, the United States began a campaign of forced assimilation under the guise of educating Native youth, formalizing the practice after the War of 1812. In 1819, Congress passed the Indian Civilization Fund Act to provide for federal oversight of the education of Native peoples and to establish an annual ``civilization fund'' of $10,000 per year for the purposes of converting them to European ways of living, speaking, and acting.\9\ Most of these funds were provided to churches and their mission schools;\10\ in Hawai`i, missionaries from the United States established day schools and boarding schools primarily aimed at ``civilizing'' and converting Native Hawaiians to Christianity.\11\ Over time, the federal government centralized administration of Indian educational efforts under the Commission of Indian Affairs within the Department of the Interior (DOI), the successor in jurisdiction to the Department of War.\12\ By 1838, the federal government operated 16 manual training schools with approximately 800 Native students, and 87 boarding schools with approximately 2,900 Native students.\13\ The policies of these schools were rooted in a belief that Native peoples were ``barbarous and heathen . . . [and] `wedded to savage habits, customs, and prejudices''' which could be ``cured'' through manual training and labor.\14\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\Act of March 3, 1819, ch. 85, 3 Stat. 516 (codified at 25 U.S.C. Sec. 271). Annual appropriations to fund Indian education continued under the Indian Civilization Fund Act until repealed in 1873 by the Act of Feb. 14, 1873, Ch. 138, 17 Stat. 437, 461. See generally Cohen's Handbook of Federal Indian Law, 22.03[1][a] at 1329-30 & n.6. \10\See S. Rep. No. 91-501 at 11, 143 (1969). \11\See U.S. Dep't of the Interior, Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report (2022) (``In 1836 . . . missionaries formed the Hilo Boarding School . . . [t]he Charter of the Hilo Boarding School . . . required schooling of Native Hawaiian male children in . . . Christian living . . . coupled with manual labor to promote good citizenship training.''). \12\See Letter from John C. Calhoun, U.S. Sec'y of War, to Thomas L. McKenney (Mar. 11, 1824), in H.R. Doc. No. 19-146, at 6 (1826); 25 U.S.C. Sec. 1; Act of July 9, 1832, Ch. 174, 4 Stat. 564. \13\S. Rep. No. 91-501, at 11 (1969). \14\Id. at 8. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Accordingly, in 1879, the federal government opened one of the first off-reservation Indian boarding schools, the Carlisle Indian Industrial School (Carlisle School), in an abandoned U.S. Army barracks in Carlisle, Pennsylvania.\15\ General Richard Henry Pratt, an Army officer and founder of the Carlisle School, established a ``rapid coercive assimilation'' approach that became the model for the federal Indian boarding school system, and required ``severe [military] discipline . . . to separate a child from his reservation and family, strip him of tribal lore and mores, force the complete abandonment of his native language, and prepare him in such a way that he would never return to his people.''\16\ General Pratt's approach at the Carlisle School was rooted in his experience with American Indians held as prisoners of war at the Hampton Normal and Agricultural Institute (Hampton School),\17\ which is regarded as the nation's first residential experiment in educating American Indians as a means of preparing them for citizenship.\18\ The Hampton School's founder, General Samuel C. Armstrong, was influenced by his parents and other missionaries in Hawai`i who were involved in the education of Native Hawaiian children. Believing that ``the Polynesian, like the Negro, suffered from a `deficiency of character,'''\19\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \15\Id. at 147. \16\Id. at 148. \17\Jon L. Brudvig, ``Make Haste Slowly:'' The Experiences of American Indian Women at Hampton Institute, 1878-1923 1 (2005), https:/ /www.se.edu/native-american/wp-content/uploads/sites/49/2019/09/ Proceedings-2005-Brudvig.pdf (``Hampton . . . was established in 1868 to serve the . . . needs of recently emancipated slaves . . . American Indian students [formerly prisoners of war] came to Hampton . . . [and] their presence . . . spawned the development of off-reservation [Indian] boarding schools''). \18\Id. \19\Ralph Canevali, Hilo Boarding School: Hawai`i's Experiment in Vocational Education 92 (1977), https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/ 5014889.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- General Armstrong modeled the Hampton School after the Hilo Boys' Boarding School in Hawai`i, a missionary-run boarding school established to primarily convert Native Hawaiians to Christianity and, ultimately, ``civilize'' them through manual labor and training.