Skip to content

senate · Committee report

S. Rept. 119-97

ACQUISITION REFORM AND COST ASSESSMENT ACT OF 2025

2025-12-02

Committees

Associated legislation

Text

Background

VA manages significant acquisition programs to procure services, supplies, technology, and systems critical to delivering timely and high-quality care, benefits, and services to eligible veterans and other beneficiaries. The Committee bill would redefine ``major acquisition program'' to focus oversight on high-cost initiatives (defined as those with life- cycle costs exceeding $1,000,000,000 or annual costs exceeding $200,000,000), addressing concerns about cost overruns and delays in programs like the Electronic Health Record Modernization (EHRM). Committee Bill The Committee bill would establish the Office of Acquisition under an Assistant Secretary, with Program Executive Officers and Deputy Assistant Secretaries to centralize oversight. It would further add provisions for independent analysis and requirements development to enhance efficiency and accountability, complementing VA's ongoing acquisition reforms. Section 3: Department of Veterans Affairs Major Acquisition Program Managers Major VA programs have faced delays and failures due to weak early oversight and leadership. GAO reviewed VA's major acquisition programs and found that nearly all (approximately 90 percent) did not use the department's official Acquisition Program Management Framework (in place since 2017), which is designed to enforce early oversight, including setting baselines for costs, schedules, and performance. Instead, these programs relied on ad-hoc, program-specific approaches that ``vary widely in robustness.''\1\ This section would require VA to appoint level-three certified project managers for all major programs under the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition. These managers will set firm baselines for costs and schedules, ensure compliance, and manage risks, helping to avoid past problems. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-22-105195, VA Acquisition Management: Action Needed to Ensure Success of New Oversight Framework (August 2022). ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Background

VA's Electronic Health Record Modernization (EHRM) program, launched in 2018, ballooned from $10 billion to over $16 billion with repeated delays and site failures by 2023, exposing chronic gaps in early program oversight and unqualified leadership.\2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-25-108091, Electronic Health Record Modernization: VA Is Making Incremental Improvements, but Much More Remains to Be Done (February 2025). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Committee Bill The Committee bill would mandate VA to appoint level-three certified project managers to all major acquisition programs to lock in baselines, enforce compliance, and mitigate risks under the Assistant Secretary, directly addressing GAO findings that 70 percent of major VA acquisitions lacked disciplined management from inception. Section 4: Department of Veterans Affairs Acquisition and Procurement Reorganization Matters

Background

Section 4 of the Committee bill would require unification within one year--with a 90-day congressional plan--to eliminate silos, streamline decision-making, and have a consolidated model. VA's three main administrations--the Veterans Health Administration, the Veterans Benefits Administration, and the National Cemetery Administration--have separate acquisition, procurement, and logistics operations, leading to repeated contracts, mismatched systems, and yearly waste. To address that, the Committee bill orders full consolidation under the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition within one year, including a plan and briefing to Congress within 90 days. This will reduce duplication, improve decision-making, and create a single system for better operations, oversight, and cost control. Committee Bill The Committee bill would mandate organizational consolidation of acquisition, procurement, and logistics activities under the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition within one year, with a plan and briefing to Congress within 90 days. Section 5: Independent Verification and Validation (IV&V) of Major Acquisition Programs of Department of Veterans Affairs VA program launches have missed early problems with usability, causing safety issues and restarts, due to reliance on contractor self-reports. The Committee bill would require VA to hire IV&V contractors for major programs within 120 days. It would further stipulate that contractors have at least three health-sector contracts, good past performance, and no conflicts. Costs would be shared across VA units for neutral reviews of technical aspects like usability and integration.

Background

VA's 2020 EHRM rollout ignored early warnings of usability flaws, leading to patient safety incidents and a 2023 program reset. The Committee bill would require contracted IV&V within 120 days with rigorous vendor criteria (three health-sector primes, clean past performance, no conflicts) and cost-sharing to ensure unbiased technical scrutiny, ending reliance on self- certified contractor reports that masked critical defects. Committee Bill The Committee bill would require VA to contract for IV&V of major acquisition programs within 120 days, with strict eligibility criteria (i.e., three prime contracts from governmental or commercial health care organizations, satisfactory past performance, no conflict of interest) and proportional funding from VA subdivisions. Section 6: Department of Veterans Affairs Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation VA often underestimates costs in major programs, without independent checks, leading to funding delays. The Committee bill would create a Director of Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation to set cost policies, make independent estimates, review program results, and send annual reports to Congress.