\20\ The Hampton School continued as a boarding school for American Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians until 1923.\21\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \20\C. Kalani Beyer, The Connection of Samuel Chapman Armstrong as Both Borrower and Architect of Education in Hawai`i (2007), https:// www.cambridge.org/core/journals/history-of- education-quarterly/article/abs/connection-of-samuel-chapman-armstrong- as-both-borrower-and-architect-of-education-in-hawaii/ 15E99DC33C913D9485CE7773D158C046. \21\See generally Ralph Canevali, Hilo Boarding School: Hawai`i's Experiment in Vocational Education (1977), https://core.ac.uk/download/ pdf/5014889.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- As mission-run boarding schools expanded their reach throughout the country and to the Hawai`i territory, in 1891 Congress authorized the Commissioner of Indian Affairs to promulgate regulations ``to secure the attendance'' of Indian children at such schools.\22\ These regulations applied to all Indian children between the ages of eight and eighteen (whether living on or off-reservation), permitted the use of law enforcement to compel attendance, and authorized the withholding of clothes, rations, and other annuities from non- compliant parents or guardians.\23\ Some Indians, such as the Hopis in Arizona, opposed the forced education of their children to the point that they were labeled ``hostiles,'' arrested, and jailed at Alcatraz Island in California for nearly a year.\24\ The overarching federal goal of compelled schooling was to reduce the cost of fighting with Indian Tribes and, ultimately, dispossess them of their homelands through the complete elimination of their languages, cultures, religions, and social bonds.\25\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \22\Act of March 3, 1891, ch. 543, 26 Stat. 989, 1014. \23\Act of March 3, 1891, Ch. 543, 26 Stat. 989, 1035. See S. Rep. No. 91-501 at 151 (1969): U.S. Cong. Serial Set, Vol. 2934, at 158-159 (1891); 25 U.S.C. Sec. 283. \24\National Park Service, Hopi Prisoners on the Rock, https:// www.nps.gov/articles/hopi-prisoners-on-the-rock.htm (last visited Mar. 31, 2025); National Park Service, The Army and American Indian Prisoners, https://www.nps.gov/articles/the-army-and-american-indian- prisoners.htm (last visited Mar. 31, 2025). \25\Legislative Hearing on H.R. 5444, Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding Schools Policies Act Before the Subcomm. on Indigenous Peoples of the H. Comm. on Nat. Res., 117th Cong. (2022) (statement of Deborah Parker, Nat'l Native Boarding School Healing Coalition). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Once at the schools, Native children were subject to systematic violence, including corporal and psychological punishment such as shaving heads to remove traditional hairstyles; confinement; flogging and whipping for speaking a Native language or engaging in other prohibited conduct; handcuffing; having older children punish younger ones; sexual abuse; neglect; and malnourishment.\26\ In some cases, children would be ``lent'' to nearby communities or adjacent states to work as servants and farm laborers, in what were commonly known as ``outing programs.''\27\ Placement at these schools led to disease, death, and the fraying of Native languages, cultural and religious practices, and social life;\28\ the physical and psychological effects of these experiences created lasting intergenerational trauma for survivors and their families.\29\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \26\U.S. Dep't of the Interior, Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report VOL. I, 7-8 (2022). \27\See, e.g., Kevin Whalen, Beyond School Walls: Race, Labor, and Indian Education in Southern California, 1902-1940 (2014) (Ph.D. dissertation, University of California Riverside); Kevin Whalen, Native Students at Work: American Indian Labor and Sherman Institute's Outing Program, 1900-1945 (University of Washington Press 2018). \28\See supra notes 7 & 26; see also, Juliet Larking-Gilmore, Homesick: Disease and Distance in American Indian Boarding Schools, Remedia (Nov. 18, 2016), https://remedianetwork.wordpress.com/2016/11/ 18/homesick-disease-and-distance-in-american-indian-boarding-schools/; Legislative Hearing on H.R. 5444, Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding Schools Policies Act Before the Subcomm. on Indigenous Peoples of the H. Comm. on Nat. Res., 117th Cong. (2022) (statement of James