Background

VA consistently underestimated major program costs--EHRM by 60 percent, VHA facility leases by 300 percent--due to absent independent cost modeling, triggering congressional holds on funding. Committee Bill The Committee bill would establish the Director of Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation to develop cost estimation policies, conduct independent cost estimates, evaluate program effectiveness, and submit annual reports to Congress, with simplified responsibilities compared to the original bill. Section 7: Improvement to Hiring of Entry-Level Acquisition Position in Department of Veterans Affairs The Department of Veterans Affairs faces persistent challenges in maintaining a robust and experienced acquisition workforce, a critical capability for overseeing complex contracts and ensuring taxpayer dollars are spent effectively on veteran services. A 2024 VA Office of the Inspector General report highlighted severe staffing shortfalls.

Background

A 2024 VA Office of the Inspector General report revealed the VA could not provide data on its acquisition workforce's education levels, years of experience, retirement eligibility, and hiring.\3\ The Committee bill would require internship growth of two to four times the FY 2025 levels until needs are met to rebuild a pipeline of certified professionals and ensure institutional knowledge retention. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-22-105031, VA Acquisition Management: Actions Needed to Better Manage the Acquisition Workforce (September 2022). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Committee Bill The Committee bill would prioritize acquisition internship programs for entry-level hiring, requiring the number of participants to not be fewer than twice the number of participants during fiscal year 2025 and not more than four times the number of participants during such fiscal year until human capital needs are met. By requiring participation to fall between two and four times the fiscal year 2025 level, the bill aims to expand the internship program at a pace that is both impactful, while helping to resolve staffing gaps, and manageable for the department's supervision, training, and budget structures. Section 8: Independent Analysis of Acquisition Process of Department of Veterans Affairs VA's uneven acquisition methods have caused incompatible IT systems and extra costs, with 2023 testimony noting no standard engineering approach. Section 8 of the Committee bill would require the Acquisition Innovation Research Center, a DoD group, to analyze VA processes over one year and report to Congress. The review will suggest engineering methods to improve workflows.

Background

VA's ad-hoc acquisition processes produced incompatible information technology (IT) systems and redundant infrastructure, with 2023 testimony citing ``no systems engineering discipline.'' Committee Bill The Committee bill would require a systems engineering analysis of VA's acquisition process by the Acquisition Innovation Research Center, chartered by the Department of Defense (DoD), with a report to Congress within one year. Section 9: Requirements Development Process VA program costs have consistently increased because of poorly written requirements. GAO says VA IT issues come from poorly defined requirements. Section 9 of the Committee bill would set a standard process for major programs using data and input from stakeholders like clinicians and require VA to report to Congress within 180 days to clarify needs and cut changes.

Background

EHRM requirements were rewritten 17 times after contract award because of the vague initial specifications, locking VA into costly change orders. Because key functional needs, interfaces, and performance expectations were not clearly defined before EHRM contract award, each adjustment to the program had to be processed as a formal change order. As a result, these repeated rewrites increased costs, delayed the schedule, and revealed that the program's requirements were not properly defined. Section 9 enforces data-driven, stakeholder- inclusive requirements within 180 days to front-load clarity, reduce scope creep, and align acquisitions with clinical and operational realities.\4\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-25-106874, Electronic Health Records: VA Is Making Incremental Improvements in New System but Needs Updated Cost Estimate and Schedule (March 2025). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Committee Bill The Committee bill establishes a standardized requirements development process for major acquisition programs, incorporating data-driven assessments and stakeholder input, with a report to Congress within 180 days. This would address GAO's findings that the VA's history of IT failures are often tied to poorly defined or changing requirements and its recommendation for VA to establish an enterprise requirements management process.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-20-719T, Veterans Affairs: VA Needs to Address Persistent IT Modernization and Cybersecurity Challenges (September 2020). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Section 10: Conforming Amendments Section 10 of the Committee bill would update laws in 38 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 8171-8175 by removing extra definitions, like ``major information technology project'' from Sec. 8171(5)-(6), while keeping those needed for Sec. Sec. 8173-8175. It would further delete all of Sec. 8172 but moves its project manager rules here. These changes ensure the bill fits with current law without adding new rules.

Background

To harmonize the improvements needed with 38 USC 8171, 8172, 8173 the definitions for ``major information technology project'' from 8171 and ``major acquisition program'' were removed. Committee Bill The Committee bill makes conforming amendments, striking section 8171(5) and (6) and section 8172 of title 38. Section 10 would strike paragraphs (5) and (6) in 8171 but kept the definitions still needed for 8173, 8174, 8175. All of 8172 was stricken but moved the project manager qualifications into this bill. Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate In accordance with paragraph 11(a) of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate and section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee provides the following cost estimate, prepared by the Congressional Budget Office: [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] S. 1591 would make changes to acquisition and contracting processes used by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). Specifically, the bill would: Establish a new office to evaluate the cost of major acquisition programs; Require several studies and reports on how VA acquires products and services; Reorganize VA's current acquisition workforce; and Establish new rules for vendors that test VA programs, such as those dealing with information technology. In total, implementing S. 1591 would cost $24 million over the 2026-2030 period, CBO estimates. Such spending would be subject to the availability of appropriated funds. The costs of the legislation, detailed in Table 1, fall within budget function 700 (veterans benefits and services). Table 1.--Estimated Increases in Spending Subject to Appropriation Under S. 1591 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- By fiscal year, millions of dollars-- ------------------------------------------------------- 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2026-2030 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cost Assessment Office: Estimated Authorization............................. 2 5 5 5 5 22 Estimated Outlays................................... 2 5 5 5 5 22 Studies and Reports: Estimated Authorization............................. 1 1 * * * 2 Estimated Outlays................................... * 1 1 * * 2 Total Changes: Estimated Authorization............................. 2 3 3 5 5 24 Estimated Outlays................................... 1 3 4 5 5 24 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- * = between zero and $500,000. Cost assessment office. S. 1591 would establish a new Director of Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation. The director would lead a team responsible for estimating the cost of new major acquisition programs and evaluating the effectiveness of existing ones. Using information on similar offices at other agencies, CBO estimates that VA would eventually require 25 full-time equivalent employees to perform the office's duties. Those employees would receive an average annual compensation of about $200,000. As a result, establishing the new office would cost $22 million over the 2026-2030 period, CBO estimates. Studies and reports. The bill would require VA to contract with the Department of Defense's Acquisition Research Center to conduct a study of VA's acquisition processes. Using information from VA, CBO estimates that satisfying that requirement would cost $1 million. The bill also would require four other studies and reports. Using information on the cost of similar efforts, CBO estimates that satisfying those requirements would cost $1 million. In total, the bill's study and reporting requirements would cost $2 million over the 2026- 2030 period, CBO estimates. Acquisition reorganization. S. 1591 would reorganize VA's existing acquisition workforce and processes under a new Assistant Secretary for Acquisition. VA currently employs people who would fill positions under the reorganization and meet the bill's requirements for acquisition processes (such as appointing managers for major programs). Thus, CBO estimates that any associated costs would be less than $500,000. Program testing. The bill would direct VA to contract for independent verification and validation (IV&V) services, including for testing information technology systems to ensure they function properly and meet VA's requirements. Any such contract must ensure that the vendor has experience performing IV&V services at other agencies and has no conflict of interest that would prevent independent testing. VA currently contracts for IV&V services for major acquisition programs. CBO estimates that the cost of modifying those contracts to meet the bill's requirements would be less than $500,000. The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Logan Smith. The estimate was reviewed by Christina Hawley Anthony, Deputy Director of Budget Analysis. Phillip L. Swagel, Director, Congressional Budget Office. Regulatory Impact Statement In compliance with paragraph 11(b) of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate, the Committee on Veterans' Affairs has made an evaluation of the regulatory impact that would be incurred in carrying out the Committee bill. The Committee finds that the Committee bill would not entail any regulation of individuals or businesses, result in any impact on the personal privacy of any individuals, and that the paperwork resulting from enactment would be minimal. Tabulation of Votes Cast in Committee In compliance with paragraph 7(b) of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate, the following is a tabulation of votes cast by members of the Committee on Veterans' Affairs at its July 30, 2025, meeting. During this meeting, Chairman Moran called up 23 bills, including S. 1591, to be considered en bloc. The bills were reported favorably by voice vote en bloc. Agency Report On May 21, 2025, Thomas O'Toole, M.D., Acting Assistant Under Secretary for Health for Clinical Services, Veterans Health Administration, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, appeared before the Committee and submitted testimony on S. 1591. An excerpt from that testimony is reprinted below: statement of thomas o'toole, m.d., acting