LaBelle Sr., National Native Boarding School Healing Coalition); Legislative Hearing on H.R. 5444, Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding Schools Policies Act Before the Subcomm. on Indigenous Peoples of the H. Comm. on Nat. Res., 117th Cong. (2022) (statement of Matthew War Bonnet, boarding school survivor). \29\See e.g., Legislative Hearing on H.R. 5444, Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding Schools Policies Act Before the Subcomm. on Indigenous Peoples of the H. Comm. on Nat. Res., 117th Cong. (2022) (statement of James LaBelle Sr., National Native Boarding School Healing Coalition); Legislative Hearing on H.R. 5444, Truth and Healing Commission on Indian Boarding Schools Policies Act Before the Subcomm. on Indigenous Peoples of the H. Comm. on Nat. Res., 117th Cong. (2022) (statement of Matthew War Bonnet, boarding school survivor); Amy Bombay et al., The Intergenerational Effects of Indian Residential Schools: Implications for the Concept of Historical Trauma, 51 Transcultural Psychiatry 3 (2014); Hope MacDonald Lonetree, Healing from the Trauma of Federal Residential Indian Boarding Schools, Administration for Children and Families (Nov. 24, 2021), https://www.acf.hhs.gov/blog/ 2021/11/healing- trauma-federal-residential-indian-boarding-schools. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Compounding such cruelty, official school policies (or in some cases, simple geography) kept children and their parents and families apart. In an 1886 report to the Secretary of the Interior, Indian School Superintendent John B. Riley wrote, ``[i]f it be admitted that education affords the true solution to the Indian problem, then it must be admitted that the boarding school is the very key to the situation.''\30\ Riley went on to say, ``[o]nly by complete isolation of the Indian child from his savage antecedents can he be satisfactorily educated . . . .''\31\ Such techniques were also used by mission-run schools. For example, in 1887, an Alaska Native mother sought a writ of habeas corpus to free her child from a government-funded Presbyterian Boarding School in Sitka, Alaska. While the judge allowed limited visitation, he required the child to stay at the school, writing, ``It is the experience of those who have been engaged in these Indian schools that, to make them effectual as disseminators of civilization, Indian children should, at a tender and impressionable age, be entirely withdrawn from the camp, and placed under the control of these schools. [Allowing parents to take their children home] would render all efforts of both the government and missions to civilize them abortive.''\32\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \30\Annual Report of the Indian School Superintendent to the Secretary of the Interior 137 (1886). \31\Id. \32\In re Can-ah-couqua, 29 F. 687, 690 (D. Alaska 1887). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to DOI's Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Report Volume II, as of July 2024, the federal government supported or operated at least 417\33\ Indian boarding schools between 1819 and 1969, across 37 states or then-territories.\34\ The total number of Native children who attended these schools is unknown, but many did not survive and their remains never returned home. The Department of the Interior concluded that, based on available records, 973 Indian child deaths were documented across the federal Indian boarding school system between 1819-1969, but acknowledged that that number is much greater due to incomplete information.\35\ Recent reports estimate that more than 3100 Native students died while attending an Indian boarding school between 1828 and 1970.\36\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \33\U.S. Dep't of the Interior, Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report VOL. II (2024). \34\Id., 92 (reporting 22 schools in Alaska, 7 in Hawai`i, 12 in Kansas, 21 in Minnesota, 16 in Montana, 3 in Nevada, 43 in New Mexico, 12 in North Dakota, 76 in Oklahoma, 30 in South Dakota, and 15 in Washington). \35\Id., 15-16. \36\Dana Hedgpeth et al., More Than 3,100 Students Died at Schools Built to Crush Native American Cultures, Wash. Post (Dec. 22, 2024), https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/interactive/2024/native- american-deaths-burial-sites-boarding-schools/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- FEDERAL INVESTIGATIONS INTO INDIAN EDUCATION\37\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \37\See Indian Education: A National Tragedy, A National Challenge, S. Comm. on Labor and Public Welfare, Special Subcomm. on Indian Educ., S. Rep. No. 91-5