assistant under secretary for health for clinical services, veterans health administration (vha), department of veterans affairs before the senate committee on veterans' affairs acquisition reform and cost assessment act of 2025 (s. 1591) This bill includes nine total sections, with section 1 providing a short title and table of contents. Section 2(a) would add new subchapter VII, ``Acquisition Organization, Cost Assessment, and Program Evaluation,'' to chapter 81 of title 38, U.S.C. The new subchapter would include section 8181, ``Definitions,'' which would add definitions for the terms ``major acquisition program'' and ``non-major acquisition program'' that would apply throughout the subchapter. Section 2(b) would amend 38 U.S.C. Sec. 308 to increase the number of Assistant Secretaries from seven to eight, including the addition of an Assistant Secretary for ``Acquisition and innovation''. Section 2(c) would add a new section 8182, ``Acquisition organization,'' to title 38, U.S.C., which would direct the Secretary to designate an Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation, who would also be the Chief Acquisition Officer (CAO). The Assistant Secretary would be the head of the Office of Acquisition and Innovation, and major program offices would align under the Office. The budget for the Office would be established in VA's budget justification materials submitted to Congress. The Secretary would appoint three Deputy Assistant Secretaries (DAS), who would report to the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation--a DAS for Logistics, a DAS for Innovation, and a DAS for Procurement. The DAS for Logistics would be responsible for the administration of logistics and supply chain operations. The DAS for Innovation would be responsible for all research development, testing, and innovation development organizations, including the VHA Innovation Ecosystem. The DAS for Procurement would be responsible for all VA procurement and contracting organizations. VA supports the intent of this section, subject to amendments and the availability of appropriations VA supports the intent of this section, subject to amendments, because it enhances the focus on and coordination of acquisition and innovation activities, ensuring they align with Presidential priorities to streamline processes, improve efficiency, and foster a more innovative approach to acquiring and developing capabilities. This new role and organization better support and reflect the CAO's responsibilities and the increasing complexity of VA's acquisition needs. The CAO serves as the primary advisor to the Secretary for all major acquisitions, manages 17,000 acquisition professionals, and is responsible for providing oversight of approximately $100 billion in VA's major acquisition programs. VA believes additional amendments are needed to give effect to the intent of this section, particularly with revising the dollar value for major/non-major acquisition programs to align with the definition of ``Major Information Technology Project'' in 38 U.S.C. Sec. 8171(5) (as added by the Department of Veterans Affairs Information Technology Reform Act of 2022 (section 403 of the Joseph Maxwell Cleland and Robert Joseph Dole Memorial Veterans Benefits and Health Care Improvement Act of 2022; P.L. 117-328, Div. U)). VA also recommends adding a DAS for Acquisition, Program Management, and Performance, who would report to the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation. This additional DAS role would focus on the critical aspects of VA's ``Big A'' acquisitions. This role would transcend mere procurement, placing a strong emphasis on lifecycle management that is intricately structured around vital elements: requirements planning, programming and budgeting, policy innovation, performance standards, governance, and enhancing the capabilities of the acquisition workforce. This comprehensive approach would ensure that our major acquisitions are both effective and forward-thinking, paving the way for successful outcomes. VA does not have a cost estimate for this section. Section 3 would add a new section 8183, ``Major acquisition program managers.'' The new section would direct the Deputy Secretary to appoint a manager to administer a major acquisition program not later than 30 days after the Secretary approves commencement of the program. Each appointed manager would report to the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation and be responsible for developing a ``program baseline.'' The program baseline would include a description of each acquisition phase; requirements for advancing the program; and estimates for cost, schedule, and performance for the lifecycle of the program. The manager would be responsible for ensuring that the program is in compliance with such requirements, securing funding, adopting standardized processes, and ensuring personnel responsible for estimating the budget for the program are able to raise concerns prior to the establishment of the program baseline. The manager would be responsible for ensuring that: the program complies with cost accounting standards as applicable; the program has a qualified workforce; and the program has adequate technology and production capacity prior to commencing if the program is related to manufacturing. The manager would be required to submit a certification, within 90 days of establishing the program baseline, stating that alternative requirements were considered prior to establishing the program baseline. The certification would be submitted to the program decision authority (the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation). The Secretary would ensure that the program management offices for the major acquisition programs are independent of VBA, VHA, and the National Cemetery Administration (NCA), and other staff offices by reporting directly to the Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation. The manager would be required to notify the program decision authority within 30 days of the conclusion of an acquisition phase of a major acquisition program. The manager would not be allowed to proceed to a subsequent acquisition phase without the authorization of the program decision authority. VA supports the intent of this section, subject to amendments VA supports the intent of this section, subject to minor amendments, as VA has taken action to establish a policy that major acquisition programs require certified program managers and teams appointed by the Deputy Secretary to ensure efficient planning, execution, and oversight of VA's most complex and high-stakes programs. VA also seeks to ensure that Assistant Secretary for Acquisition and Innovation would align and seek input from other senior functional areas regarding statutory requirements for program oversight. VA does not have a cost estimate for this section. Section 4 would transfer all contracting officers and acquisition centers to the Office of Acquisition and Innovation. All activities related to the administration of logistics and supply chain operation would be consolidated under the DAS for Logistics. VA supports the intent of this section VA does not have a cost estimate for this section. Section 5 would require the Secretary to enter into one or more contracts for the independent verification and validation (IV&V) of a major acquisition program or major information technology project. To be awarded a contract, the CAO would have to determine that the entity performs or has performed, within a 3-year period as prime contractor, IV&V or systems engineering and technical advisory support of major acquisition programs or defense systems. The entity, including its subsidiaries, subcontractors, and investments, would be precluded from receiving an award if it was performing or had performed within a 3-year period a covered contract for the project or system involved or for VA. If requested by Congress, contracting officers would be required to submit an organizational conflict of interest mitigation plan submitted by the entity within 30 days from the request. VA would send a copy of the IV&V to Congress not later than 30 days after it was performed. The Chief Financial Officer would need to ensure, to the extent practicable, that each organizational subdivision that enters into a contract for IV&V proportionally contributes to the funding of each contract. VA supports the intent of this section, subject to amendments VA supports the intent of this section, subject to amendments. With the exclusive mandate for IV&V by external contractors, the Department would need to carefully review existing IV&V and testing-related contracts for compliance while ensuring continuity. This shift may unintentionally exclude experienced VA contractors who lack the required DoD- related contract experience; therefore, VA believes refining the proposed legislative language for clarity and proactively addressing these exclusions would be crucial to mitigating operational disruptions. To preserve operational integrity and effectiveness, leveraging both governmental expertise and external contractor support in IV&V processes is vital, and adhering to industry standards such as IEEE Std. 1012 while maintaining flexibility in IV&V implementation will ensure comprehensive oversight without compromising quality. VA does not have a cost estimate for this section. Section 6 would add a new section 8184, ``Cost assessment and program evaluation.'' This new section would establish a Director of Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation (CAPE) who would report directly to the Secretary. The CAPE Director would provide independent analysis and advice to the Secretary and other senior VA officials on matters assigned to the Director pursuant to this section and to 38 U.S.C. Sec. 303. Proposed section 8184(c) would establish two Deputy Directors within the CAPE Office, one for Cost Assessment and one for Program Evaluation. Proposed section 8184(d) would define the responsibilities of the CAPE Director. The Secretary would have to ensure that the Director promptly received the results of all cost estimates and cost analyses conducted by VBA, VHA, NCA, or staff offices and all studies conducted by the Administration, in connection with such cost estimates and cost analyses for major acquisition programs and major automated information system programs of the Administrations. The Director also would have to have timely access to any records and data in the Department. Proposed section 8184(h) and section 6(b) of the bill would define VA's annual reporting requirements. Finally, section 6(b) would define reporting requirements on the monitoring of operating and support costs for major acquisition programs. VA does not support this section While VA agrees with the intent behind establishing a CAPE Director function to enhance oversight, VA does not support this section. VA does not believe that establishing the function and roles in law is necessary. VA seeks the flexibility to develop and expand existing capabilities within the Office of Management without the additional constraints prescribed in this section. VA does not have a cost estimate for this section. Section 7 would add two new sections, 8185 and 8186, titled ``Other transaction authority'' and ``Advance market commitments for technologies or services for provision of health care,'' respectively. Proposed section 8185 would establish another transaction authority (OTA) that would permit VA to enter into transactions with non-traditional contractors to perform certain types of research or innovation development activities. The authority could also be exercised by the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Innovation for activities that align with the mission of the VHA Innovation Ecosystem, provided certain requirements are met. The criteria include research that is not duplicative, a determination by the senior procurement executive that the research is appropriate, that the transaction will not exceed $5 million to include all options (unless a determination is made to exceed such limits), and other details and limitations. It also would specify notice and reporting requirements to Congress, require VA prescribe regulations to carry out the section, and lim

Source: https://api.congress.gov/v3/committee-report/119/srpt/97